Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Women in 'men's' jobs

265 replies

WhiteVanWoman91 · 13/11/2021 18:05

Leading on from the thread about why trade/construction jobs aren't more widely considered outside of the working class, I feel the same way that they're never really something us females are ever told much about.

WC lads often do pretty shit at school, but then end up ok after finding a trade. Maybe not earning £100k bigshot money but £40k+. However, I feel wc class women often end up in shit retail jobs or serving coffee etc.

I'm a female trucker in the construction industry, getting all my qualifications for site management etc. Trying to decide whether I'd rather be in transport or site management. But right now I love my job and earn circa £40k in an environment I Iike. Hate offices tbh.

I think despite people saying that male dominated sectors are hostile to women, I reckon many wc women would feel less intimidated in the sort of environment I work in than in a corporate office. They'd be working with the kind of guys they're married to, grew up with, and less likely to feel looked down on - people tend to be pretty snobby in this country even if most people claim to value 'diversity'.

I feel like a lot of women moan about 'not enough women in xyz sector' but not many want to lead by example. Will post some pics of some of the women I find inspirational as they seem to be pretty much ignored despite all the talk of male dominated this and that.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
WhiteVanWoman91 · 18/11/2021 22:06

where they won't have to do twice as well as the men to be seen as as good as them, or won't miss out on that promotion when men who aren't quite as good are somehow worthy of it.

My ex flatmate actually got a pay rise by bursting into tears in the review meeting and saying it wasn't fair that other people had got one - she always had a touch of the drama. She got given an extra £5k despite not ever really going the extra mile from what I can see. Turning on the waterworks doesn't really work for men!

OP posts:
WhiteVanWoman91 · 18/11/2021 22:00

@FuckingPissedOff

I feel like a lot of women have a very defeatist attitude sometimes. Like moaning about not enough women in a job but then finding all the excuses why they couldn't possibly do the job.

When are "excuses" reasons. When is a "defeatist attitude" actually an honest appraisal of realistic chances of reward for effort put in. How many times do you expect individual women to be able to fight the system?
Perhaps you were lucky enough to not grow up somewhere where girls are told that particular toys are only for boys, and that they are only valuable for their looks and as sex objects: but the rest of us were not. We are surrounded by such messages more than ever now in the days of the internet, and girls and women who defy them are not welcome, wanted, or tolerated.

Some of us ignore the messages and do what we want.
OP posts:
CatsArePeople · 18/11/2021 11:20

A lot of these "men's jobs" are not very family friendly. And childcare/school hours is a thing that mainly concerns women unfortunately.

ErrolTheDragon · 18/11/2021 10:53

This piece in the Times today is more about professional engineers than 'trades' ... somewhat depressing but at least the problem is being recognised now.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/women-and-minorities-are-lost-in-engineering-brain-drain-z8ssxqh5q?shareToken=6b0c5696a7780b4ac6d0f8967159bf28

EBearhug · 18/11/2021 08:41

My male colleagues were freely discussing something which included derogatory comments about women (no need to specify here)

I've had that in a couple of workplaces, and when I've pulled them up on it, they've said, "Oh, you don't count, you're one of us!" It's nice to know they see me that way, but it seems to be at the expense of recognising me as a woman, and in any case, they shouldn't be talking like that in the workplace whether a,woman is there or not.

I once went to a women in IT event, and one of the speakers said, "you do tend to get a particular type of woman doing this sort of work," - because you do need to be thick-skinned at times, obstinate and assertive, to survive, when you're the only one, and on a daily basis, it's okay, but over the years - it's death by 1000 cuts, the cumulative effect of all those little things that were meaningless on their own. What I've seen happen in IT a lot, and I suspect happens in a lotof other male-dominated workplaces, is that the women grit their teeth and carry on, but when something happens to force their hand on thinking about their career, such as redundancy, (and I've seen a few departments lose their token woman in a round of redundancy, because she just doesn't fit in so well, doesn't seem to be such a team player... because none of you included her, or shared the knowledge like you did with you male colleagues,) or maternity, then that's where they decide they're sick of battling this shit all the time, and they can do something else where they won't have to do twice as well as the men to be seen as as good as them, or won't miss out on that promotion when men who aren't quite as good are somehow worthy of it. And over years, it's exhausting.

Libelula21 · 18/11/2021 05:17

One of the barriers to becoming a plumber / electrician, etc, is the idea of going into the homes of so many strangers. Often putting yourself in vulnerable positions, literally - lying down on the floor to check services, etc. I’d worry that one day, eventually, my luck would run out. Don’t know if that’s a rational fear, but would deter me.

