Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that very few celebrities have the 'x factor'

256 replies

Bargaincatfood · 13/11/2021 21:30

not an intellectual thread
Especially not most of those who won the show?! I remember the year 1direction were in it, my friends and I used to watch it before going out. We used to talk about the curly haired one, he wasn't that good looking, wasn't the best singer or the best dancer but my god was he mesmerising. Even my mum commented on him. Now he's the only one out of that insanely popular band with any semblance of a career.
It makes me think how few celebrities there are with that utterly mesmerising, star quality, where they're the only person you pay attention to on stage. It's hard to distinguish this from talent, obviously you pay attention to someone with an amazing voice. But that's not enough on it's own, as poor Leona found out.
I used to think it about Corrine Bailey Rae too, she was just so unique in tone and beautiful, but then she faded into oblivion so i mustn't have been in the majority.

Who has the X factor for you?

OP posts:
YellowandGreenToBeSeen · 14/11/2021 09:52

*palm

YellowandGreenToBeSeen · 14/11/2021 09:52

Madonna - like or loathe, she’s got IT in buckets. Always has.

Beyoncé has it when she’s being Sasha Fierce but less so ‘off duty’.

Bruce Forsyth! I once saw him entertain an audience whilst waiting for a show to begin. It was off the cuff and unscripted. It was incredible - he had the entire 500 people in the pan of his hand. Never seen anything like it before or since.

aSofaNearYou · 14/11/2021 09:51

I think a lot of this has to do with perspective, and the eras you live through and how certain films affected you, perhaps how uncynical you were at the time, rather than any objective fact.

I have grown up with the stars of the last twenty years or so and honestly, there are lots of actors I find very charismatic, whereas a lot of the stars of bygone eras, including lots of the one's mentioned here, leave me quite cold. It's all to do with the time in your life that you properly absorb things and buy into them.

I do agree somewhat about musicians, though, but I think that has more to do with the way the industry has changed and leant away from eccentricity. I don't think there was ever much eccentricity in Hollywood.

DrSbaitso · 14/11/2021 09:48

I think Jessica Chastain is a fantastic actress. I don't care if she's not massively engaging as herself. That just means she's an even better actress when she chooses to switch it on. Nobody is "on" all the time.

suckingonchillidogs · 14/11/2021 09:42

I think people with charisma break the mold and go against what's in the mainstream. I know they weren't the first grunge band by any means but Nirvana hit at the right time, also Prince, Madonna, Adam Ant, Sex Pistols. They may not have been the best in their genres (except Prince - he was 😬) but they all exploded. Someone needs to be brave and do something new.

Brainstorm21 · 14/11/2021 09:40

The problem with Jessica Chastain is that while she's an amazing actress she comes across as a bit cold on screen and in person. Also while obviously she's a stunning looking women she's not sexy. I can't imagine her playing the Sharon Stone role in Basic Instinct or even the Rosamund Pike role in Gone Girl for example.

She did do Miss Sloane and it didn't work for that reason.

I used to have the same opinion of Amy Adams but since seeing her in American Hustle have changed my mind.

It may just be the roles and scripts nowadays are more focus grouped and bland.

DrSbaitso · 14/11/2021 09:37

An actor should have charisma only if the role requires it. Plenty of roles require the actor to be dull, unassuming and not at all starlike.

Beaconoflight · 14/11/2021 09:37

Crossed post 😂

Beaconoflight · 14/11/2021 09:36

Don’t know if anyone mentioned Lady Gaga ? She is special and has the wow factor !

supermoonrising · 14/11/2021 09:36

@Branleuse
Gaga has it but not the other two. Gaga is a powerful singer and string, original live performer. The other two are just averagely talented musicians with top notch marketing teams.

supermoonrising · 14/11/2021 09:33

@araiwa
I don't like her music at all but she's clearly an excellent singer

Adele has an excellent and strong natural tone, but I wouldn’t call her an excellent singer. Shes great at belting things out. Big power ballad type stuff. But otherwise just ok. Her singing lacks nuance. Very average range - when she sings live she never even sings the top notes in her biggest hit!

LynetteScavo · 14/11/2021 09:33

He's nit a sex God, but he has buckets of charisma.

LynetteScavo · 14/11/2021 09:32

Tom Hanks has charisma.

Branleuse · 14/11/2021 09:26

I would say people like Lady Gaga have it too, Billie Eilish, Miley Cyrus.

Yamayo · 14/11/2021 09:25

I don't think Tom Hanks has charisma. He comes across as a lovely man but I don't find him compelling on screen. To me charisma is when an actor 'steals' the screen.
There aren't many like that these days.

