Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WiBU - school or me?

112 replies

StonedRoses · 14/11/2021 08:42

DS is in Yr6. I don’t work on Mondays so those days I sort out pick up drops of etc. Rest of the week we share it.
Last Monday I get a call from school around 11am asking me to pick him up. Apparently he had a headache and looked pale. So I told them I’d be there ASAP but would take about 40min
Although it was my day off I’d popped into town to do some jobs and get stuff I can’t get locally - so I’d gone on the train as parking is impossible. Hence it took a little while to get to station and wait for train
School were not happy and said I should have been immediately available. Is that reasonable? Or possible? If I’d been working it would have taken longer

As an aside DS is hardly ever ill. So it’s not a regular thing. And perked up very quickly with a dose of calpol and an afternoon of gaming….

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Skysblue · 15/11/2021 11:03

School being v unreasonable. Are they really suggesting that no mothers should work??

FateHasRedesignedMost · 15/11/2021 07:20

A hospital doctor, HCP , nurse, a teacher, a lecturer, carer, a contractor/ labourer in midst of a job, none of those for eg could walk out of their responsibilities immediately to go collect a child from school

Some can. I work in a hospital, if any staff are called to school to pick up an ill child the rest of the MDT take on their workload and delegate anything urgent, re-organise staff to make up the numbers etc. (By ill I mean child is primary age and vomiting/injured/properly unwell not a teenager with a headache).

The same happens if a member of staff is suddenly taken ill at work and has to leave; nobody expects them to spend half an hour handing over or briefing colleagues. They just inform whoever they must and go. It happens a lot, eg when norovirus or other winter bugs hit the wards and staff drop like flies. Ward managers are prepared for any staff member (of any discipline) to get sick at any moment and have to go straight home (or straight to the bathroom until they’re fit to drive in some cases).

A child ill at school is unfortunate but IME schools do seem to expect you to get there quickly. I appreciate that’s impossible for some parents. But school staff are stretched for numbers too, so a vomiting or feverish child needing to be isolated on a 1:1 for an hour takes a member of staff away from their job, as well as exposing him/her to a bug.

safclass · 14/11/2021 23:58

At all of our schools they call the number that parents put first on their contact list, and work down the list until they get a response.

lanthanum · 14/11/2021 23:38

@Mistressiggi

I can guarantee you that if I see the name of my dc's schools flash up on my watch during class time, I will be answering that call!
In a way, it's better if they contact the school office, for a teacher parent. That way, someone can start organising cover immediately, so that by the time you get the message you know that someone is on their way.
Mistressiggi · 14/11/2021 23:17

I can guarantee you that if I see the name of my dc's schools flash up on my watch during class time, I will be answering that call!

SweetBabyCheeses99 · 14/11/2021 18:42

Surely plenty of the staff at the school have school ages children of their own?! Is your child’s teacher able to answer personal calls during lessons and then leave immediately? Of course not. Ridiculous.

Whereismumhiding3 · 14/11/2021 18:35

And most people would be lucky to work within 10 minutes of their child's school!

What about the parents that don't drive? They might be a 45 mins walk away, even for their catchment school. In London children can end up going to schools over an hours commute away. Let alone the distance then for parent from their job as well, Eve if they did leave immediately.

Whereismumhiding3 · 14/11/2021 18:32

No yanbu
School were being unreasonable
You can take this up by an email to the head
That you responded and came direct to the school and would they like to show the policy that says "parents cannot work nor run essential errands during the school day as they must be within 10 minutes of the school at all times"?

No ? That's because there is no policy that says that and it would be unworkable as would discriminate against working parents.

A hospital doctor, HCP , nurse, a teacher, a lecturer, carer, a contractor/ labourer in midst of a job, none of those for eg could walk out of their responsibilities immediately to go collect a child from school (unless it was high risk for the child as they were waiting for an ambulance or had covid symptoms- we would risk assess)

Whynotnowbaby · 14/11/2021 18:17

Also, emergency contacts are tricky too, I don’t have any friends who are at home all day and could pick up my child either, my parents live in another country so the emergency contacts listed for my dc are really just other people who won’t be able to collect them, not ideal but I’m not sure what else I’m supposed to do.

Whynotnowbaby · 14/11/2021 18:15

I think some pp are incredibly lucky they have jobs that are so easy to hand over and be out the door. I am a teacher in a school that is struggling for staff, it would be very difficult for me to get out at short notice, although of course my colleagues would rally round to help if they could. It must be lovely for the staff in these schools that they can clearly be at their own children’s schools in the blink of an eye and so imagine we all can, but many of us just can’t!

