Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how I make her feel more secure

233 replies

Partnersworries · 13/11/2021 19:50

NC for this as outing on several finance bits.

Partner and I have been together for nearly 2 years. Last year we bought a house; she owns 50% of the house with the exception of my substantial deposit (62k which I legally ringfenced as this came from inheritance pre our relationship).

I’m the main earner of the two of us, my salary is just north of 95k and hers 30k. As such we split the mortgage 50/50 (It’s a house we chose together, small 3 beds and affordable for both).

I pay 3/4 of the other bills and for joint holidays etc. I also pay for my dog as he’s an old boy and quite expensive in insurance etc

However, she has raised some concerns that she feels that there is big financial inequity between us and worries about being dependent upon me financially. I don’t see it that way, but I wouldn’t would I!

I also have about 80k in ISAs (stocks and shares and cash ISAs)

How do I make her feel more secure? I’ve suggested she reduces down her bills contribution to save more (to give her a financial buffer) but she still seems worried.

What do I do? Do I just give her a 3 month financial buffer? I could do this without much hardship TBH but worry it would make things feel even more inequitable.

I don’t want this to impact our relationship but am a bit of a loss on how to make her feel better about this without a)being a dick and b)keeping her happy

OP posts:
Cocomarine · 14/11/2021 18:58

As an aside: I did assume the OP was female also.
Mostly because my sister is gay and rather fond of the joke, “what does a lesbian bring to a second date? - Her furniture!” - and that seemed rather apt here 🤣

PurpleOkapi · 14/11/2021 18:56

Difference here is OP’s partner is talking bollocks. Who (financially) fears their partner’s death when they stand to get £570K plus their share of the house (from the deposit at least another £60K) plus 70% of the pension - which for someone earning £95K is not going to be fuck all 🤷🏻‍♀️

Yep. She's not really afraid of him dying. She's afraid of them splitting up, because she knows she wouldn't be able to afford the property or the same lifestyle if that happened. And that's an understandable enough fear, because she's right - she can't. Going back to living on 30k won't leave her with 900+ left over to play with every month.

But what some seem to be missing is that if they split up, there's no reason that shouldn't happen, because why the heck should he keep paying for her in that situation? He'd probably buy her out with the house, and then she'd get back every cent she paid, which is equivalent to having lived there rent-free for however long. Failing that, they can sell it, and she'll still get at least the same amount back. I'm just not seeing a real problem here.

Cocomarine · 14/11/2021 18:55

@TractorAndHeadphones “OP also hasn't commented on why he/she doesn't want to marry until being 100% sure but jumped straight to buying a house with a partner of less than two years. Whatever happened to renting?”

Why not buy together instead of rent?

It wouldn’t be my decision, but it’s not a bad one. If they split up, they’re not stuck in the house together - either one has financial wherewithal to move out to another place quickly. They’ll a most certainly have saved money on rent, and most likely made money via capital growth on the house.

Thwackit · 14/11/2021 18:43

Also, I’d be very careful about having someone you’ve been dating for less than two years as the beneficiary to your will when you aren’t married. It all seems like she’s getting an incredibly good share of all of this for someone who isn’t your wife. Your share of the house, your inheritance, your life insurance etc and you’ve not been together two years or married? But your brother gets less than her?

Thwackit · 14/11/2021 18:38

She’s not dependent on you financially and I’m not why she feels she is. Dependent would be her being without a property if you split up, whereas she owns half the house minus the deposit. Similarly, you aren’t paying her mortgage for her - she’s paying half, so she’s not reliant on you for that. You pay proportionally more for bills as you earn more. If she’s unhappy with that, she can go halves on that too! It sounds like ‘reliant’ isn’t the right word as she’s clearly contributing. Perhaps she means it feels unfair or is worried that you might resent paying for more? Your situation is almost identical to mine was when I met my husband btw.