GlitterSquid · 18/11/2021 04:47

I started in my engineering career 25 yrs ago. I'm 40.
Today I had a 'customer' approach me, 'Are you an engineer? (Big hearty laugh)'
Me 'Yes'.
Him 'Oh.....Right.'

I had another, also today, 'Alright love, do you know what these are? (holds up a bag of bolts)'
Me 'Yes, they're the fittings to attach the x/y/z'
Him 'I know. I just wondered if you did'

And previously, 'No offence love, mind if I speak to one of the lads?'

There's a long way to go.

TowerOfGiraffes · 18/11/2021 03:54

@HelloDulling

OP, in your industry, what are the expected working hours? Could a parent (male or female) arrive at 9:15, after the school run? And take leave if a child is sick? Part of the reason women end up in poorly paid jobs is the flexibility that they allow for anyone with caring responsibilities.
And yet those of us who are lone parents manage to work full time and provide for our children and do everything else. Hmmmm.... a lot more of this is a choice that people pretend.
FuckingPissedOff · 18/11/2021 02:12

I feel like a lot of women have a very defeatist attitude sometimes. Like moaning about not enough women in a job but then finding all the excuses why they couldn't possibly do the job.

When are "excuses" reasons. When is a "defeatist attitude" actually an honest appraisal of realistic chances of reward for effort put in. How many times do you expect individual women to be able to fight the system?
Perhaps you were lucky enough to not grow up somewhere where girls are told that particular toys are only for boys, and that they are only valuable for their looks and as sex objects: but the rest of us were not. We are surrounded by such messages more than ever now in the days of the internet, and girls and women who defy them are not welcome, wanted, or tolerated.

CheeseMmmm · 18/11/2021 01:29

In my sector/ work history I've never known a woman do that. Maybe we should more? Rather than trying to deal with every single thing on our own.

A friend at work was sexually assaulted and even then she wasn't sure what to do. Report or leave it etc.

Complaining about blokes chatting well I never have I don't think it would end well for me.

Worst was probably a man starting to tell me and some blokes around his desk about paying for sex.. He didn't use words quite like that though. I was sitting with him and we were in the middle of looking into something when he decided to change the subject..

FarEscape2945 · 18/11/2021 01:14

I was at work this week
My male colleagues were freely discussing something which included derogatory comments about women (no need to specify here)
I think they forgot that I was there
I made a funny comment, which made them all laugh & the conversation changed topic

However, I can imagine that a woman of a more feminine disposition would be greatly offended & put in an official complaint

I'm not saying that it is right
The comments were not directed at me, just in general

How many people would put up with this kind of behaviour?

I think this kind of thing puts off some females

I've even been asked about working with "men" in some interviews

CheeseMmmm · 15/11/2021 22:43

What do you think the real reason is?

Do you have a specific type of engineering in mind?

Was just googling about it top testing interesting-

hbr.org/amp/2016/08/why-do-so-many-women-who-study-engineering-leave-the-field

WhiteVanWoman91 · 15/11/2021 15:45

I doubt any women would talk openly to you, given your dismissive attitude. So if you have had any conversations with women face to face about their experiences in male dominated industries, I doubt you are getting the full story from them.

Being frightened or sexually harassed at work is not an excuse, its a reason.

I'm not convinced that fear is the main reason women don't want to become engineers etc.

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 15/11/2021 10:33

I feel like a lot of women have a very defeatist attitude sometimes. Like moaning about not enough women in a job but then finding all the excuses why they couldn't possibly do the job.

I doubt any women would talk openly to you, given your dismissive attitude. So if you have had any conversations with women face to face about their experiences in male dominated industries, I doubt you are getting the full story from them.

Being frightened or sexually harassed at work is not an excuse, its a reason.

Bargaincatfood · 15/11/2021 09:02

@WhiteVanWoman91 that's an attitude which comes easily to you. If you have anxiety, depression, low self esteem or are just really young then it's much harder to have that self belief that you can go against the naysayers.
Fwiw I work in a prison environment. Now I can walk onto the communal areas and feel the leers/ hatred and not be bothered. There's no way I could do this at 18. My colleague was folllowed home by someone's visitor who then fed back to them where she lived. The reason women feel scared in a lot of male dominated spaces is because men are scary. The news proves this!
I would completely understand why a 17 year old apprentice, who is navigating her sexual boundaries and might have been coerced or abused in the past, wouldn't want to be alone in a workplace with a load of men.

