Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Women in 'men's' jobs

265 replies

WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 18:05

Leading on from the thread about why trade/construction jobs aren't more widely considered outside of the working class, I feel the same way that they're never really something us females are ever told much about.

WC lads often do pretty shit at school, but then end up ok after finding a trade. Maybe not earning £100k bigshot money but £40k+. However, I feel wc class women often end up in shit retail jobs or serving coffee etc.

I'm a female trucker in the construction industry, getting all my qualifications for site management etc. Trying to decide whether I'd rather be in transport or site management. But right now I love my job and earn circa £40k in an environment I Iike. Hate offices tbh.

I think despite people saying that male dominated sectors are hostile to women, I reckon many wc women would feel less intimidated in the sort of environment I work in than in a corporate office. They'd be working with the kind of guys they're married to, grew up with, and less likely to feel looked down on - people tend to be pretty snobby in this country even if most people claim to value 'diversity'.

I feel like a lot of women moan about 'not enough women in xyz sector' but not many want to lead by example. Will post some pics of some of the women I find inspirational as they seem to be pretty much ignored despite all the talk of male dominated this and that.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Rugsofhonour · 14/11/2021 06:07

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Rugsofhonour · 14/11/2021 06:03

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Charley50 · 14/11/2021 05:03

I work in a college. I was talking to a group of school-links girls who were doing Hair & Beauty. I asked them why they had chosen this option. They said they hadn't chosen it. School had. The boys from their school had been sent to Construction. Some of them would have liked to have been put on a construction course. I raised it with my colleague to raise with the school. Vocational courses are still very much divided by sex.

Namenic · 14/11/2021 04:51

@starrynight21 - as pp have said, healthcare and care home work can entail night shifts and odd hours constantly changing on a rota. Pretty hard to manage with childcare too - but maybe now has more part time opportunities (still have to do rota though).

Stuff to do with physical activity does seem to put off females though - like less sport uptake in schoolgirls. I think this is likely to be a societal thing. However - nursing, caring and cleaning can also be incredibly physical jobs - and doesn’t seem to put women off.

Athrawes · 14/11/2021 04:44

I worked for 15 years in a heavily make dominated engineering field. I was told not to have babies. I was not allowed to go to some places because I was a greater insurance (kidnap) risk. I was physically intimidated and groped.
I eventually had to leave, despite loving the job, because I couldn't juggle children and work.
I am now an invisible 50 year old teacher. I would love to return to engineering but can't see a route back in.

starrynight21 · 14/11/2021 04:23

@Changemusthappen

In my experience the construction industry is very sexist and it would be very difficult to work in a trade as a woman. I may be generalising but men in these types of jobs don't take well to a woman being as good if not better than them, which frankly isn't difficult. Lastly I have found that men don't want to deal with a woman and certainly don't want to be told what to do by one.
I think this is changing pretty rapidly. My DS is a tiler on high-rise construction sites and he has said that about 10% of the tilers are now women. The owner provides women's toilets ( they are obviously porta-potty style but the women do get designated ones). He said the men really like having a mix of sexes, since many of them remember the days when you wouldn't see a woman on site at all , which isn't normal !

I'm glad that this is happening - in the past there was no real option for women to do trades . They can make good money, and many of them progress to owning their own businesses.

The only down side is the hours - most construction trades have to start very early since that is how the workplace functions. A tradesperson can't decide to work school-friendly hours, since the workplace opens and shuts at a certain time and then the place is closed securely.

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 03:33

They get them from men? I can't see that. It's more a societal thing. Surely.

You agree that one reason is hostility from men in those roles though. I mean for sure that's a big problem.

WhiteVanWoman91 · 14/11/2021 03:27

Sorry lost. You mean men make schoolgirls think that?
What do lesbians have to do with anything?
Can you elaborate?

Two posts up I said: ’ The woman earlier in thread who went to schools to speak to girls said a common criticism is that they were ‘dirty’ jobs and for lesbians.’

