Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how I make her feel more secure

233 replies

Partnersworries · 13/11/2021 19:50

NC for this as outing on several finance bits.

Partner and I have been together for nearly 2 years. Last year we bought a house; she owns 50% of the house with the exception of my substantial deposit (62k which I legally ringfenced as this came from inheritance pre our relationship).

I’m the main earner of the two of us, my salary is just north of 95k and hers 30k. As such we split the mortgage 50/50 (It’s a house we chose together, small 3 beds and affordable for both).

I pay 3/4 of the other bills and for joint holidays etc. I also pay for my dog as he’s an old boy and quite expensive in insurance etc

However, she has raised some concerns that she feels that there is big financial inequity between us and worries about being dependent upon me financially. I don’t see it that way, but I wouldn’t would I!

I also have about 80k in ISAs (stocks and shares and cash ISAs)

How do I make her feel more secure? I’ve suggested she reduces down her bills contribution to save more (to give her a financial buffer) but she still seems worried.

What do I do? Do I just give her a 3 month financial buffer? I could do this without much hardship TBH but worry it would make things feel even more inequitable.

I don’t want this to impact our relationship but am a bit of a loss on how to make her feel better about this without a)being a dick and b)keeping her happy

OP posts:
Sunflowers095 · 14/11/2021 11:43

@Partnersworries

Thank you for your advice. I chatted to her some more this eve and asked her what it would take to make her feel financially secure in our relationship.

She said two things are the ones that really bother her

  1. that she has minimal savings and no buffer and as such feels like I see the world differently from a financial POV. That I’m more ‘what ever happens will be fine’ because I have alternative savings/passive income. She is happy for me that this is possible but I don’t think about ‘pay check to pay check’ which admittedly I don’t

  2. That if anything did happen to me (god forbid) she wouldn’t be able to stay in our home (the mortgage is just over 700 quid but she doesn’t feel this would be doable on her salary alone)

She should be a beneficiary on your life insurance policy so if anything happens to you she can stay at the house with the mortgage paid off.
LaLaLaOh · 14/11/2021 11:39

@Boatonthehorizon

Too right too. Thid thread could be held up as an educational case study of why women should always marry before buying a house together.

The poor woman, she's lost her independence, esp her financial independence, is over stretched financially trying to live a lifestyle beyond her means, and is insulted and maligned by all and sundry: as a gold digger and, interestingly, a failure career wise for not earning 90k.
She's far better off with someone on an equal footing, equal salary, or back on her own and independent. (or married and dependent if she must)

I don’t for one second believe this is what you’d be saying if a woman came on here asking this about a man.
nanbread · 14/11/2021 10:15

@Partnersworries

To those asking for specific circumstances, my partner has said to me she has circa £950 per month left for savings and fun money.
This is loads IMO, as long as you aren't expecting her to pay out for lavish expensive dinners, days out etc

You don't say what career she's in but if she's that fussed about money she could always look to get a better paid job.

She could be saving £3-500 a month easily.

Frlrlrubert · 14/11/2021 10:09

Another here that will happily take her place! I think you've been more than fair financially and I'd be over the moon with £950 a month to save or play with on a £30k wage. I'm on slightly less than that and we have literally nothing left at the end of the month because DH isn't on as much as you (though more than me) our mortgage is similar, and we have childcare costs.

You say you're 35 but you don't say how old she is (unless I missed it - apologies if I did).

Have you discussed children? Could she be worried about what will happen if she gives up work or goes part time in the future? Like PPs I think she's probably hinting that she'd like to get married, but as you say, your relationship isn't that long, could she feel there are time constraints?

I've made some assumptions, so I apologies if they are wrong and I'm way off the mark.

kazzer2867 · 14/11/2021 09:44

@Cocomarine

I have a feeling this won’t be a popular view… You’ve been with her less than 2 years, yet she’s already the main beneficiary of your will, your pension and life insurance? Yet she says she worries financially about “if something were to happen to you”. Which is absolutely and utterly groundless. Plus… so what? She’s a grown arse woman who can just do exactly what she’d do if the two of you split - get on with her life. You don’t have kids together, and it doesn’t sound like she’s made big detrimental financial decisions around your relationship - like losing a career path job to trail after yours. So frankly, who point 2 is bollocks, and sounds like she’s angling for marriage BECAUSE you have those assets. I’d tread carefully - I think she’s taking the piss with “what if something happens to you” - when she already knows that “what happens” is half a million in life insurance. For starters 🙄

FWIW, I earn 80k to my husband’s 20K, we’re married, he’d get my pensionspousal element I pay for everything except when he makes ad hoc food shops (not all our good)… so please don’t write me off as someone who doesn’t think you should pay more as a higher earner!

But my husband certainly never complained about lacking financial security when he was already in line for a bigger pension on my death than he’d ever save himself!

This 100%. Be very careful OP.
Cocomarine · 14/11/2021 09:33

@Boatonthehorizon

Too right too. Thid thread could be held up as an educational case study of why women should always marry before buying a house together.

The poor woman, she's lost her independence, esp her financial independence, is over stretched financially trying to live a lifestyle beyond her means, and is insulted and maligned by all and sundry: as a gold digger and, interestingly, a failure career wise for not earning 90k.
She's far better off with someone on an equal footing, equal salary, or back on her own and independent. (or married and dependent if she must)

Poor woman? The one thing she isn’t, is poor 🤣

You’re nuts!

“Overstretched financially”

I dare you to start a thread:

  • I have £30K salary
  • pay £350 mortgage
  • 25% of bills
  • am saving 22% of my salary to pension
  • my girlfriend pays for our nights out and holidays
  • I have £950 a month left to save / spend on fun

I am poor.

You know full well you would (rightly) get your arse handed to you on a plate 🤣

Go on - tell me you wouldn’t!

Thehop · 14/11/2021 09:26

@CuteAndFluff

Only one person getting 'fleeced' here and it's not op.

Not married, no kids and pays only 350 a month into an asset rather than rent a studio apartment.
Earns 30k a year. Puts 22% into a pension and pays limited bills and gets free holidays, dates paid for and is named in their boyfriends will etc.

Erm... ok.

Give me a call op when this ends lol. Sounds a great deal.

This is how I see it.
Thehop · 14/11/2021 09:21

See I’d be the opposite. She’s paying £350 a month on the mortgage and 1/4 of the bills. I’d be saving quite a lot, but I’m good at declining invites I can’t afford now. I wouldn’t have been in, say, my early 20s.

I agree, @Embroidery it would be good to know her situation.

lunar1 · 14/11/2021 09:04

I think you are being taken advantage of, £950 is more than enough to be saving something every month.

You are paying the majority of the bills, reduced the mortgage with a big deposit, all the extra expenses.

She's building equity in a house, having everything subsided, more than enough left over to save some, and yet she's not.

She's your main beneficiary of your will and you are talking about handing over more of your money.

Keep things as they are, if you eventually marry and have a family your nature as a saver will benefit her.

She isn't on a low wage for goodness sake! She earns plenty!

How much life insurance does she have in your name? What does her will say? You don't sound like you are compatible regarding attitude to money.

NCkitchen · 14/11/2021 09:00

I wouldn't pool money until your married.

Also wouldn't have added her to my Will either!

I understand the life insurance as you have a joint mortgage.

She has plenty of disposal income.

If you did die she could sell the house and downsize, but I guess the insurance would pay out so there's no real worries for her there either.

I'm not understanding her issue, something seems odd about her "concerns"

Sunshinealligator · 14/11/2021 08:59

@Boatonthehorizon

Too right too. Thid thread could be held up as an educational case study of why women should always marry before buying a house together.

The poor woman, she's lost her independence, esp her financial independence, is over stretched financially trying to live a lifestyle beyond her means, and is insulted and maligned by all and sundry: as a gold digger and, interestingly, a failure career wise for not earning 90k.
She's far better off with someone on an equal footing, equal salary, or back on her own and independent. (or married and dependent if she must)

Is over stretched paying £350 pm mortgage, and 1/4 of the total bills? With just under £1k left for herself each month?