StonedRoses · 14/11/2021 18:15

Maybe I’m a bit hard-hearted because of my job (anaesthetist) - but he certainly wasn’t critically ill when I got there!! I answers straight away when they called and told them I was on my way and would be about 45min. They asked if I could come any quicker and the tone seemed to be that they weren’t happy with that!

At least school called me first, the boy told them rightly that’s his mum works on a Monday but I don’t. It doesn’t mean I don’t have things to do though. I’m now wondering whether it’s safe to go for a short walk tomorrow or should I stay within 5min of my car at all times!

OP posts:
coldwarenigma · 14/11/2021 18:04

Utterly silly, most parents work and can't just drop everything. Schools need to get real.
As others have said it's not that far in the distant past that once a child was in school then parents were generally uncontactable. I can't remember being called to pick my DC up but it was a village school 8 miles away. I didn't have a car for periods of time. And in my case, in the stone age certainly most of my classmates and I didn't have home phones, mobiles were Sci fi..we had a sick room and unless it was something that required a doctor you stayed there until home time.

DeepaBeesKit · 14/11/2021 17:35

I think schools assume most parents choose a school that’s within easy reach of their workplace or a relative, just in case

This is mad. There are very few employers within 30 mins of my child's school, I'd be limited to working in the supermarket!

DeepaBeesKit · 14/11/2021 17:31

Work understand that an ill or injured child means you need to drop everything and go. I’m surprised more workplaces don’t get that.

A "headache and looks pale" isn't "drop everything and go".

Nyxly · 14/11/2021 17:29

@FateHasRedesignedMost

How old are your kids? And where do you live that you get so much choice in which school your kids go to

Eldest is 6, I’m pregnant with the next one.

I had son in nursery full time before school, if he was struck by a vomiting bug or covid symptoms nursery expect you to pick up ASAP, I can’t imagine they’d be impressed with a 40-minute wait. School were much the same in Reception. Once he had an accident in the playground and they rang me advising it might need stitching, it was a cut to his face. I was able to pick him up within 10mins, clean it and steri strip it at home. Rather than him sitting distressed and bleeding in reception while the staff panicked about what to do. I realise I’m lucky, but I also made choices along the way that allowed me to be in a position to pick up when needed.

We live in a medium sized town, but chose the nursery and school closest to our house. One of us is often WFH. I changed jobs to be closer to home when we moved. Otherwise I’d have had over an hour’s commute if anything happened and DH wasn’t available. He often works abroad.

Work understand that an ill or injured child means you need to drop everything and go. I’m surprised more workplaces don’t get that. If I have to dash off I simply handover to the nearest colleague, leave a message for the ward manager and go.

Most can't/ don't wfh.

Most people do apply for schools closest to their school because closest to work is a catchment criteria. Neither is 'near an emergency contact.'

Most people would fling work at a colleague but that also takes a few minutes. Then walking to the car. Then driving, parking up and walking into the school.

Most people can't just move jobs to one closer to their home, because they want to be close to school, just incase the child is ever ill.

Most people give lots of different contact numbers.

Most people wouldn't be able to just be close by and work because their husbands were away.

I live a 5 min walk from my sons school and do wfh. But it's really not that hard to think of a situation where its just not possible.

If I was in the office, I would need to brief one of my staff on a meeting I would need them to do on my behalf. Maybe a couple. I can't just hand paperwork over and expect them to take time out, to get up to speed. Thats not how my job works.Then get out of the office then drive to the school. Again, our head office is a 10 minute drive from my house. But you can't park near the near the to the school. The parent parking is further away than my house. So I need to park at home.

Even with me being close by, adapt would be around 30 mins. 10 mins less than it took the op. Trains run through the town I live in. I could easily get stuck at a crossing for 10 mins on the way.

ASAP is nor a specific time. If it takes 40 mins it takes 40 mins. That is as soon as its possible.

DeepaBeesKit · 14/11/2021 17:29

Ha. Neither DH or I can get home from work in under an hour, and tbh that's with regular rush hour trains, there's a window in the middle of the day when there's fewer trains and it can take 1h 30 to get home.

I have a local childminder/mum friends who could help in a serious/no option situation (for example: school is flooded all children must be collected immediately). I wouldnt expect to call on that for the situation you describe.

