Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how I make her feel more secure

233 replies

Partnersworries · 13/11/2021 19:50

NC for this as outing on several finance bits.

Partner and I have been together for nearly 2 years. Last year we bought a house; she owns 50% of the house with the exception of my substantial deposit (62k which I legally ringfenced as this came from inheritance pre our relationship).

I’m the main earner of the two of us, my salary is just north of 95k and hers 30k. As such we split the mortgage 50/50 (It’s a house we chose together, small 3 beds and affordable for both).

I pay 3/4 of the other bills and for joint holidays etc. I also pay for my dog as he’s an old boy and quite expensive in insurance etc

However, she has raised some concerns that she feels that there is big financial inequity between us and worries about being dependent upon me financially. I don’t see it that way, but I wouldn’t would I!

I also have about 80k in ISAs (stocks and shares and cash ISAs)

How do I make her feel more secure? I’ve suggested she reduces down her bills contribution to save more (to give her a financial buffer) but she still seems worried.

What do I do? Do I just give her a 3 month financial buffer? I could do this without much hardship TBH but worry it would make things feel even more inequitable.

I don’t want this to impact our relationship but am a bit of a loss on how to make her feel better about this without a)being a dick and b)keeping her happy

OP posts:
Embroidery · 13/11/2021 22:25

I did read the OP.

You are fleecing her. And you can't bully me.

In a proper marriage, all monies are joined, fixed expenditure goes out and the rest would be split 50:50.
But I get the impression you'd hate that.

Will she even get 50% of the equity when you split? That is why shes pushing herself to pay 50% and no wonder she feels insecure. She is pushing herself into relative poverty while you stockpile even greater riches. This is unfair.

And i know what bills are. Theyre all tiny and often used by men as a 'I pay 75% of the bills' weapon. Probably a tiny tiny fraction of your salary and interesting that you keep on bringing it up. Bet she thinks that too.

Id run a mile.

godmum56 · 13/11/2021 22:24

@Nyxly

I think she needs to explain in more detail.

She isn't financially dependent on you.

Does she mean if you split she wouldn't be able to keep the house?

Dp and myself earn similar amounts with me as the higher earner. J wouldn't see it as my responsibility to make him feel more comfortable with me earning alot more.

I think she isn't saying what she means.

If she isn't happy paying half of the mortgage then any equity should be split as the payments are. I don't believe she should be able to pay, say, 30% of the mortgage but entitled to 50% equity after your deposit.

If its, that she is worried about splitting and not being able to afford the house, then there's not much you can do. Even if you were married and had kids she would be unlikely be able to stay in the house if yiu split.

If this is her hint at marriage, I would be taking sometime to think about it. Because ot appears finances are driving that. I don't like people who hint and I am very cynical.

I think you need to have a further converstatiom and ask her what would make her feel secure. Then, you take time to think about what her solution is.

this^^ I think this needs more honest, gentle conversation between the two of you.....and yes, I am not crazy about hinters either
Partnersworries · 13/11/2021 22:13

@Embroidery not sure if you read the OP but I do pay 75% of bills. I pay 50% of mortgage, I would happily pay more (75% or even all) but my partner does not want to do that. She wants to pay 50% to ensure her asset is protected.

OP posts:
Nyxly · 13/11/2021 22:11

@Embroidery

Your salaries are 3:1. You should pay 75% and her 25%. Of all household expenses inc mortgage.

I would never buy a house without marriage.

Not sure its forever? = planning to dump her.

But in the meantime massively fleecing her to pay your mortgage while you get even richer. Nice.

How is that true?

She has interest in the property. The ops deposit allowed her to move out of somewhere she wants happy. And the deposit reduced the mortgage substantially.

She wants to pay 50% because she wants 50% of the equity if they split.

Its not the ops mortgage. Its a shared one.

Embroidery · 13/11/2021 22:08

Your salaries are 3:1. You should pay 75% and her 25%. Of all household expenses inc mortgage.

I would never buy a house without marriage.

Not sure its forever? = planning to dump her.

