Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think you can regret having a second child?

114 replies

MoonRiverLaLaLa · 13/11/2021 09:52

I have 1 DC and I can't decide whether to have another.
I don't really feel a desire for another child just yet, but I am feeling guilty that my child won't have a sibling. Or that if something were to happen to my DC, then I won't have anyone left.

You keep hearing that "you never regret having another baby (even if they end up having complex special needs), but you can regret not having a baby". But is it really true?

Tell me your stories where you or someone you know wanted to give your child a sibling and it all went wrong, and now you regret it.

YABU - you can never regret a second child, even if your life becomes much harder
YANBU - you can regret having a second child

OP posts:
RealBecca · 13/11/2021 11:40

Plenty of people dont like their siblings and i take comfort in knowing i have no obligation to keep going if i lost my child.

Unless you feel like you NEED another baby i think ots a bad decision. Plenty of research supports the benefits of only children.

Phoebesgift · 13/11/2021 11:40

My second DD has autism. Honestly feel DD1 would've been happier as an only. DD2 is a lovely child but she causes her sister embarrassment at school and with friends and DD2 can be quite mean and unfriendly to her a lot of the time.
Life would've been easier without her but I can't say I regret it. I wish they were close though and had a good sibling relationship though.

Fifthtimelucky · 13/11/2021 11:36

Of course you can regret having a second child- or a third, or a fourth or indeed a first.

I had two and don't regret it for a minute. I slightly regret that I didn't have a third, but know that we were right to stop when we did (both because of our ages and financially).

I think it can be hard to separate out your feelings for the child and your feelings for the situation and I imagine it's difficult to people to say that they regret having a child because it's tantamount to saying that you wish that one of your children hadn't been born. Few parents will ever want to admit that.

I'd say if you don't feel a desire for another child you shouldn't have one.

BadwordMcGee · 13/11/2021 11:23

I love both my children, and I'm very glad I got to meet DC2, she's been very healing of the trauma I experienced from DC1. However there are lots of times I wish I'd stuck to one child. If DC1&2

VladmirsPoutine · 13/11/2021 11:20

My position has always been don't have a child unless you desperately want one. That said, this:

"Tell me your stories where you or someone you know wanted to give your child a sibling and it all went wrong, and now you regret it."

Sounds very 'This is Life'.

BruiserWoods · 13/11/2021 11:19

I can recognise that my life would have been much calmer and easier if I hadn't had second child. Different sexes as well so I struggled to get a 3 bed place. a 2 bed would have been cheaper and easier. 2nd child has demand avoidance. it's been hard. it's still hard. Not that I care anymore but obviously you're a less attractive prospect to a potential new relationship if you have not one but two children and one of them very difficult. I'd say that the way having a second child impacted on my life as a single mother was poorer quality of housing because I always had to have 3 bedrooms and staying single. I had too much on my plate for a new relationship(tried a couple of times, too hard) so, 14 years on, still single, still in a place with 3 beds but it's really shabby, tiny, delapidated, too far out of the town we live in.

But perhaps the worst thing is that dc1 gets annoyed that I cannot treat them ''the same''. They are different. Different abilities, different emotional levels, different sexes, different people. But yet dc1 angry and that has affected our relationship negatively.

Hoppinggreen · 13/11/2021 11:19

I adore DS but I think DD would have been happier as an Only.
I wouldn’t say I regret having him as he’s awesome but if I could turn the clock back I probably wouldn’t do it again

Dixiechickonhols · 13/11/2021 11:15

I my have a second child because you want one. I have an only and it’s been a great fit for us. Easier to work in professional job. She obviously benefits materially - holidays, activities etc. She is happy as an only. Lots are onelies now or from different family set ups. I personally don’t believe all lose old stereotypes.

Onatree · 13/11/2021 11:15

Hypothetical discussions about the emotions you may feel in un/planned scenarios are: hypothetical discussions.

You will not be able to establish how exactly you may or may not feel after a 6-9 lb human emerges out of you - with or without special needs, with or without certain delightful or awful traits, with or without any family fortunes or disasters unfolding.

IncompleteSenten · 13/11/2021 11:13

Nobody can say that it is impossible for anyone, anywhere, under any circumstances to regret a second child.

Don't have a child for any other reason than you really want a child.

Notgettingbetter · 13/11/2021 11:12

My one child is still an horrific sleeper at four years old. If someone could guarantee a good sleeper for a second child I'd go for it, but I'm not prepared to take the risk.

Comedycook · 13/11/2021 11:11

Well of course you can. Some people regret having one child,or two or three. I have two. I'm happy with that. I don't have three because I know I would regret that.

I will say though that two is a manageable number and actually can make life easier as they have each other for entertainment rather than just you!

olderthanyouthink · 13/11/2021 11:10

@AreYouRightThereSkippy same DC1 was a horrendous sleeper, DC2 is an great sleeper. I thing DC1 will just be harder than DC2 so i thinking it would be easier to have regrets if they were the other way round

User310 · 13/11/2021 11:06

I think it’s very hard to regret a child that you love immensely. I think you can recognise life would have been easier and less stressful with just one though.

Notgettingbetter · 13/11/2021 11:05

Additionally, I have two siblings and we are not close at all.

Lorw · 13/11/2021 11:04

Don’t feel pressured into having a second just to give your first a sibling, there is no guarantee they will get on and no guarantee life will be better. If you are content with just one just keep with one.

Nocutenamesleft · 13/11/2021 10:54

I fell in love with my second straight away.

I’m lucky that my kids get on so well with each other and are like best of friends. They are the same gender and have the exact same interests.

My friend though had a much bigger age gap between her two and they don’t even speak to each other. They don’t converse. They don’t play. One doesn’t like the others things to do so there’s always one which is unhappy. I find she gives in way more to her little one. So her bigger one is always sad and left to the sidelines. It’s almost like it’s pure luck involved.

Franca123 · 13/11/2021 10:49

I love having two. I hated my brother growing up but love having him as an adult. It's good to know you will always have that support. Plus I love my nieces. My neices have a fantastic relationship with each other. Although having the second has been tough at times, I've never really regretted it ever. But then my two don't fight with each other........ yet. Don't feel any pressure for a second. Do what you want to do.

FreeBritnee · 13/11/2021 10:40

I think only children will be fine. I also think children with siblings can have an enriched experience or a negative one. For me the age gap was too big so having a sibling was neither hear nor there. For my kids they adore each other and I suspect they’ll have a friendship for life.

Franca123 · 13/11/2021 10:39

Also, my friend is happily an only child and she fully intends to stick at one herself.

georgarina · 13/11/2021 10:39

You can regret anything, it depends on your life and circumstances.

I was lonely as an only child so it was very important for me to have more than one.

But everyone is different and does things for different reasons.

Nothing is 100%.

Franca123 · 13/11/2021 10:38

I think my mum regrets having me! Not in a really horrible way as I know I'm loved but since being an adult the family have been quite open that I was a 'mistake' as opposed to the 'miracle' I'd been led to believe I was. I'd say overall my parents are glad with how things turned out!

Needhelp101 · 13/11/2021 10:34

I don't regret having a second child.

But my life would be infinitely easier if I hadn't (he has ASD).

But I can't regret it. I love him so much and so does his brother.

AreYouRightThereSkippy · 13/11/2021 10:29

Yes, I think you can.

Tbh, when I fell pregnant with dc2, I wasn't at all sure we'd done the right thing! When he arrived though, I really did fall madly in love with him. And he was a fantastic sleeper (still is), which helped immensely.

Dc1 just didn't sleep. I assumed it was that way with all babies until I had dc2. If we'd had the good sleeper first and the one who didn't sleep second, I think it would have been a horrible shock tbh! Can imagine regretting that.

Only have one if you want one. Don't be pressured by all the silly stigma there still seems to be towards one child families.

I will say, that the saying that two is easier than one has actually been true for us to a point, as they do keep each other entertained sometimes. But it wouldn't be a good enough reason to have a second. Babies are hard work no matter how comparatively easy they are.

tickledtiger · 13/11/2021 10:24

I think it’s taboo to say you regret having a child regardless of how many you have. I’m sure there are many people who regret a second but never say anything about it.

I know a woman (the second child) whose dad told her he regretted her and never loved her but I think that can be put down to him being a waste of oxygen more than anything else.

Swipe left for the next trending thread