Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that very few celebrities have the 'x factor'

256 replies

Bargaincatfood · 13/11/2021 21:30

not an intellectual thread
Especially not most of those who won the show?! I remember the year 1direction were in it, my friends and I used to watch it before going out. We used to talk about the curly haired one, he wasn't that good looking, wasn't the best singer or the best dancer but my god was he mesmerising. Even my mum commented on him. Now he's the only one out of that insanely popular band with any semblance of a career.
It makes me think how few celebrities there are with that utterly mesmerising, star quality, where they're the only person you pay attention to on stage. It's hard to distinguish this from talent, obviously you pay attention to someone with an amazing voice. But that's not enough on it's own, as poor Leona found out.
I used to think it about Corrine Bailey Rae too, she was just so unique in tone and beautiful, but then she faded into oblivion so i mustn't have been in the majority.

Who has the X factor for you?

OP posts:
thedarkling · 14/11/2021 13:00

@MintyGreenDream

I'll probably get torn apart but I don't get the hype around Beyonce.
There's a really funny sketch about how you're not allowed to not like Beyoncé. I can't remember where it's from but your post reminded me (I'm not a fan either!)
ChequerBoard · 14/11/2021 12:50

"Men right now is harder. On a TV level right now I find the Culkin brother who plays Roman in Succession fabulous- to me he really dominates the cast."

I'm late to the party and only just starting watching Succession but I have to agree. Roman is fabulously morally ambivalent

I'd have to add Michael Sheen. Whatever he is in, he is that part. Even in the quite trashy TV series Prodigal Son, he steals every episode with his portrayal of the serial-killer father. You can see how much he is enjoying it!

ChiefClerkDrumknott · 14/11/2021 12:48

@SalsaLove Yes, James Spader has so much charisma he managed to make Ultron seem compelling with just his voice, despite the film being shite

Adam Driver deffo has it, as do McConaghey and Tucci.

Colin Farrell has a look at me factor about him, especially in a quirky role

I’d also throw Mads Mikkelsen into the charismatic pile (or my bed 🤣🤣)

SwedishEdith · 14/11/2021 12:44

I had absolutely no idea who Adam Driver was when watching him on Graham Norton the other night. I started off thinking he was quite ugly but then switched to finding him rather attractive. So he's definitely got 'something'.

SwedishEdith · 14/11/2021 12:38

Frances McDormand has that kind of intelligent seriousness I think of as X factor/star quality. As well as Judi Dench and Maggie Smith.

Saw Rufus Wainwright recently - again, has that star quality mix of serious talent, presence, intelligence and wit.

Eleganz · 14/11/2021 12:37

If we are talking about pop singers and TV hosts then it is very much style over substance. That means it is actually really hard to peel back the layers of production, make up, etc. to see if someone really has a huge amount of talent. It is only when they are in a situation that requires them to have real talent that you can tell.

I was reminded of this when listening to Alexandra Burke's rushed, out of tune and overly busy version of 'Abide with me' at the Festival of Remembrance last night. Sadly she didn't quite cut it.

An example of the opposite is Myleene Klass where she is presented as a pretty, smiling pop star turned TV host, but she is actually an excellent classically trained singer and pianist.

Mermaidwaves · 14/11/2021 12:23

Jack Nicholson has it for me, the eyes and that grin, terrifying!

lousanne · 14/11/2021 12:20

'Freddie Mercury, Elton John in his prime, Tina turner… I don’t know everyone just seems so blah and dull these days. No personality.' @Confiscatedpopit

You're just showing your age Wink there are plenty of young talented performers. Lady Gaga, Taylor swift. Bruno Mars, Sam Smith, and John Legend have incredible voices and songs.

Sia's voice is mesmerising.
Those are just from the top of my head.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 14/11/2021 12:13

I think that there is also a reliance on a standard of prettiness which has made things more bland. Think Bette Davies or Joan Crawford - can’t imagine either would get a break today.

Thedogscollar · 14/11/2021 12:11

Judi Dench
Maggie Smith
Eileen Atkins
Maureen Lipman
Freddie Mercury
All above spellbinding to see performing.

DrSbaitso · 14/11/2021 11:52

@Gohugatree

Stanley Tucci is very charismatic.
And he can make it creepy too. His Caesar Flickerman was creepy, but charismatic and watchable. Like Joel Grey in Cabaret...
Cocolapew · 14/11/2021 11:45

I agree with Sharon Stone and Jude Law.
Theres a scene in Casino where SS is at the blackjack table and looks up and smiles and it's the same effect Marilyn had, her whole face lights up.
Jude Law did nothing for me but he was mesmerising in The Talented Mr Ripley.
There's no new music stars that has the same effect as say Elvis or Prince.

