Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or are my kids awful

88 replies

legalseagull · 13/11/2021 08:20

I'm so hurt. I have a 3yo DD and 2yo DS. They're amazing kids (obviously)

Last Christmas we spent it at my mum and step dads. Three nights. At that point the kids were JUST turned 3 and 1. Both were terrible sleepers. My eldest was also in the terrible 2's. Plus it was Christmas and a year of lockdown so the first time staying away. so over excited and stimulated. That being said, I don't think they were too bad. The break ended in the biggest argument I've ever had with my mum though. After days of little digs every time one of the whinged or tantrummed (for example when 1yo got upset that her dog stole his toy), it came to a end when they were screaming not to go to bed. They kept opening the bedroom door and shouting to come down. DH went up to calm them and DM started her "no wonder they cry if you pander / spoiling / lack discipline routine.

Fast forward to last weekend. We went again for three nights (they live far away). They're now a year older and generally much happier and calmer. All weekend they were brilliant in my view. A delight. On the last day they were obviously shattered, falling asleep etc. Step dad made Sunday lunch and the kids wouldn't eat it. "No. Don't want it". They also both threw admittedly huge tantrums when trying to leave. Thankfully my mum seems to have learnt to bite her lip. Step dad however started saying how he "didn't envy us. Kids playing up. Lacking discipline. Naughty at dinner. You need to do X Y Z"

AIBU to think they're pretty normal kids and it's just their ages, and being so close in age meaning they wind each other up?! I'm so upset that my parents ignore the 3 days of wonderful behaviour and just judge and criticise me for the bad. We don't feel welcome there at all. As soon as the kids whinge or strop I instantly feel judged and then get told all the things I'm doing wrong.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Borrasca · 14/11/2021 08:49

Thank you so much for starting this thread @legalseagull - I feel so on edge when I go to my parents, so it's a relief to know that I'm not alone and will just add to my resolve for next time they start!

EmeraldShamrock · 13/11/2021 21:58

They forget how things were with their own DC plus old style disciplinary tactics no longer exist thankfully.

DeepaBeesKit · 13/11/2021 21:30

Yanbu

But I would have different expectations of your nearly 4 yo vs 2 yo.

Nearly 4 I would expect not to be outright refusing a meal unless it was something quite odd/not child friendly etc.

clatterclatter · 13/11/2021 20:32

Glad you are feeling better OP. As everyone has said it’s selective memory and the fact that many previous generations parented via fear as default.

It amuses me (only very slightly) that we seem to have a bit of an opposite situation going on with my parents. DS is king and can do no wrong in their eyes. He gets away with murder at their house. And when I was a kid we literally never put a foot wrong for fear of my dad. My childhood memories of him are him losing his temper and shouting at us about something inconsequential on repeat for 18 years.

legalseagull · 13/11/2021 20:18

You really have all made me feel so much better. Thank you so much

OP posts:
Meatshake · 13/11/2021 20:08

It's a generational thing (and yes I am generalising, no I'm not ageist)

When I was young, consensus was generally that tantrums were a sign of a naughty, willful, disobedient child and should beaten out of tthechild.

hToday I thinkmost people recognise a tantrum as a child communicating that they are overtired, overstimulated or have big feelings that they are struggling to communicate effectively.

legalseagull · 13/11/2021 19:45

@NeverTheHootenanny

If you were there for three days and the only massive tantrum was on the last day, then you’re doing amazingly well in my book. My two year old has several meltdowns daily. Your parents would be horrified.
Thank you. I mean, they whinge and fight with each other a bit every day, but at my mums they were so distracted by all the lovely surroundings (she lives on a farm whereas we're in a city). They were a bloody dream.

I'll try not to take it personally. I remember SD actually being the same with our dog when he was a pup. He hated him and told me regularly how awful he was and that I was allowing him to be 'too dog' Hmm Needless to say at 6 years old he's now a lovely dog and it was just age.

We're going to have Christmas here! We'll go up there for New year, but we've decided to get an Air BNB on the pretext of it being too noisy for the kids to sleep during their house party. Perfect

OP posts:
beachtosunset · 13/11/2021 17:18

Avoid Christmas with Mum and SD

Enjoy your childen at home just your happy unit Smile

NeverTheHootenanny · 13/11/2021 16:57

If you were there for three days and the only massive tantrum was on the last day, then you’re doing amazingly well in my book.
My two year old has several meltdowns daily. Your parents would be horrified.

Muchuseaschocolateteapot · 13/11/2021 16:39

My twins are nearly 18 so it’s been a while since we had toddlers to look after, but my sister in law brings her 18 month old around every now and then and it’s EXHAUSTING! SIL is a lot younger than her siblings and it is a really tricky balance between studiously ignoring tantrums and wanting to give advice that you genuinely think might help. Perhaps that is how the grandparents feel with you OP? You are used to the maelstrom of baby/toddler life so your lives are full and very busy I would imagine and if your little ones are unsettled by change perhaps your parents could come to you?

I’ll give you an example of what I mean. When my nephew was a little baby he was crying and his parents were trying to get him off to sleep. His dad was shushing him, only after a while did we realise he was actually shushing all the adults in the room into silence. We all stood like statues in silence for about 15 minutes until he fell asleep. They felt it best that the house was silent for him to sleep. My husband said to his sister that she should let him get used to a bit of noise. Fast forward 18 months and once he has gone to bed at 7pm you can’t flush the loo, shower or have your phone ringer on. His parents are used to it and it’s their choice but of course for the rest of the family it’s either amusing or irritating. Their child and their choice, but it wears thin pretty quickly when they are staying with you!

MarmaladeToastAndAMarmaladeCat · 13/11/2021 16:38

I have children a little older than yours with the same age gap and this sort of behaviour sounds very familiar to me. Especially when we are away somewhere and they are overtired, have wound each other up and are out of their normal routine. I’ve had similar comments from my dad and mil and it is annoying. I smile and nod generally but it does get to me when they act as if we were always well behaved when we weren’t and that it was all down to their superior parenting. Nothing to do with the fact I was terrified of my dad because one wrong move would end in me being smacked.

Chasingaftermidnight · 13/11/2021 16:00

Agree with everyone else about selective memories/blurred memories. Both sets of grandparents in our family have this, especially my in-laws. Apparently my husband slept through the night from day one, never woke up early always ate whatever was put in front of him and never had a tantrum. What a miraculous child!

NellWilsonsWhiteHair · 13/11/2021 15:44

"I would agree with this comment.
Sometimes either the grandparents forget or they view it all through rose tinted classes. Or sometimes they are just out of the habit of dealing with toddlers.

There may also be other factors at play due to your historical relationshiop with them. Jealousy even.

I had one of my grown up siblings voice criticisms about my toddler even though she had never had kids of her own. No idea of how that tiredness/hungry/unfamiliar environment/excitement thing can play out with toddlers and disrupt their routine, especially on special occasions like Christmas where expectations generally run high anyway with all concerned, and where to be honest there is usually a lot of sweets/sugary food involved which tends to hype them up anyway.

I also used to get a lot of flack for trying to limit their sugar intake on such occasions. Some but not all granparents see it as an act of love to give sweets etc.

Not so much for the parents. I totally noticed throughout DD's younger years that her behaviour was always more hyper when she ate party foods, or too much sugar. Occasionally of course it is fine, but a parent can't be blamed for wanting to stick to a routine because they know it works best.

Outdoors helps. But then again older folks (and I now class myself as one of those) may be reluctant to brave the weather.
With toddlers though, it really helps for them to burn their steam off outdoors...

So as a mum you have got a whole load of different needs going on there and a mismatch.

If you ask me that is where the arguments come from.
Hungry/not right types of foods as Christmas
Expectations (too high on their part and possibly yours_

It's like that thing that people say going on holiday with kids is never a holiday. (Except perhaps if it an extremely child friendly hotel where everything is organised, you can be outdoors and it is a kids club) and adults can have a few hours off.

Just something that looking back on it all I wish I had worked out earlier.

But parenting doesn't come with instructions or a manual. Therefore even more important to exchange on here so that you don't blame yourself.

Just the way toddlers are."

I loved this post @beigebrownblue

Yes, it's a big mismatch. And it's upsetting when as a mum you're doing overtime to try to make it all work, based on all your near-invisible knowledge about what your children need and like and think and feel, and all you get is criticism when the wheels come off.

YANBU OP.

I really hope if/when I'm a grandparent I'll be able to acknowledge what my children are doing rather than grumble that they're getting it wrong. My DC are still small - I hope I'll remember.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 13/11/2021 15:31

I'm so glad posters have been so supportive.

Of course your children are not awful. Your parents' comments are, however. I don't know why some people have to be so unkind, sure way to create distance.

Please tell us you won't go there for Christmas.

legalseagull · 13/11/2021 15:21

@CactusLemonSpice

Your DC were overtired and over stimulated and acted out a bit on the last day.

Your SD was overtired and over stimulated and acted out a bit on the last day.

