Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the future property market won't perform as well as it has previously?

29 replies

flashbac · 13/11/2021 09:55

Seeing posts telling OPs to keep property as it will increase in value like the property they bought in the 90s did. I think that ship has sailed now that everyone knows about it. Plus, being a (good) landlord is not as easy as people make out.
But what do I know!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RitaFires · 15/11/2021 11:55

I was saying something similar to my partner about the houses on my mother's street. They're worth 5 times what my parents paid in the early 90s, so the families that moved in back then can afford to add extensions, conservatories and convert the attic etc because even if it doesn't add much value the house is still worth so much more than they initially paid. Anyone who bought more recently would make profit if they sold now but it wouldn't be many multiples of what they've paid and any additions may not be worth it as they may not make the money back.

I think property is a good investment and will hold its value but I genuinely hope that prices don't climb to the same extent they've done in the past.

Cinderella121 · 15/11/2021 11:23

I wish it would but unfortunately don’t think it will as everyone seems to keep being able to come up with the money every time the prices rise !!
Of a friendship group of 25, me and my OH are the only ones who haven’t had any financial help to buy (and still can’t afford to!). Everyone else has been given huge amounts of help mainly through inheritance or a few when their parents have downsized. So I think home ownership will continue to depend on how much money your family can afford to give you rather than salaries etc.

onlychildhamster · 15/11/2021 09:48

@invisiblecats also over 90% home ownership in Singapore despite Being a country with the highest population density in the world

onlychildhamster · 15/11/2021 09:46

@invisiblecats in Singapore, no one thinks government housing is a handout because it is built for the poor, the middle income and to a certain extent the rich (the ones who choose to invest their money in other things or who buy the executive condos). 85% of the population live in government housing- it ranges from tiny 1 room rental flats at a few dollars nominal rent a month to the most common dwelling (4/5 room flat with 3 bedrooms and 1000 square feet) and also executive condos (includes swimming pool, tennis court and karaoke room but sold according to government housing affordability criteria). The key is that if the average person thought they could also benefit from it, they would also support it and it would also help enhance the neighborhood to have some middle class people living in it (who are more likely to push for improvements etc). I can see a successful council estate with mainly rental units for the poor but having a certain percentage of owner occupied housing where a middle earner can pay a cheaper price to live in (with the caveat he cannot rent it out or can only sell to the middle earner). m.youtube.com/watch?v=3dBaEo4QplQ

invisiblecats · 15/11/2021 09:31

@MissyB1

So only privileged people will be able to buy houses basically Well when I was a child in the 70s everyone I knew lived in council houses. Home ownership wasn’t for everyone, you didn’t assume you would own a property. It was totally normal to rent for life. But of course we had council properties in those days - but then the “right to buy” came in Angry I guess it wouldn’t have mattered so much but they basically stopped building them, they didn’t replace what they were selling!
It was a deliberate policy by the Tories to get rid of council housing.

They not only brought in right to buy, they actively banned local councils from reinvesting the money in new housing. Selling council housing would be fine if more was being built to replace it.

If we had a social housing scheme fit for the 21st century, it would save the tax payer so much money, plus be an investment in society and community.

I don't know why people think council housing is a hand-out, when the rent money comes into the system, and for those on benefits, it's money going round in circles within the system, rather than being syphoned off to private landlords. getting rid of council housing IS a handout - to private landlords.

Well I do know why people don't see that, it's the result of PR on behalf of those who want to exploit us.

When are we going to get some decent political leaders who will actually say this stuff out loud? Labour is an embarassment at the moment IMO.

Bluntness100 · 14/11/2021 19:52

Sadly op the rental market is littered with people who thought Like you. Always waiting for it to crash. Always being priced out.

The truth is the value of money increases. Forty years ago a packet of crisps cost approx 6 pence. It’s now ten times that. Bricks and mortar long term is Always the safest investment.

