Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that very few celebrities have the 'x factor'

256 replies

Bargaincatfood · 13/11/2021 21:30

not an intellectual thread
Especially not most of those who won the show?! I remember the year 1direction were in it, my friends and I used to watch it before going out. We used to talk about the curly haired one, he wasn't that good looking, wasn't the best singer or the best dancer but my god was he mesmerising. Even my mum commented on him. Now he's the only one out of that insanely popular band with any semblance of a career.
It makes me think how few celebrities there are with that utterly mesmerising, star quality, where they're the only person you pay attention to on stage. It's hard to distinguish this from talent, obviously you pay attention to someone with an amazing voice. But that's not enough on it's own, as poor Leona found out.
I used to think it about Corrine Bailey Rae too, she was just so unique in tone and beautiful, but then she faded into oblivion so i mustn't have been in the majority.

Who has the X factor for you?

OP posts:
GrabbyAbbie · 14/11/2021 08:08

I think part of it is that practically everyone has their 5 minutes of fame now especially through reality shows and talent shows like the X factor BGT etc.
Gone are the days where only a select few ( usually talented) people were famous.

Gohugatree · 14/11/2021 08:07

X post with Artesia - absolutely agree

dozyrosie33 · 14/11/2021 08:07

I always thought Robbie Williams had the X factor. Not the best singer, not especially good looking but such a great entertainer with an infectious personality. He's faded away a bit now though as well.

ChiefClerkDrumknott · 14/11/2021 08:06

I think the opposite of Daniel Craig 🤣 He’s good looking but not knock out stunning (although I bet he is irl) and can look rough as hell if needed. But his charisma, part of which is his amazing eye colour, is what makes him really attractive

I’ve never thought Sean Connery was particularly good looking tbh hides

Sam Rockwell is an example of a modern star who has charisma for days. He’s average looking but amazingly charismatic on screen. That is what pushes him into being really attractive (being an excellent actor helps)

Gohugatree · 14/11/2021 08:05

Lots of the old Hollywood stars certainly seemed to have an aura around them which in unusual these days, the likes of Katherine Hepburn, Clark Gable, Cary Grant, Lauren Bacall, Marilyn Monroe etc.

I think it's because there was a certain 'aura' around them, and no-one was spilling their guts on social media and in the tabloids every five minutes. It's difficult to see someone as an icon if they've just posted a badly spelled IG story about how buff their beach bod is right now.

There ain't no mystery any more, and it's the mystery that's so alluring.

tinselandlights · 14/11/2021 08:03

I don't think it's that there were more in the past, it's that we look back and see lots and see very few now; but actually they are sprinkled through 100 years of cinema and music where we might only have two or three people with genuine star quality at any one time.

RuthW · 14/11/2021 08:02

I think maybe it's because they get rich so quickly. They don't need to work because they have enough to last them a good few years so disappear for years. In the old days they needed to keep working longer.

Artesia · 14/11/2021 07:59

Do you not think over-exposure plays a huge part too? There's no magic or mystery about "stars" any more- the paps photograph them filling their cars with petrol, doing their shopping, pulling a funny face.

AnnaSW1 · 14/11/2021 07:59

@WhatAHexIGotInto it's in Essex!

dunroamingfornow · 14/11/2021 07:57

Corrine Bailey Rae's husband tragically died of an overdose at the height of her fame which I suspect led to her retreating from the limelight www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/methadone-killed-bailey-rae-s-husband-1208493.html

DrSbaitso · 14/11/2021 07:55

[quote WhatAHexIGotInto]@DrSbaitso 🤣 Shoeburyness sounds like it's a place in Dorset or something.[/quote]
I've never written that word out, where did autocorrect even get it??

My autocorrect has been so embarrassing lately, I might have to name change just for that!

WhatAHexIGotInto · 14/11/2021 07:54

@DrSbaitso 🤣 Shoeburyness sounds like it's a place in Dorset or something.

Megalameg · 14/11/2021 07:53

@DrSbaitso

Film was most definitely its own medium by then. Epics, Hitchcock movies, movies crossing continents - none of this remotely possible in theatre.

Bond is dumb entertainment, who cares if it “makes sense”? I seriously doubt it would have lasted this long if the first incarnation was a boring psychopath without charisma or silly sex appeal.

I’m just saying, charisma still exists obviously, but there’s a blandness to movie stars today that crept in around 2010, perhaps a bit earlier. Maybe having to be too sanitised and careful not to offend is responsible for the lack of personality.

DrSbaitso · 14/11/2021 07:51

[quote WhatAHexIGotInto]@DrSbaitso. Dani was initially the much bigger star in Australia before Kylie was even in Neighbours. By the time the gold hotpants came along Kylie had already been mega famous for over a decade although they definitely helped a resurgence of her career at the time.[/quote]
Ah OK. Thank you.

DrSbaitso · 14/11/2021 07:50

Shoeburyness? When have I ever written that out, autocorrect?? Showbusiness!

My autocorrect is going insane lately. Sigh.

WhatAHexIGotInto · 14/11/2021 07:48

@DrSbaitso. Dani was initially the much bigger star in Australia before Kylie was even in Neighbours. By the time the gold hotpants came along Kylie had already been mega famous for over a decade although they definitely helped a resurgence of her career at the time.

DrSbaitso · 14/11/2021 07:48

take Daniel Craig as James Bond, handsome? Sure. But nowhere near as charismatic as Connery.

He was playing a different character, though. Connery's Bond was cool and suave, Craig's was a psychopath. Which is the only interpretation that makes sense, really.

I really think that if Craig had been the original Bond, people would say similar things about him.

We always say that X is the only person who could play Y, but if there's one thing the Shoeburyness industry isn't short of, it's talent. (Yes, it's a shame so many sub par people get huge success, but I guess enough fans are throwing enough money to maintain it.) If you look at old screen tests, you can see that there were often lots of people who could have made a role their own. I adore Vivian Leigh, but I've seen Paulette Goddard's screen tests as Scarlett O'Hara, and she would have been incredible. I think she lost the role only due to a scandal. I don't think Clark Gable was in the original pool for Rhett either.

Old Hollywood was often essentially theatre on screen. Film hadn't fully become its own medium at that point.

Confiscatedpopit · 14/11/2021 07:46

I think my rose tinted specs are about to come out… but we did seem to have more in days gone by. Perhaps I’ve just forgot the dross alongside them at the time.

Freddie Mercury, Elton John in his prime, Tina turner… I don’t know everyone just seems so blah and dull these days. No personality.

BlusteryLake · 14/11/2021 07:45

I think it's also about being "of their time". Usually success comes because they tap into the zeitgeist, like the Spice Girls and girl power, or the Beatles and 60s cool, or the Beach Boys and California surfing.

Megalameg · 14/11/2021 07:42

@SpangoDweller

Is there though? Is anyone going to be talking about Harry Styles 30 years from now or playing his music?

Megalameg · 14/11/2021 07:40

These days it’s true. Very few really charismatic (which is what I think X factor is) celebrities. Oh they’re good looking but not especially charismatic.

Hollywood actors for example - take Daniel Craig as James Bond, handsome? Sure. But nowhere near as charismatic as Connery. Then (since he plays similar action parts) take Chris Pratt and compare him to younger Harrison Ford - again nowhere near the same charisma.

The actresses are even worse. I can’t remember a truly charismatic actress in the last ten years. Scarlet Johanson and Jessica Chastain for instance - good looking but zero X factor. Compare that to actresses from the 50’s, or 60’s or 70’s.

Old Hollywood and the entertainment industry might have had a lot of abuse and sleaze behind the scenes but they also had charismatic stars and energy. The metoo era Hollywood is just bland, bland, bland. Sexless unmanly men and boring uptight women.

DrSbaitso · 14/11/2021 07:40

@felulageller

Years ago I read a magazine article about this (pre x factor).

It compared Kylie and Dannii Minogue. Dannii was the bigger star first, she's the better singer. But Kylie's the superstar because she has the X factor.

She had better songs and wore gold hotpants. She has an awful voice but she's wonderfully entertaining.

I don't remember Dannii ever being a bigger star, though. Didn't Kylie become known for Neighbours, moved into singing and Dannii came on after that?

felulageller · 14/11/2021 07:37

Years ago I read a magazine article about this (pre x factor).

It compared Kylie and Dannii Minogue. Dannii was the bigger star first, she's the better singer. But Kylie's the superstar because she has the X factor.

tttigress · 14/11/2021 07:34

Yeah, it's mainly luck, and often connection's, it is surprising how many famous actors had parents that were already in the business, even if they were not in a camera facing role.

DrSbaitso · 14/11/2021 07:32

It's an amorphous concept. It's in the eye of the beholder.