I doubt that her life was quite as comfortable when living alone. I really, really think you've missed the point here.

She isn't overstretched living a lifestyle she can't afford.
She isn't a failure career wise, there are families who live on 30k per year, and interestingly pay more in household expenses.
£350pcm is less than rent monthly on a council house.

She certainly would not be better off with someone who also earned 30k a year, because she would still need to pay 50% mortgage, then would need to pay 50% of household bills, then if she wanted a meal out would need to pay her way more than is expected now. No way would a partner earning similar be able to be as generous as her partner is being with his larger income.
Oh and let's not forget, the deposit that her partner put into the house makes her mortgage payment less than it would be otherwise.

JollyJoon · 14/11/2021 08:42

@Boatonthehorizon
You are massively in the minority here there is nothing poor about this woman. She has been given a huge leg up the property ladder and only pays out 350 quid a month for the privilege. How much do you think she paid in rent and bills for her studio, probably double so shes already winning. She didnt even have to scrimp and save for a deposit. She has 900 quid a month to spend on clothes, drinks, holidays, savings. She doesn't even go halves on their dinner dates. Your mindset is old fashioned. A misogynist is someone who thinks women are less capable than men and this seems to be your attitude.

Boatonthehorizon · 14/11/2021 08:34

Too right too.
Thid thread could be held up as an educational case study of why women should always marry before buying a house together.

The poor woman, she's lost her independence, esp her financial independence, is over stretched financially trying to live a lifestyle beyond her means, and is insulted and maligned by all and sundry: as a gold digger and, interestingly, a failure career wise for not earning 90k.
She's far better off with someone on an equal footing, equal salary, or back on her own and independent. (or married and dependent if she must)

WellHereWeGoAgain · 14/11/2021 07:50

@Partnersworries

To those asking for specific circumstances, my partner has said to me she has circa £950 per month left for savings and fun money.
I think this is quite a reasonable amount to be left with each month really. It does seem like she's hinting towards marriage. She's talking about financial security but I think marriage is what it's really about.
Valeriane · 14/11/2021 07:20
Shock

I can't imagine ever pushing for anything other than a bill and mortgage split at just 2 years into the relationship. Its certainly bold of her. A financial advisor? Thats really odd. She doesn't seem to need any advice, she has become a homeowner and has herself 950 a month to mess around with, basically thanks to you.
She can see you are a "nice" guy (with nice meaning naive): after all, you've done all this two years in, when as PP said, in modern dating terms that's moving pretty fast. So now she's going to have a go at playing the "vulnerable" card probably hoping it will lead to marriage.

If a woman came on saying she had been with a guy for 2 years and he was already on a mortgage with her, and all the other stuff (will etc) and STILL wanted more, she would be told that all of these are massive red flags.

Tell her she should be able to save and create her own financial security out of 950 a month and ask her what her financial plan was before she met you. I also think it's weird she met a FA. When you're on a high salary it makes sense to reflect on what to do with your money, on her salary the options are pretty workaday. Who paid the FA fee?
Don't be a mug, OP.

ElftonWednesday · 14/11/2021 07:07

i I don’t want to rush into marriage until we are both 100% sure of forever.

Getting a mortgage together is a huge committment - certainly one I wouldn't have entered into with DH without at least being as sure as you can be at the time that we are "forever".

Yayaga · 14/11/2021 06:58

@HollowTalk
Why on earth should OP pay all the bills? She only pays 350 a month currently and has a grand a month to save from and treat herself

Brenttent · 14/11/2021 06:03

@TestingTestingWonTooFree

I think 2 years after meeting is early today be getting married.
This
Nyxly · 14/11/2021 06:00

How is it misogyny to suggest she is verging on being a 'gold digger'.

The vast majority of people that I know that have tried to take advantage of a partners larger earning potential have been been men.

The facts are despite being an adult and seeing an FA and a solicitor, she is saying that she is worried about what happens if op dies. Despite the op ensuring sure she will be very well looked after. I don't believe for a second she doesn't understand that. So that's not the issue.

She also has the ability to save whilst living in a house, that's better than her studio and is quite cheap be aywe she has bought as part of a couple AND because ops deposit substantially lowered the mortgage amount.

She has security. She has financial interest in the house, is looked after if op dies and her own income.

I think pooling money is a terrible idea and actually doesn't address the issue. Because she would be still financially dependent on him. If that was really her issue, she wouldn't want to pool money. It certainly doesn't give her anymore security.

If she does want marriage, she is pushing for this only as a financial issue. Again, for me (if I was op) that would really concern me and I date men. So not based in misogyny.

I think counselling maybe a good idea. Because marrying someone who wants one thing but tries to get it by saying something else is a recipe for disaster.

But the op would be silly to miss the red flags here. The partner has far more security that she did 2 years ago. She likely has more disposable income than she had before and is still unable to save.

If she feels the disparity impacts her because it gives the op more say over things, she was fully aware of that before she moved in

If she wanted to head towards marriage and was clear about that, for me it would be less concerning.

Wether people want to admit it or not, marriage is a big risk for people who earn alot of money or have a lot in assets. And if ops partner was a man no one would be telling them they need to pool the money to make him feel better.

CombatBarbie · 14/11/2021 02:23

I'm fairly certain this thread was posted before, did she want to work part time? Apologies if it's not the same person but the details are so very similar!!

Even if its not you, the genuine consensus was that you should not marry and she was verging on cocklodging/gold digger..... Same applies here!!

ConsuelaHammock · 14/11/2021 02:10

She wants you to propose.

PurpleOkapi · 14/11/2021 01:58

If I were you, I wouldn't give her anything. Yes, there's a huge financial inequality, but have you done anything to hamper her career prospects or earning potential? If not, then it's not at all your responsibility mitigate that difference. She freely chose your living arrangements. The downside (for her) is that she's financially dependent on you. The upside (for her) is that she gets to enjoy a much better standard of living than she'd ever have had as a single person, or with a partner who earned the same as she does. That's a pretty big upside, and it's not possible without the corresponding downside of financial dependence. She wants it both ways, and even if that wasn't laughably entitled of her, it would still be mathematically impossible.

I'm a woman who's the sole earner. I pay for everything. I'm fine with that. But if my husband ever told me that he needed me to straight-up write him a check for three months worth of our current living expenses so that he "felt secure," I'd laugh hysterically and start shopping for a divorce lawyer. This very transparent attempt to extort money via emotional manipulation would be immediately recognised for what it is if the sexes were reversed. If her security and happiness in the relationship is inextricably linked to your willingness to give her money, that's a huge red flag.

ImustLearn2Cook · 14/11/2021 01:50

However, she has raised some concerns that she feels that there is big financial inequity between us and worries about being dependent upon me financially. I don’t see it that way, but I wouldn’t would I!

@Partnersworries Does your partner want you to make her feel more secure? Or does she just want you to respect her financial independence? Is she concerned about having less money than you? Or is she concerned about your attitude towards her having less money than you? Is she just trying to have a conversation about financial attitudes and expectations?

Maybe it would help to clarify her actual concerns.

LaLaLaOh · 14/11/2021 01:47

unless of course shes paying 50% of a mortgage beyond her means

In what world is £350 pm mortgage beyond anyone’s means when earning 30k? OP said she has £950 a month left to play with. If she’s struggling on that then it’s her own fault. She’s getting a great deal. Less mortgage because of OP’s big deposit and 1/4 of bills. She’d surely be paying more than that living by herself.

When i was fresh out of uni I was in a flat share paying £600pm for rent and bills and earning far, far less than 30k.

Seems glaringly obvious to me that it’s marriage she’s after here OP. How else could you possibly make her feel more secure? I’m a female and the breadwinner in my relationship and I’d run the fuck away if a man was saying this after I’d put all the things in place for him you have for her (not that I ever would after so little time together), I’d tread carefully.

ImustLearn2Cook · 14/11/2021 01:44

@youvegottenminuteslynn Absolutely, you are right. It is completely up to her to decide and achieve Smile