Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unreasonable cost of tool hire…! What to do about this

33 replies

Zzzexhaustedzzz · 13/11/2021 14:13

So, I don’t have a sander. I borrowed one from a hire company I used before. They were ok last time just a bit disorganised. So they have my details. I went in and the older guy in there was friendly but very flakey, said I could take it, when he’d found it, was vague about the price, said It’d be ok as I was a previous customer. I don’t think I signed anything.
Stuff came up and I ended up keeping it for 2 weeks. Half way through I checked the website and it said £20 per hire plus 12.50/ week. Then add 20% vat. So it should cost 45 , 54 with vat.
I got my son to return it as I was really busy, then a man (not the nice one) rang with the price. He said it would be 77!! Now I could’ve bought a sander for that! I said I’d have to call him back when I’d checked. He was insistent on the price though it must be wrong.
Since then he has called me twice and now emailed with the same price.
I haven’t felt able to answer! There’s no way I would have hired it for this price. I’m really stressed about money at the moment anyway!
Can they get nasty? I got the impression that they’ve a few bills they’re chasing due to the way they run it!

Should I
A. Pay up. B. Pay by transfer what I thought it would be. And write an email stating why I think that’s all I should pay.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Seafog · 14/11/2021 03:19

It sounds like you were both at fault, id call and ask for a breakdown of charges

TirednWorried · 14/11/2021 02:51

Maybe rhey lost out on a hire because it wasn't returned on time, and there is a penalty charge because of this?

CheeseMmmm · 14/11/2021 02:47

Is it a big company? Are prices on the site? Etc. You could take head office route.

If a proper professional heavy duty sander in surprised they that cheap to buy.

Can you go in and work through with them? That might be better than phone.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 14/11/2021 02:05

Dear Toolman,

Thanks for your email of [date] however I think there may have been an error in the invoice.

Based on your website, I was expecting to pay £54 comprised of:
£20.00 initial hire
£12.50 per week (week 1)
£12.50 per week (week 2)

£45.00 subtotal
£ 9.00 vat
_
£54.00

Please could you check your calculations to see if I have been charged correctly?

Thank you.

Put it in writing. Always put it in writing!

ThinWomansBrain · 14/11/2021 01:52

charging VAT twice gets it to £64.80 - you definitely need a credit note for that! Can you work out from the invoice what the rest of the discrepancy is?

Sounds very dodgy - you can check they have a valid VAT number here.
www.tax.service.gov.uk/check-vat-number/enter-vat-details
I once uncovered a fraud where a supplier had been charging VAT monthly, but wasn't actually VAT registered - so pocketing the 20%

BudrosBudrosGalli · 13/11/2021 20:31

In that case OP, fair enough, I would ask for a proper invoice too.

Zzzexhaustedzzz · 13/11/2021 19:44

I rang them after a week and no answer, left a message to say I still had it and would return in a week.
Yes Thankyou, I know I’ve been disorganised etc. When I say things came up I mean I was snowed under with work and couldn’t bike it down there.
Yes they had it back exactly 2 weeks later.
Thanks for the reminder that there’s no need for drama, honestly I needed to hear that! I think the initial phone call, attitude on the phone has stressed me out!
I will ask for a more accurate breakdown than in the bill he Emailed me. VAT seems to have been added twice, to the tool hire and again at the end of the bill…. Hmmm

OP posts:
ThinWomansBrain · 13/11/2021 19:39

email your query as to how they got to the £77, along with the screen shot of the advertised price, and your calculation in the email.
if they don't come up with an explanation, try sending a cheque! (yes I know!) with "in full and final settlement" written on the on the back.

You could always report to trading standards - but to be honest, not agreeing a price and hire period in advance, you've kind of set yourself up for this.
For £20 - I think I'd just learn from the experience be more organised and use a more professional company in the future.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 13/11/2021 19:27

Ask for a break down of the costs, but often the lowest prices on on long term (several weeks) and/or hires booked in advance, or a cheap first week as a “hook”. Don’t assume that 1 week’s hire is the same as the next week’s.