But in the meantime massively fleecing her to pay your mortgage while you get even richer. Nice.

Cocomarine · 13/11/2021 22:06

And… point 1, the buffer, no savings…. Yet earns £30K, has a mortgage of only £350 and pays less of the bills and you pay the big things like holidays. So why doesn’t she have a buffer? She could start saving.

That feeling of being OK isn’t just £ in the bank, it’s personality.

I mentioned my husband and his 1/4 is my gross salary. I’m the one who worries about redundancy, has life insurance, etc. He just thinks what will be will be, and whatever happens we’ll be OK.

Cocomarine · 13/11/2021 22:01

I have a feeling this won’t be a popular view…
You’ve been with her less than 2 years, yet she’s already the main beneficiary of your will, your pension and life insurance?
Yet she says she worries financially about “if something were to happen to you”.
Which is absolutely and utterly groundless.
Plus… so what? She’s a grown arse woman who can just do exactly what she’d do if the two of you split - get on with her life.
You don’t have kids together, and it doesn’t sound like she’s made big detrimental financial decisions around your relationship - like losing a career path job to trail after yours.
So frankly, who point 2 is bollocks, and sounds like she’s angling for marriage BECAUSE you have those assets.
I’d tread carefully - I think she’s taking the piss with “what if something happens to you” - when she already knows that “what happens” is half a million in life insurance. For starters 🙄

FWIW, I earn 80k to my husband’s 20K, we’re married, he’d get my pensionspousal element I pay for everything except when he makes ad hoc food shops (not all our good)… so please don’t write me off as someone who doesn’t think you should pay more as a higher earner!

But my husband certainly never complained about lacking financial security when he was already in line for a bigger pension on my death than he’d ever save himself!

Nyxly · 13/11/2021 21:58

@Partnersworries

Reflecting on your comments, I do now think this is about marriage rather than the issue discussed! Lots to think about and thank you for your advice Smile
If thata the case, you need to think about sharing everything with someone who isn't going to be clear about what they want for your life together.

Imo, hinting is a form of manipulation. The fact that you have spoken twice about what her actual problem is and she seems to be making things up (I am not sure I believe she just doesn't grasp the plan if you die and needs you to explain again) isn't a good sign.

You have a lot to lose including a chunk of your pension, if you marry.

Many are willing to risk that and that's fine. But many regret it later.

You need open honest conversations, like do you want kids. Will one of you give up work, both reduce hours, both work? Etc

Dropcloth · 13/11/2021 21:52

@Partnersworries

It’s a good question, and we may well get married in the future, if we do (and I hope we do assuming things stay good) then I would expect to pool all of our finances together including removing the ringfenced deposit and giving her equal access to my savings, plus my ‘first flat’ which I own by myself etc.

It does feel quite early to be considering marriage with 22 months together in total. I love her and we bought the house because it seemed silly not to! She was renting a studio flat (which she wasn’t particularly happy in) so thought it made sense to buy and live together rather than spend on rent.

See, I think this is quite mad. You don’t sound particularly committed to her, or as if you necessarily envisage a shared future or marriage — but you bought a massively expensive shared asset together because she didn’t like her studio flat and you thought it was silly to pay rent? That sounds to me as if you let property precipitate you into a situation where you committed because of money — and now the fact that you co-own a house despite wildly disparate income levels is causing issues.
Thatsplentyjack · 13/11/2021 21:50

Sexes, not semester Hmm

Partnersworries · 13/11/2021 21:50

Reflecting on your comments, I do now think this is about marriage rather than the issue discussed! Lots to think about and thank you for your advice Smile

OP posts:
Thatsplentyjack · 13/11/2021 21:49

If you swapped the semester here people would be telling the OP that their partners lack of saving wasn't their problem, and they needed to make sure their money if protected. They certainly wouldn't be telling a woman to marry a man earning a third of their salary to make him feel more secure Confused

Partnersworries · 13/11/2021 21:48

I don’t honestly think this is about the future, she is my 70/% named beneficiary on my pension, my brother is the other 30%

Same for life assurance (6 x salary)

The house and savings are left to her in my will.

I’m not planning to ‘pop my clogs’ any time soon as I’m still relatively young!

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 13/11/2021 21:48

@CloseYourEyesAndSee

Have you made a will? If you would want her to stay in the house if you died then make a will that leaves her enough money to make that affordable? I also think you should be paying 100% of the bills with such a disparity in salary and if you're only paying £350 a month mortgage you must be rolling in it!!! If she only pays £350 a month she can easily save on a salary of £30k so that's her responsibility and opportunity to build a nest egg.
I sorry but I don't see her issue. She wants to pay half the mortgage £350, she only pays 25% of the bills. Surely she gets about 2k a month and if all her bills came to 1k that's still 1k to spend or save.
RaininSummer · 13/11/2021 21:47

You sound lovely. I think your set up seems quite fair especially if you have covered protecting her rights and ability to keep the house if something awful were to happen to you I think she may be sounding you out in a roundabout way about future marriage plans. This isn't bad if so but don't be rushed into into out.

Thatsplentyjack · 13/11/2021 21:45

What's she worried about? As long as she is a joint owner of the house I don't see the problem. 30k is a decent salary.

Partnersworries · 13/11/2021 21:45

@Nyxly I have discussed this previously but maybe I need to reiterate it and explain everything I have in place to ensure she would be protected if anything happens to me (hopefully not obvs as I’m only 35!)

I have life assurance of 6 x salary and a will.

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 13/11/2021 21:44

Your paying most of the bills and she only pays half mortgage so surely she has quite a bit left over so save or spend?

As for you dropping down dead, you could take an insurance policy out to cover the mortgage and make sure you have a will.

OnTheBoardwalk · 13/11/2021 21:42

Agree mortgage insurance and Will will give financial assurance more than access to your bank account

Nyxly · 13/11/2021 21:41

Did she not know that?

Why would she be worried about it, if there's something in place?

I think she is still dancing around what her actual issue is, if she knew you already had those things set up.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 13/11/2021 21:40

Have you made a will?
If you would want her to stay in the house if you died then make a will that leaves her enough money to make that affordable?
I also think you should be paying 100% of the bills with such a disparity in salary and if you're only paying £350 a month mortgage you must be rolling in it!!!
If she only pays £350 a month she can easily save on a salary of £30k so that's her responsibility and opportunity to build a nest egg.

Partnersworries · 13/11/2021 21:39

I have a will, everything is left to her apart from my first flat which would go to my brother as he doesn’t have much and it could be a little pension for him.

I also have life assurance with her as the main beneficiary

OP posts:
Nyxly · 13/11/2021 21:37

@Partnersworries

Thank you for your advice. I chatted to her some more this eve and asked her what it would take to make her feel financially secure in our relationship.

She said two things are the ones that really bother her

  1. that she has minimal savings and no buffer and as such feels like I see the world differently from a financial POV. That I’m more ‘what ever happens will be fine’ because I have alternative savings/passive income. She is happy for me that this is possible but I don’t think about ‘pay check to pay check’ which admittedly I don’t

  2. That if anything did happen to me (god forbid) she wouldn’t be able to stay in our home (the mortgage is just over 700 quid but she doesn’t feel this would be doable on her salary alone)

2 is easy. Get life insurance that's pays off the mortgage and get a will leaving her the house.

If she wants more savings then she needs to either pay less of the bills or cut down her spending.

To be honest, the first point sounds like she is becoming resentful of your financial situation. Which isn't good. I wouldn't be with someone who was.

But, surely she is better off (financially) than she was living on her own. Giving her more money to save herself? If not then that's the problem.

Marshy86 · 13/11/2021 21:36

Could you take out a mortgage life insurance? Then if the worst was to happen to either of you it would protect the house ?

Nemorth · 13/11/2021 21:35

Surely the "anything happening to you" worry is easy to sort with the right insurance? If it pays off the balance of the mortgage and then your will makes her the beneficiary?

You could pay for that bill yourself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread