Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did anyone not live with their Mum growing up? AIBU?

91 replies

AwesomeFishsticks · 13/11/2021 08:37

This is me. We're very close though had some terrible rows in my late teens. But sometimes even many years later there's a sadness that when she went on to get married and have more children, I wasn't there with her. Her husband is a really good bloke as well, but he was never my 'dad'. I never had one of those!

I grew up with a relative I adored who adored me btw so it's not like I missed out. Hence feeling a bit of a daftie for even feeling like I missed out, in a way.

I'm tired of trying to understand why I feel this, but gosh it does still cause me hurt sometimes - I wish it wouldn't because especially when there are other big things going on emotionally, it seems to come back at me.

Can anyone relate? AIBU to feel confused or hurt over this? Do I just need to grow up and get a grip?

OP posts:
WholeClassKeptIn · 19/11/2021 19:53

I bought that book a year ago Mamette! I just haven't faced reading it...

Mamette · 19/11/2021 19:51

Honestly I think I am suffering a sort of traumatic flashback at times. I get moments of feeling just complete terror and despair and alone-ness and sadness connected to the situation with my Mum (triggered by something else that's happening, which I have no control of).

Have you read this? It’s a little heavy-going but gives so much insight, I found.

Did anyone not live with their Mum growing up? AIBU?
WholeClassKeptIn · 19/11/2021 19:50

My mum wasnt safe to look after me. I moved in my dad who didn't want me. My teens were awful. I think the damage is deep.

Waterlemon · 19/11/2021 19:44

I’m not adopted/fostered but I found this really informative and it might explain Some of your feelings. It mentions growing up without a birth mother as a trauma even if there hasn’t been any traumatic experiences, it’s still a bereavement or loss..

www.educating-ella.co.uk/post/a-note-to-teaching-staff-from-the-parent-of-an-adopted-child

Wildrobin · 19/11/2021 19:26

OP I too think your feelings incredibly valid. However happy your childhood there would still be a fundamental sense that your mother didn’t look after you. I think that can go very deep even when you don’t want it to, and it’s normal . I would feel the same no matter how loved I’d been .

AwesomeFishsticks · 19/11/2021 19:22

Emdr rather Blush

OP posts:
AwesomeFishsticks · 19/11/2021 19:22

I'm just looking at therapists near me now...don't really know what to look for tbh. I don't know if talking can really help.

Could edmr help with feeling like I do?

OP posts:
AwesomeFishsticks · 19/11/2021 18:13

Thank you all for your further replies. I have to come back to this thread, because I just feel a bit lost all week. Very confused, can't understand my feelings and going round in circles.

I had thought I had resolved how I felt about things and made my peace with it all, but seems I haven't fully done so.

Also might sound silly but how does therapy really work for stuff like this? How will it help me feel somehow better?

Honestly I think I am suffering a sort of traumatic flashback at times. I get moments of feeling just complete terror and despair and alone-ness and sadness connected to the situation with my Mum (triggered by something else that's happening, which I have no control of). They don't last very long but are very strong in the moment.

I'm fine usually, and in a good long term relationship, so not sure how I'm capable of feeling so "abandoned" in those moments. So it's frustrating as hell to get these stabs Confused but the pain is honestly very real at the time.

OP posts:
Notgettingbetter · 13/11/2021 11:02

I'm reading this with interest. I have severe depression and I really struggle with my daughter. I have a lot of fantasies about suicide and about leaving to live by myself. But I know either of those would be incredibly damaging for her so I keep going. It's incredibly hard but she didn't ask to be born and I love her more than anything. I'm so sorry to everyone who's mother let them down. I hope you're all doing okay.

MrsWooster · 13/11/2021 10:20

I did, op, and however wonderful the replacement parent figures are /were, it has a fundamental impact.

Could you consider getting some counselling-I’d recommended a modality like transactional analysis or similar that pays attention to primary attachment and its impact.

It’s not ‘you’ and it’s not something that can’t be resolved /allayed.

Sian73 · 13/11/2021 10:08

My mum died when I was 12, OP.

I've lived with that emptiness ever since and it's massively shaped who I am now and how I behave as an adult.

There's one part of me that is very resilient and independent and another that is crumbling and traumatised. Having my own kids was so hard at first but over time they've helped me to heal. Time has done that too.

I've found pouring my love into my kids and creating the relationship with them that I'd like to have had with my mum has helped. We can't re-create what's gone - but can work with what is actually there and present now instead.

LolaButt · 13/11/2021 10:03

Quite simply an absent parent makes you question your self worth - what is it about me that’s so terrible my own parent couldn’t/wouldn’t be there for me.

dottiedodah · 13/11/2021 09:47

missing link to bio parents i mean !

dottiedodah · 13/11/2021 09:46

I think this is entirely reasonable TBH. Many children who are adopted and have happy lives, still have that missing link to their adoptive parents. Recently there was an article about an adopted child ,and she said she was always made to feel "grateful" for being adopted! There is a biological need to be close to our birth parent thats a fact .YANBU at all! I would look into a Counsellor .If you feel uncomfortable or not happy with the first one then try another .You need somewhere to explore your feelings in depth .I think that will help you come to terms with what has happened to you .The fact is you had a good RL with your relative which is good ,but you still need to come to terms with it

GoodnightGrandma · 13/11/2021 09:44

[quote Oneforthemoneytwo]@GoodnightGrandma clearly said by someone who hasn’t a clue[/quote]
Right back at you.

Oneforthemoneytwo · 13/11/2021 09:39

@GoodnightGrandma clearly said by someone who hasn’t a clue

DaisyDozyDee · 13/11/2021 09:24

I lived with my mum until I was 15, but we were a couple of hours away from several of my siblings. We all had a rather difficult relationship with her anyway, but I will never understand the thought process that led her to think that moving that far away from some of her children and splitting up siblings was a good idea. It was a horrific experience. For a couple of decades after I moved out we saw each other a few times a year if that. We managed a friendship in the end, but it was never the same as a mother-daughter relationship should be.
I don’t think you’re being at all greedy to be sad that you didn’t get that relationship with your mother growing up, and it doesn’t mean you’re not grateful for the love and care you were given by other people.

GoodnightGrandma · 13/11/2021 09:22

I would suggest that you learn to accept that this is your life, you don’t get a second go. And I know that it’s easy to say.
You need to make peace with it and accept it, rather than pushing against it.
I think counselling would be a great idea.

WarmthAndDepth · 13/11/2021 09:17

The two are not mutually exclusive, and you are not unreasonable for allowing the feeling of loss into your awareness. We feel how we feel, feelings are responses to our experiences. We're not unreasonable, greedy or guilty.
My guess is that you may be experiencing some cognitive dissonance; a difference is occurring between your actual experience and your belief system (which is likely to be so deeply rooted that you may not even be aware if it as an actual belief system as opposed to "reality"). As a young person you are likely to have internalised other people's ideas around being grateful for the loving care you received in the care of your relative, praised for how 'reasonable' and 'resilient' you were in your unusual circumstances, your mother's affirmation for being 'understanding'; any number of projections. These may have led to you adopting a sort of performative 'stoicism', which would make it difficult for you to recognise and give space to any more complicated feelings of loss or rejection. Deep belief systems around our life stories can serve to protect us from opening to and processing very difficult feelings; could it be that you are currently in a settled and 'safe' point in your life and that on some level, you have capacity to allow the feelings about the separation from your mother to surface?
I really recommend counselling.

chipsandfizz · 13/11/2021 09:08

Second the inner child healing. I agree it also sounds a bit wanky.

The more I read about attachment and trauma experienced in childhood, the more a lot of behaviour in adulthood makes sense.

thosepens · 13/11/2021 09:07

Yes @AwesomeFishsticks I can relate. Like @TestingTestingWonTooFree's post, I went to live at my grandparents' and my younger siblings stayed with our parents.

It still affects me, and counselling has helped. But I still have low self worth and fear rejection.

As an adult, I have looked for stability in relationships above all else and tried to give my DCs the happy home I never had.

AwesomeFishsticks · 13/11/2021 09:06

Thank you all for your thoughts on this. It's helpful to read.

OP posts:
chipsandfizz · 13/11/2021 09:05

I think your feelings are entirely natural. You are in no way greedy. It is fantastic that you had the maternal relationship and love with another. But even so that does not replace the fact it was given by another and not your mother.

I think you need to be kinder to yourself as it reads as though you feel that the feelings you experience are in some way your fault. I think they are natural and you are expecting too much of yourself to feel any differently.

marthasmum · 13/11/2021 09:03

Hi OP. This is not my situation but is my partner's. He and his brother were brought up by grandparents and his mum went on to have other children and was in their lives as an 'auntie' figure. They don't see her now though - I think for him, having our own children made him look differently on it. He doesn't talk much about it but for what it's worth, my observation over the 20 plus years of our relationship is that a child's relationship with their biological mum is a one-off. Other people may love you dearly (and I'm really glad you had that) and that is very powerful and protective. But I think if your biological mum is in your life, and you could have had that, yet you didn't...I think that's really difficult. Its different from being adopted and never having known your biological mum. I think your feelings are completely understandable and wish you well.

SnowWhitesSM · 13/11/2021 09:01

YANBU and you are not greedy. I think counselling will help. You need to parent your inner child (sounds wanky but that's the process).