Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how I make her feel more secure

233 replies

Partnersworries · 13/11/2021 19:50

NC for this as outing on several finance bits.

Partner and I have been together for nearly 2 years. Last year we bought a house; she owns 50% of the house with the exception of my substantial deposit (62k which I legally ringfenced as this came from inheritance pre our relationship).

I’m the main earner of the two of us, my salary is just north of 95k and hers 30k. As such we split the mortgage 50/50 (It’s a house we chose together, small 3 beds and affordable for both).

I pay 3/4 of the other bills and for joint holidays etc. I also pay for my dog as he’s an old boy and quite expensive in insurance etc

However, she has raised some concerns that she feels that there is big financial inequity between us and worries about being dependent upon me financially. I don’t see it that way, but I wouldn’t would I!

I also have about 80k in ISAs (stocks and shares and cash ISAs)

How do I make her feel more secure? I’ve suggested she reduces down her bills contribution to save more (to give her a financial buffer) but she still seems worried.

What do I do? Do I just give her a 3 month financial buffer? I could do this without much hardship TBH but worry it would make things feel even more inequitable.

I don’t want this to impact our relationship but am a bit of a loss on how to make her feel better about this without a)being a dick and b)keeping her happy

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 13/11/2021 23:21

Also OP how much does she pay - if you pay 3/4 surely you know how much the remains quarter is

TractorAndHeadphones · 13/11/2021 23:20

OP kindly ignore @Embroidery they have a bone to pick. literally the only poster saying that you’re being unfair which is rare on MN 😂😂

and you never said you were a man which they keep assuming unless I’m missing something

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 13/11/2021 23:19

Surely she can save some of her salary? Her outgoings can't be very much if her share of the mortgage is £350 and you pay 3/4 of the bills. My salary isn't much more, my outgoings are greater and I still manage to save a fair bit each month.

Partnersworries · 13/11/2021 23:18

@Embroidery I’m sorry you feel so angry about this

I was genuinely trying to get other people’s opinion on how I could make my partner feel more secure.

OP posts:
youvegottenminuteslynn · 13/11/2021 23:13

To people suggesting she pays less - she pays £350 + 1/4 of shared bills!! I paid about that to my mum when I was on £15k just after leaving uni.

It's already a very manageable and below market rate mortgage contribution and bills contribution for someone on a £30k salary!

Embroidery · 13/11/2021 23:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Nyxly · 13/11/2021 23:07

@Embroidery

Thank you. And re your point....unless of course shes paying 50% of a mortgage beyond her means, while simultaniously trying to live up to a 90k (+ property) lifestyle which is also beyond her means. Independent woman and all that. He doesn't want to support her and she doesn't want to be supported. He doesnt even know what living paycheck to paycheck means!

It's amazing she's not descending into debt. She might well be. I would be in this scenario.

Why are you just making things up?

£350 isn't beyond her means and if she thought it was she could have just not bought with the op.

And who says she is spending money trying to keep up? Again, she could say 'no'.

Why does it matter if the op doesn't know what it's like living pay check to pay check?

The girlfriend has fairly small bills. If she is living paycheck to paycheck, that's likely because she isn't managing her money.

Which would be another reason to not join finances.

DillyDilly · 13/11/2021 23:06

She’s happy to pay 50% of the mortgage as it’s a tangible asset.

You’d want to be very careful here, next there will be pressure to get married so she’ll have a bigger claim on your financiers. Warning alarms are sounding, be very careful.

shiningstar2 · 13/11/2021 23:04

I think she is probably concerned about the disparity in your disposable incomes. Very hard to live with someone who has a decent amount of personal spending when she is working hard and has little left after paying her share of the bills. I think it would be fairer and give her more reassurance if bills were shared in proportion to income. No need for marriage if neither of you want that. Lots of couples go for financial proportionate financial arrangements. As the bigger earner you would still, naturally, have more disposable income than her but this would give her a greater degree of financial independence.

Embroidery · 13/11/2021 23:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Aquamarine1029 · 13/11/2021 23:02

How is it your fault that you're more financially stable than she is? If she was so concerned about being financially vulnerable, perhaps she shouldn't have bought a home with you. I don't understand what she wants from you, honestly. The way your bills are split seems more than fair to me.

DillyDilly · 13/11/2021 23:02

I think be very careful here OP. Love can be blind. Not together 2 years and you are talking of pooling salaries because she isn’t happy with the disparity in earnings. Do not do this.

Whether you do marry or not do keep your deposit ring-fenced.

To me it seems as if your DP is making a play for your money which is a danger sign so early in your relationship.

Thehop · 13/11/2021 22:55

@Embroidery

Yeah *@Thehop* she just needs to get a job earning 90k and her own flat in the backburner too. Wonder why she hasnt? Lazy?
Apologies if I insinuated that was easy, I certainly didn’t mean to. I definitely couldn’t!

What I mean is, if she wants more financially she should work for it or change her situation. It’s not OPs job to give her financial security. I think the OP had already behaved very fairly in terms of Will etc.

OP partner is child free. They have plenty of expendable income to invest in their future and savings,

youvegottenminuteslynn · 13/11/2021 22:53

I don’t honestly think this is about the future, she is my 70/% named beneficiary on my pension, my brother is the other 30%

Same for life assurance (6 x salary)

The house and savings are left to her in my will.

Bloody hell, if youve not even been together two years yet and share no children then this is absolutely loads of commitment! It seems unusual after such a short time to have made her beneficiary of everything, so she surely sees you're serious?

I think your current arrangement is good as I wouldn't want to be financially dependent on another party in her situation.

So I would assume that her insecurity isn't financial or she simply wants to have more disposable income from her salary which she needs to just communicate with you like an adult s you can discuss.

