Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Women in 'men's' jobs

265 replies

WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 18:05

Leading on from the thread about why trade/construction jobs aren't more widely considered outside of the working class, I feel the same way that they're never really something us females are ever told much about.

WC lads often do pretty shit at school, but then end up ok after finding a trade. Maybe not earning £100k bigshot money but £40k+. However, I feel wc class women often end up in shit retail jobs or serving coffee etc.

I'm a female trucker in the construction industry, getting all my qualifications for site management etc. Trying to decide whether I'd rather be in transport or site management. But right now I love my job and earn circa £40k in an environment I Iike. Hate offices tbh.

I think despite people saying that male dominated sectors are hostile to women, I reckon many wc women would feel less intimidated in the sort of environment I work in than in a corporate office. They'd be working with the kind of guys they're married to, grew up with, and less likely to feel looked down on - people tend to be pretty snobby in this country even if most people claim to value 'diversity'.

I feel like a lot of women moan about 'not enough women in xyz sector' but not many want to lead by example. Will post some pics of some of the women I find inspirational as they seem to be pretty much ignored despite all the talk of male dominated this and that.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 20:08

Hours aren't particularly parent friendly. I average about 10 but have to accept that getting stuck on mway due to crash can turn it into 12. But in bad weather I often get several days off on full pay and on winter do a lot of half days (again on full pay).

One benefit is that it's a job you could easily bounce back into after mat leave. You'd be back on the road in days if you wanted quite literally.

OP posts:
CovidCorvid · 13/11/2021 20:04

I used to do a very “male” job. 20 years ago when I was doing it I think I was one of 3 women in the country doing it. It paid fairly well and I was earning over 30k, nearly 40k a year. I had my Streetworks licence and can certainly operate diggers, whackers, do tarmacking, etc.

Then I had Dd and the job was a nightmare. They changed the system so previously if you were still on a job at 5pm you handed it over to the on call crew. But then they said you had to finish the job, even if it took 2 hours and claim overtime. So they could ring you at4.55pm with a new job which could take hours to complete. I had no guarantee I could get to the childminders to pick Dd up so had to leave.

Pokemonpoolparty · 13/11/2021 20:04

It's institutional and it will take time to break. But it is happening. I am 40 and was young and naive enough in my 20s to think women and men were equal. My DH has worked in the council for almost 20 years. When he started, male refuse collectors received a bonus. Because they were men. And God forbid they be paid the same as women on the same scale.

Now there are female drivers and refuse collectors. But I'd say that's only been in the last five years, after a female head of service came in. So it's changing. But change will take time.

WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 20:02

@kittenkipper

I'm a female gas engineer. Training was so hard and left me quite depressed. All Men and a hugely sexist attitude from all of them. I had to work harder to get the same approval, and when I did get anything wrong it was put down to being a female. There were many other trainees far worse than me and when they got stuff wrong it was put down to being new. Once I got through the training and apprenticeship, I find that many many customers don't trust me- men question me and offer their armchair knowledge. I go to tool fairs and get offered higher rates as they presume I'm not trade. The rage I get from men drivers when I'm driving a van is shocking! Nothing like the "normal" rage I get driving in my car. I often am assumed a lesbian for some reason?

However on the plus side I love my job. I'll never not have work. I get paid very well, set my own hours and whilst sometimes men are awful- women LOVE having a female engineer. I could quite easily never have to encounter another man in work again. Older ladies, single mothers, just women generally always seem to take up my quotes. And become long term customers. And what's more, and true of a stereotype- they TALK. Do good work for 1 single mum and she will sing your praises and you'll get 5 referrals .

I can imagine it must be pretty annoying dealing with patronising armchair experts. Luckily I don't get told how to drive by men as most can't drive a truck. They REALLY don't like being flashed when hogging the middle lane and seeing it's a girl driving. 🤣 Love using the airhorn when situation calls.
OP posts:
onceandneveragain · 13/11/2021 19:59

it's a really good point OP. It's a catch-22, what would probably encourage more women to go for those jobs were if other women (and all different types, like those you follow on insta) were doing them, but until more women do them those role models aren't out there...

I personally would feel much more comfortable with a female plumber/electrician at home if I was home alone, would feel less likely that I was being ripped off by a female mechanic, etc.

WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 19:57

@olivehater

Should we not be looking at why female dominated careers always pay less? Because we don’t value feminine characteristics as much.
In reality tho that would probably just result in a lot of moaning and not much else. Paralysis through analysis as my boss loves to say.

If women want to do a job then they should do it. If they don't then it's a bit rich to complain there's not enough women doing it. If trucking was a 50/50 split it wouldn't be considered a man's job.

OP posts:
kittenkipper · 13/11/2021 19:57

I'm a female gas engineer. Training was so hard and left me quite depressed. All Men and a hugely sexist attitude from all of them. I had to work harder to get the same approval, and when I did get anything wrong it was put down to being a female. There were many other trainees far worse than me and when they got stuff wrong it was put down to being new. Once I got through the training and apprenticeship, I find that many many customers don't trust me- men question me and offer their armchair knowledge. I go to tool fairs and get offered higher rates as they presume I'm not trade. The rage I get from men drivers when I'm driving a van is shocking! Nothing like the "normal" rage I get driving in my car. I often am assumed a lesbian for some reason?

However on the plus side I love my job. I'll never not have work. I get paid very well, set my own hours and whilst sometimes men are awful- women LOVE having a female engineer. I could quite easily never have to encounter another man in work again. Older ladies, single mothers, just women generally always seem to take up my quotes. And become long term customers. And what's more, and true of a stereotype- they TALK. Do good work for 1 single mum and she will sing your praises and you'll get 5 referrals .

jazzupyourchuff · 13/11/2021 19:55

I would say we're pretty WC, I work in admin, he works in the food industry. I prayed that my daughter would be academic rather than my son, if only one of them could be. It doesn't seem this is going to the case and I'm trying so hard to get her to catch up and set ambitious goals. None of my WC female school friends have jobs which could support themselves, myself included.
Me: low level admin
Friend 1: retail
Friend 2: cafe manager
Friend 3: dental nurse
Friend 4: bank clerk
If you're not academic and you're female then you're usually fucked. Any career progression you had ahead of you is usually taken off the table if you have a family, for example retail, if you become a store manager for Aldi or Lidl they expect you on call pretty much 24/7 and you couldn't do it if you had dependents.
Their husbands are typically earning double what they are (tradespeople, site managers, mechanics) it seems so unfair that men typically do alright with or without qualifications. Who decided that dental nursing was worth £9.50 an hour and bricklaying was worth £19. Both are skilled jobs which require certain attributes (big hands, small hands) and a certain amount of dexterity. I would say both are equal in terms of responsibility and liability.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/11/2021 19:55

@olivehater

Should we not be looking at why female dominated careers always pay less? Because we don’t value feminine characteristics as much.
It's been observed that when various types of jobs go from being predominantly male to predominantly female, their status and pay tends to fall.
WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 19:53

@Thewomeninthemirror

I work in hgv transport. I’m sorry, I'm prepared to be flamed for this but I love the fact it’s male dominated. If there’s an issue, men deal with it and move on. The women I have employed have been a pain in the arse, moaning, bitching and drama.
Lol, I wasn't going to have...the balls....to say it but it's true! I can stand drama and find dealing with lad culture much less of a chore. At least you can take them down a peg or two with some banter if you're not a total snowflake (sorry hate that term but it was most suitable one).

With office drama/grudges it's so much harder because you say the wrong thing and it's hello HR dept.

OP posts:
Footprintsinthegrass · 13/11/2021 19:48

@seemingseamstress that is something that boils my blood so hot!

I saw someone recently who I went to school with and the convo went like

Him "so where are you working now?"
"Oh I'm on farm full time now"
Him "oh wow you're a farmers wife?!"
"No actually I'm a farmer"
Him "but I guess you look after your kids to"

Well fucking yes I do but you wouldn't suggest a nurse was any less of a nurse because she looked after her kids. No I don't "work" the 60hr weeks my dh does but when I am working I work just as bloody hard.

Luckily these conversations are becoming fewer these days. My MIL is one of the hardest working women I know but gets so little credit compared to her husband (also farmers) I won't stand for it

WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 19:48

@TractorAndHeadphones

Also OP can you post the links to their 'grams I'd like to follow it too
Following a lot more than I realised! Here are some....

www.instagram.com/p/CWOSazMIIs3/?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/cocotruckergirl?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/norwegiantruckergirl?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/womenintrucks?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/little.trucker.girl?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/becky_giles16?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/truckergirl95?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/truckergirlsclubnorway?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/worldwidetruckergirls?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/trucker_girl_nessi?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/trucker_jamaican_girl_angellie?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/trucker_barbies?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/girl.truckers?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/mallu_trucker_girl?utm_medium=copy_link

instagram.com/truckergirl01sb?utm_medium=copy_link

OP posts:
Thewomeninthemirror · 13/11/2021 19:46

I work in hgv transport. I’m sorry, I'm prepared to be flamed for this but I love the fact it’s male dominated. If there’s an issue, men deal with it and move on. The women I have employed have been a pain in the arse, moaning, bitching and drama.

olivehater · 13/11/2021 19:45

Should we not be looking at why female dominated careers always pay less? Because we don’t value feminine characteristics as much.

SeemingSeamstress · 13/11/2021 19:40

Oh the point about farming is relevant, I met someone socially recently who introduced a "farmer's wife" - turned out when I spoke to her about which one was theirs, it's her farm! And her DH married into the family. And she's the one operating the machinery and feeds at 4am etc, while he does the taxes and business side (vat stuff and some other stuff I didn't quite understand). I'm sure that isn't typical but I did wonder if I should have said something to her about how she'd been described by the host, but figured it wouldn't change anything. That one was a few months ago now and I'm still pissed off for not questioning it at the time though. It feels like i should have.

Camomila · 13/11/2021 19:39

@WhiteVanWoman91 DS1 has commandeered my laptop to watch youtube but I'll have a look for you later/tomorrow Smile

IloveRitaConnors · 13/11/2021 19:36

I worked in the motor trade for 12 yrs, also police for 6/7 yrs. Both male dominated areas. Comparing it to education /schools I have worked in which were female dominated areas, I personally felt more comfortable in the male dominated areas.
I have always naturally went against stereotypes and challenged any stereotypes I have come across either my own or other peoples, even as a youngster.
I suppose some are more naturally comfortable with this and others, well it may just take a bit more time. Who knows.......

lomaamina · 13/11/2021 19:32

This is so interesting. There was a BBC series a few years ago called "no more boys and girls" which had a segment where the children in a primary school class were asked to imagine what a car mechanic looks like and then what a ballet dancer looks like, followed by the opposite to the expected stereotype walking through the door, much to their excitement (the boys were very impressed by the male dancer's athleticism Smile). I couldn't find that clip but here's another that I think is very telling about our expectations for our sons and daughters: www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p05d9kmg

Ricetwisty · 13/11/2021 19:31

I don't think the jobs in these fields is promoted as a viable option in schools at all really. I remember one of the boys in sixth form was looked down on for going on to study plumbing even though he achieved really high grades. He excelled and has his own business and earns as much if not more than if he gone into a different career. I think that a lot of jobs aren't family friendly like truck driving, and although of course mums should be equal to dad's I don't know many who would want to be away much etc. If they were encouraged as good careers, which they are, and conditions improved probably more people overall, including women, would want to do them.

I work in a male dominated industry, it has probably worked in my favour to be honest though as I have had great opportunities to promote encouraging women into the industry etc which has been interesting and enjoyable.

TheMoth · 13/11/2021 19:30

A lot starts at home, then permeates into school. We tend to get an equal mix doing hospitality/ cooking. But DT is all boys. Health and social all girls.

A level too, is becoming more polarised. Boys doing lit used to be rare, now non existent. Makes me wonder why we're still studying so many dead white men.

We've always encouraged our dc to go for their strengths. But I still see hints of dh's upbringing, when he talks about ds doing an apprenticeship. Ds is academic through and through. He will probably end up doing History or politics. Dd is the doer, the lego builder extraordinaire and logical thinker, but dh doesn't quite know what to say to her.

Scrowy · 13/11/2021 19:24

@Footprintsinthegrass

I'm a farmer, I work alongside my husband but I'm definitely a farmer in my own right. The farming world is changing lots and I've seen lots more women giving it a go in the last 5 years, it's fantastic.

My car mechanic is also female and I've so much respect for her. She's told me so any stories about how she's been treated. Not many people bat and eye now but 10yrs ago she had a hard time

Yes farming is a profession in which it genuinely seems its now just as likely to a daughter taking over than a son, and mostly people aren't batting an eyelid about it.

Although women have always been present in farming, they just often didn't get the credit or the acknowledgement for it until recently.

WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 19:24

@NeedsCharging

Sorry White But "happy to piss on the seat" blokes not caring is only adding to the problem. My brother and my son are labourers. They work way from home on site. They are not feral.
Sorry to sound like I'm knocking the lads but you'd honestly not want to use the portaloos at 99% of the sites I work at. Luckily many now actually have separate loos attached to the site offices with running water cubicles, increasingly more an actual ladies loo.
OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 13/11/2021 19:23

@Camomila

Ooh I studied this a bit for my dissertation. Girls that do engineering/STEM apprenticeships tend to do really well, and also women do well in transport (because it is heavily unionised).

Tfl is a great employer if you live in London - DH started off on the stations but moved to the office and now mainly works from home.

Do you have links to your research - I'd love to see it! Very interested in this as I'm a programmer and there's lots of these diversity etc programs floating around (sorry OP not quite relevant to your post). They all seem to miss the point spectacularly though
TractorAndHeadphones · 13/11/2021 19:22

Also OP can you post the links to their 'grams I'd like to follow it too

Shedmistress · 13/11/2021 19:21

Ex civil engineer here. Also worked for CITB in management roles. I was on sites in the late 80s and 90s moving into management in the 2000s.

What can I say about the hours, we were expected to be there earlier and later than the men to prove we deserved to be there. Sigh.