Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Women in 'men's' jobs

265 replies

WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 18:05

Leading on from the thread about why trade/construction jobs aren't more widely considered outside of the working class, I feel the same way that they're never really something us females are ever told much about.

WC lads often do pretty shit at school, but then end up ok after finding a trade. Maybe not earning £100k bigshot money but £40k+. However, I feel wc class women often end up in shit retail jobs or serving coffee etc.

I'm a female trucker in the construction industry, getting all my qualifications for site management etc. Trying to decide whether I'd rather be in transport or site management. But right now I love my job and earn circa £40k in an environment I Iike. Hate offices tbh.

I think despite people saying that male dominated sectors are hostile to women, I reckon many wc women would feel less intimidated in the sort of environment I work in than in a corporate office. They'd be working with the kind of guys they're married to, grew up with, and less likely to feel looked down on - people tend to be pretty snobby in this country even if most people claim to value 'diversity'.

I feel like a lot of women moan about 'not enough women in xyz sector' but not many want to lead by example. Will post some pics of some of the women I find inspirational as they seem to be pretty much ignored despite all the talk of male dominated this and that.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 22:32

Just as an aside, whenever I’ve heard women say that women are harder to work with due to bitchy behaviour, I have without exception found the woman who thinks this to be the worst person to work with.

Who’s saying that?

OP posts:
CheeseMmmm · 13/11/2021 22:31

Not posts on this thread. Threads on Feminism. Sorry if that wasn't clear!

Got s link to the survey? That's interesting. Was it because of bitchiness? Really like to read!

WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 22:29

I never understand these posts.

I always think there's a subtext of. Women are happy for men to do the 'dirty work' and thats out of order.

This comes up a lot on feminist threads. Usually mining is cited as a horrible job that women swerved.

What posts?

OP posts:
WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 22:27

Just as an aside, whenever I’ve heard women say that women are harder to work with due to bitchy behaviour, I have without exception found the woman who thinks this to be the worst person to work with.

But there must be something more to it. They surveyed 500,000 women and the unanimous verdict was that they’d rather have a male boss.

OP posts:
CheeseMmmm · 13/11/2021 22:27

Ha true.

I worked for a charity that was maybe 40 women. 1 man. Zero issues with 'bitchiness'.

Some teams are awful some shit. Usually to do with one or two horrible people. The way the horribleness manifests does differ by sex probably. But it's just as bad whichever.

WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 22:25

@Madreb

From a teaching perspective I have often noted how the boys who are less interested in A levels/Uni have a huge variety of future careers they may express an interest in, and often it is the case that if they were to be even moderately successful in them, they would earn well. The girls disproprtionately show an interest in hair/beauty/childcare which is not linked to flexibility, 15 year olds don't consider flexibility.
Agree.
OP posts:
MaryLennoxsScowl · 13/11/2021 22:18

True but many wc women are in jobs where they interact with these men all day already. Like women working in cafs or the women in transport office at work.

Are you crazy? They are not at all comparable. The women in the cafs or offices are not competing with the men or stepping outside their usual roles or trying to change the regulations/facilities to make things more equal.

Just as an aside, whenever I’ve heard women say that women are harder to work with due to bitchy behaviour, I have without exception found the woman who thinks this to be the worst person to work with.

HarrisonStickle · 13/11/2021 22:15

@Namechangeforthis88

Primary school got a female caretaker and she made the male caretakers look like a pair of utter clowns. Why not more female caretakers?
Because they make the males look like clowns...
ChristmasTreeBee · 13/11/2021 22:00

@Xiomara22 sounds all too familiar…

Xiomara22 · 13/11/2021 21:53

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

EBearhug · 13/11/2021 21:53

there's lots of these diversity etc programs floating around (sorry OP not quite relevant to your post). They all seem to miss the point spectacularly though

Because they don't include the bulk of the men who make up the workforce and therefore mould the working culture. Those few of us women get told all the stats and the barriers, and the rest of them are left thinking that women just choose to do other things, and as long as they're not groping anyone behind the bogs or anywhere, then they aren't part of the problem so don't need to change or even think about it.

CheeseMmmm · 13/11/2021 21:46

Also I've never met a male office worker who would want to be in the trades either.

Madreb · 13/11/2021 21:46

From a teaching perspective I have often noted how the boys who are less interested in A levels/Uni have a huge variety of future careers they may express an interest in, and often it is the case that if they were to be even moderately successful in them, they would earn well. The girls disproprtionately show an interest in hair/beauty/childcare which is not linked to flexibility, 15 year olds don't consider flexibility.

CheeseMmmm · 13/11/2021 21:45

I never understand these posts.

I always think there's a subtext of. Women are happy for men to do the 'dirty work' and thats out of order.

This comes up a lot on feminist threads. Usually mining is cited as a horrible job that women swerved.

The fact that women did go down the mines until they were banned from doing so because it meant they lacked morals and it wasn't feminine...

Meh.

Whole thing should be all individuals can and should do any job according to interests skills and ability. Rather than women constantly being asked why they don't work on bin round/ roofing etc.

BoredZelda · 13/11/2021 21:43

If manual handling rules mean any woman doesn't do the heavy work then she's not going to be popular is she! I mean. On a small site etc. And not working for a company. Who's going to hire her?

Manual handling rules mean nobody is doing heavy work. Anything over a certain weight needs to be mechanically lifted or needs to be a two person lift.

Roofers don’t lug roof tiles up as it is unsafe for anyone to be doing it.

biscuitbadger · 13/11/2021 21:40

I retrained as a gardener in my 30s. I'm not sure if gardening counts as a trade or male dominated, but it's a different kind of job to what most women choose. And I love it so I'm just going to give it a little plug...

I think gardening is dominated a bit by men with vans and power tools, so I was a bit nervous about it, but it has been really easy to find work. I have many customers who say they feel more comfortable with a woman and who recommend me to their friends, so I don't advertise but I am regularly turning work away.

I normally work on my own, so have no problem with colleagues being sexist. And I have a little network now of other female gardeners I've met over the years. I'm self employed so set my own rates and choose when I want to work. Downsides are just the weather and the lack of things like sick or holiday pay. I would encourage any woman who was interested to get into gardening, it's fun and healthy and really rewarding.

CheeseMmmm · 13/11/2021 21:40

@BoredZelda

Also with the trades I don't think there are roles that you need to be pretty strong.

The work is physical, but as a tradie, the manual handling rules do mean you aren’t shifting heavy weights. Most women would be physically capable of most jobs on site. Labouring might be the most difficult.

If manual handling rules mean any woman doesn't do the heavy work then she's not going to be popular is she! I mean. On a small site etc. And not working for a company. Who's going to hire her?

It's not reasonable to say that a 5 foot 7 stone woman could be a roofer lugging tiles up etc if... Manual handling says she should only take half the amount an average sized man could!

WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 21:37

Not sure I'd fancy construction or warehousing tbh. I don't have to unload my truck so no really physical work for me.

OP posts:
ChristmasTreeBee · 13/11/2021 21:36

Off the top of my head I know 4 female hgv drivers, 2 female plumbers and 1 female sparky, I’ve yet to meet one female bricklayer (I’m sure there must be a few) and I have never met a female ground worker.

CheeseMmmm · 13/11/2021 21:36

Most men can do female dominated jobs perfectly well but with many that's still relatively unusual. So it goes both ways.

Eg I've never met s male PA even though it's a job that can be v lucrative if you're good.

BoredZelda · 13/11/2021 21:35

Also with the trades I don't think there are roles that you need to be pretty strong.

The work is physical, but as a tradie, the manual handling rules do mean you aren’t shifting heavy weights. Most women would be physically capable of most jobs on site. Labouring might be the most difficult.

ChristmasTreeBee · 13/11/2021 21:34

I am a site manager in construction, in my entire 20 year career I have only met 3 other female site agents/managers. Most of the females I meet are either office/admin staff.

There has been a massive drive for women in engineering, which I believe have been slightly successful. Most women engineers I know in the construction side of things do not actually attend site.

I’m pretty sure I have heard it all about women on site before, you do have to have a certain disposition to deal with it day in and day out.

BoredZelda · 13/11/2021 21:33

True but many wc women are in jobs where they interact with these men all day already. Like women working in cafs or the women in transport office at work.

Comparing these two interactions makes me wonder how much time you’ve actually spent on site day to day. Having seen how female sparks, joiners, plumbers are treated and what they have to put up with, is entirely different from what those working in the canteen face.

CheeseMmmm · 13/11/2021 21:33

Also with the trades I don't think there are roles that you need to be pretty strong. So of course some women could do it but not all, so the pool is not the whole female population in the first place iyswim.

Sometimes because just manually heavy work which eg a 5 foot 7 stone woman would not be great. And secondly because so many tools etc are man size as it were.

Eg I am good at practical things but when it comes to things like fixing something involving things plumbed in I can never undo things that have been screwed man- tight. And DH drill I can barely pick up. And if you're drilling something really hard it's just easier if you're stronger and heavier etc.

So not saying women can't of course but it's a subset who are physically suited given so many areas like that involve things where the way it works is suited to men.

I did meet a female electrician I hired (I try to hire women for this stuff) and she was great. She had been police SO19 left because treated so badly (sexism).

BoredZelda · 13/11/2021 21:31

One of the main issues with the construction industry is, a lot of the work is difficult to do with the flexibility that is required for a working parent. Sites start at 7am and often involve a lot of travelling. You can’t just knock off at 2.30 to do the school run.

I’m a construction professional and applied for a job with a main contractor. Even though I was site office based, there was an unwillingness to offer any flexibility. I do the almost identical job but on the client side and there is no reason the job can’t be done flexibly as I’m doing it now. It is definitely still very much a man’s world on site and blaming any woman for not wanting to go in to that is ridiculous.