Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Women in 'men's' jobs

265 replies

WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 18:05

Leading on from the thread about why trade/construction jobs aren't more widely considered outside of the working class, I feel the same way that they're never really something us females are ever told much about.

WC lads often do pretty shit at school, but then end up ok after finding a trade. Maybe not earning £100k bigshot money but £40k+. However, I feel wc class women often end up in shit retail jobs or serving coffee etc.

I'm a female trucker in the construction industry, getting all my qualifications for site management etc. Trying to decide whether I'd rather be in transport or site management. But right now I love my job and earn circa £40k in an environment I Iike. Hate offices tbh.

I think despite people saying that male dominated sectors are hostile to women, I reckon many wc women would feel less intimidated in the sort of environment I work in than in a corporate office. They'd be working with the kind of guys they're married to, grew up with, and less likely to feel looked down on - people tend to be pretty snobby in this country even if most people claim to value 'diversity'.

I feel like a lot of women moan about 'not enough women in xyz sector' but not many want to lead by example. Will post some pics of some of the women I find inspirational as they seem to be pretty much ignored despite all the talk of male dominated this and that.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
LobsterNapkin · 14/11/2021 02:13

@Chesneyhawkes1

I'm a train driver. There were hardly any women when I started, we do have a few more now, but still a massively male dominated industry.

I think perhaps it's the shift work, 24-7 364 days a year. It wouldn't work for childcare, school runs etc.

I'm not sure about this. On the one hand I do know that in some sectors, like my husband's, which is science, women seem to gravitate to the jobs that are better lifestyle choices with kids. So in the public sector where he is it is female dominated more often, compared to universities and the private sector.

On the other hand, nursing is very much female dominated, and that's often 24/7 shift work, certain kinds of social work that are similar have a lot of women, call centers often have plenty of women, many kinds of doctors are majority women.

When we had some work done on our house last year, one of the carpenters was a woman, and they were off at 5 on the dot every day, and didn't work weekends. That is a lot better for childcare than nursing would be.

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 02:05

WhiteVan I'm sure you said women didn't work though?

'The manual nature of the jobs meant that it was nearly always the man who was the main breadwinner, meaning that up until recently women had to rely on men.'

How does that follow? That was specific to mines. How does that indicate that across the board women didn't work and were dependent on men? Whether manual work or otherwise.

WhiteVanWoman91 · 14/11/2021 02:01

I think perhaps it's the shift work, 24-7 364 days a year.

Surely it’s not possible to only sleep once a year?

OP posts:
WhiteVanWoman91 · 14/11/2021 01:58

Working class women have always worked, and have always done heavy manual work. Just not in the well-paid trades/craftsmens guilds, because they were shut out.

With the mines women were banned from the job - I can find a link. This caused serious issues in families due to the loss of money coming in.

Exactly what I was saying.

The manual nature of the jobs meant that it was nearly always the man who was the main breadwinner, meaning that up until recently women had to rely on men.

Whereas men have always had the burden of providing on their shoulders. It wouldn’t surprise me if this influenced men’s nature in evolving to be more competitive, aggressive, better at collaborating, etc.

OP posts:
CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 01:55

'It's true the men might not be as polished and pc as those in an office type setting, but it seems to me it's a mistake to conclude they are less likely to like and respect women.'

Yes I mentioned this earlier.

Of course there are sexist/ misogynist men everywhere.

And imo as per the accounts on here of women having massive issues with sexism in traditional male sectors/ jobs etc.

The concealed simmering resentment of so many men is office jobs is a massive issue.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 14/11/2021 01:53

I'm a train driver. There were hardly any women when I started, we do have a few more now, but still a massively male dominated industry.

I think perhaps it's the shift work, 24-7 364 days a year. It wouldn't work for childcare, school runs etc.

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 01:47

Change very good of you to Google for OP.

With the mines women were banned from the job - I can find a link. This caused serious issues in families due to the loss of money coming in. All because of concerns about women, femininity and morals...

LobsterNapkin · 14/11/2021 01:44

I don't see a lot of women in trades where I am, but the ones I do see tend to do very well, and like it. It's true the men might not be as polished and pc as those in an office type setting, but it seems to me it's a mistake to conclude they are less likely to like and respect women. And being a woman can be an advantage in some ways as they are under-represented so that opens up some special programs and such.