Most people where we live are in the same position - commuting to London. Its an expensive area and there aren't that many SAHPs because most people need two incomes to afford housing here.

It used to be common here to rely on au pairs but they are increasingly hard to get.

DixonD · 14/11/2021 17:15

I work a 15 minute drive from my child’s school. It would still take me about 40 minutes to get to her, including packing up time at work.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 14/11/2021 17:14

Also, school have the phone number for my office, the ward and reception in case they can’t get hold of me on my mobile. The same goes for other staff, it’s not unusual to take an urgent message for someone who needs to pick up their ill child from school.

I guess it’s different in secondary when kids can wait longer?

FateHasRedesignedMost · 14/11/2021 17:10

How old are your kids? And where do you live that you get so much choice in which school your kids go to

Eldest is 6, I’m pregnant with the next one.

I had son in nursery full time before school, if he was struck by a vomiting bug or covid symptoms nursery expect you to pick up ASAP, I can’t imagine they’d be impressed with a 40-minute wait. School were much the same in Reception. Once he had an accident in the playground and they rang me advising it might need stitching, it was a cut to his face. I was able to pick him up within 10mins, clean it and steri strip it at home. Rather than him sitting distressed and bleeding in reception while the staff panicked about what to do. I realise I’m lucky, but I also made choices along the way that allowed me to be in a position to pick up when needed.

We live in a medium sized town, but chose the nursery and school closest to our house. One of us is often WFH. I changed jobs to be closer to home when we moved. Otherwise I’d have had over an hour’s commute if anything happened and DH wasn’t available. He often works abroad.

Work understand that an ill or injured child means you need to drop everything and go. I’m surprised more workplaces don’t get that. If I have to dash off I simply handover to the nearest colleague, leave a message for the ward manager and go.

lentilsforever · 14/11/2021 16:55

@FictionalCharacter

Schools can be quite ridiculous. Our primary was like this, they’d get huffy if you couldn’t be there when they summoned you. Each time I’d just remind them I was at work, a considerable train commute away, and ignore their huffing. Not once was the situation serious or urgent. They’re stuck in a mythical world of the old Topsy and Tim books, where Dad goes to work and Mum is at home all day, and everyone lives a 5 minute walk from school. Even though most primary teachers and school secretaries are women and often mothers themselves, and therefore wouldn’t be able to drop everything and walk out of work if their own child needed collecting.
The OP is MALE Grin
lentilsforever · 14/11/2021 16:54

@TerryIsAllGold

The “call mum first” is beyond infuriating. DS school used to do this despite DH being first contact and working 10 mins down the road. I on the other hand at best was an hour away and about 50% of the time either over two hours away by train or a flight away.

Interestingly looking back now the only teacher at primary who ever managed to call DH first was the male class teacher.

The op is MALE
DahliaMacNamara · 14/11/2021 15:18

@FateHasRedesignedMost

School is U, but ideally you would have one parent or an emergency contact available to get there sooner. What if he’d had an accident (eg injury in PE) and needed an ambulance? Or was vomiting or very ill and distressed? 40minutes (assuming the train was on time) must feel like ages to a child, and a long time to staff if they’ve had to isolate him.

Personally I wouldn’t go shopping so far away unless DH was on call to deal with any accidents/illnesses, or my mum or aunt were staying.

I think schools assume most parents choose a school that’s within easy reach of their workplace or a relative, just in case?

I'd be astonished if there was a single school in the country that had 'distance to workplace/relative' in their admissions criteria.
billy1966 · 14/11/2021 14:55

Utterly ridiculous.

Have you asked for a clarification?

Completely inappropriate response from them.

Parents do not spend their time whilst their children are at school hovering 2 minutes away, waiting for a possible call.

🙄

Meatshake · 14/11/2021 14:04

@LeroyJenkinssss

I’ve had similar to a previous poster. School have rung me twice, were irate that I didn’t pick up straight away. I wasn’t best pleased that they hadn’t tried my DH who is a SAHP and listed as first contact. Their response? We always ring mum first regardless.
That's utterly stupid and sexist. Your poor DH! Sad Well done for not telling them that "that sounds like a you problem, not a me problem" or similar!
Mistressiggi · 14/11/2021 13:39

Teachers leave school too when their dc are unwell. You can't literally walk out but a phone call and a quick discussion and you're out the door. I've stayed till the end of a lesson when it was cleared not very urgent, but I'm not normally called about non urgent things.

Swipe left for the next trending thread