Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if I should have known? Or does it happen later?

31 replies

Todaywastheday · 14/11/2021 08:13

I’m getting out of an emotionally abusive marriage and have so many thoughts going round my head.

I’ve noticed a lot of threads on here saying ‘why would you have kids with someone like that?’ But the more I think about my own situation, everything was ok before kids and since then its been different (mainly expecting me to do a lot and calling me a bully if I ask for help/support/giving me the silent treatment if I don’t just accept his way).

AIBU to have not realised sooner? Some things I’ve read suggest that emotional abuse can start after children. Any thoughts on whether that’s right? Or why?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Todaywastheday · 14/11/2021 14:19

Thank you all. Its been really helpful to get out of my head and hear your thoughts. Its so tough because obviously I’m not perfect and finding a balance between taking responsibility for my part and not falling in a hole of self blame is hard.

OP posts:
FreedomFaith · 14/11/2021 12:29

I think the same as others, that there maybe are signs before having children, but they are so subtle that it's difficult to notice a pattern, plus you also aren't knackered, stressed etc so things go unnoticed.

Like pressuring for sex after having children. This is likely to have still been the case before children too, but you weren't knackered then. You probably wanted it too, whether to make a baby or just for pleasure and out of love for your partner, so it never felt like pressure and you rarely said no. Suddenly though the baby comes along and you're now too tired and sore to have sex. The abusive partner doesn't give a toss though.

Or the tidying up the house. They probably didn't help much before anyway other than doing a few jobs, and you had more time because you had no baby, so you didn't notice or care much. Thought he would change when the baby comes along and help out more. But he doesn't help out more, and lack of the sex he wants makes him want to help less.

It's still all the abusive partners fault though. No one has a reason to be abusive towards another person, ever. So no matter what, whether there were maybe subtle signs or nothing at all, it's not your fault.

Catastrophejane · 14/11/2021 11:05

@FOJN

OP I'm an absolutely take no shit from anyone type of person but I could not clearly see the abuse in my marriage until it was over. So often the abuse is insidious, it ramps up almost imperceptibly and becomes normalised in the process. You recognise something is wrong but your abuser convinces you it's your fault even though that doesn't feel quite right either.

The boiling a frog analogy works and its impossible to understand if you haven't experienced it. When you look back you can see critical points where you think what was happening should have been obvious but it wasn't to you at the time. It's very confusing but it was not and never will be your fault, it's the nature of relationships with abusers.

If someone doesn't understand it I try to feel pleased for them that they have never been in that situation. More abused women in the world would not be a good thing.

This is exactly my experience.

Even 5 years down the line, I was questioning myself this morning - thinking about how things could’ve been very different if I’d just noticed something or responded differently to his abuse.

The truth is that anyone in your position would’ve behaved the same way. People are kidding themselves if they think they’d have noticed or behaved differently.

There is a myth pedalled that domestic abuse victims are singled out because they are already ‘vulnerable’ or ‘susceptible’. That is bullshit. It’s also the reason why it took me so long to realise what was happening- domestic wasn’t the kind of thing that could happen to me. I’m confident, independent, healthy self-esteem etc.

You were just unlucky

TrollsAreSaddos · 14/11/2021 10:27

OP
I guess the problem is that I have done things wrong and could have been better, which I think is probably true of everyone in any relationship

I'm sure that there are some 100% blameless people in the world but surely they are rare. Acknowledging that you've made some bad decisions or done the wrong thing sometimes means you are more more likely to know what NOT to do next time. It isn't victim blaming, It's acknowledging that you are human. NOONE deserves to be abused in a relationship even if they were not perfect themselves.

sassbott · 14/11/2021 10:03

OP.

You could have done everything right. You could have been the ‘perfect’ mother (and I’m not saying you aren’t already by the way). You could have been the perfect wife - never stressed, or tired etc etc. This will still have happened I’m afraid to say. The thing about abusers is it doesn’t matter what you do, what you say, it is never enough. They will constantly come at you and find something in you lacking.

You’re trying to figure this out, that’s good. But if stop focusing on what you could have done differently and instead understand the makeup/ mind of the abuser. Once you understand the beast you are dealing with, you will appreciate how little it was to do with you and how this is him.

Kind and loving people do not use their partners mental health (PND), against them, ever.

I highly recommend you read a boom by Lundy Bancroft, why does he do that? It’s so well written and will help you unpick some of this x

ChinstrapBobblehat · 14/11/2021 09:58

The birth of our kids was also the tipping point in my marriage. As PPs have said, the combination of pressures - small children, lack of sleep, moving to a bigger house, higher outgoings, much more stressful job - resulted in DH’s mental health taking a nosedive. As a result of which he became ever more unreasonable, demanding, controlling, spiteful and generally cunty.

And I had stupidly given up my career a few years in, so I was effectively quite isolated and felt like it was my ‘job’ and duty to make everything ok for him, so increasingly the whole household revolved around his needs and no one else’s.

The whole shitshow was a bit of a boiled frog situation, tbh - over a 10 year period we slowly went from being happy and optimistic and effectively a pretty good team, to me being permanently anxious, unhappy and treading on eggs, and him being correspondingly more controlling and abusive (though never physically).

We’re still together (when he realsed I was about to leave him for good it shook him out of his denial) but it’s taken years of work to repair the damage and it’ll never be the same as it was when we were young. There’s part of me that’ll always be a little bit broken, I think, partly from the shame of it (I appear to be a stridently confident and articulate person; no one in a million years would guess that was the true dynamic of our relationship behind closed doors), and partly from grief at those lost years when I was in the thick of it.

The other thing to say is that my DH, though he has behaved unforgivably in some ways, is a good person, who battles daily with his mental health and demons from his awful childhood. People are complicated. Relationships are difficult.

So in answer to your question, OP, no, you definitely can’t always see it coming, and anyone who tries to blame or shame you can get to fuck.

Todaywastheday · 14/11/2021 09:52

@GoodnightGrandma

While you are continuing to blame yourself he is still abusing you. Please set yourself free, and well done for getting out 💐
I guess the problem is that I have done things wrong and could have been better, which I think is probably true of everyone in any relationship…
OP posts:
Todaywastheday · 14/11/2021 09:51

@Dozer

It sounds like you’re v much in still in the abusive relationship. Have you made the decision to plan to separate?
I’ve filed for divorce but we are having to still live in the same house
OP posts:
CaptSkippy · 14/11/2021 09:46

OP, sometimes there are signs before hand (although those can also be difficult to recognize unless you know exactly what top look for), but just as often there are no signs till marriage or pregnancy or some other important lifechanging event. Or it starts so slowly that it's like a frog in slowly boiling water situation.

Problem is that we are not experts. We often don't learn what to look for till we are faced with the situation outselves.

GoodnightGrandma · 14/11/2021 09:26

While you are continuing to blame yourself he is still abusing you.
Please set yourself free, and well done for getting out 💐

lazylinguist · 14/11/2021 09:26

I would never say 'Why did you have children with this man?!' because it's pointless and because there are lots of women with have traumatic pasts or dysfunctional family backgrounds who understandably find it difficult to make good relationship choices.

However, that doesn't mean that the signs aren't there early on in a relationship, even if the man doesn't become abusive until later. Very often in threads where a woman is contrasting what their husband was like early on compared with what he turned into later, the description of the 'perfect' early version sets my alarm bells ringing tbh.

Anyway OP, it's very unlikely he's changed from a good, kind man into a horrible one. He's probably just showing his true colours which were there all along underneath. Either way, it's not your fault. How could it be?

Dozer · 14/11/2021 09:12

Accusations of ‘bullying’ can be abusive.
Silent treatment is abusive.
Saying nasty things about your PND is abusive.

Dozer · 14/11/2021 09:12

It sounds like you’re v much in still in the abusive relationship. Have you made the decision to plan to separate?

TrollsAreSaddos · 14/11/2021 09:06

I suspect there are often signs that someone is abusive before they snd their partner has kids and sometimes it's is appropriate to wonder why on earth the woman has kids with them. That's NOT victim blaming though. There are lots of reasons why women have kids with men who are abusive. I suspect hormones play a massive part. My drive to get pregnant when I was younger was massive and I'm sure it is for others. Look at the millions of threads where women are contemplating having kids when their are a million reason they shouldn't.
It's also hard to leave someone even if they are abusive . Again look at the zillions of threads where women (with and without kids) stay with abusive men. It's not victim blaming to question it. It helps understand why they are in that situation. You can be sympathetic and understanding at the same time
I know some men only become abusive after a woman has had a child but I bet with many are beforehand too it's just that it's not as much as a 'problem' before having kids where stress, money issues, sex issues(? I guess) attention, tiredness etc become more of a problem.

Todaywastheday · 14/11/2021 09:03

@jamaisjedors

I've asked myself this question a lot and i understand why you are going over this in your mind.

I still feel a lot of grief more than 2 years after leaving, although it was unquestionably the right thing to do.

For me, with hindsight, there were some red flags there from the start or at least indications of controlling behaviour but i was young and ignored them.

Also it was only occasional so didn't seem an issue.

It's hard to put my finger on the combination of things which made it turn into emotional abuse... Having kids, stress at work for exh, 2 high pressure jobs, a big house and garden... Or getting older and reverting to childhood patterns...

I'm not excusing it, exh knew what he was doing and thought i deserved to be "punished".

But i understand you are looking for answers about how things could have gone differently.

