Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WiBU - school or me?

112 replies

StonedRoses · 14/11/2021 08:42

DS is in Yr6. I don’t work on Mondays so those days I sort out pick up drops of etc. Rest of the week we share it.
Last Monday I get a call from school around 11am asking me to pick him up. Apparently he had a headache and looked pale. So I told them I’d be there ASAP but would take about 40min
Although it was my day off I’d popped into town to do some jobs and get stuff I can’t get locally - so I’d gone on the train as parking is impossible. Hence it took a little while to get to station and wait for train
School were not happy and said I should have been immediately available. Is that reasonable? Or possible? If I’d been working it would have taken longer

As an aside DS is hardly ever ill. So it’s not a regular thing. And perked up very quickly with a dose of calpol and an afternoon of gaming….

OP posts:
Nyxly · 14/11/2021 13:25

@FateHasRedesignedMost

School is U, but ideally you would have one parent or an emergency contact available to get there sooner. What if he’d had an accident (eg injury in PE) and needed an ambulance? Or was vomiting or very ill and distressed? 40minutes (assuming the train was on time) must feel like ages to a child, and a long time to staff if they’ve had to isolate him.

Personally I wouldn’t go shopping so far away unless DH was on call to deal with any accidents/illnesses, or my mum or aunt were staying.

I think schools assume most parents choose a school that’s within easy reach of their workplace or a relative, just in case?

How old are your kids? And where do you live that you get so much choice in which school your kids go to.

Most people don't vet a huge choice in schools and certainly don't get to pick a school close to an emergency contact, based on that.

If he needed an ambulance the school would call one and the parent would meet them at the hospital.

BadwordMcGee · 14/11/2021 13:17

What if he’d had an accident (eg injury in PE) and needed an ambulance? In that situation, work would understand that I had to drop everything and couldn't make alternative arrangements/ cancel meetings. But it's a different league to a headache!

TheBitchOfTheVicar · 14/11/2021 12:44

What do schools expect their own teachers who are parents to do if called about their own children? Drop everything and walk out of the class, leaving the pupils unsupervised?

Sometimes I wonder why the staff at my DCs' primary school behave as if many of them have never had their own children.

I have had the situation from both primary and secondary schools where they try me and don't bother with DH, despite the fact that I didn't pick up, and also wondering why I'd take so long to get to my sick child, when I work a 40-min drive away Confused

lollipoprainbow · 14/11/2021 12:40

Ridiculous don't they realise most parents work nowadays, not all sat at home drinking coffee waiting for a call from the school !!

FictionalCharacter · 14/11/2021 12:30

Schools can be quite ridiculous. Our primary was like this, they’d get huffy if you couldn’t be there when they summoned you. Each time I’d just remind them I was at work, a considerable train commute away, and ignore their huffing. Not once was the situation serious or urgent.
They’re stuck in a mythical world of the old Topsy and Tim books, where Dad goes to work and Mum is at home all day, and everyone lives a 5 minute walk from school. Even though most primary teachers and school secretaries are women and often mothers themselves, and therefore wouldn’t be able to drop everything and walk out of work if their own child needed collecting.

icedcoffees · 14/11/2021 12:28

@FateHasRedesignedMost

School is U, but ideally you would have one parent or an emergency contact available to get there sooner. What if he’d had an accident (eg injury in PE) and needed an ambulance? Or was vomiting or very ill and distressed? 40minutes (assuming the train was on time) must feel like ages to a child, and a long time to staff if they’ve had to isolate him.

Personally I wouldn’t go shopping so far away unless DH was on call to deal with any accidents/illnesses, or my mum or aunt were staying.

I think schools assume most parents choose a school that’s within easy reach of their workplace or a relative, just in case?

If he needed an ambulance, the school would ring one and a teacher would accompany the child - the parent would have to meet them at the hospital, surely?

I was sent home from school sick with stomach bugs several times and regularly had to wait 3+ hours for my parents to pick me up, and they only worked 20 minutes way.

Most parents don't work in jobs where they can just drop everything and rush out of the door on the schools' say-so, lol. They have to hand over to other colleagues, get permission from management, deal with the patient/customer they're dealing with, cancel appointments etc...

Rosebel · 14/11/2021 12:28

School are being ridiculous. Most days either me or my husband can do a pickup within about 20 minutes but if we couldn't for any reason I would expect the school to just accept we don't sit around all day waiting for a phone call

BadwordMcGee · 14/11/2021 12:27

@Gliderx

What do schools expect their own teachers who are parents to do if called about their own children? Drop everything and walk out of the class, leaving the pupils unsupervised?

If they accept that no, a teacher in charge of children cannot just leave without putting in place arrangements to cover their responsibilities, then it shouldn't be too difficult for them to comprehend that there are other professions where it is equally difficult for a parent simply to up and leave.

Happily, when we as parents entrust the welfare of our children to schools, we do so in the knowledge that they have protocols and procedures in place to deal with situations where children are unwell or injured. So they are perfectly capable of holding the fort until a parent can get there, whether it takes 2 minutes or 2 hours. It is in fact part of their job.

Schools are very good at forgetting that teachers and parents are both "ordinary people" with lives outside of the school gates.
SirChenjins · 14/11/2021 12:21

If he’s ill I mean.

SirChenjins · 14/11/2021 12:21

@Plumbear2

Just to warn you this continues untill year 11. Even in secondary they carnt send them home without an adult if they feel ill.
That’s not the case in my DS’s high school - he’s in S3 and has been able to walk home alone (with my permission and with the school’s knowledge) for over a year now.
SirChenjins · 14/11/2021 12:17

I think schools assume most parents choose a school that’s within easy reach of their workplace or a relative, just in case

What a daft thing to say.

TerryIsAllGold · 14/11/2021 12:14

The “call mum first” is beyond infuriating. DS school used to do this despite DH being first contact and working 10 mins down the road. I on the other hand at best was an hour away and about 50% of the time either over two hours away by train or a flight away.

Interestingly looking back now the only teacher at primary who ever managed to call DH first was the male class teacher.

radiohelen · 14/11/2021 12:07

YANBU my ds secondary have a detention policy that means they can text at any point in the day to say ds has detention that day and I need to pick him up at 4.15pm. We are expected to be able to do this at any time. I was told it was my problem and they expect learners to make their own arrangements to get home. They also suggested if I couldn't get him he could do it the next day but he would have to do 2hrs detention instead of 1hr.
This came to light because he was left sitting outside school for an hour after a detention I had not picked up on. He was 12 and not one teacher who walked by on their way home asked why he was there.
I think it's a safeguarding issue but they weren't arsed!

BadwordMcGee · 14/11/2021 12:04

Absolutely ridiculous. I work virtually next door to my son's school, but I'd need to handover work/ cancel meetings (no admin) find management cover. Could easily take half an hour or more.

Gliderx · 14/11/2021 11:44

What do schools expect their own teachers who are parents to do if called about their own children? Drop everything and walk out of the class, leaving the pupils unsupervised?

If they accept that no, a teacher in charge of children cannot just leave without putting in place arrangements to cover their responsibilities, then it shouldn't be too difficult for them to comprehend that there are other professions where it is equally difficult for a parent simply to up and leave.

Happily, when we as parents entrust the welfare of our children to schools, we do so in the knowledge that they have protocols and procedures in place to deal with situations where children are unwell or injured. So they are perfectly capable of holding the fort until a parent can get there, whether it takes 2 minutes or 2 hours. It is in fact part of their job.

claymodels · 14/11/2021 11:37

@FateHasRedesignedMost

School is U, but ideally you would have one parent or an emergency contact available to get there sooner. What if he’d had an accident (eg injury in PE) and needed an ambulance? Or was vomiting or very ill and distressed? 40minutes (assuming the train was on time) must feel like ages to a child, and a long time to staff if they’ve had to isolate him.

Personally I wouldn’t go shopping so far away unless DH was on call to deal with any accidents/illnesses, or my mum or aunt were staying.

I think schools assume most parents choose a school that’s within easy reach of their workplace or a relative, just in case?

Most parents don't put their life on hold, work or otherwise, just in case their child may need an ambulance at school. I realise in some cases where a child has known medical conditions that make the chances of admission by ambulance higher, then being available quickly may be sensible. But generally, for all parents? The idea is ridiculous.

Whataday21 · 14/11/2021 11:28

FateHasRedesignedMost 😆

BungleandGeorge · 14/11/2021 11:16

Yes things have changed. In the days before mobile phones it was pretty common that a parent couldn’t be contacted at all!

Sceptre86 · 14/11/2021 11:15

if my dh was in the office it would take him an hour to get to our kids outside of rush hour. If they called me it would take longer as I would need my boss to get cover otherwise the pharmacy would have to close until another pharmacist arrived.

Even for a sahp it is ridiculous for them to expect you to be available immediately. What if you don't drive and need to walk or take a bus?

School are being unreasonable.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 14/11/2021 11:10

That's utterly farcical.

I regularly pick up my nieces and nephews. I'm listed as an emergency contact and they know when I'm coming. They rang my sister when she was in labour as one of them wasn't well. They knew she was in labour, they knew I was doing pick up, they have my number. What the fuck.

In usual times, my sister could be at work (without a car) about 5 miles away, not far in itself but would take a long time to walk.

WeBuiltCisCityOnSexistRoles · 14/11/2021 11:09

How long did you take to get there @StonedRoses?

I once had a call about a head injury and could I come ASAP? School was over 30 miles away and I couldn't drive. They rang an ambulance and I met DC at hospital (luckily no fractures just a concussion). The difference is that DC attended a special school and that was the nearest suitable school.

Not everyone can get there ASAP for all sorts of reasons and good schools recognise that. If the child cannot wait for 40 mins to be collected and taken for medical attention, surely school should be ringing an ambulance anyway?

FateHasRedesignedMost · 14/11/2021 11:03

School is U, but ideally you would have one parent or an emergency contact available to get there sooner. What if he’d had an accident (eg injury in PE) and needed an ambulance? Or was vomiting or very ill and distressed? 40minutes (assuming the train was on time) must feel like ages to a child, and a long time to staff if they’ve had to isolate him.

Personally I wouldn’t go shopping so far away unless DH was on call to deal with any accidents/illnesses, or my mum or aunt were staying.

I think schools assume most parents choose a school that’s within easy reach of their workplace or a relative, just in case?

Tailendofsummer · 14/11/2021 11:02

The one time I got a call from primary that included the word "ambulance" in it is was amazing how quickly I was out the door and driving to the hospital.
I think you need to think how you would react to getting to a mildly poorly child but also how far away do you want to be in a genuine emergency.

Bunnycat101 · 14/11/2021 11:00

Well if I was in London it could take nearly 2 hours depending on trains. I don’t have family any closer. Wfh reduces the probability of problems but there isn’t much I can do about it if I want a job. Equally a sahm could be out for the day and not immediately available.

Iamnotthe1 · 14/11/2021 10:59

@AnUnlikelyCombination

Which is why parents need to think very carefully about who they list as emergency contacts (if theu have options). Sometimes there needs to be a clear difference between parental contact and emergency contact.

Absolutely. Local granny is third on the form with a note saying she’s local and to call her if they can’t get me or DH (we sometimes wfh, so it’s worth trying us first). But it doesn’t happen, last time I emerged from underground to three missed calls, DH got one, they didn’t try granny.

Ugh. Can't help schools who don't help themselves.