Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most bizarre seller ever

110 replies

Briscarta · 12/11/2021 18:26

Totally prepared to be told I’m at fault but I’ve reached the end of my tether. I purchased a lovely pair of heels from a seller and used PayPal to purchase them. In purchased them on 25th October - wore them out on 31 October and the sole fell off. I contacted the seller who apologised but then suggested I have them mended and they would transfer me the money.

I declined and asked for a new pair - I asked for a return postage label and means to return - they arrived in large plastic parcel envelope I don’t have anymore. I got an emailed label with no accompanying confirmation that I would receive new shoes.

I queried this and said I found the interaction with them poor.

The seller has become very nasty - hurling accusations of me acting superior etc. I stated not to worry about replacement but could I have a refund. The response - “take it up with PayPal”.

Has anyone had any experience with this?- are PayPal helpful in these situations?. I’m honestly baffled as to how the conversation deteriorated like it has with the seller. I have evidence of all interactions between us and I showed a friend who though the seller sounded unhinged.

I just want my money back - the shoes were a gift from my husband so I want to purchase another pair elsewhere ASAP for our upcoming wedding anniversary. Should I kiss goodbye to my refund?

OP posts:
Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 21:22

I don’t have any sisters - 😂😂😂

Rovicha88 · 12/11/2021 21:19

@Noodella18 I thought the same Grin

Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 21:18

Nope. - not OPs sister - I’d be getting pissed now if I was!😂. I just think some are being unfair to Op. it’s sad - Mnet didn’t used to be this ‘mean girls’

Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 21:16

I think the response the OP got is what’s causing the drama - some of you need to grow up! Grown women in an internet site being nasty to a stranger.

Feel sorry for the seller!- ? The seller is sitting pretty - got rid of shoddy goods and £50 better off into the bargain. The OP may be guilty of being naive but she doesn’t come across as trying to be a bad customer.

Obviously she doesn’t have need to return things often or she would know about packaging.

Hardly a serial scammer.

rwalker · 12/11/2021 21:13

Every time I've sent stuff back it's been on me to supply the packaging .

How difficult would it be to track down a shoe box place it in a bin bag fold it over and tape it . Put address on piece of paper and tape the to parcel.
If there faulty the seller normally refunds postage unless it's in there And C's that they don't

Sorry but massive drama for nothing .

Noodella18 · 12/11/2021 21:11

@Usedandhurt you're OP's sister right 😂 Literally every other poster on this thread can fully see why the seller got frustrated with her!

SwishSwishBisch · 12/11/2021 21:06

Opening line of the OP; “Totally prepared to be told I’m at fault”
🤣🤣🤣 sure Jan!

Send the shoes back. Await refund. If no refund materialises, contact PayPal and get your money back. Bravo for turning a very mundane issue into such a drama though!

Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 21:04

No - if you read below the anger came when OP asked the seller to confirm she would get a new pair - fairly generous if the OP in my opinion as I wouldn’t accept further products from them as firstly the first pair of shoes were shit quality - And and secondly the seller sounds batshit- who disagrees with a customer and thinks that being horrible and aggressive helps the situation. Referring to any customer as superior is fairly out there from a customer service point of view. Gross misconduct in my business.

I declined and asked for a new pair - I asked for a return postage label and means to return - they arrived in large plastic parcel envelope I don’t have anymore. I got an emailed label with no accompanying confirmation that I would receive new shoes.

I queried this and said I found the interaction with them poor.

The seller has become very nasty - hurling accusations of me acting superior etc. I stated not to worry about replacement but could I have a refund. The response - “take it up with PayPal”.

category12 · 12/11/2021 20:56

The seller wasn’t angry re the packaging - the anger was apparently because the op wouldn’t repair brand new shoes that had the sole fall off!!

No, I think the anger stemmed from OP querying lack of return packaging and along with a criticism of their poor interaction.

Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 20:54

Can some of you please rtft- she says she got the point about the return envelope. 🤦‍♀️

Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 20:51

Why is the OP asking for packaging concerning you all more than the shit product provided to her and the sellers shoddy treatment?!!!

All the seller had to say was - no - you provide the return packaging - here’s a return label - I’ll give you a refund once received.

The seller wasn’t angry re the packaging - the anger was apparently because the op wouldn’t repair brand new shoes that had the sole fall off!!

On what planet is it unreasonable for the OP not to want to do that!.

Mydogmylife · 12/11/2021 20:50

@Noodella18

I'm really starting to feel sympathy for the seller!
Me too! Op , just send the shoes back, get a proof of delivery and ask for your refund . If you don't get the refund from the seller, PayPal will refund you. I don't get your issue I'm afraid
Cissyandflora · 12/11/2021 20:45

@Noodella18

I'm really starting to feel sympathy for the seller!
Yes me too. Just get the shoes fixed why don’t you?
Babyvenusplant · 12/11/2021 20:45

@Briscarta

No I haven’t returned them - I can’t yet -I originally asked the seller to send me a box/packaging and a return label - and confirm I Would receive a replacement pair of shoes.

