Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does your 5 yo still have tantrums (assuming no SEN)?

60 replies

wouldthatbeworse · 13/11/2021 15:47

Mine does. Although have always wondered if she may have ASD.
Today she asked me to make a small ‘starter’ opening in a packet so she could open it. I accidentally opened it all the way. She then refused to eat the contents insisting on a new packet. I said no, offered to put in a bowl, etc. She then became so entrenched in her silly position that it turned into a full tantrum to the point she could hardly talk/ was breathing in gulps. Then DH saw how upset she was and agreed to the new packet as long as she ate the open ones tomorrow.

We have these mega tantrums 3-4 times a month, maybe more. Is this normal? Bad parenting? Only interesting as part of a wider pattern of behaviour? Thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
olivo · 13/11/2021 21:30

I misread your title as 15 and nodded as my DC still has the occasional tantrum at 15. Highly sensitive and tired and hungry seem to be the reasons.

Housechaos · 13/11/2021 21:30

Once home from school my children 4, 6 and 8 all tantrum to varying degrees.

MrsPerfect12 · 13/11/2021 21:26

My DS is 5, he seems to be growing out of it but yes has some petty meltdowns. He ask for cheese on toast today for lunch so made it as requested then he had a tantrum because I put the cheese on it and it melted 🤯

DeepaBeesKit · 13/11/2021 21:21

Mine gets over upset for eg. If his lego model breaks, or he's struggling with a zipper or something. Hes always had an emotional streak and it's way, way worse when he's tired.

wouldthatbeworse · 13/11/2021 20:24

I don’t think she was tired or especially hungry. Snacks are a major trigger point for us as the kid is a very fussy eater and a total sugar addict. We try to stick to clear boundaries 3 meals, 2 snacks but DD is inclined to push.

OP posts:
purpleme12 · 13/11/2021 20:14

God yes
Mine isn't 5 anymore
In fact she's 8
She still kicks off when she's not happy cos she's not got her way for whatever reason unfortunately
I guess I'm a way it's a 'tantrum' you just wouldn't describe it as that when they're older
I'm quite sure she doesn't have any additional needs she just struggles to control her emotions unfortunately

TreeLawney · 13/11/2021 20:07

Yes my ds definitely did at 5, fairly frequently (never, ever at school though). He still has the odd one at 7 but not anywhere near as regularly (plus I think we’ve got better at supporting him through them).

Your dh was silly to give in though. That’s not going to help long-term at all.

shouldistop · 13/11/2021 20:01

Not anymore, he can be whiny though which is irritating.

Is your dd perhaps tired or hungry when the tantrums happen?

naughtyfurballs · 13/11/2021 19:59

Mine did - when she was in reception, on a bad day she'd fall apart once she saw me; I have very clear memories of DD lying at my feet and screaming in the school playground more than once. Usually over something I couldn't change, but it wasn't a parenting high point! It's got better.

Onionbhajisandwich · 13/11/2021 19:34

My 5 year old has some almighty tantrums at least once a week. I’m told she’s an angel at school though. Neither me or DH back down but it still don’t discourage her from sharing her rage with/at us.

starcocoon · 13/11/2021 19:27

Mine definitely still has tantrums. Nearly always when she doesn't get her own way.

BadwordMcGee · 13/11/2021 19:26

My 5yo has more tantrums now than when he was 2. We have several a month but usually grouped together. Often when he's over tired or is having a stressful time at school.

Full on growling and screaming because it was bedtime and he couldn't finish building the model I'd warned him not to start when giving the 5mins to bed time warning.

A screaming tantrum because his tablet ran out of battery.

Etc.

I can usually anticipate them and understand the motivation behind them. I've no concerns of SEN and most of my mum friends with same age kids have mentioned similar with their kids. Triggers are often different based on what stage their kid is at. As demonstrated above DS is struggling with transitions currently but a few months ago it was like your DD and loss of independence.

Suspiciousmind20 · 13/11/2021 18:55

Totally normal. Different people have different tolerance levels for stressors but it’s very common at that age. Yes French at home rather than childcare.

Tired. Hungry, Dopamine crash after a ‘no’, stress, not enough sleep, illness, inconsistent boundaries and an emotionally volatile atmosphere can all be causal or maintaining factors. Good to go through the list to see if anything can be changed.

DockOTheBay · 13/11/2021 18:50

Occasionally. She's more likely to cry because she's overwhelmed or tired. I try to spot the signs of overwhelmed and tiredness and try to keep things easy at those times e.g. asking what she wants for dinner rather than just making something and putting it in front of her, offering for her to watch TV for a bit, not playing games might might wind her up or result in a tantrum. Of course it can't always be avoided and I was say we have big tantrums a few times a month.

UsernameUnavailable1 · 13/11/2021 18:47

@bizboz

That's interesting Blanktimes. My DD's tantrums read more like meltdowns according to that list. I did wonder about autism when she was younger but she didn't match any of the criteria except the meltdowns.
Same here, according to that tantrums here are 'meltdowns'. My 5 year old just gets over-tired occasionally and everything is wrong for no reason, no fixing it haha. Been the same with all 3 of mine and none of them are autistic. As toddlers sometimes tantrums because they wanted something, but often forgot what they wanted haha. But quite often it was an indication they needed a nap or an early night - still is! My brother has asperges and to be honest his looked more like the tantrum but lasted ages, usually in the form of sulking for days about whatever it was that he 'needed'. Same for a few autistic adults my partner works with. So I'm not entirely sure that chart is entirely accurate.
Cheerbear23 · 13/11/2021 18:46

That’s really interesting @BlankTimes.
My DS is a teenager now but he had frequent loud tantrums when he little probably up to age 5. Tiredness was a big trigger, after school, homework (still wince at those). He is NT, but always had very strong feelings about things, and still isn’t afraid to vocalise them!

Whatafustercluck · 13/11/2021 18:44

By 5yo ds had outgrown tantrums, but then his were never really that spectacular.

Dd is 5 in two weeks. She still regularly displays this behaviour, but we do suspect she is neurologically diverse in some way and they definitely read like meltdowns and not tantrums - she has a lot of sensory issues when stressed. She's the perfect pupil at school, but another story at home. In many other respects she appears very neuro typical - interacts and socialises well, meeting all developmental milestones etc. But she really struggles with emotions and it's noticeable in comparison to her peers. She also builds a lot of routines/ rituals into her day to help her feel in control or calm down.

Meatshake · 13/11/2021 18:41

5 is very young and a very transitional age- they're going from being in charge of their own activity direction at preschool or nursery to having to toe the line in reception or year 1. It's understandable that they grasp what control they can.

I'd be a bit pissy if someone else undermined me if I'd decided it was a hill to die on.

We probably have something like this every 2-3 weeks. Child is possibly neurodiverse but not bad enough to diagnose- a lot of sensory processing/seeking stuff going on but bright and social.

Playdoughcaterpillar · 13/11/2021 18:39

Hell yes my 12 yo does. Intelligent, eloquent and NT. They're not quite the same but she has always been prone to loosing her shit 🤣

bizboz · 13/11/2021 18:38

That's interesting Blanktimes. My DD's tantrums read more like meltdowns according to that list. I did wonder about autism when she was younger but she didn't match any of the criteria except the meltdowns.

Fallagain · 13/11/2021 18:34

@NuffSaidSam

Ime from working in childcare, most 5 year olds don't, some 5 year olds do.

It's like with anything, they mature at different rates. Some 5 year olds are still struggling with their big emotions, others have a little more grasp on them (although often that just means tantrums are replaced with stroppy behaviour!).

Your DH undermining you won't have helped though.

Its normal for older children to tantrum in their safe place so at home but nit at school or childcare.

My 5 year old tantrums mostly when she is tired or hungry or both, especially if something she was then expecting to happen doesn’t. Tantrums are always at home and never at school.

ImFree2doasiwant · 13/11/2021 18:31

Ds2 is almost 5 and yes, screaming tantrums. No additional needs or other issues

GorgeousLadyofWrestling · 13/11/2021 18:29

My Reception age/ 4 year old still has a lot and it’s exhausting. Just read up on the info posted above about tantrums v meltdowns and they’re definitely tantrums. There’s usually some kind of stand off and it’s definitely around her wanting something/ not wanting to do something - but she escalated into desperate screaming and begging if she’s put on a time out. Have discovered we have to remove her to her room, wait for the screaming to subside, have lots of cuddles and then talk it through. When she’s in a state, you cannot get through to her.

I do wonder when we’ll start getting through to her. She’s articulate generally, but in the moment, shuts down and won’t communicate what’s wrong. I find myself at frequent impasses with her. Like today she had a birthday party - she wanted me to stay but I couldn’t because I had my older children with me. I could see she was shy so suggested we go home and she didn’t have to stay but she started crying. So there we were - I can’t do A but you don’t want B. and it becomes impossible to resolve. Eventually a friend took her in and she was fine.

It’s frequent and exhausting, and I dread the next one. I do wonder about SEN but there’s so many consistently NT behaviours she exhibits so I don’t think it’s strictly that. I think probably she just gets overwhelmed with emotion, is stubborn, and completely shuts down so it’s difficult to logic or reason with her.

wouldthatbeworse · 13/11/2021 18:27

@BlankTimes that’s an interesting summary of the difference. Although there is some cross over - I think it’s unfair to say a young tantrumer is really in control / wants to be tantruming - this was definitely more tantrum than meltdown

I know we should stand up to her but after half an hour you really start to wonder if you’ve picked your battle well. Because the starting point is so inconsequential entrenching yourself in the no new packet camp also feels quite petty

OP posts:
BlankTimes · 13/11/2021 17:59

There is a vast chasm of difference between a tantrum and autistic meltdown.

A tantrum is stopped in its tracks by the child getting what they want.

An autistic meltdown is caused by overwhelm, the child can not help their actions when in a state of overwhelm and cannot be 'brought around' by actions or bribes, it has to run its course and the child may well be exhausted afterwards.

Does your 5 yo still have tantrums (assuming no SEN)?