Yamayo · 14/11/2021 11:32

I saw Lenny Kravitz live. He was pretty cool. Grin

Gohugatree · 14/11/2021 11:29

Stanley Tucci is very charismatic.

Yamayo · 14/11/2021 11:29

I was going to say Adam Driver! Before he was Kylo Ren I remember watching Girls and finding him weirdly compelling.
He seems very shy and awkward in real life but he has great screen presence.

pictish · 14/11/2021 11:28

“Totally. Dave Grohl is a nice guy and a solid musician but doesn't have 'it'. No offence to him but he never would have had the career he's had if it weren't for Kurt Cobain.
Who incidentally had 'it' in spades.”

Couldn’t agree more.
The Foo Fighters are just okay.

BadPlaceJanet · 14/11/2021 11:27

Jon Hamm has this IMO. I'd basically watch anything with him in, I find him so compelling. I'd watch a 3-hour film of him reading the phone book and I'd be gripped Grin

Yamayo · 14/11/2021 11:27

Totally. Dave Grohl is a nice guy and a solid musician but doesn't have 'it'. No offence to him but he never would have had the career he's had if it weren't for Kurt Cobain.

Who incidentally had 'it' in spades.
If we are going back to the 90s, another beautiful charismatic musician who left us way too soon was Jeff Buckley. A friend of mine had the pleasure of meeting him backstage at a gig in France and still remembers to this day.

PuppyMonkey · 14/11/2021 11:26

The only stars I can think of who have that X factor special thing going on are Jodie Comer and Adam Driver.

It’s the Marilyn Monroe thing, where if they’re in the shot you’re not looking at anyone else.

Don’t think any modern pop stars have this tbh.

supermoonrising · 14/11/2021 11:23

Dave Grohl? Really? Top musician, but I think he ex-band mate had 10x more “x factor” surely?

PlausibleSuit · 14/11/2021 11:20

The X Factor as in the TV show always was a cynical pastiche of that kind of star power though. It sort of promised to bestow 'the x factor' (as in charisma, talent) onto participants and deliver them, newly charismatic, onto a waiting audience. But it was all a lie, really. Just a manufactured format to sell advertising revenue on ITV.

Proper charisma is rarer and doesn't happen through TV shows. Harry Styles is a nice lad and has a cool dress sense but he's not especially charismatic or talented, really. He's just talented enough and has been very well marketed.

The only manufactured act that I ever thought managed to find someone with real charisma was Popstars the Rivals, and Sarah Harding. She was an absolute bloody character and I don't think Girls Aloud would have been as big as they ended up being without her.

Charisma is about drawing the attention (and sometimes stealing scenes) on movies/TV -- Annette Bening has it, even when she overdoes it you can't take your eyes off her. Gillian Anderson has it as well. Grace Jones is basically six feet of pure charisma. Tupac, yes definitely. Denzel Washington ditto. And whatever you think of Catherine Zeta Jones as an actor she isn't half charismatic.

Kylie is a far better singer live than you'd expect. (I've seen her live three or four times.) And she can hold a stage. All the glitter and costumes definitely helps but she's got something beyond that for sure.

Snaketime · 14/11/2021 11:17

Johnny Depp, Robert Carlyle and Jonathan Davis (from Korn)

TableFlowerss · 14/11/2021 11:12

@Gohugatree

Lots of the old Hollywood stars certainly seemed to have an aura around them which in unusual these days, the likes of Katherine Hepburn, Clark Gable, Cary Grant, Lauren Bacall, Marilyn Monroe etc.

I think it's because there was a certain 'aura' around them, and no-one was spilling their guts on social media and in the tabloids every five minutes. It's difficult to see someone as an icon if they've just posted a badly spelled IG story about how buff their beach bod is right now.

There ain't no mystery any more, and it's the mystery that's so alluring.

I agree with this.
covetingthepreciousthings · 14/11/2021 11:09

Not now, but she used to. She's jumped on the LA bandwagon now, insta q&a, Oprah etc.

Tbf I think that's only because she's got an album to promote, I think she'll go back to being quite private once this has died down. She doesn't post everything on social media, she's still quite elusive in that way I think.

covetingthepreciousthings · 14/11/2021 11:08

@HelloDulling

Matthew McConaghey. Absolute star quality. Julia Roberts is the same. When they smile, you can’t help but smile back. For me, anyway.
Yes to Matthew McConaghey, he seems so charismatic and charming.