TractorAndHeadphones · 14/11/2021 18:35

[quote Cocomarine]@PurpleOkapi I think the reference is to me 😀

I don’t know… maybe he is a golddigga and I’m a fool and rubbish at spotting it 🧐
Or maybe I’m financially a because although he’s much better off now he’s with me, I still have more money than him and I sure as fuck am not planning to pool it! 🤣

I’m with you though… like yours, my husband isn’t manipulative at all.

I have less money because of him, but I’m still happy with what I have.
He has less money than me, but more than he had without me.
So he’s doing better than me purely in terms of the financial impact of our relationship.
But… I love the bugger, so 🤷🏻‍♀️

Difference here is OP’s partner is talking bollocks. Who (financially) fears their partner’s death when they stand to get £570K plus their share of the house (from the deposit at least another £60K) plus 70% of the pension - which for someone earning £95K is not going to be fuck all 🤷🏻‍♀️

I note though, that the OP has not commented on this oddness of attitude.[/quote]
OP also hasn't commented on why he/she doesn't want to marry until being 100% sure but jumped straight to buying a house with a partner of less than two years. Whatever happened to renting?

Aishah231 · 14/11/2021 18:09

It sounds like she wants a proposal.

Cocomarine · 14/11/2021 17:48

@PurpleOkapi I think the reference is to me 😀

I don’t know… maybe he is a golddigga and I’m a fool and rubbish at spotting it 🧐
Or maybe I’m financially a because although he’s much better off now he’s with me, I still have more money than him and I sure as fuck am not planning to pool it! 🤣

I’m with you though… like yours, my husband isn’t manipulative at all.

I have less money because of him, but I’m still happy with what I have.
He has less money than me, but more than he had without me.
So he’s doing better than me purely in terms of the financial impact of our relationship.
But… I love the bugger, so 🤷🏻‍♀️

Difference here is OP’s partner is talking bollocks. Who (financially) fears their partner’s death when they stand to get £570K plus their share of the house (from the deposit at least another £60K) plus 70% of the pension - which for someone earning £95K is not going to be fuck all 🤷🏻‍♀️

I note though, that the OP has not commented on this oddness of attitude.

PurpleOkapi · 14/11/2021 17:38

There was a woman up thread who admitted she paid for everything. Is her DH a gold digger too. That passed you all by!

If that's a reference to me, then no, he's not. He earned more than I did initially, and supported me while I studied. As a result, I earn 4-5x more that what he'd realistically get. If his career progression hadn't been impacted by multiple moves to pursue my education and career, his earning potential might be higher, but still no more than 1/3 to 1/2 of mine. But the trade-off for him is that he doesn't have to worry about money and doesn't have to work if he doesn't want to, and he thought that sounded pretty appealing. I see his point. I'm happy with him staying at home, because having the household stuff taken care of makes my demanding job easier. But if he wanted to do something else, I'd encourage and support him in that, too. If that meant we needed to hire a cleaner or eat out more often, then we'd be able to afford it, so there's no problem either way. He's a large part of the reason I can so cavalierly say that, so of course he should enjoy the benefits of my income. One of them is being able to do what he wants, work-wise.

But as I said in my first reply, he doesn't try to emotionally manipulate me into giving him huge sums of cash. That's what I think is the huge red flag here. My husband, like most lower-earning spouses of high earners, is in a much better financial situation than he'd have been in without me. He knows that, because he can do basic arithmetic.

The same is true of OP's girlfriend. She's an adult who presumably considered her financial situation before agreeing to their arrangement, and who can afford it perfectly well from what OP says. If she's putting 22% every month into a pension, that's more than enough for her to save a buffer out of her own money if she's so inclined. OP shouldn't be expected to buy her happiness by literally writing her a check.

Kisskiss · 14/11/2021 16:39

Ps her being with the OP isn’t impacting her negatively, from a financial standpoint .. yea he earns more, and if there really is insecurity about that, then honestly the only way to change it is to work out how she can get to a higher wage ( if it’s possible )

Kisskiss · 14/11/2021 16:37

@Embroidery

I did read the OP.

You are fleecing her. And you can't bully me.

In a proper marriage, all monies are joined, fixed expenditure goes out and the rest would be split 50:50.
But I get the impression you'd hate that.

Will she even get 50% of the equity when you split? That is why shes pushing herself to pay 50% and no wonder she feels insecure. She is pushing herself into relative poverty while you stockpile even greater riches. This is unfair.

And i know what bills are. Theyre all tiny and often used by men as a 'I pay 75% of the bills' weapon. Probably a tiny tiny fraction of your salary and interesting that you keep on bringing it up. Bet she thinks that too.

Id run a mile.

You sound really angry about this? I don’t think OP is ‘stockpiling riches’ at the expense of their partner. She owns a 50 pct interest in the property ( and probably wants to pay 50pct of the mortgage for this reason) Frankly they both sound like two very reasonable people who are trying to figure out what works for them financially. No big disaster here, just a good , grown up conversation that needs to be had.. IMO this sounds more like a marriage commitment thing than anything elss
insatiableme · 14/11/2021 15:53

I think you are being fair op. Especially if you pay for food etc when you go out and she has plenty left over every month to save if she wanted too. And if anything did happen to you she is in your will. Personally I think 22 months is not long enough to consider getting married. And this maybe more than about money!

billy1966 · 14/11/2021 15:08

@Aquamarine1029

Unless you're married, do not pool your wages. What a horrible idea. Your partner is not being treated unfairly. It's not your fault or problem that you make more money than she does. She's playing you.
I completely agree.

22 months together and she is so bothered by you having more money than her?

I think you have rushed things.

Keep your finances separate and do not rush into being married.

I would be 100% wary.

alwaysout · 14/11/2021 15:04

She wants to get married. The financial insecurity is just an excuse

bleedinora · 14/11/2021 14:23

@Cocomarine

I have a feeling this won’t be a popular view… You’ve been with her less than 2 years, yet she’s already the main beneficiary of your will, your pension and life insurance? Yet she says she worries financially about “if something were to happen to you”. Which is absolutely and utterly groundless. Plus… so what? She’s a grown arse woman who can just do exactly what she’d do if the two of you split - get on with her life. You don’t have kids together, and it doesn’t sound like she’s made big detrimental financial decisions around your relationship - like losing a career path job to trail after yours. So frankly, who point 2 is bollocks, and sounds like she’s angling for marriage BECAUSE you have those assets. I’d tread carefully - I think she’s taking the piss with “what if something happens to you” - when she already knows that “what happens” is half a million in life insurance. For starters 🙄

FWIW, I earn 80k to my husband’s 20K, we’re married, he’d get my pensionspousal element I pay for everything except when he makes ad hoc food shops (not all our good)… so please don’t write me off as someone who doesn’t think you should pay more as a higher earner!

But my husband certainly never complained about lacking financial security when he was already in line for a bigger pension on my death than he’d ever save himself!

I have to agree with this. I don't like the sound of her based on what you've written. Make sure you go into marriage with her with open eyes.

TractorAndHeadphones · 14/11/2021 13:44

@youvegottenminuteslynn

She has £1k left per month. She has financial freedom more than she would if she wasn't with op.

This! I don't know anyone on £30k who is a homeowner with only a £350 monthly mortgage contribution - it's a bloody good deal comparing to rent or most mortgages.

Not to mention that she doesn’t pay for leisure out of that 1K OP pays for eating out!

The key is comparing her financial state to what it was before. Not compared to the OP. If her definition of financial security is her current state (with the OP) then she’s a gold digger.

Sunflowers095 · 14/11/2021 13:44

[quote Cocomarine]@Sunflowers095 she’s already the beneficiary. To the tune of £570K.