I’m saying that young girls don’t get these ideas out of the blue.

OP posts:
CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 03:22

'Men didn’t want women going into trades in the 1800s and many don’t seem to be keen on it nowadays.'

You mean that many men are hostile to women in those roles?

Yes for sure. I've seen it and plenty of PPs agree.

That is s part of the answer to your OP re why don't more women go into those roles.

'Where do you think young schoolgirls get the idea that the only women who do manual jobs are lesbians?'

Sorry lost. You mean men make schoolgirls think that?
What do lesbians have to do with anything?
Can you elaborate?

WhiteVanWoman91 · 14/11/2021 03:19

The nature of a passing comment is that it is often a spontaneous thought. Sometimes it’s a valid point and other times it’s not after further digging. It’s not the same as a well researched argument.

OP posts:
WhiteVanWoman91 · 14/11/2021 03:17

making a subtle point about social expectations, patriarchal society, and constant enforcement of sex roles from cradle to grave?

No, as I said I was making a passing comment which I then got drawn into discussing. I’m not going spend any more time derailing the thread talking about it. Men didn’t want women going into trades in the 1800s and many don’t seem to be keen on it nowadays. Where do you think young schoolgirls get the idea that the only women who do manual jobs are lesbians?

OP posts:
CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 03:15

I think you are trying to make s point about men being expected to earn all the money often in jobs that are hard graft.

While women are historically and currently used to being provided for and so pick and choose work and not interested in things which are physically demanding.

I mean that's what I'm getting.

Of course I could be off the mark. So it would be really good if you could be straightforward about what you're getting at. And why that involves bringing up women not working/ men being breadwinners/ sectors like construction being male dominated.

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 03:12

Maybe this isn't the case? Maybe?

It's a bit off to post something to prove your point about women not working. Not bother reading it. When pointed out it doesn't back up what you said. Say oh this is a sidetrack let's drop that conversation.

And then say something else that sounds iffy and off we go again...

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 03:08

The concerns were from men. The women did the job as needed the money. Same as the men. It was a dangerous, exhausting, horrible job.

I don't see how you get from-

Men banned women going down coal mines

To

'However, the concerns that caused them to ban women from these job (being seen as unladylike and unfeminine) are still the same things that put some women off today so it is a valid point in that respect. '

Unless you're making a subtle point about social expectations, patriarchal society, and constant enforcement of sex roles from cradle to grave?

WhiteVanWoman91 · 14/11/2021 03:04

Ok, I didn’t read it properly but we’re getting massively sidetracked over a passing comment which was basically me reflecting that perhaps the physical aspects mentioned in this thread as offputting to women may be part of the reason why men were the main breadwinners in days past when physical jobs were more common. Maybe this isn’t the case. It was a passing comment not based on loads of research. The topic of the thread is about why wc women often end up in low paid jobs.

However, the concerns that caused them to ban women from these job (being seen as unladylike and unfeminine) are still the same things that put some women off today so it is a valid point in that respect. The woman earlier in thread who went to schools to speak to girls said a common criticism is that they were ‘dirty’ jobs and for lesbians.

OP posts:
Mypathtriedtokillme · 14/11/2021 02:45

My come from a farming family and the “farmers wife” always worked just as hard as the farmers doing farm work that would of been unrecognised or they had a “town” job during the hard years so they could actually eat and keep the family farm.

MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 14/11/2021 02:38

The lads in trades still need to have decent GCSEs and often have to resit them.
Its not like it was years ago when it was a case of knowing someone who could get you in the door.

Tbh where I live there's a LOT of typically male dominated, highly skilled industry. And women and girls are actively encouraged to apply for apprenticeships. I know 3 female welders. As contractors theyre on £70 an hour. One has been given the opportunity to work in Australia.

That would have been unheard of even 20 years ago.

Changechangychange · 14/11/2021 02:34

Did you read that link?