He has less of an excuse, as he has had more time to work on his emotional regulation.

But I think that's what happened 👴👶

This is so true. I'll try to give him a bit of slack too.
OP posts:
legalseagull · 13/11/2021 15:20

@Boombastic22

I’m surprised you spent so long together last Xmas. Was very glad the Covid rules meant we should stay at home.

I recommend avoiding long trips at someone else’s house if you have poor sleepers, it’s not fun for anyone

They're not poor sleepers now. They went straight to bed, no fuss and slept until 630. A HUGE improvement from last year.

Thank you everyone you've really made me feel better. I'll try to take it less personally. DM is judgemental about lots of things, I'm just not used to being on the receiving end and I obviously feel fiercely protective of my kids.

OP posts:
CactusLemonSpice · 13/11/2021 14:56

Your DC were overtired and over stimulated and acted out a bit on the last day.

Your SD was overtired and over stimulated and acted out a bit on the last day.

He has less of an excuse, as he has had more time to work on his emotional regulation.

But I think that's what happened 👴👶

legalseagull · 13/11/2021 14:55

@LunaAndHerMoonDragons

Hearing echos of FIL reading this. His was that he was glad they lived far away and he didn't have to see the DC more often. Of course he only said things like this when STBXH was out of the house.

YANBU, your DC are little kids that's all. Would I be right in thinking your stepdad like my FIL had very little involvement with children?

Yes very little involvement with his own kids. He had a SAHW looking after them
OP posts:
Boombastic22 · 13/11/2021 14:08

I’m surprised you spent so long together last Xmas. Was very glad the Covid rules meant we should stay at home.

I recommend avoiding long trips at someone else’s house if you have poor sleepers, it’s not fun for anyone

twoshedsjackson · 13/11/2021 14:00

I think selective memory is one of Nature's ways of ensuring the continuance of the human race!
I heard somebody once say that little ones are naturally cute (to their parents at least) because otherwise the fury they can stir up could be disastrous!
Similarly, it is in the character of most good-natured people to remember the good bits of their past. If they didn't, "Never again!" might come into play.
It fascinates me that very few of us have any memories of the really early part of our lives, yet the baby and toddler stage is the most formative period in our lives.
Your children sound perfectly normal, and the fact that they are improving shows that you are steering them in the right direction; well done for that!
My late DF, a lovely, kind man, used to have a gentle joke (he was actually delightful with small children.) "Bye bye dear, see you again when you're 21!"

Mummyoflittledragon · 13/11/2021 12:56

Sounds as if your mum has rose tinted glasses or was more authoritarian as were many parents including mine. Did your sd have a family to know what really young children are like? It doesn’t much sound like it or perhaps he was not actively involved.

CuteAndFluff · 13/11/2021 12:29

@5128gap

There can be huge differences between the tolerance levels for DC behaviour between the generations. To many older people, today's DC can seem poorly behaved because ideas around discipline have changed. The more suthitarian approach taken in the past often tended to result in more compliant DC, who were obedient through fear. Obviously no one today thinks that is remotely ok, but the trade off, if you like, are more spirited DC than older people are used to. You're doing nothing wrong OP, but its not unusual for your parents generation to be critical.
This is true. We were whalloped as children at the slightest misdemeanour. So yes we might have looked better behaved. I wasn't when I grew up though, I was sneaky instead Older generation can see talking to children as a waste of time and indulgent when it comes to discipline.
Larabananas · 13/11/2021 12:25

Reminds me of my mum.. She came to live with me and dp when we had teenagers who liked to disagree about everything. She took great pleasure in telling us that she couldn't remember me being anywhere near as bad... Until I reminded her of my own expulsion from school!! I would take it all with a pinch of salt, older people can have very selective memories in my experience!

CuteAndFluff · 13/11/2021 12:24

Some great autocorrect in that post. Your not you're.
I hate tech

CuteAndFluff · 13/11/2021 12:22

@legalseagull

They've just really made me feel like I'm doing something wrong. I'm not in complete denial, they can be bloody hard work and the tantrum they threw at home time was horrific. Surely refusing to eat and go to bed is normal toddler behaviour though. I used to be so close to my mum but since having kids our relationship has taken a dive.
I feel the same op. I thought having children would make me feel closer but it drove a wedge between us. Mine I figure just isn't tolerant of kids. She never Waa as I grew up and that extends to my children. She'll say I never behaved terribly and finds small children exhausting. I now don't stay there if I visit. Keep visits short etc.

You're children sound normal op. Try to separate people's judgement from what's really happening.

Swipe left for the next trending thread