Poetrypatty · 14/11/2021 19:50

Yes that's very true onlychildhamster It won't go to what it once was.

onlychildhamster · 14/11/2021 19:42

@Poetrypatty prices can go down. It may crash.

But that doesn't mean that in the long term, property ownership would not become harder or that house prices would not continue to be high relative to income/average's person ability to get a mortgage.

Poetrypatty · 14/11/2021 19:40

On the one hand people think there's not enough property to go round, ie to buy, so prices will always go up. But on the other, a reasonable proportion of this now is BTLs, eg in the hands of private landlords who are not emotionally attached to that property. As soon as prices go down, eg if interest rates go up and there are economic troubles, then those BTL owners will all scramble to sell and prices will start to go downwards.

I say that as someone who's old enough to remember when prices could never go down before, until they did. So I think YANBU

onlychildhamster · 14/11/2021 19:33

@MissyB1 I can quite imagine future generations renting rather than owning. It may even become affordable to rent in retirement if there are rent controls (and there may be in urban areas). And what may happen is due to retirement age increasing, people may find themselves working until age 70 plus, at which point they may have saved enough to buy something small rurally for cash or enough for rent for the next 20 years until they need a care home which would be paid for by the state.

I own my home (in London) but I don't foresee myself retiring before retirement age and I am only 29. Sometimes I think that if renting was more pleasant with longer term tenancies, it would make no sense for me to buy in London as even in my 20s I have enough equity in my home to buy a terraced house outright in Yorkshire and while yorkshire may not be that cheap when I retire, I think if i saved invested my deposit instead, i would probably still have enough to buy a small place up north outright when I retire and so will have a place to live rent free. That may be a better option than buying a home in London and having my money tied up in my primary home for all those years. But the fact is, renting is quite unstable at the moment so I bought. But that could change for future generations.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 14/11/2021 17:51

30 years ago mortgage rates were about 12%.

MissyB1 · 14/11/2021 17:22

So only privileged people will be able to buy houses basically
Well when I was a child in the 70s everyone I knew lived in council houses. Home ownership wasn’t for everyone, you didn’t assume you would own a property. It was totally normal to rent for life. But of course we had council properties in those days - but then the “right to buy” came in Angry I guess it wouldn’t have mattered so much but they basically stopped building them, they didn’t replace what they were selling!

flashbac · 14/11/2021 17:11

@Naughtynovembertree

Property will always go up in the UK, we are an increasingly crowded island and millions of people are desperate to come here still that won't change m
I think the new energy efficient measures will have an impact on the value of older properties. There is already talk of banks not lending if the property doesn't reach a minimum standard.
OP posts:
NekoShiro · 13/11/2021 12:33

[quote onlychildhamster]@NekoShiro associate salary at JP Morgan/other comparable banks is 80k. Not even counting the other professions who pay well..plus inheritance. DH's friends in north London all got gifted deposits. It will just be very unequal. Most gen Z would be very poor and rent, but a minority would be able to afford big properties and many BTL if they wish. John Lewis are also getting into the rental market, they may start buying up properties in addition to investing in build to rent. Foreign investment. There is the demand for housing.[/quote]
So only privileged people will be able to buy housing basically. That's not sustainable I know there are high paying jobs but I'm thinking about everyone within the UK.

Earning £80k would put you in the top 5% of earners in the UK. www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/politics/2019/nov/22/factcheck-earning-80000-or-more-top-5-of-uk-earners-labour

Blossomtoes · 13/11/2021 12:30

@NekoShiro

I think the bubble will burst soon. Whose going to buy you're ever increasing expensive property? Gen Z who are earning what, £20k a year?

Didn't the government also recently say people are going to have to get used to a renters economy, so you're gonna end up being a landlord most likely which is a lot more work than just selling the property.

House prices can't inflate indefinitely.

