Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Morning visitors

103 replies

SaturdaySummer · 12/11/2021 14:06

Hello

Can I ask what time people think it's acceptable to visit in the morning? My MiL wanted to bring something for my husband. He explained that he would be out the night before and wouldn't be wanting an early visit. She then turned to me and said 'you'll be up with the baby' to which I said yeah but we won't be wanting visitors if daddy is sleeping and I'm trying to get baby ready'. I thought this was firm enough but apparently not.... here she is at 8am at our door. In all honesty I'm normally a bit of a people
Pleaser and would have let her come in despite all of the above and the house being a tip but I was annoyed with her blatantly ignoring our requests so I kept her at the door and didn't let her in. Is this unreasonable?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SaturdaySummer · 15/11/2021 18:53

@Nowomenaroundeh

You are my hero OP. My blood pressure went up reading that.

I don't really understand the debate about it being too early. IMO that is irrelevant, you told her she wasn't welcome and she came anyway after telling you that you would be up. That's just dismissing you as if it's her sons house and she won't let you stop her coming when she sees fit. (Unless of course she's getting a little confused but you would have mentioned this.)

I have no PIL in the country now thankfully but I did have ex PIL living locally when I was younger with a then-DP and no kids. They were an absolute nightmare for this sort of stuff. They owned the apartment we lived in. An utter shitshow. I paid above market rent but my DP got a free pass most of the time.

So we were treated like guests in their place, they used their keys and came in for a nosy whenever they fancied it. I worked 60+ hour weeks but that didn't stop them assuming if they needed me at home the following morning to let in a tradesman or look at some fabric (I'm not kidding) with MIL I'd just sit in and wait. Multiple times I or DP said "do not ring the doorbell" for a solid reason yet there they would be ringing the doorbell, walking straight in, showing their friends around, pointing out the view. My DP never stood up to them as he had it good with the optional rent but this was an expensive area and I was putting a significant amount of my salary into funding his lifestyle. His father once walked uninvited into the bathroom and handed me a gstring in disdain suggesting I pick up my own personal items. I refused to take it.

I should have changed the locks citing my rights as a tenant. The luxury of hindsight.

Omg I think you have had it FAR WORSE then me, I'm sorry you went through this. Talk about having no boundaries eh? I think people know this is wrong but choose to suit their own wishes at the expense of others simply because they think they're more important
OP posts:
Nowomenaroundeh · 15/11/2021 15:03

You are my hero OP. My blood pressure went up reading that.

I don't really understand the debate about it being too early. IMO that is irrelevant, you told her she wasn't welcome and she came anyway after telling you that you would be up. That's just dismissing you as if it's her sons house and she won't let you stop her coming when she sees fit. (Unless of course she's getting a little confused but you would have mentioned this.)

I have no PIL in the country now thankfully but I did have ex PIL living locally when I was younger with a then-DP and no kids. They were an absolute nightmare for this sort of stuff. They owned the apartment we lived in. An utter shitshow. I paid above market rent but my DP got a free pass most of the time.

So we were treated like guests in their place, they used their keys and came in for a nosy whenever they fancied it. I worked 60+ hour weeks but that didn't stop them assuming if they needed me at home the following morning to let in a tradesman or look at some fabric (I'm not kidding) with MIL I'd just sit in and wait. Multiple times I or DP said "do not ring the doorbell" for a solid reason yet there they would be ringing the doorbell, walking straight in, showing their friends around, pointing out the view. My DP never stood up to them as he had it good with the optional rent but this was an expensive area and I was putting a significant amount of my salary into funding his lifestyle. His father once walked uninvited into the bathroom and handed me a gstring in disdain suggesting I pick up my own personal items. I refused to take it.

I should have changed the locks citing my rights as a tenant. The luxury of hindsight.

SaturdaySummer · 15/11/2021 12:27

@Cherrysoup

8am? I’d be in bed still. She’s extremely rude to turn up at that time, particularly when your dh said he wanted a lie in and you have a newborn.
I think so too. Bad enough doing it when we asked her not to, but to then stand there waiting to be invited in...... wtf?
OP posts:
Cherrysoup · 13/11/2021 18:36

8am? I’d be in bed still. She’s extremely rude to turn up at that time, particularly when your dh said he wanted a lie in and you have a newborn.

Ameanstreakamilewide · 13/11/2021 18:24

@Flowerlane

I have a sibling who likes to pop round early if they need to drop something off or pick something up…usually between 6:30am and 7:30am!

It use to drive me crazy, as we would all be asleep and the door would go! We are now use to it so if we know they are popping around we prepare for the early riseGrin

I would not put up with this from anyone else but my sibling is lovely and always ready to help me when I need it. It’s just part of their characterSmile

Man alive! Half 6 in the bloody morning! 🤯

My sibling would only do it once, I know that.

Flowerlane · 13/11/2021 09:01

I have a sibling who likes to pop round early if they need to drop something off or pick something up…usually between 6:30am and 7:30am!

It use to drive me crazy, as we would all be asleep and the door would go! We are now use to it so if we know they are popping around we prepare for the early riseGrin

I would not put up with this from anyone else but my sibling is lovely and always ready to help me when I need it. It’s just part of their characterSmile

SaturdaySummer · 13/11/2021 08:54

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

Yanbu, but I would have said specifically what time was the cut off- “please come after 10” or similar.

Why did she even want to come that early?

She is just an early riser but I take your point about being more specific
OP posts:
SaturdaySummer · 13/11/2021 08:53

@Kite22

YANBU at all. I am quite often a defender of MiLs on here, but the thing here is that she asked, and was clearly told that wasn't convenient time to call, and then she called anyway.

I mean, I think 8am is a ridiculous time to call on anyone, regardless but that isn't really relevant - the crucial fact here is she asked, then ignored the replies.

Thank you, I agree. It just seems she expects everything to be on her schedule.
OP posts:
SaturdaySummer · 13/11/2021 08:52

@HikingforScenery

Wow, you sound very rude. Did you say she was doing your husband a favour? Maybe she needed to go elsewhere, hence turning up at that time.

If you were up, I don’t see the problem tbh.

No she doesn't have plans for the day she is just an early riser but when we had already asked her not to come in the morning I think it's rude to do so anyway just because it suits her
OP posts:
SaturdaySummer · 13/11/2021 08:51

@GreyhoundG1rl

How did you keep her on the doorstep, did you physically bar her way? That was ill mannered, tbh.
Turning up at someone's house after being asked not to at that time is ill mannered
OP posts:
SaturdaySummer · 13/11/2021 08:50

@sweeneytoddsrazor

You see her weekly, yet yesterday you said she hadn't seen your son for 3 weeks so they hadn't bonded properly? She has only got him one 2nd hand present since he was born but has also shown him his Xmas presents? She sounds bonkers and it sounds like you don't like her.
She is usually weekly but hasn't been recently and up until this week had only bought used presents
OP posts:
sweeneytoddsrazor · 13/11/2021 01:29

You see her weekly, yet yesterday you said she hadn't seen your son for 3 weeks so they hadn't bonded properly?
She has only got him one 2nd hand present since he was born but has also shown him his Xmas presents? She sounds bonkers and it sounds like you don't like her.

GreyhoundG1rl · 13/11/2021 01:14

How did you keep her on the doorstep, did you physically bar her way?
That was ill mannered, tbh.

HikingforScenery · 13/11/2021 00:57

Wow, you sound very rude.
Did you say she was doing your husband a favour? Maybe she needed to go elsewhere, hence turning up at that time.

If you were up, I don’t see the problem tbh.

notangelinajolie · 13/11/2021 00:56

8am? I wouldn't have answered the door.

NowEvenBetter · 13/11/2021 00:51

Get her son to tell her no.

Kite22 · 12/11/2021 23:47

YANBU at all.
I am quite often a defender of MiLs on here, but the thing here is that she asked, and was clearly told that wasn't convenient time to call, and then she called anyway.

I mean, I think 8am is a ridiculous time to call on anyone, regardless but that isn't really relevant - the crucial fact here is she asked, then ignored the replies.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 12/11/2021 23:31

Yanbu, but I would have said specifically what time was the cut off- “please come after 10” or similar.

Why did she even want to come that early?

CSIblonde · 12/11/2021 23:21

That's a really inconsiderate time to call on anyone in my opinion. 10am at the absolute earliest would be more acceptable , due to most people having a morning routine to sort/do. If anyone calls before that, unless it's a parcel I'm expecting I don't answer.

SaturdaySummer · 12/11/2021 23:18

@Stovetopespresso

come on OP you've go this! "sorry 8 is way too early - how about a coffee at 10?". as pp have said she's possibly bored and lonely so a day out here and there, or you dropping by hers etc might be good.
We see her weekly and seen her on Thursday (yesterday) and have arranged to see her in Tuesday. This is why I really don't understand the urgency. She is dropping of a jacket, my husband already had multiple jackets so waiting until tues would not be an issue. It's nothing that important
OP posts:
SaturdaySummer · 12/11/2021 23:07

@ufucoffee

You could be annoyed, tell her you were annoyed and still have let her in. You were being harsh in my opinion
Do you not think it unreasonable to ignore someone's explicit instruction to NOT come to their home first thing in the morning? I think it's more rude to ignore that to suit yourself to be honest
OP posts:
SaturdaySummer · 12/11/2021 20:24

@Pumpkinsonparade

My ils used to get to ours at 8.30 on the off chance they could take the dc to school... Even though I had said No Way Never.. Made sure I had left at 8.25 to miss them!! Mil wore her glasses to help fil drive... Mil had a cushion on her seat and never got past second gear..
Sweet Jesus I can only imagine that image GrinConfusedif it takes two of you to make the drive then it's time to give up the car
OP posts:
SaturdaySummer · 12/11/2021 20:23

@Rogue1001

How long did she stay pressing the buzzzzzzzer?

And how did it end? Who broke first?

She kept ringing for a good few minutes and I thought about firing the buzzer off but then thought it would cause problems as she obv knew we were in. I answered the door in my pjs and dressing gown and just kept the door closed
OP posts:
Rogue1001 · 12/11/2021 18:29

How long did she stay pressing the buzzzzzzzer?

And how did it end? Who broke first?

Pumpkinsonparade · 12/11/2021 18:19

My ils used to get to ours at 8.30 on the off chance they could take the dc to school...
Even though I had said No Way Never..
Made sure I had left at 8.25 to miss them!!
Mil wore her glasses to help fil drive...
Mil had a cushion on her seat and never got past second gear..