ShowOfHands · 14/11/2021 09:25

I was going to post what a pp already said. The market is saturated. People are famous because they are famous. Famous for being rich, writing a self help book, because Mum turned them into a brand, dated a footballer, said vile things in the press and on and on and on. Hundreds of new songs released each month seemingly and every artist is on Instagram revealing everything about themselves.

When there's nothing left to the imagination, there's no X factor. In fact, the celebrities who I think do have an old school X factor, are the ones who don't reveal everything about themselves and seem like something of a mystery. And that's not true either. I happen to sort of know (through a friend) a Hollywood A Lister who is supremely talented and who I think would fit the bill for most people. She's pretty private and not on social media and not hounded by press. In real life, she's completely and utterly normal. And objectively, no different to her public persona but you could perceive her differently if you hadn't seen her rolling her eyes at her stubborn teenager whilst trying to get out the house on time.

Old school celebs seemed mysterious and untouchable and lived different lives sold to us only through the press. Now Bob next door can be famous if he says the right stuff on Twitter and sells his story to the right corner of the press.

bizboz · 14/11/2021 09:21

"Showbusiness" thèse days is dominated by nepotism or people with family money. It's probably not that likely that you have one or both of these plus a magnetic personality. There are probably musicians or actors with the X factor who just don't have the chance of a breakthrough.

The flip side of celebrity these days is reality shows and social media influencers where it seems almost the opposite of charisma is desirable and it's better to be as bland and dumb-seeming as possible, and to look exactly the same as everyone else rather than show any individuality.

Megalameg · 14/11/2021 09:17

@FrankButchersDickieBow

Adele’s private life is private? Guess you haven’t seen any of her most recent interviews. It’s all about her private life, her divorce, why she wanted a divorce, what her son thinks about it, what she thinks of what her son thinks about it etc.
I’ve rarely seen a star spill their guts to the level she has been lately. It’s kinda gross.

CounsellorTroi · 14/11/2021 09:16

Tom Hanks definitely has charisma.

Ponoka7 · 14/11/2021 09:14

"The actresses are even worse. I can’t remember a truly charismatic actress in the last ten years. Scarlet Johanson and Jessica Chastain for instance "

That's were it becomes subjective. I love Scarlett Johansson, she can carry a film, as she did Lucy.

"Not sure whether that’s sarcasm or not?
If not Melissa Mcarthy and Toni Colette aren’t exactly Grace Kelly and Katherine Hepburn are they?"

There's loads of comedy actresses from the 40/50s, Peggy Mount, Hylda Baker, Hattie Jacques etc who they could be compared to. All great actresses, just different roles, looks and personas.

Adele from day one complained about paying tax and said lots of unsavoury things. I don't know if then a whole down-to-earth-adele/ fat-girl-breaking-barriers campaign was launched by her PR team, which changed how she was thought of.

Disfordarkchocolate · 14/11/2021 09:13

To me Daniel Craig, charisma. Sean Connery, good looking when younger but no charisma. Roger Moore, charisma.

Harry Styles, definitely.
Adele, definitely not.
Chris Pratt, definitely not, his ugly views shine out
Will Smith, hell yes.

bevelino · 14/11/2021 09:12

There are few celebrities with the X factor due to the overwhelming nepotism that exists in the media and entertainment industry. It demonstrates that having star quality is not really needed for success.

190190tnt · 14/11/2021 09:12

Alan Rickman had the x factor for me, not conventionally good looking but such a strong presence - loved him as the villain in Die Hard and Robin Hood, fantastic in Truly, Madly, Deeply...and that voice! I saw him on stage and he was mesmerising.

CottonHeadedNinnyMug · 14/11/2021 09:11

This is really interesting, I work in the 'business' and have seen and met alot of folk. The only person that I have seen who had the X factor in the original sense of the word is Jude Law - I don't fancy him at all, but he is absolutely magnetic, I couldn't take my eyes of him. This is the Hollywood x factor that people like Marilyn Monroe had I think.

FrankButchersDickieBow · 14/11/2021 09:09

I think because we know so much about these people's lives. The stars with the x factor manage to keep their lives private.

What do we actually know about George Clooney's private life? I don't think there has ever been picture of his kids in the press. Brad Pitt, Jennifer Aniston etc. Never pictured rolling out of clubs.

Gaga is an absolute phenomenon IMHO. Her voice is absolutely amazing. And again, what do we know of her private life? Nothing really.

Adele is absolutely meh. Her songs are trash, again IMHO, but when she is in the media etc., she comes across as a delightful, funny, witty, lovely woman. But again, her private life is private.

Social media has a lot to do with it and accessibility to these people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread