Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how I make her feel more secure

233 replies

Partnersworries · 13/11/2021 19:50

NC for this as outing on several finance bits.

Partner and I have been together for nearly 2 years. Last year we bought a house; she owns 50% of the house with the exception of my substantial deposit (62k which I legally ringfenced as this came from inheritance pre our relationship).

I’m the main earner of the two of us, my salary is just north of 95k and hers 30k. As such we split the mortgage 50/50 (It’s a house we chose together, small 3 beds and affordable for both).

I pay 3/4 of the other bills and for joint holidays etc. I also pay for my dog as he’s an old boy and quite expensive in insurance etc

However, she has raised some concerns that she feels that there is big financial inequity between us and worries about being dependent upon me financially. I don’t see it that way, but I wouldn’t would I!

I also have about 80k in ISAs (stocks and shares and cash ISAs)

How do I make her feel more secure? I’ve suggested she reduces down her bills contribution to save more (to give her a financial buffer) but she still seems worried.

What do I do? Do I just give her a 3 month financial buffer? I could do this without much hardship TBH but worry it would make things feel even more inequitable.

I don’t want this to impact our relationship but am a bit of a loss on how to make her feel better about this without a)being a dick and b)keeping her happy

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nemorth · 16/11/2021 19:39

22 months is plenty to decide about marriage. My DH proposed to me (the first time) after 3 months. I said no because he was drunk at the time. He proposed again, sober, the next month and we've been happily married for 17.5 years now. Together 19.5 years.

Valeriane · 14/11/2021 22:50

OP has a financial adviser who should probably be fired

wobblywinelover · 14/11/2021 22:48

OP knows exactly where they stand financially, you don't earn his/her salary and have investments to that degree by being financially naive.

whitehorsesdonotlie · 14/11/2021 22:45

And I certainly wouldn't make her your main beneficiary after such a short time. Red flags...

whitehorsesdonotlie · 14/11/2021 22:44

Just read your update. I'd be careful. It sounds as though she's a bit too keen on your money.

Didn't you discuss what you'd do about wills and the house if either of you died, so the other could pay off the mortgage??

Why can't she work harder to save instead of relying on you? How old is she?

Be careful, op. Seriously.

whitehorsesdonotlie · 14/11/2021 22:41

What does she mean by she worries about being dependent upon me financially? She's not if you're both paying for the house. Your financial split sounds fair.

Talk to her. Ask her what she means. We don't know!

22 months is very early to marry. I wouldn't rush into that.

I think if a woman has posted this, they'd be getting very different replies. Don't rush to share all your assets with a woman you've only known for 22 months, I'd say. Protect yourself.

wobblywinelover · 14/11/2021 22:36

So now you have all of these replies from women about what would be deemed acceptable by many/most women, how are you going to deal the situation now?

CuteAndFluff · 14/11/2021 22:34

@Valeriane

"She has said it makes her feel better knowing that."

Really? I thought her concern was her inability to save?

Yeah now she knows she doesn't need to bother.
CuteAndFluff · 14/11/2021 22:33

[quote Partnersworries]@Cocomarine she hadn’t known the amount of the policy until this weekend but did know I had an LA policy with work. She has said it makes her feel better knowing that.[/quote]
I bet it does.
Watch you don't end up at the bottom of a cliff. 🤑🤑🤑

Valeriane · 14/11/2021 20:41

"She has said it makes her feel better knowing that."

Really? I thought her concern was her inability to save?

TractorAndHeadphones · 14/11/2021 20:36

@Partnersworries

We bought the house together as I was planning to buy a house anyway, and we agreed it was sensible to have a joint mortgage rather than her living with me without building any equity.
Also I find this argument strange - if she was paying rent she wouldn't be building any equity anyway. You provided all of the deposit which she piggybacked on. But it's your call
TractorAndHeadphones · 14/11/2021 20:35

£700 rent on 30K p.a. is affordable for a single person. Do you actually believe her when she said that?

Partnersworries · 14/11/2021 20:07

@Cocomarine she hadn’t known the amount of the policy until this weekend but did know I had an LA policy with work. She has said it makes her feel better knowing that.

OP posts:
Cocomarine · 14/11/2021 20:00

@Partnersworries when she said she was worried that she couldn’t pay the £700 mortgage her on if you died, presumably you pointed out the £570K life insurance. What did she say to that? Had she just forgotten it?

Partnersworries · 14/11/2021 19:54

We bought the house together as I was planning to buy a house anyway, and we agreed it was sensible to have a joint mortgage rather than her living with me without building any equity.

OP posts:
Partnersworries · 14/11/2021 19:53

Thank you all for your advice

For those who have asked on why she is the beneficiary, my family are fairly affluent so would likely look after my other siblings with their wills.

OP posts:
Cocomarine · 14/11/2021 19:51

@TractorAndHeadphones I don’t disagree with you personally - no way in hell would I have bought a house together at this point as the stronger financial party, and probably not as the weaker. Far too much could go wrong - more from a human (poor) behaviour point of view than the financials in this case. I just don’t think it’s a totally crazy thing to have done!

Cocomarine · 14/11/2021 19:47

@NadiaVulvokov not offended at all! Admittedly, I just don’t understand why people post on 8 page long threads without scanning all the OP posts 🤷🏻‍♀️
But having pointed out to you what the OP had already done - my question to you was genuine, did you think it was enough?

I agree with you that it’s not always about the exact £. But, would you agree with me that to extent this is about £ (and keep in my the OP’s partner said it was in part about financial security if OP died unexpectedly) then well north of half a million definitely covers off the £.

I do agree with you that feeling important in a relationship is key. But would you feel unimportant to someone, if less than 2 years in, they’d made you their main beneficiary? That act says a lot completely regardless of what it adds up to in pounds and pence.

NeverChange · 14/11/2021 19:36

OP, I think you need to open your eyes here.

In less than 2 years, her life and wealth has improved massively.

She owns 50% of a house she could never afford in her own and her insurance of paying 50% of the mortgage speaks volumes in terms of her intention to retain it.

She's a named beneficiary on everything.

I'm not sure she is the one that should be insecure under the circumstances.

You need to talk to her. Hopefully, it's just a messed up way of her pushing for marraige because if it, she's out to fleece you.

TractorAndHeadphones · 14/11/2021 19:36

Also to add I'm aware other people have different views but the point is that people have different timelines in their heads.

TractorAndHeadphones · 14/11/2021 19:31

[quote Cocomarine]@TractorAndHeadphones “OP also hasn't commented on why he/she doesn't want to marry until being 100% sure but jumped straight to buying a house with a partner of less than two years. Whatever happened to renting?”

Why not buy together instead of rent?

It wouldn’t be my decision, but it’s not a bad one. If they split up, they’re not stuck in the house together - either one has financial wherewithal to move out to another place quickly. They’ll a most certainly have saved money on rent, and most likely made money via capital growth on the house.[/quote]
Because buying a house together is the biggest financial commitment you can make to a partner (kids excepted). House prices could fall, people could be in negative equity (as many were in 2008, not so long ago!). There are too many variables to consider.

DP and I have been together for a similar amount of time as OP, lived together for 1.5 years and are now considering buying a house. I'm very clear that I consider this a big step and expect marriage after we've saved up enough for the wedding post house buying, which he agrees with. Vague timelines, marrying at 'some point in the future' etc etc is not something I'll accept.

Maybe a mortgage is less of a financial commitment for the OP but what do they mean by 100% sure? What would make them 100% sure? 2 years of living together? 5? 10? After a certain point it's not wrong for one party to expect marriage. In terms of timeline just under 2 years is very short. However in terms of milestones achieved (providing for her in his will, buying a house together) the relationship is very advanced. That's why the message is confusing.

NadiaVulvokov · 14/11/2021 19:24

@cocomarine firstly my apologies to the OP for not having RTFT. I don’t think they’d be offended by the nature of my suggestions given they’ve already adopted most of them. However you do seem to be very offended on their behalf.

One thing I would say to you though is sometimes whether or not someone feels secure is down not the monetary amounts involved but whether they feel equally important in the relationship. That’s why my post focuses on proportions not on specific amounts.

There is something about a love based relationship being cognisant of love and care and not just money that is absolutely central to it. If you love someone you want to take care of them and make sure they are safe. It’s not all about the £.

Cocomarine · 14/11/2021 19:16

@NadiaVulvokov you can use “see all” to read all the OP’s threads, if you don’t want to read 8 pages of replies.

OP already is paying for life insurance, which will pay out to the partner £570K.

Would you say that was enough to give your partner a sense of financial security in case of your death?

She also gets OP’s share of the house (so at least £60K of deposit, any further capital growth and mortgage repayment effect. And 70% of her pension. And she is already one of the beneficiaries of the will.

Do you reckon that’s enough?

NadiaVulvokov · 14/11/2021 19:11

Add up your mortgage and other core living costs.

Compare your take home pay. Your take home must be double hers. Work out what proportion

Split those costs proportionately on take home pay. You must take home a bit more than double her take home pay?

So basically you are both contributing the same proportion of your income to your joint life. Then you are in an important sense contributing equally to a shared endeavour.

But maintain the 50/50 ownership of house.

Also think about things like a life insurance policy with her as a beneficiary that would at least pay off the house if not a bit more. Also having a will that makes things clear like you’d leave her your share in the house including deposit (if you have someone else you’d like to leave this too then make sure the life insurance policy replaces that too as well as the outstanding mortgage amount).

Another thing to consider is to vary the shared amount further so she make pension/savings contributions that are a similar proportion in relation to her take home income as they are to yours.

Basically create a space where both your futures are equally protected.

julieca · 14/11/2021 19:01

I didn't assume any of the sexes.
I still think the issue is one of communication.

Swipe left for the next trending thread