“For the 1841 census, the directions for enumerators stated that “The professions &c. of wives, or of sons or daughters living with and assisting their parents but not apprenticed or receiving wages, need not be inserted“

It goes on to list further issues with the way data was recorded in the 1851 and 1861 censuses, but you can read it yourself.

Also - don’t you know this? If you are working class, didn’t your own mum, grandmother and great grandmother work? And all the rest of your community? Mine certainly all did Confused

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 02:31

If you read you wouldn't have to guess. Just as a general suggestion.

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 02:30

Table one you're looking at?

It's always a good idea to look at context though.

Text before table says census data re women work is totally unreliable.

If it's not from table one can you say where? It's a long read. I just searched 30 and table 1 said women 30%. Apols if it's elsewhere.

'Unfortunately, the historical sources on women’s work are neither as complete nor as reliable as we would like. Aggregate information on the occupations of women is available only from the census, and while census data has the advantage of being comprehensive, it is not a very good measure of work done by women during the Industrial Revolution. For one thing, the census does not provide any information on individual occupations until 1841, which is after the period we wish to study.3 Even then the data on women’s occupations is questionable. For the 1841 census, the directions for enumerators stated that “The professions &c. of wives, or of sons or daughters living with and assisting their parents but not apprenticed or receiving wages, need not be inserted.” Clearly this census would not give us an accurate measure of female labor force participation. Table One illustrates the problem further; it shows the occupations of men and women recorded in the 1851 census, for 20 occupational categories. These numbers suggest that female labor force participation was low, and that 40 percent of occupied women worked in domestic service. However, economic historians have demonstrated that these numbers are misleading. First, many women who were actually employed were not listed as employed in the census. Women who appear in farm wage books have no recorded occupation in the census.4 At the same time, the census over-estimates participation by listing in the “domestic service” category women who were actually family members. In addition, the census exaggerates the extent to which women were concentrated in domestic service occupations because many women listed as “maids”, and included in the domestic servant category in the aggregate tables, were really agricultural workers.5'

WhiteVanWoman91 · 14/11/2021 02:23

If I’m reading this census data right, women only made up 30% of occupied jobs in the mid 1800s. My guess is still that this is because of the hard physical aspect of it.

eh.net/encyclopedia/women-workers-in-the-british-industrial-revolution/

OP posts:
Mypathtriedtokillme · 14/11/2021 02:23

My sister is a butcher.
She was apprentice of the year countrywide which was a huge finger to the boys club.
My mum was a boner at the meat works then later a prision officer.

Both male dominated industries.
My other sister works in the Print industry also a boys club while I worked in admin and accounting in a professional industry.

I’m the one who’s had the most issues for harassment but not when I was working in Male dominated horticulture.
Just the office jobs.

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 02:18

OP I think it would be good to be direct.

What are the reasons that you think women don't go into manual jobs much?

Why do you keep insisting that women 200 years ago wouldn't have worked much at all? And that the reason they didn't then is the same as now. Again, what reason? You obviously have a reason in mind.

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 02:15

Loads of women work for tfl in jobs with shift patterns is another example.

I'm sure there's plenty more.

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 02:14

@WhiteVanWoman91

I think an interesting thought is that it’s possible that the things that prevent many women from going into manual jobs are the same reasons why men became the main breadwinner in the first place (as most jobs would’ve been more manual a couple hundred years ago).
Yes this post.

It reads to me-

Most jobs were manual couple hundred years ago

The things that prevented women going into work then in manual jobs was probably the same as what prevents them now

Hence men were the breadwinners as the women in general weren't working due to most jobs being manual

But it's not true that women in general not working 200 years ago because most jobs were manual.
And that due to that families in general had one source of income from the man.

You have pointed at women being banned from going down mines as supporting your view. I don't see how though. As women aren't banned from manual jobs now. So if the idea is that women don't do manual jobs generally now because men have made it illegal. Isn't much of an argument.

Swipe left for the next trending thread