This and the threshold for repaying student loans is about to be decreased. There’s an entire generation that won’t be able to afford to buy. BTL isn’t big enough to buy all the property in the first home bracket. I personally think prices will fall, slowly at the bottom initially and gradually impacting the rest of the market. It’s happened under previous governments - just ask anyone who went into negative equity in the 90s.
Naughtynovembertree · 13/11/2021 12:20

Property will always go up in the UK, we are an increasingly crowded island and millions of people are desperate to come here still that won't change m

onlychildhamster · 13/11/2021 11:57

@NekoShiro associate salary at JP Morgan/other comparable banks is 80k. Not even counting the other professions who pay well..plus inheritance. DH's friends in north London all got gifted deposits. It will just be very unequal. Most gen Z would be very poor and rent, but a minority would be able to afford big properties and many BTL if they wish. John Lewis are also getting into the rental market, they may start buying up properties in addition to investing in build to rent. Foreign investment. There is the demand for housing.

NekoShiro · 13/11/2021 10:24

I think the bubble will burst soon. Whose going to buy you're ever increasing expensive property? Gen Z who are earning what, £20k a year?

Didn't the government also recently say people are going to have to get used to a renters economy, so you're gonna end up being a landlord most likely which is a lot more work than just selling the property.

House prices can't inflate indefinitely.

howmanyhats · 13/11/2021 10:24

The gains have been going on a lot longer than 30 years, in London at least. My parents bought the London townhouse I grew up in about 50 years ago.

There had been a boom and houses in that area had trebled in 3 years: from £5k to £15k.

The person they'd bought it off, paid £1k for it. So that's going back probably at least 60 years if not more.

It's now worth at least £2million. (Shame they don't own it any more, though!)

We may well reach societal collapse at some point, given how poorly governments are tackling the major problems of today, and then the property market will be meaningless. But until then, it'll keep going up I reckon,

onlychildhamster · 13/11/2021 10:20

@sst1234 I bought in London and I could not afford to buy in Tel Aviv, Munich, New York, San Francisco as well as many other cities.

To think that the future property market won't perform as well as it has previously?
flashbac · 13/11/2021 10:19

I don't think there will be a crash but the returns won't be as good. That, coupled with headache of being a landlord, may mean investing in a tracker or similar might be better, especially if its tax free.
Also, people are forgetting about capital gains tax. This could take 20 to 40% of any gain.

OP posts:
sst1234 · 13/11/2021 10:18

@Ricetwisty

The most sensible thing is to just buy a house to live in rather than make loads of investments that will probably make a return, but not necessarily. It has to peak at somepoint, who knows when.
Commodity prices can never peak until the number of people on the planet stops growing. Supply and demand.
sst1234 · 13/11/2021 10:17

Property prices haven’t increased at the same rate across the country. And to be honest property prices in this country have not done anything out of the ordinary when you compare against G20. In fact we have seen lower house price growth than many other countries. The problem is not mostly property prices - just bear with me. It’s low wages. We have a low wage culture in this country propagated by government subsidies for the low paid. Tax credits is when all this started. And housing benefit is also part of this. Wages would have kept up with inflation if this culture of subsidizing low wages hadn’t become so prevalent in the late 90s and early 00s.

TakeYourFinalPosition · 13/11/2021 10:14

There’s no way to know.

I’d bet that the governments will do all they can to keep property as valuable as possible, for economic reasons.

But it’s a bet. Even the economists and statisticians can’t agree. It’s predicting the future, and so you have to be aware of all eventualities… theres been masses of people preparing everyone for a crash that hasn’t come for years and years. There will always be people selling property as a get-rich-quick idea that will sucker some people in and lose them money, too.

I’d bet that it’ll keep going up; but there’s no way to know.

SoniaFouler · 13/11/2021 10:14

I see your points OP but in an ever-desperate scramble for home ownership in this day and age, I just don’t think not keeping property as opposed to keeping property is a bad decision and a money-losing one.