So her whining about needing financial security if something happens to OP is manipulative bullshit 🤷🏻‍♀️[/quote]
Did not spot that - yeah in that case not sure why she's worried about what would happen if something happens to OP. I think pooling finances partially and proportionally to income as well as the life insurance is enough security/financial equality.

LaLaLaOh · 14/11/2021 13:24

No financial freedom, overstretched to keep up

Why are you making things up? Literally nowhere in a single one of OPs posts does he even slightly begin to indicate this. Where you do you live where £950 a month spare money that you don’t even need to use to contribute towards date nights or holidays is overstretched?

Massive disparity in incomes

And? How is that OPs fault? Why should he give her money for just existing? She has enough spare of her own. As a woman I’ve been on here in the past asking about the huge disparity in income between myself and my partner (me being the breadwinner) and every single person advised me to protect myself until we were married.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 14/11/2021 13:15

She has £1k left per month. She has financial freedom more than she would if she wasn't with op.

This! I don't know anyone on £30k who is a homeowner with only a £350 monthly mortgage contribution - it's a bloody good deal comparing to rent or most mortgages.

Nyxly · 14/11/2021 13:13

There was a woman up thread who admitted she paid for everything. Is her DH a gold digger too. That passed you all by!

Because that poster did ask for advice? And ita quite clear they feel happy with the set up.

Again, where is it said she is over stretching herself to keep up.

If she felt that way, she didn't need to move in. Why isn't she responsible for financial decisions.

She has £1k left per month. She has financial freedom more than she would if she wasn't with op.

Is there a reason you keep just adding this in? Is it because you are in the partners position.

And quite frankly I think its funny you would consider not going on a date because of MN. Not sure if that was designed to make people feel bad, retract their opinion change their opinion or what. But I found it funny.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 14/11/2021 13:10

I bet she's early twenties. Why can she not spend her money?

What?! She has a grand a month to spend on whatever she wants because her mortgage is incredibly low!

Why must she save 22% to a pension?

There's no 'must' about it - she doesn't have to do this at all and at no point has OP suggested he said she 'must'. Her FA recommended it, OP said he thought it was a good recommendation.

No financial freedom, overstretched to keep up. Massive disparity in incomes.

The disparity in incomes isn't something one partner should subsidise less than two years in with no kids, when the lower earner still earns a decent salary AND has low outgoing costs! OP pays for meals out, holidays etc.

Show us where OP's partner has 'no financial freedom' and is 'overstretched to keep up' despite being on the housing ladder, having a £350 mortgage and over a grand disposable income every month.

Stop infantilising women.

Boatonthehorizon · 14/11/2021 12:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

knittingaddict · 14/11/2021 12:50

@toolazytothinkofausername

my salary is just north of 95k and hers 30k. As such we split the mortgage 50/50

You should not be paying 50/50 for the mortgage.

You should be paying 2/3 of the mortgage, and she should pay 1/3 of the mortgage.

Agree with this. The disparity between your wages are quite high, but net income should be taken into account.
whoopy1 · 14/11/2021 12:48

@Embroidery

I did read the OP.

You are fleecing her. And you can't bully me.

In a proper marriage, all monies are joined, fixed expenditure goes out and the rest would be split 50:50.
But I get the impression you'd hate that.

Will she even get 50% of the equity when you split? That is why shes pushing herself to pay 50% and no wonder she feels insecure. She is pushing herself into relative poverty while you stockpile even greater riches. This is unfair.

And i know what bills are. Theyre all tiny and often used by men as a 'I pay 75% of the bills' weapon. Probably a tiny tiny fraction of your salary and interesting that you keep on bringing it up. Bet she thinks that too.

Id run a mile.

To be honest, with your views on what is fair, I think anyone interested in a relationship with you should be the ones to run a mile!
Cocomarine · 14/11/2021 12:45

@Sunflowers095 she’s already the beneficiary. To the tune of £570K.

So her whining about needing financial security if something happens to OP is manipulative bullshit 🤷🏻‍♀️