MargaretThursday · 13/11/2021 19:27

Ask for a break down.
if they charged you £20 + £12.50+VAT a week then for 2 weeks it would come to £78, which is one possibility.
However I think more likely from your vague "Stuff came up and I ended up keeping it for 2 weeks" that you have been charged more for not returning it when they expected.
So if you'd told them you were keeping it for 2 weeks then you would only have been charged £54. Because you told them you were (or maybe didn't tell them you weren't) only taking it for a week, the price goes up accordingly.

ChequerBoard · 13/11/2021 19:22

Given that you kept it longer than the agreed hire period and they have had to chase you for payment /return, I think it's pretty obvious that a penalty fee of some kind has been added to the whatever the basic hire fee for the 2/3 weeks would have been.

Seems fair enough to me. You need to be more organised and should have return led the equipment on the agreed date.

Dishwashersaurous · 13/11/2021 19:16

Based on the prices you quote I can't work out how he got to £77. Even if you kept for three weeks it would be £69.

Basically you just need to ask for a price breakdown of what's been charged

jetadore · 13/11/2021 19:08

Even better ask them to provide a copy of the hire agreement signed by you, agreeing to the cost/their terms, with the dates of hire/return, also singed. Bear in mind if they do have it you might have to pay up!

jetadore · 13/11/2021 19:04

Have they got the sander back now? Just don’t pay, or pay what you think is right, by the sounds of it they’re probably not organised enough to chase you for it. And if you didn’t sign anything then there was no contract in place so they haven’t got a leg to stand on either. You won’t be able to go back there again though!

BudrosBudrosGalli · 13/11/2021 18:40

@drpet49

* Stuff came up and I ended up keeping it for 2 weeks.*

^Your fault isn’t it.

Lol I did not even see that bit. OP, you make yourself sound a bit of a brat here. Pay up and take it as a good lesson to be more organised in the future.
kazzer2867 · 13/11/2021 18:39

@MasterBeth

They seem a bit unorganised, but so do you. You thought it would be £55 and it’s more like £75? It’s expensive but not extortionate. It’s not like it’s 2/3 times what you thought you’d pay.

I’m afraid it’s an expensive lesson to you to get a quote next time.

This. You had a responsibility to check the price when in store. What do you think they'll do if you just keep ignoring their call??
drpet49 · 13/11/2021 18:36

* Stuff came up and I ended up keeping it for 2 weeks.*

^Your fault isn’t it.

BudrosBudrosGalli · 13/11/2021 18:33

You might be able to buy a budget DIY sander for under £50 but a decent sander does cost more. The price actually seems normal for tool hire. They are expensive but that is how they make their money.

MasterBeth · 13/11/2021 18:15

They seem a bit unorganised, but so do you. You thought it would be £55 and it’s more like £75? It’s expensive but not extortionate. It’s not like it’s 2/3 times what you thought you’d pay.

I’m afraid it’s an expensive lesson to you to get a quote next time.

Sirzy · 13/11/2021 18:13

Did it go into the third week? Or was it exactly 14 days?

Legoisawesome · 13/11/2021 18:11

Are you sure your 2 weeks isn’t actually 2 weeks and a day as that might put you in to the third week category and explain the extra cost?

araiwa · 13/11/2021 15:59

Ask for a breakdown of cost and find out why it's different to your expected price.

No need for drama

slashlover · 13/11/2021 15:53

Did you inform them you would be keeping it for 2 weeks or did you hire it for a few days and then just not return it?

Theunamedcat · 13/11/2021 15:41

Ask him to send you a copy of the hire contract you signed as you seem to have misplaced your copy

Also point out to him you have worked it out by the figures given on his website at a different amount

Zzzexhaustedzzz · 13/11/2021 14:52

Yes, I can’t remember whether I signed something actually. Slight problem that! It was all so slapdash.I know it’s a crazy price isn’t it? I only have a bike and returning it was an issue as I just found I had too much on. What an idiot! I’m talking about the smallest size sander!!

OP posts: