Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? If only was you was a girl!

56 replies

AIBUboygirlwhocares · 13/11/2021 22:04

I have five sons. Me and DH are happy with our boys and have never wished for a girl etc.

MIL turned round to my youngest DS today and said "if only you was a girl..." referring to something girly she saw.

AIBU to be annoyed? My poor DS didn't know what to say back.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Maulstick · 15/11/2021 15:30

But the OP's grammar, from what I remember, was perfectly standard apart from the quotation from her MIL, so I assumed it was a deliberate reportage of her MIL's remark. Which was incredibly unpleasant anyway, regardless of its phraseology.

tallduckandhandsome · 15/11/2021 13:59

@WildExcuses

For the OP to correct her MIL's grammar would have been a perfectly appropriate response to a dimwit, insensitive comment -- I mean, engaging with the actual intent behind the comment would be just depressing.

But for all we know it could have been OPs grammar that was ‘wrong’ instead of or as well as the MILs ....posters are aware of that and pretending they’re not. 🙄

Exactly. OP has explained it’s a regional accent so she probably says ‘you was’ too.

And yes, people here are pretending they haven’t seen that so they can keep indirectly sneering at OP.

Comedycook · 15/11/2021 10:37

She shouldn't have said that to him..poor boy

WildExcuses · 15/11/2021 10:36

For the OP to correct her MIL's grammar would have been a perfectly appropriate response to a dimwit, insensitive comment -- I mean, engaging with the actual intent behind the comment would be just depressing.

But for all we know it could have been OPs grammar that was ‘wrong’ instead of or as well as the MILs ....posters are aware of that and pretending they’re not. 🙄

RosettaR · 15/11/2021 10:21

My husband has an older brother and his parents always talk about how they wanted a girl, in fact they were told he was a girl at their scan so the were disappointedwhen he was born. We now have two boys and if we ever talk about having a third child my husband sees it in terms of how badly do we want to try for a girl. I've explained you can't see it like that, if we have a third it's 50 50 and it's not like you can hand it back if it's a boy!

People are strange basically. But no she shouldn't have said that.

EmeraldShamrock · 15/11/2021 10:12

It is an awful thing to say under normal circumstances given your update it was more than awful, absolutely disgusting comments from Granny.
I'd have ask the DC to wait outside and ate her for breakfast.
I'm so sorry for your losses. Flowers

Maulstick · 15/11/2021 10:09

@WildExcuses

Message deleted by MNHQ.
For the OP to correct her MIL's grammar would have been a perfectly appropriate response to a dimwit, insensitive comment -- I mean, engaging with the actual intent behind the comment would be just depressing.
Cherrysoup · 15/11/2021 10:08

I think I’d pick her up on this and give her an absolute rollicking. What a horrible thing to say to your boy, particularly given it’s her son that has decided the sex of the children.

AryaStarkWolf · 15/11/2021 10:06

@AIBUboygirlwhocares

Well actually there is a back story I have two living sons. My other three sons died at birth. So you'd think she wouldn't say shit like that and be grateful that my two living boys thrived but hey. BlushSad Makes me feel like she wants me to get pregnant for the sake of giving her a grand daughter.
I'm so sorry for your loss, that really makes her comment shitty (it wouldn't have been good either way obviously)
WildExcuses · 15/11/2021 10:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Maulstick · 15/11/2021 09:47

@IncyWinceySpiderWillies

You should have corrected her grammar.
Grin Grin
tallduckandhandsome · 15/11/2021 09:46

My advice would be to ignore the grammar pedants who clearly have nothing better to do and OP to keep saying ‘you was’ if she wants to.

IncyWinceySpiderWillies · 15/11/2021 00:23

OP needs actual advice not a smug and glib response
What was your good advice to Op?

I’m sorry for your losses, op.

Greygreenblue · 14/11/2021 11:24

It would make me livid. I always wondered if my parents wished I was a boy (am youngest of 3 girls). It may have been off the cuff as Pp said but a comment like that from my grandmother would have confirmed what I already feared.

I also have 3 girls and do not appreciate any suggestions we might wish otherwise.

Somethingsnappy · 14/11/2021 11:00

'If only you were a lovely grandmother', sounds like the perfect response. I definitely agree with a PP on that one.
So sorry for your losses.

Cheeserton · 14/11/2021 10:39

Definitely the grammar first.

Cocomarine · 14/11/2021 10:37

It depends on how old your son is, what his relationship is like with his grandmother, and if she’s usually an arsehole.

Pointing to a frilly tutu and nudging a 10yo and saying, “if only you were a girl” with a big smile and him then laughing and saying, “nooooo - that’s hideous!” (Or a laughing: “hmmmm, I reckon I could rock that as a girl or boy nana, we don’t do sexism now you know 😝”) would just be perfectly normal messing around.

Possibly over reaction?

Sally872 · 14/11/2021 10:21

Rubbish thing to say and even worse seeing your update. Sorry for your loss Flowers

Eyesofdisarray · 14/11/2021 10:18

Hurtful OP, especially with your history ⚘

NoDecentHandlesLeft · 14/11/2021 10:12

I would have been annoyed too OP. Probably too annoyed to reply!
Apart from being hurtful, what exactly is "girly" anyway? Sexist as well.

QueenofLouisiana · 14/11/2021 09:54

My MIL would probably have said something similar. She’s never forgiven me for producing a son and stopping at one. In her mind we could afford more children and she wanted a girl so why didn’t we oblige? (Crippling PND with intrusive, self-harming thoughts mainly.) Instead she has limited herself to complaining that I could have waited a few hours and finished giving birth in the same month as her birthday, rather than late at night on the final day of the preceding month. I’d been in active labour for 20 hours and couldn’t have told you what day if the week it was, never mind the month!

StepAwayFromGoogling · 14/11/2021 09:51

@cheeseismydownfall - yep, that's why I'm asking. I studied linguistics at university. There's a lot of appalling use of language that people excuse by saying 'oh, it's regional' when it's not.

Penistoe · 14/11/2021 09:49

Depends on what you mean saw something girly.

If she saw a beautiful dress and said to her grandson if only you were a girl it’s a harmless off the cuff comment more related to the dress than the kid. I am quite shocked it’s caused a huge drama. Unless there is a whole evil mil backstory.

2typesofjungle · 14/11/2021 09:49

Fuck me, seeing your update I can without a doubt in my mind confirm that your MIL is an absolute cockwomble and she needs to fuck right off.
YANBU!

cheeseismydownfall · 14/11/2021 09:48

@StepAwayFromGoogling

In what part of the country is 'you was' part of regional dialect?! It's just shit grammar.
Jesus christ, have you bothered to read all the OP's posts?