Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most bizarre seller ever

110 replies

Briscarta · 12/11/2021 18:26

Totally prepared to be told I’m at fault but I’ve reached the end of my tether. I purchased a lovely pair of heels from a seller and used PayPal to purchase them. In purchased them on 25th October - wore them out on 31 October and the sole fell off. I contacted the seller who apologised but then suggested I have them mended and they would transfer me the money.

I declined and asked for a new pair - I asked for a return postage label and means to return - they arrived in large plastic parcel envelope I don’t have anymore. I got an emailed label with no accompanying confirmation that I would receive new shoes.

I queried this and said I found the interaction with them poor.

The seller has become very nasty - hurling accusations of me acting superior etc. I stated not to worry about replacement but could I have a refund. The response - “take it up with PayPal”.

Has anyone had any experience with this?- are PayPal helpful in these situations?. I’m honestly baffled as to how the conversation deteriorated like it has with the seller. I have evidence of all interactions between us and I showed a friend who though the seller sounded unhinged.

I just want my money back - the shoes were a gift from my husband so I want to purchase another pair elsewhere ASAP for our upcoming wedding anniversary. Should I kiss goodbye to my refund?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MrsBungle · 13/11/2021 08:59

This really isn’t the most bizarre seller ever Grin this is a straightforward case of wrap up the shoes, shove the label on, return the shoes then you’ll be refunded!

Pigeoninthehouse · 13/11/2021 08:49

If a buyer sent me a message saying their item was damaged and wanted a replacement or refund I would mortified and understand why they were annoyed, I would sort it out straight away and wouldn't be calling them superior!
I also doubt you are an online seller, a significant one anyway. You would spend a good portion of your week mortified.
Coming up with reasons not to return a 'faulty' item is good indicator someone wants something for free.

sunglassesonthetable · 13/11/2021 08:47

I'm laughing at the OP asking/expecting a BOX 😀to be sent out to her for her BROKEN shoes to be sent back in, when the company sends NEW ones in a bag.

I would totally expect a new pair of shoes in this circumstance. I'm with OP on that, but the company has to have the broken shoes back in the first instance.

Standard.

Weirdwonders · 13/11/2021 08:17

God just get the damn shoes fixed, they’ve offered to pay

jetadore · 13/11/2021 07:42

Take (plenty of) photos of shoes showing damage and also general condition that they’re still new. Pack them (in bag if that’s what they gave you). Return, getting proof of postage/receipt. Yes they should cover the postage cost for faulty goods. Get that up front (I.e prepaid label) if it seems like they’re going to be difficult. If they don’t refund then raise a case through PayPal. With the messages between you and photos, proof of return, PayPal should find in your favour.

itsabouttimee · 13/11/2021 06:33

If a buyer sent me a message saying their item was damaged and wanted a replacement or refund I would mortified and understand why they were annoyed, I would sort it out straight away and wouldn't be calling them superior!

This person has never owned a small business selling things online....

I used to get at least a few messages a week claiming this or that. Most of them were absolute chancers and could be proven because RM offers delivery confirmation.

It used to be the number one scam until they realised paypal sides with seller if you have confirmation.

Wrong item is another one, because they don't realise things are barcoded and the system won't let you ship it unless the barcodes match.

Then you have the ones who wear or use the thing for a night / weekend / event before deliberately breaking or damaging it and claiming they received it faulty. Not as often as the delivery nonsense but it happens.

"Sorting it out straight away" is exactly what the seller has done. Offered to pay for a repair, and when seller said no they asked for the item to be returned. Any more and for every genuine person you bend over backwards for, 10 scammers will be bending you over.

Op sounds EXACTLY like the scammers with the 101 excuses for why they can't return the item. Usually it's something ridiculous like a button that the chancer clearly intends to get their granny to sew back on. If I had to guess I'd say the seller was being perfectly polite right up until OP demanded they send out replacement packaging. Seller smelled a rat and here we are.

amylou8 · 13/11/2021 06:18

I'm a full time ebay seller and you sound like my idea of a pain in the arse buyer. They're broken after you've worn them. Seller hasn't quibbled this and has sent you a prepaid label to return them. What happens now is you package them up in whatever material you have to hand (plastic bag and sellotape works fine) stick the label on the front and post them. Seller gets them back and refunds you. There's absolutely no need for all this drama.

Prattypitel · 13/11/2021 06:01

If I understand correctly,under the consumeract,the seller has a right to repair faulty goods.You send the shoes,they repair and send the shoes back to you.The seller send you a free return label to send the shoes back for repair.the seller did everythi g correct and no wonder,they get annoyed with you.If you want a refund,its up to the sellers discretion to do this.No seller would refund until they got the shoes back first.if you send the shoes back and the seller does not refund,then you can take action.

Keeping2ChevronsApart · 12/11/2021 22:26

@category12

Depends what OP said in her message, doesn't it? OP refers to criticising their poor interaction, to which the seller responded that she was acting superior.

Naturally OP thinks whatever she said was reasonable and depicts the seller as "hurling accusations", but it's quite possible her criticism of them was harsh/patronising.