Thank you for this. What you have described (minus the garden) is basically my exact situation. We’ve had so much on our plate with the kids and work and obviously covid and lockdowns as well. I have sometimes got to tired and stressed and he says I have taken that out on him and I wish I could go back and handle it all better. But then I think I really have tried my best. He never seems to offer me support and if I ask he says I’m bullying him and then will ignore me until I try and make amends. I know its not right but I can’t help but think maybe if i had been better it could have been avoided
OP posts:
IknowwhatIneed · 14/11/2021 09:02

I guess this is all tied up with worrying its all my fault after all. I think he changed, but did I cause that I suppose is what’s going through my head.

It might help to recognise this thought pattern as part of the abuse? You’re left feeling it’s your fault because he communicates day after day that it’s you - if you just did x, y and z he wouldn’t need to be so cruel to you. You bring it out in him you see?

And of course, it’s designed to make you not challenge, and certainly not leave, because if it’s your fault you deserve to be treated badly.

Try instead to put responsibility where it belongs, firmly at his door. He chose his behaviour, he did it. You’re doing the only safe, honourable thing in the circumstances- leaving him to get on with it.

FOJN · 14/11/2021 09:00

OP I'm an absolutely take no shit from anyone type of person but I could not clearly see the abuse in my marriage until it was over. So often the abuse is insidious, it ramps up almost imperceptibly and becomes normalised in the process. You recognise something is wrong but your abuser convinces you it's your fault even though that doesn't feel quite right either.

The boiling a frog analogy works and its impossible to understand if you haven't experienced it. When you look back you can see critical points where you think what was happening should have been obvious but it wasn't to you at the time. It's very confusing but it was not and never will be your fault, it's the nature of relationships with abusers.

If someone doesn't understand it I try to feel pleased for them that they have never been in that situation. More abused women in the world would not be a good thing.

jamaisjedors · 14/11/2021 08:51

I've asked myself this question a lot and i understand why you are going over this in your mind.

I still feel a lot of grief more than 2 years after leaving, although it was unquestionably the right thing to do.

For me, with hindsight, there were some red flags there from the start or at least indications of controlling behaviour but i was young and ignored them.

Also it was only occasional so didn't seem an issue.

It's hard to put my finger on the combination of things which made it turn into emotional abuse... Having kids, stress at work for exh, 2 high pressure jobs, a big house and garden... Or getting older and reverting to childhood patterns...

I'm not excusing it, exh knew what he was doing and thought i deserved to be "punished".

But i understand you are looking for answers about how things could have gone differently.

Bagelsandbrie · 14/11/2021 08:48

Don’t start blaming yourself. People who say these things often have NO experience of what these types of men are like or what it’s like to be in this sort of relationship.

I was with my now ex for nearly 6 years before we had dd. We were blissfully happy, no issues whatsoever. He turned into an abusive arsehole the minute I had dd. I had a bad birth experience and he would pressure me into sex, bully me and basically make my life hell. I left when she was about 8 months old. But before I had dd I could never have predicted what would happen.

Todaywastheday · 14/11/2021 08:45

I guess this is all tied up with worrying its all my fault after all. I think he changed, but did I cause that I suppose is what’s going through my head.

OP posts:
Todaywastheday · 14/11/2021 08:43

@Tal45

And of course people may not realise they are in an abusive situation because they are being lied to, coerced, manipulated, gas-lit etc and it can be quite subtle especially at first.
Yes, I think it can be hard to understand this if you haven’t been through it.
OP posts:
Todaywastheday · 14/11/2021 08:42

@mdh2020

My sister was married to an an abusive man. The abuse started on honeymoon. We never liked him - too smarmy - but never suspected what he would do to her physically, emotionally and mentally. She lasted three years and ran away one night in bare feet with just the clothes she stood up in. some men are good actors.
That’s awful. I hope she is doing ok now.
OP posts:
Tal45 · 14/11/2021 08:32

And of course people may not realise they are in an abusive situation because they are being lied to, coerced, manipulated, gas-lit etc and it can be quite subtle especially at first.

mdh2020 · 14/11/2021 08:30

My sister was married to an an abusive man. The abuse started on honeymoon. We never liked him - too smarmy - but never suspected what he would do to her physically, emotionally and mentally. She lasted three years and ran away one night in bare feet with just the clothes she stood up in. some men are good actors.

Todaywastheday · 14/11/2021 08:29

@parrotonmyshoulder

People very often stride in here shouting ‘why did you have kids with this person?’. It smacks of an insidious type of victim blaming. The dynamic changes when you have children, of course. Their needs come first for you, for a long time.
Thank you. I think I needed to hear this.

Its hard because I had PND with our first which he throws in my face, but I’ve been well a long time and had another since with no PND, so I can’t help but think if things had been different and if I juggled everything better we might still be together. Sometimes its just so overwhelming though. I really have tried my best.

OP posts: