Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think you can regret having a second child?

114 replies

MoonRiverLaLaLa · 13/11/2021 09:52

I have 1 DC and I can't decide whether to have another.
I don't really feel a desire for another child just yet, but I am feeling guilty that my child won't have a sibling. Or that if something were to happen to my DC, then I won't have anyone left.

You keep hearing that "you never regret having another baby (even if they end up having complex special needs), but you can regret not having a baby". But is it really true?

Tell me your stories where you or someone you know wanted to give your child a sibling and it all went wrong, and now you regret it.

YABU - you can never regret a second child, even if your life becomes much harder
YANBU - you can regret having a second child

OP posts:
themerrywifeofwindsor · 13/11/2021 21:32

I know it won't be this way forever, but right now I regret having more than 1. I have 2 and all they do is fight, from morning until night. You would not believe the things they find to fight about. It's like a competition to see who can get more attention by behaving the worst. We now do stuff with them separately as much as possible as they're both much better behaved without their sibling there.

userisi · 13/11/2021 21:23

I've seen it spouted on here endless times, extremely irresponsible. I can completely imagine regretting having another child, which is why I won't do it despite my hormones sometimes telling me to go for it.

Darkstar4855 · 13/11/2021 21:21

I think my son gets far more benefit from the time that I have for him as an only child than he loses by not having a sibling. If I’d had a second I wouldn’t have been able to do half the stuff like swimming lessons, outdoor activities, travel etc. because I’d have been too busy looking after the baby.

Do what feels right for you.

Peeceandquite · 13/11/2021 21:14

Don't regret the first 2 at all. Don't regret the 3rd as such as I love him dearly, but my health has deteriorated a lot since he was born and I'm not in the situation I thought I'd be in. Life is generally a struggle. During low moments I wonder how much easier things would be if I'd made a different decision. I absolutely wouldn't be without him now though, but if I'd never had him I wouldn't know any different.

But then I wonder if I hadn't had him would I be sitting here wishing I'd had another 🤷

drpet49 · 13/11/2021 20:59

The only regrets I know of are from people who chose to have 1 child.

saltontoast · 13/11/2021 20:52

We had a second DC, I love him more than anything. Things have changed dramatically and I'm not better off for it but hey, he's here and I wanted him. I do worry and have a lot more stress than I used to, basic things are a lot harder for us but this is due to a small age gap.

I count my blessings he's here, because we were infertile and needed ivf to have first DC but I did have regrets at times but I think that was the baby blues

JSL52 · 13/11/2021 20:43

To dread every part of parenting day and night. http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4400859-to-dread-every-part-of-parenting-day-and-night

0verth1inker · 13/11/2021 19:42

If you don’t want a second child don’t have one. Don’t defend your choice, don’t feel guilt you do you!

I won’t be helpful as the second child is the second light of my life and I adore her. The thought of her (or the elder!) not existing doesn’t bear thinking about!

The only person I’ve ever met who’s ‘regretted’ a subsequent child was her third and they had severe disabilities after an awful birth. She loves them obviously but it’s changed the family hugely, she’s had to stop working, it’s impacted the older children and their lifestyle beyond belief. We are very close and she’s confided a few times she wish she’d never had a third. He’s a gorgeous child but life is hard.

HelloBunny · 13/11/2021 19:37

I’m really thrilled with my kid. I love being a mum. I had him quite late in life & have no intention of having another child. So, no regret here at not having a second child. I don’t think it about much at all. Go with your gut feeling...

Ricetwisty · 13/11/2021 19:32

[quote Justheretoaskaquestion91]@Ricetwisty

Ok thank you for sharing! It’s a worry of mine given my siblings/my own childhood but I’ve always told myself with a loving and stable home it wouldn’t happen to my children. I’m sorry to hear about your brother[/quote]
He is a minority, and providing a stable and loving home absolutely has huge benefits anyway.

Nailingnow · 13/11/2021 19:30

No way.

I knew I wanted a small age gap (2 years) and knew I had to get pregnant sooner than I was ready.

I knew when I was ready for the 2nd baby I would hate the 9 month pregnancy wait and so I just went for it.

My two boys are so funny together and keep each other entertained so much

Teaandtoastedbiscuits · 13/11/2021 19:28

My life would be 100% easier if I didn't have a second as I had them really close together but they are great friends and it is getting easier in some ways(and harder in others). I definitely don't regret having a second though it's just life is much more chaotic. Friends of mine who didn't have them so close together seem to cope better than me but the gap is too large for them to play together. I realise this might not be helpful but this is just my experience of it. I think if you are happy with the way your life is now you shouldn't feel pressure to have another.

InvincibleInvisibility · 13/11/2021 19:16

My 2nd vastly improved our family life. DS1 was/is very intense (now diagnosed with ADHD and dyspraxia) and DS2 diluted him and made everything lighter.

They adore playing together and help each other out. Yes there's squabbles but it's rare and never mean.

DS2 made DS1 less self centered - dS1 really cares about DS2 is a way thats different to how he cares about us. DS 2 has learnt a lot from Ds1 and together they can do things I wouldn't let them do by themselves.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 13/11/2021 19:13

@Ricetwisty

Ok thank you for sharing! It’s a worry of mine given my siblings/my own childhood but I’ve always told myself with a loving and stable home it wouldn’t happen to my children. I’m sorry to hear about your brother

Ricetwisty · 13/11/2021 19:01

Did wonder if concealed abuse or something took place, but as he used emotional blackmail as a form of control I'm sure he would have said for his own benefit.

Ricetwisty · 13/11/2021 19:00

[quote Justheretoaskaquestion91]@Ricetwisty

Can I ask what your childhood was like? Did your brother experience differently from you? I’m so curious about why one sibling can turn out differently like that, particularly if they both come from a stable and loving home[/quote]
Nothing at all, my parents were extremely fair in term of money and time spent on us etc. We didn't have a lot, but we had enough that we didn't miss out on anything or worry where our next meal was coming from; no one in even the extended family has ever been in trouble with the law or taken drugs (to an extent it affects their life anyway, I'm sure some have dabbled socially!). The only thing between us is he was diagnosed with ADHD as an adult, and apparently that can lead to addictive behaviours, although obviously not saying everyone who has it is like that, but I wonder if it played a part. Obviously once he became a living nightmare he had a disproportionate amount of time and money spent on him, but prior to that nothing was different.

BadwordMcGee · 13/11/2021 18:56

@Justaflippertyjibbet

I am an only child and I longed for sibling all my life. Now in my mid seventies. I was lonely at times during my childhood, like holidays, festivals and of course, in my day, every Sunday. I did have a large family of cousins with whom I spent many happy days as we all lived locally.

I felt very alone when dealing with end of life events with my parents. Thank goodness I had the support of my two adult children.

My first child was a first grandchild to each family, and to my eyes perfect. I worried endlessly over a second child in case of disability etc. However they turned it to be as equally perfect as my first. Very different but have wonderful relationship as adults.

I'm sorry you felt that way.

I have 5 siblings, and longed to be an only child my entire childhood. As adults, none of us speak, not due to falling out but as we have virtually nothing but our parents in common. Having to undertake joint decision making (such as care of elderly parents) has been a nightmare, and there's been no support from siblings at all. We're either all at odds about the best course of action or feel one or the other isn't pulling their weight or is taking over things. I doubt once both parents are dead we'll not see each other again.

Roselilly36 · 13/11/2021 18:51

I have two DS’ very close in age, DS1 was the most easy baby, great sleeper, very contented, lulled me into a false sense of security, I wanted another DC by the time DS1 was four months old, I was pregnant by the time DS1 was a year old. DS2 was a total different story, very difficult baby, the first 7 mths were total hell, thank goodness for my lovely MIL that helped us so much. Now my two DS’s are 20 & 18 they are best friends as well as brothers, they love each other so much, and share such a bond. No regrets in having my two, and if DS2 hadn’t been such a difficult baby, I would have considered a 3rd.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 13/11/2021 18:48

@Ricetwisty

Can I ask what your childhood was like? Did your brother experience differently from you? I’m so curious about why one sibling can turn out differently like that, particularly if they both come from a stable and loving home

Ricetwisty · 13/11/2021 18:43

@Justaflippertyjibbet

I am an only child and I longed for sibling all my life. Now in my mid seventies. I was lonely at times during my childhood, like holidays, festivals and of course, in my day, every Sunday. I did have a large family of cousins with whom I spent many happy days as we all lived locally.

I felt very alone when dealing with end of life events with my parents. Thank goodness I had the support of my two adult children.

My first child was a first grandchild to each family, and to my eyes perfect. I worried endlessly over a second child in case of disability etc. However they turned it to be as equally perfect as my first. Very different but have wonderful relationship as adults.

Not all siblings get on though, my brother abused me, stole from me, commanded all of my parents time, was an addict and all round ruined my childhood. I thankfully have nothing to do with him now, and deal with people's judgement on that and a feeling of guilt around it. I'd rather DS feels like he potentially missed out on a wonderful sibling relationship rather than risk it.
Justaflippertyjibbet · 13/11/2021 18:38

I am an only child and I longed for sibling all my life. Now in my mid seventies. I was lonely at times during my childhood, like holidays, festivals and of course, in my day, every Sunday. I did have a large family of cousins with whom I spent many happy days as we all lived locally.

I felt very alone when dealing with end of life events with my parents. Thank goodness I had the support of my two adult children.

My first child was a first grandchild to each family, and to my eyes perfect. I worried endlessly over a second child in case of disability etc. However they turned it to be as equally perfect as my first. Very different but have wonderful relationship as adults.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 13/11/2021 17:53

I genuinely feel as if having 2 has just been 2 x the love and 2 x the happiness! Hopefully I feel like that with #3 😆

NellWilsonsWhiteHair · 13/11/2021 17:44

There are no guarantees of what 'a sibling' will be to your existing child, are there.

My second-born is a delight. She's lovely company and for the most part the pair of them adore each other and we're all glad she's here. But that sibling bond has been hard-won, and I very much wanted a second child, and even still over the past couple of years (money troubles and pandemic stress) I've frequently thought how much easier many things would be if I'd stopped at one.

Definitely the one-child families I know (peers of both my eldest and my youngest) lead what look like more fulfilling and adventurous lives than we currently do. And likewise my family experience of caring for elderly parents is that siblings don't necessarily share the burden or provide solidarity. There's a lot to be said for stopping at one.

GreekGod · 13/11/2021 17:35

I didn't regret it but I know family and friends who did. My eldest cousin just walked out one day on 3 kids many years ago and got on a motorbike and went travelling. She just couldn't take it and said she was going to have a break down. She got pregnant with the second and in the end they were twins and she had 3 whereas before she had one child and she had no family or friends nearby. She told me at the eldest one's wedding last year that she only fell pregnant to give a sibling to the first one but knew deep down she didn't really want a second and then of course she had twins. Her relationship with her kids has never been great and the kids are closer with her mum (my aunt, the grandmother) than with my cousin - very sad. If she only had one, she may have stuck around in my view.

I also know friends who feel resentful and extremely stressed when having a second child but our religion/society puts pressure on them to do so. So, i would say only have a second if 100% you want a second, its a lot of work and although I don't regret having 3, you have to really be in the right place mentally to raise 2 or more kids in society today

Thwackit · 13/11/2021 17:30

These threads pop up all the time. Tbh it’s
such a massively personal thing that a two option poll is not really worth a jot. The only person who can reliably confirm relief or regret at the decision you make will be you…after you’ve already made it and it’s too late to choose the other option!

I guess what I’m saying is that comments about ‘won’t your only child be lonely’ etc etc aren’t worth a penny, simply because nobody else has the same combination of partner, other sibling, job, income, house, personality, support network etc etc, nor is one baby as easy to manage as the next. I don’t understand how any stranger can say ‘YABU - you can never regret a second child’ when there are infinite variables at play.’ They might not have done but you could do.

You aren’t physic. Use your own gut instinct. It’s the only thing that remotely counts in the decision.

Swipe left for the next trending thread