Changechangychange · 14/11/2021 01:42

OP, if you don’t want to look it up yourself, read this link:

spartacus-educational.com/ExamIR19.htm

Women down coal mines well into the 1850s, hauling wagons of coal in tunnels too narrow to fit pit ponies. They were also in factories, working in the fields (harvesting by hand is backbreaking), working as laundresses (also bloody hard work) etc etc.

Working class women have always worked, and have always done heavy manual work. Just not in the well-paid trades/craftsmens guilds, because they were shut out. This idea of Victorian ladies sitting at home and sewing all day is based on rich women in period dramas - it wasn’t the reality for most.

XenoBitch · 14/11/2021 01:35

I said upthread that I was a hospital porter... a role that is traditionally a male one. I was the only woman porter in my NHS trust (which consisted of at least 6 hospitals, so not small!).

Fine to be in the role and thing everything was fine.. it wasn't. I would get bleeped and when the person on the other end found out I was female, I was told to get a bloke to do the job instead. This happened all the time!
There was a newsletter for our trust, and several times my manager wanted to do a write up about "letting" a woman be a porter. I refused every time.
I had a good relationship with most of my colleagues.. but some were dodgy, I was alone with one and he suddenly tried to grab my tits. I was WTF, and he had a go at me and called me frigid. I was in my 20s, and he was in his 60s.
I did love my job. I loved the environment, and most of my colleagues. But there was this overwhelming feeling that it was not right for me to be there because I was a woman.

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 01:20

Lemon yes quite.

Some women may be strong enough but heavy work just isn't going to be suitable for many women.

I wrote a longish post about it earlier.

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 01:17

Hotel Help I agree with the bit about women having to do more to make the money.

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 01:16

'I think I’m more talking about men working in roles (generally more physical), not having to manage anyone, not having worked their way up or anything like that but probably earning more than the person in my first paragraph and from their first day on the job.'

You have to train to do any job though! From gardening to driving a lorry to plumbing to anything.

I mean even labouring you're going to need to learn the names for stuff and be able to anticipate what needs doing without being told and before you know that you're not nearly as useful.

I'll bet if you said that anyone could walk off the street and do his job as well as him straight away he'd not be very impressed! I mean obv don't know you but I can't think of anything where you don't need to learn or know anything at all.

LemonSwan · 14/11/2021 01:11

Its interesting topic. I work as a gardener - part of which is in a care home, and many of the older generations are surprised that a female does the work I do (running round with machinery).

Its an interesting topic because when your doing such a variety of manual jobs like you do when your gardening - it really does show the differences between men and women.

I always prefer working in a mixed sex team, and so do my coworkers. And our industry is very mixed sex.

Generalising here; but us women are much more adept to climbing under/or through a bush and also doing the maintenance through the beds (ie. yoga with tiny feet and a lower centre of gravity).

But sometimes you just cannot beat the man power of a bloke with a pick ax, the pulling/ lifting power of a man, or the additional upper body strength/ reach when doing long periods or difficult pruning/trimming jobs.

And as someone who is now in their 30s, I am already feeling the wear on my knees. And so fitness is not just a male/female divide; I also consider it an age divide between the young and those with fresh cartilage vs the older of us who have to watch what we are doing a bit more.

So when I do my hiring and looking to build in a team, sometimes I do want a stronger man, or a more agile woman, or a fresh young one. And thats OK in my opinion.

But I suppose those requirements also lead into other sectors where people do focus on specific areas. So if I was solely running a business which specialised in heavy work, I may verge towards hiring brute man power - even as a woman and feminist myself. I am not sure what can really be done to resolve that.

Hotelhelp · 14/11/2021 01:04

I’m not sure if we are thinking along the same lines. I’m maybe not expressing myself properly.

It sounds like you’re talking about people progressing into higher paid roles via on the job training and experience rather than going to uni and going in that way. Working up the way, taking on more responsibility etc. I’m certainly not denying that happens.

I think I’m more talking about men working in roles (generally more physical), not having to manage anyone, not having worked their way up or anything like that but probably earning more than the person in my first paragraph and from their first day on the job.

I don’t want to name the job my DH does but I feel like I know so many men earning £35-38k which is good money here in Scotland and they are just turning up, putting in a shift and going home. I just can’t think of the current female equivalent of these types of job. To make that money I do think we generally need to do more, think more, manage more people etc.

I’m waffling a bit! I just think we’re maybe at cross purposes.

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 00:59

'I have no evidence but I suspect that higher earning women is more a middle class thing'.

Class is a very subjective thing, hope we are all on the same page! I bet we're not.

Is it level of education, what jobs parents have, where grew up etc?

Anyway yes there are plenty of women I know who earn well who don't have degrees, nor do parents who had dad in trades etc if that's what's meant. Putting aside the fact plenty of people with parents not in office work or whatever do get degrees and etc...

But anyway. That doesn't sound like a fair assumption. I mean if you mean it's rare for women with certain backgrounds or whatever to rarely earn well. What do you mean by higher earning though that is relevant!

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 00:53

@Hotelhelp

I’m more referring back to my own post where I referenced my DH who earns a decent (by Scottish standards anyway!) without any.
DH has a degree. He works in a role with no related formal quals in a vv male public sector thing.

I think he earns a v decent wage for what he does.

I think there's a lot of assumptions on the thread which is totally understandable because we generally only know about things family friends etc do iyswim.

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 00:51

@Hotelhelp

What are the ‘female’ equivalent was of these jobs? Are there any?

Cheese says there are plenty of men in the low paid office and retail jobs but are there maybe women earning £35-40k with no qualifications in non stereotypically male roles I wonder.

I think so. In my sector there are lots of 'entry level' roles. And opportunities if you are good and want them.

I mean that's true generally I think?

Now the qualifications have got a bit silly but lots of companies rolling back on the degrees for filling job type stuff.

I started work as a temp at big local company doing filling. In fact I often ask when I meet people at work and the vast majority started as temps at big local company!

Were good offered role on X team. Trained up (no specific courses etc). If good. Lead a team. Manage a dept. Move to other companies for better role. Develop interest in specific area and shift. For some get job with more specialised employers. Sky is the limit if you are intelligent, work hard, deliver results, get on with people etc.

In retail there's progression manage section, store. Move to head office.. Get into logistics or sourcing new lines or whatever.

Very few office jobs are truly dead end really, I don't think.

Hotelhelp · 14/11/2021 00:50

I’m more referring back to my own post where I referenced my DH who earns a decent (by Scottish standards anyway!) without any.

Ricetwisty · 14/11/2021 00:45

@Hotelhelp

What are the ‘female’ equivalent was of these jobs? Are there any?

Cheese says there are plenty of men in the low paid office and retail jobs but are there maybe women earning £35-40k with no qualifications in non stereotypically male roles I wonder.

Labourers etc have qualifications.
CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 00:41

Whitevan-

You're stating things that aren't right though.

100, 200 years ago. You said women didn't work and so men were the ones who brought in the money.

But women have always worked. We have been banned from various jobs at various points- by men. Eg going down mines.

There's a lot of information and history that you aren't aware of. To state oh women didn't work 100, 200 years ago. Is just wrong. You can't just post anything you like and then when told it's not accurate just sort of. Wave it away and basically repeat what you said before.

If you're interested in these things then don't you want to find out more? When I find something I thought is wrong I think really that's interesting and go and look into it. Learn more.

Aren't you interested in women and work 100/ 200 years ago in UK?

WhiteVanWoman91 · 14/11/2021 00:34

@Hotelhelp

What are the ‘female’ equivalent was of these jobs? Are there any?

Cheese says there are plenty of men in the low paid office and retail jobs but are there maybe women earning £35-40k with no qualifications in non stereotypically male roles I wonder.

I have no evidence but I suspect that higher earning women is more a middle class thing
OP posts:
WhiteVanWoman91 · 14/11/2021 00:32

‘Been able to’ that should be

OP posts:
Hotelhelp · 14/11/2021 00:31

What are the ‘female’ equivalent was of these jobs? Are there any?

Cheese says there are plenty of men in the low paid office and retail jobs but are there maybe women earning £35-40k with no qualifications in non stereotypically male roles I wonder.

Swipe left for the next trending thread