WhiteVanWoman91 · 14/11/2021 19:31

I feel like a lot of women have a very defeatist attitude sometimes. Like moaning about not enough women in a job but then finding all the excuses why they couldn't possibly do the job.

In my job I've found it easier to prove myself than when I worked in a team doing office work. It can never be said that my team carried me etc. I rock up, reverse in, whack chute on, do the pour, then fuck off. If it's all neatly done nobody can say shit, or try to take the credit for themselves.

OP posts:
Ekofisk · 14/11/2021 19:18

I worked as a construction site engineer in the 80s/90s, and I found it more sexist in the office (with professional males) than on site.

I mucked in on site, did what was required (probably more than) and thanked my co workers. I could just about drive a digger but no way could I ever have the skill of the guys that could peel off a piece of turf, dig a hole, backfill and then relay the turf.

DdraigGoch · 14/11/2021 19:11

@ErrolTheDragon

Many unions have fought against opening industries up to women on that basis.

Not sure if it's been mentioned on this thread, but this reminds me that many women who'd perfectly competently filled many jobs during the world wars were kicked out when it was over.

The unions have certainly been no friends of women over the years. Carry On Cabby encapsulated it perfectly. A male cab driver was ill and his wife turned up to fill in. The union rep wouldn't have it. Good old fashioned protectionism. Just like how in apartheid South Africa there were jobs (such as locomotive footplate work) reserved for unskilled white men.

Not forgetting that it was the fact that women had so competently filled many jobs which finally pushed through suffrage.

DdraigGoch · 14/11/2021 19:05

@ErrolTheDragon is that Year 1 teacher still around? I'm sure that their face would be a picture if your daughter went back to tell them where they went wrong.

Talk of disparaging careers advice reminds me of a boy from Scunthorpe who was told by a school careers advisor that he couldn't be a pilot (being from a secondary modern or comprehensive), "you get a job in a factory, young man". He ended up as Red 1, commanding the Red Arrows.

ErrolTheDragon · 14/11/2021 18:58

Many unions have fought against opening industries up to women on that basis.

Not sure if it's been mentioned on this thread, but this reminds me that many women who'd perfectly competently filled many jobs during the world wars were kicked out when it was over.

DdraigGoch · 14/11/2021 18:51

@tentative3 yes, there are plenty of male prima donnas among traincrew; one station I know had a second messroom opened to add capacity during covid. Staff from other depots tend to gravitate to the new one to avoid the whinging from the locals.

I'm sure that there is still a diminishing minority of old drivers who still think women shouldn't be allowed in (even though at least one female driver I know started as a secondman long before I was even born, so it's hardly a new concept). They're probably the same ones muttering about "boil-in-the-bag" drivers. There's nothing overt here though, I've never heard it said out loud.

DdraigGoch · 14/11/2021 18:26

@CheeseMmmm

Change very good of you to Google for OP.

With the mines women were banned from the job - I can find a link. This caused serious issues in families due to the loss of money coming in. All because of concerns about women, femininity and morals...

Not just that, reducing the labour pool increases wages for the men. Many unions have fought against opening industries up to women on that basis.
LemonSwan · 14/11/2021 15:57

@CheeseMmmm

Exactly. And for those who are strong enough - ie. I am really quite strong - can drag and lift a builders tonne bag of packed in wet leaves. I dont think its strength which is sustainable.

Even my 30s male colleages have had knee issues. After the wet season where loads get heavier due to the water weight in material; I end up in knee support braces every year - when my male colleagues dont.

I just researched and apparently they do have way more cartilage than us women. academic.oup.com/rheumatology/article/42/11/1317/1788427

Camomila · 14/11/2021 15:13

@WhiteVanWoman91 sorry just getting back to you - I don't have links because all my uni work is saved on an external hard drive I put in a drawer away safely so obviously I can't find it Grin

But, I remember reading a report by the "Young Womens Trust" that focused on apprenticeships.

ErrolTheDragon · 14/11/2021 14:50

@2pinkginsplease

My dd has just started uni studying engineering and out of 100 students 10 are girls!

She has wanted to do this for years and even with people saying oh that’s a man’s job or it’ll be all guys you’re working with, she is still determined to succeed.

Good for her! Mine finished her MEng this year, her course had a whopping (!) 25% women. I don't think anyone ever tried to deter her since her yr 1 teacher told her girls couldn't be builders, to DDs disgust. She knew even then she wanted to build things and wasn't at all impressed by the girls in her class mostly answering the 'what do you want to be when you grow up' with 'ballet dancer'.
Swipe left for the next trending thread