Now I just want a box to return them a return label and a refund.

I think it was awkward of you to ask for packing to send them back, nobody does that
Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 20:42

I think the OP said earlier that she was heading out do she won’t be responding I think. Can I ask why dine if you are being so horrible- she says she would send the shoes back once she was guaranteed her money back.

I can see why she’s worried about using her own packaging - the seller seems to be horrible to deal with. No doubt seller would try to wriggle out of refund saying OP causes further damage with her choice if packaging. The op has says the packaging the shoes arrived in was torn so not reusable. I’m sure I’d the seller wasn’t so ignorant and aggressive in their interaction with the OP then this would have been resolved.

Tbh The op was right to have refused to get the shoes fixed - the seller seemed to get angry and be unreasonable. Op I’d wait on PayPal and do exactly as they say.

I also agree that some posters need to relax. OP is not that one who sold substandard goods and then got angry about it. I’ve a business myself and if a member of my team behaved that way to a customer they would be severely disciplined.

Also OP did not name the company- she’s not trying to exploit anything from what I gather.

OP get the refund and write an honest review on the company page.save some other person having the same treatment. Ignore some posters on here who are strangely taking this very personally.

You all honestly seem more concerned about an envelope than the shoddy treatment OP has received. Now that is bizarre!!!

Catra · 12/11/2021 20:40

You clearly don't understand how PayPal buyer's protection works - it doesn't matter whether you send them back in a bin bag, a box, or a jumbo jet, as long as you can prove you returned them, PayPal will refund you if for any reason the seller doesn't.

As others have said completely unreasonable to expect the seller to send you packaging or refund without receiving the item back.

I sell online and you sound like an utter nightmare customer.

Scirocco · 12/11/2021 20:39

You need to return the item before you can expect a refund.

If they've sent you out a label, package up the shoes and send them back to the seller. Take photos of them before postage, get proof of postage and a receipt for the cost of sending them back.

Once the company receive the returned package, they should contact you about the refund. If there are any issues, you could also ask for them to cover the cost of postage, as some companies are willing to do this as a gesture of goodwill (although it's not required of them).

Any issues from that point on, raise with PayPal. If you've got proof of purchase, proof of return and correspondence from the seller, PayPal will arrange for your money back fairly easily.

It's unrealistic to expect the company to send you out additional packaging, so just use something from home or get packaging from your local post office. Having to pay for sending back items is an occupational hazard of buying online if you don't make sure to keep original packaging from deliveries.

category12 · 12/11/2021 20:38

Ugh, no-one sends you a box to post things back in - you use your own packaging.

They'd agreed the goods were faulty, agreed for you to return them, so you should have just done that. Then if you didn't get a refund, you'd raise a case with Paypal/Ebay.

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 12/11/2021 20:32

I've had shoes sent in just a plastic bag and they've been fine. I'd wrap them in a bag for life, then perhaps put some newspaper around it to make the shape even, and then put it in one of those big plastic envelopes.

MrsJackWhicher · 12/11/2021 20:28

PayPal are very good at refunding -I had similar

LettertoHermoine · 12/11/2021 20:24

YABVU.

Return the shows and be reasonable. Sitting waiting for them to send you a box to return them in is just ridiculous.

You are totally prepared to be told you are at fault? That is so funny!

Bellie710 · 12/11/2021 20:19

Paypal almost always go in favour of the buyer, so you will definitely get a refund.

elbea · 12/11/2021 20:18

YABU in expecting a company to send you a box so you can post them back, I’ve literally never heard of anyone doing this. It’s bizarre.

They sent you a label like you asked, you wrap it up with whatever you have and then stick on the label they sent.

I’d imagine PayPal are going to award to the seller because despite sending you postage for a return, you are refusing because they aren’t wastefully posting you a box.

Waspsarearseholes · 12/11/2021 20:15

Totally prepared to be told I’m at fault

Except you're not, are you? Demanding a box gets sent to you to return broken shoes is bizarre. If they're broken you can just wrap them in a binbag and return them. They are faulty, you have photographic proof of it,.so once you have returned them you will get a refund. Would you go to a shop on the high street and tell demand a refund/replacement without returning the shoes? Or then demand the shop pays for you petrol/parking costs to return the shoes, plus a shopping bag in which to carry them as you binned the one they gave you with the purchase? You are sounding more and more like a giant PITA with every update. Return the shoes and they will refund you. It's literally as simple as that. That is how shopping works, and has worked for many years. Are you brand new?!

ALittleBitWorrriedNow · 12/11/2021 19:59

Just take it up with PayPal OP, they are really good at sorting these kind of things out swiftly and you can claim back your return postage as well - make sure you send them tracked/signed for and insured for the correct amount.