Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to boycott products made in China and India?

210 replies

Lowkeyloopy · 14/11/2021 08:42

So angry that they have watered down an agreement aimed at saving the planet that my (shortly to be born) child will be living in.

Yes people will say it’s unfair that the more developed economies have enjoyed all the benefits of burning fossil fuels and are now dictating that other countries should stop. Well, tough. We are where we are and the world is on fire.

I’m also sick and tired of people saying that individuals can’t make a difference, AND of the government congratulating itself on bringing down our own carbon emissions. We don’t MAKE anything in this country - we ship it in from other countries. If we all stopped buying crap we don’t need that is manufactured on the cheap in those countries, we could actually help ensure those countries cut their carbon emissions and genuinely bring down our own individual carbon footprints.

So I guess I’m angry at China and India for watering down the COP agreement, but I’m angry at us for creating the circumstances that facilitates the attitude that made them do that.

So, I’ll now be even more consciously checking where my products are from and will not be buying anything made in China or India.

Who’s with me? (YANBU)

Who’s not? And why, out of interest? (YABU)

Happy Sunday all…!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jgw1 · 16/11/2021 07:18

[quote PlanDeRaccordement]@jgw1
they are foreign

I hope you are guessing at @HarrietsChariot’s reason!
But yes, I get that (racist) assumption a lot being of Chinese ethnicity myself.[/quote]
In a sense I am not guessing as like you suggest, it is a very common reason.

gofg · 16/11/2021 00:56

It's hard to boycott Chinese products because they are so insidious, their components are everywhere. I do try to avoid them where possible though and certainly never order food from a Chinese takeaway or deal with businesses owned by people of Chinese origin.

Are you for real !!!!!! How utterly ridiculous.

Andante57 · 15/11/2021 23:10

We never heard "think of the natives" when being told to boycott South Africa or Israel

Very true.

PlanDeRaccordement · 15/11/2021 18:05

@jgw1
they are foreign

I hope you are guessing at @HarrietsChariot’s reason!
But yes, I get that (racist) assumption a lot being of Chinese ethnicity myself.

Cornettoninja · 15/11/2021 13:42

I do try to avoid them where possible though and certainly never order food from a Chinese takeaway or deal with businesses owned by people of Chinese origin

@HarrietsChariot ah come on, surely you know that’s ridiculous?

If you’re too young have a google about Americans boycotting french fries. Same thing and just as daft.

Djifunrsn · 15/11/2021 13:41

I'm not sure you can make an ethical choice with your next phone OP. The (hazardous) components needed for it are mined and then often sorted by children, no matter who assembles or sells the phone.

Who do you think ships a shit tonne of coal to India? It's Australia. Should we boycott them also?

IsleofRum · 15/11/2021 13:35

We never heard "think of the natives" when being told to boycott South Africa or Israel.

Also if it's our fault because we "invented the industrial revolution" then that's taking " sins of the father's" way beyond sanity. Even the Nazis went back four Generations.... But then again we are talking the purest of puritans.

DrSbaitso · 15/11/2021 13:19

@HarrietsChariot

It's hard to boycott Chinese products because they are so insidious, their components are everywhere. I do try to avoid them where possible though and certainly never order food from a Chinese takeaway or deal with businesses owned by people of Chinese origin.
That's very noble of you. No, not noble. That other thing...
MareofBeasttown · 15/11/2021 13:08

@HarrietsChariot

It's hard to boycott Chinese products because they are so insidious, their components are everywhere. I do try to avoid them where possible though and certainly never order food from a Chinese takeaway or deal with businesses owned by people of Chinese origin.
Love how this thread has exposed all the closet racists on MN. You 'shouldn;t buy anything American or Australian really, by that logic.
jgw1 · 15/11/2021 12:59

[quote PlanDeRaccordement]@HarrietsChariot
certainly never order food from a Chinese takeaway or deal with businesses owned by people of Chinese origin.

Er why would that be? I understand buy local to reduce carbon footprint, but excluding local sources because they’re Chinese....why? What’s the reason?[/quote]
They are foreign.

PlanDeRaccordement · 15/11/2021 12:21

Its all very well engaging in posturing but its rank hypocrisy for the countries who created this problem and continue to be the world's biggest polluters to point the finger at countries which are still developing.

Let’s be frank. The only country that consistently is on every list no matter how you calculate- total current emissions, per capita current emissions, total cumulative emissions since 1750, per person emissions 1850-2021- is the USA 🇺🇸

Hands down the US always was and still is the elephant in the room.

PlanDeRaccordement · 15/11/2021 12:17

@Appleandoranges
Per person, UK has contributed far, far more to global warming than China and India has.

I think you misread the table in your source,
www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-which-countries-are-historically-responsible-for-climate-change

The table on the left is cumulative carbon emissions from 1850-2021 divided only by 2021 population which doesn’t show the actual per person contribution from 1850-2021. It’s to show how meaningless a simple per capita cumulative calculation is because countries didn’t have the exact same population from 1850 to 2021.

The table on the right shows the true per person contribution by country as it divides each year’s carbon emissions by that year’s population from 1850-2021 and then takes an average. As you can see, UK, India and China are not in the top 20. It doesn’t go below that.

But the point of the table is that the top 20 countries with the highest per person contribution to cumulative carbon emissions from 1850-2021 are:

  1. New Zealand
  2. Canada
  3. Australia
  4. United States
  5. Argentina
  6. Qatar
  7. Gabon
  8. Malaysia
  9. Republic of Congo
10. Nicaragua 11. Paraguay 12. Kazakhstan 13. Zambia 14. Panama 15. Cote d’Ivoire 16. Costa Rica 17. Bolivia 18. Kuwait 19. Trinidad and Tobago 20. United Arab Emirates

So it’s not really a case of “rich” countries vs “poor” countries. It’s a case of everyone’s caused this and we need everyone to be part of the solution.

PlanDeRaccordement · 15/11/2021 11:57

@gofg

U.K. is smaller market than their own country....they’re buying more of those products themselves than they are exporting to the U.K.

Do you seriously think that those countries export goods only to the UK??

Er no? My posts implies nothing of the sort. Of course they export elsewhere too. My point is that their domestic market is bigger than the UK export market.
PlanDeRaccordement · 15/11/2021 11:56

[quote Appleandoranges]@PlanDeRaccordement - your link shows that per person/capita India produces far less greenhouse gases than the UK. And also China produces far less greenhouse cases per person than Ireland and US.

ourworldindata.org/greenhouse-gas-emissions[/quote]
Yes, exactly that. Your initial post implied that U.K. emissions were more than double those of China, which is incorrect. Perhaps you meant to say US?

PlanDeRaccordement · 15/11/2021 11:53

[quote Daftasabroom]@PlanDeRaccordement emissions are measured in tonnes of CO2 equivalent and include all greenhouse gases not just carbon dioxide.[/quote]
They weren’t by the sources I was posting. They were separated out. So I felt it was more accurate to mention that than have people assume wrong that the CO2 cumulative tonnes I was posting included gasses other than CO2.

Teaandlipstick · 15/11/2021 11:52

But burning coal in India is bad for india too. I have families in India. Indian cities are the most polluted in the world. People are breathing toxic air.
Also the logic of per capita emissions is poor one. US definitely needs to lower its consumption significantly but a country like China is also responsible for overall emissions they are causing.

PlanDeRaccordement · 15/11/2021 11:50

@HarrietsChariot
certainly never order food from a Chinese takeaway or deal with businesses owned by people of Chinese origin.

Er why would that be? I understand buy local to reduce carbon footprint, but excluding local sources because they’re Chinese....why? What’s the reason?

HarrietsChariot · 15/11/2021 11:47

It's hard to boycott Chinese products because they are so insidious, their components are everywhere. I do try to avoid them where possible though and certainly never order food from a Chinese takeaway or deal with businesses owned by people of Chinese origin.

DdraigGoch · 15/11/2021 11:07

Global supply chains being what they are, you're never going to eliminate every dubious source of components unless you bought a smallholding and went full on for the Good Life. Even if you could it wouldn't change the policy. However, despite some of the defeatist comments, that's not a reason not to do what you can. In short, we just need to consume less all around.

A smartphone is essential for modern life and even if the phone itself was made in South Korea or Japan, many components will be Chinese. But even though it isn't something you can do away with entirely, there is scope for reducing the impact by using your phone for as long as possible and repairing rather than replacing when it goes wrong. Only once it is irreparable do you replace it. Even better, if you buy reconditioned gadgets, the manufacturing emissions have already been 'paid off' by the previous owner so the impact of your purchase is limited to whatever repairs were done in between.

Clothing-wise, buy better quality so that it will last. Even better, buy second hand from a charity shop.

Most of the top 100 polluting companies are oil giants. If you attribute pollution to the end user, every time you fill your petrol tank (or take a delivery from a diesel van) you bear responsibility for all that methane leaked from oil fields or flared off. So find alternatives to car transport. Even electric cars aren't ideal so a bike is preferable.

Daftasabroom · 15/11/2021 10:52

@Tealightsandd I had a feeling that the Oxfam numbers were easily misinterpreted so did a few checks.

A single person in the UK on the NLW is in the top 5.1% of global rich. A couple on UK average wage with 2 dependant children are at 3%. A joint income of £120k with 2 dependants would be comfortably in the top 1%. Even universal credit would someone in the 30%

C8H10N4O2 · 15/11/2021 09:01

Its all very well engaging in posturing but its rank hypocrisy for the countries who created this problem and continue to be the world's biggest polluters to point the finger at countries which are still developing.

As pointed out upthread, a child born in the developed world consumes bastly more than one born in the developing world. Our pet dogs consume more than children born in some parts of developing world. We cut overseas aid which funded women's education and reproductive health in poorer countries.

But yes its so much easier to point the finger at the still developing countries than really take responsibility for our own actions.

jackstini · 15/11/2021 09:00

[quote Daftasabroom]@jackstini while there may be good reasons to favour South Korea over China, emissions isn't one of them. South Korea's per capita emissions are double that of China's.[/quote]
Just to confirm I'm not recommending anything, just wanted to let the OP know this website existed
She will likely want to know that info though based on her posts so thank you 😊

Daftasabroom · 15/11/2021 08:57

@jackstini while there may be good reasons to favour South Korea over China, emissions isn't one of them. South Korea's per capita emissions are double that of China's.

jackstini · 15/11/2021 08:48

Here you go OP - this should help with the phone and other things

chinanever.com/categories/phones-not-made-in-china

Daftasabroom · 15/11/2021 08:24

@PlanDeRaccordement emissions are measured in tonnes of CO2 equivalent and include all greenhouse gases not just carbon dioxide.