If a buyer sent me a message saying their item was damaged and wanted a replacement or refund I would mortified and understand why they were annoyed, I would sort it out straight away and wouldn't be calling them superior!
Keeping2ChevronsApart · 12/11/2021 22:22

Oh and they don't need a box just wrap in newspaper and put in a bag for life and tape up

Keeping2ChevronsApart · 12/11/2021 22:20

I have a shop on eBay just do the following:

Open up a case as item not as described
Take plenty of pictures as PayPal will want to see

PayPal will pull a hold on the funds / put her account in negative balance and tell you to return using a tracked method - second class recorded is about £4

You can upload the tracking details and once delivered PayPal will refund you the the original price you paid plus the return postage

I have drummed it into DP always use PayPal if possible !

category12 · 12/11/2021 22:16

Depends what OP said in her message, doesn't it? OP refers to criticising their poor interaction, to which the seller responded that she was acting superior.

Naturally OP thinks whatever she said was reasonable and depicts the seller as "hurling accusations", but it's quite possible her criticism of them was harsh/patronising.

Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 22:15

Thanks pigeon

Pigeoninthehouse · 12/11/2021 22:08

Different user name just a very similar thread.

Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 22:05

pigeon did the op have a previous thread like this?- can you link it?

Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 22:04

I REALLY want the op to come back with an update once PayPal got involved.

I also would love to see the online review - cringing for the company already

Pigeoninthehouse · 12/11/2021 22:04

Again - the OP is a customer - why is it ok for the seller to make a silly suggestion re mending but not the purchaser re packaging.
Its pretty standard to offer a repair or replace on faulty goods. Whereas demanding packaging and refusing to return until the seller sends her an appropriate box, is just strange.
The op sounds like a pain in the arse and I'm on the sellers side.
This thread sounds like the MLM Lipstick one from a week or so ago.,
Did you return you lipstick and get your refund op ?

Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 22:02

Yes - from what I’m getting from her posts the seller wanted OP to mend the shoes - she says no- asked for packing and postage - obviously the seller didn’t want to send packaging - whatever way it was communicated the OP said she was unhappy with interaction - seller says take it to PayPal.

Either way I can’t imagine any customer raising an issue with me for me or a member Of my staff to tell the customer to basically shove it and take it to PayPal.

Some people shouldn’t be in business. Truly.

category12 · 12/11/2021 21:55

Yes = I queried this and said I found the interaction with them poor.

But you initially said that the seller got angry because OP refused to get the shoes mended.

Which wasn't the case, they got angry after OP went back to them over the returns label.

Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 21:50

Sorry I may have misread - I though the seller requested op mend the shoes - op declined - said she would return shoes but wanted confirmation she was getting a new pair?-

I’d love to know what she said also but I bet she won’t come back to the thread - she got piled on - maybe send her a PM you never know - she might tell you

category12 · 12/11/2021 21:45

then sending a returns label for the shoes when that [suggestion] was declined.

I don't really understand why you're having trouble with that sentence, but I hope my addition helps. ^

I'd be curious to know what exactly OP said in her criticism of the seller's interaction.

Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 21:38

As in I think she declined to get the shoes mended not declined the return label

Usedandhurt · 12/11/2021 21:36

Again - the OP is a customer - why is it ok for the seller to make a silly suggestion re mending but not the purchaser re packaging.

Perhaps I have misread but I don’t think OP did decline ?- she asked for seller to confirm new shoes would be sent.

I’ve had customers screaming down the phone - one told me I had caused her emotional distress because an item she liked had sold out - another put her husband on the phone to explain why I should sell her a product at half the advertised price - he called me a stupid bitch when I refused.

Part of being in business is not to react. I can only imagine what the seller OP dealt with would do if she dealt with some of the customers I do!

It’s business - suck it up

category12 · 12/11/2021 21:27

@Usedandhurt

No - if you read below the anger came when OP asked the seller to confirm she would get a new pair - fairly generous if the OP in my opinion as I wouldn’t accept further products from them as firstly the first pair of shoes were shit quality - And and secondly the seller sounds batshit- who disagrees with a customer and thinks that being horrible and aggressive helps the situation. Referring to any customer as superior is fairly out there from a customer service point of view. Gross misconduct in my business.

I declined and asked for a new pair - I asked for a return postage label and means to return - they arrived in large plastic parcel envelope I don’t have anymore. I got an emailed label with no accompanying confirmation that I would receive new shoes.

I queried this and said I found the interaction with them poor.

The seller has become very nasty - hurling accusations of me acting superior etc. I stated not to worry about replacement but could I have a refund. The response - “take it up with PayPal”.

Yet you said The seller wasn’t angry re the packaging - the anger was apparently because the op wouldn’t repair brand new shoes that had the sole fall off!! Hmm

The interaction didn't turn nasty until OP went back about lack of packaging for the return plus whatever she said about "poor interaction". Up until then, the seller had perhaps made a silly suggestion of getting the shoes fixed and them transferring money for it, and then sending a returns label for the shoes when that was declined.