You sound very sensible and fair.

HikingforScenery · 13/11/2021 22:49

I think your arrangement sounds fine tbh. Unless there’s a legal doc you could draw around the house to reassure her. I don’t understand her insecurity otherwise. You were earning this high (or close) when you met, I assume . So was she. You pay bills pro rata and she can buffer her savings with what she hss.

Embroidery · 13/11/2021 22:45

Yeah @Thehop she just needs to get a job earning 90k and her own flat in the backburner too.
Wonder why she hasnt?
Lazy?

TractorAndHeadphones · 13/11/2021 22:42

@Embroidery did you miss the part where OP said it's the partner who insists on 50/50?
Honestly I don't see how the partner isn't rolling in cash at this point.
Also why did you mention 'men' - where does it say that the OP is a man?!?!

Nyxly · 13/11/2021 22:39

@Embroidery

Nyxly In a living together relationship it should be in proportion to relative earnings. In this case: 3:1. 3/4 1/4 With full 50:50 equity agreed and bound by solicitors. Im not saying she should have free ride but he shouldnt do this to her. (Lazily stockpile riches while she runs to keep up.)
No it shouldn't. That's your opinion.

Different people do things in different ways. £350 for a house is cheap in most places. The partner is paying their own mortgage, not ops.

Who says her 50% isn't bound. Op, sensibly, protect their deposit. So in on liklihood the 50:50 on the remaining equity will be bound by a solicitor.

What exactly is the op doing to her. The op pays over 66% of bills, 75% in fact. And the partner then pays her own half of the mortgage.

She is a grown adult with a job. Why exactly, shojldnt she pay half the mortgage if she wants half of future equity?

Again, you feel someone who is in a relationship with higher earner doesn't need to cover their own bills and financial interests.

TractorAndHeadphones · 13/11/2021 22:39

*by securing the house I mean why are you enabling her to keep it in case of your death?

Also if she;s worried about not having a financial buffer she must have some hard numbers to show you. Vague statements don't cut it when it comes to finances

Thehop · 13/11/2021 22:39

@dustofneptune

I'm not sure I fully understand. She feels insecure as in she is worried, because she can't save/invest as much as you? That she has less in the way of assets, savings, etc.?

I don't understand how being with you makes her financially dependent on you. Is she somehow worse-off being with you than she would be living alone?

Have you asked her what she needs to feel more secure? It doesn't make sense to me.

Exactly this. I don’t see her problem. If she’s worried about her future she needs to work on increasing her income, or prioritise savings.

I think your split of bills is fair

TractorAndHeadphones · 13/11/2021 22:37

Your entire post is strange OP.
30K is by no means minimum wage.
Why buy a house instead of renting together? Whose idea was it to buy - yours or hers?

Regarding point

  1. : I can see the clashes if she's careful with her money while you spend lots based on your salary. Honestly this isn't much of a problem as long as you're picking up the extra. Based on the concept of 'scaling' - i.e. you splash out on what you can both afford but however much she pays is as much as she'd normally spend if she was on her own. Does she have a budget in mind?

  2. If you do point 1 correctly and she has enough of a buffer then financial independence is not an issue. The goal shouldn't be to maintain the life she had when living with a higher earner but to go back to her previous state. Why have you made so much provision for her including life insurance? Why are you so intent on securing the house? in any case if you split up/pop your clogs she will have an asset to sell and will get a nice bit of cash where she previously had none so she's better off already without you doing anything!

Something smells fishy about this entire set-up. I can't work out whether it's you, her or both.

Embroidery · 13/11/2021 22:34

Nyxly
In a living together relationship it should be in proportion to relative earnings. In this case:
3:1.
3/4 1/4
With full 50:50 equity agreed and bound by solicitors.
Im not saying she should have free ride but he shouldnt do this to her. (Lazily stockpile riches while she runs to keep up.)

NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/11/2021 22:32

[quote Partnersworries]@1u1a perhaps I am being too fussy about who pays for what! Would you suggest we just pool wages now (genuine q) I’m open to this.

I don’t want to rush into marriage until we are both 100% sure of forever.[/quote]
You've just spent hundreds of thousands of pounds on a home and are in debt for the next 15-30 years as a result. How rich are you that this isn't a huge risk to take with a relationship that 'might not be 100% forever'?

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 13/11/2021 22:30

@Embroidery

I did read the OP.

You are fleecing her. And you can't bully me.

In a proper marriage, all monies are joined, fixed expenditure goes out and the rest would be split 50:50.
But I get the impression you'd hate that.

Will she even get 50% of the equity when you split? That is why shes pushing herself to pay 50% and no wonder she feels insecure. She is pushing herself into relative poverty while you stockpile even greater riches. This is unfair.

And i know what bills are. Theyre all tiny and often used by men as a 'I pay 75% of the bills' weapon. Probably a tiny tiny fraction of your salary and interesting that you keep on bringing it up. Bet she thinks that too.

Id run a mile.

Eh? She earns £30k and pays £350 per month mortgage and 25% of household bills She's not in any kind of poverty She's paying into an asset that she will have rights over if they split He is not fleecing her by any means
Nyxly · 13/11/2021 22:28

In a proper marriage, all monies are joined, fixed expenditure goes out and the rest would be split 50:50.

They aren't married. So talking about what happens in some marriages, is irrelevant.

Why wouldn't she get half the equity?

Sounds like you are projecting.

The ops partner is paying a smaller mortgage, due to ops finances. And she is paying her own mortgage AND for a small portions of the bills .
Do you really believe the boyfriends/ girlfriends of high earners, don't have to pay any of their own bills?

Swipe left for the next trending thread