Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to hate my engagement ring? Been married 5 yrs.

185 replies

CharlieBird25 · 12/11/2021 13:59

So me and husband have been married for 5 years (together 11 years in total). We have a child together. There's been some good years and some bad years but on the whole we have a good relationship and both work hard for our family.

Anyway... yeah theres no point dancing around the subject - i HATE my engagement ring.

He chose it for me. I had no idea he was going to propose. He went to a lot of effort to organise the proposal - got our family involved. It was sweet. But yeah as soon as he showed me the ring I was like "mmmmmmmmyeah I hate it" (in my head).

I haven't ever told him. I haven't told anyone. But yeah I hate it it's just not "me".

It's got quite a unique wrap around twisted/spiral design with a suspended diamond. I mean I'm sure it would look great on someone but i just don't love it. When I showed my friends they were all like "hmmmm thats....nice! All that matters is that you like it" I said i did because i felt obligated to but really.....i hated it.

I wanted to say something at first but there were people around at the time of the proposal so I didn't want to embarrass him and he was so on cloud-9 that night I didn't want to hurt his feelings. Then it became awkward the next morning because everyone wanted me to wear the ring and take pictures of it which got uploaded to social media and it became harder and harder to say anything. Then more time passed and it just became impossible. I just accepted my fate that I was going to have to wear an ugly ring forever. I told myself it didn't matter. That I was lucky to have a ring at all. That my husband went to a lot of trouble with the proposal it would be really shitty of me to say something after all this time.

Also, because of the unusual design we had to buy a very specific (ugly) wedding ring to fit around it so now I don't like my wedding ring OR my engagement ring. Hilarious.

To rub further salt into the wound my dragon in law (MIL) got engaged a year after us and she and her fiance went to CHOOSE her rings together. Conveniently she CHOSE a ring that had the exact same twisted/spiral/wrap around design. The only difference was it had a bigger rock in it than mine (because OF COURSE she wasn't going to be out done by her daughter in law) but it was, and still is, a reminder of a) how she wants to 1-up me and b) how much I really don't like the ring anyway regardless of whether she chose something similar.

Given how controlling and manipulative she is I would not be at all surprised to find out she influenced my husband in his decision. MIL is extremely materialistic and hugely narcissistic. She will only shop in Waitrose or John Lewis. Wouldn't be seen dead in Aldi. I shit you not I've seen this woman throw a fit in the middle of Tescos because she wanted to buy "Tescos Finest" sausage rolls and we said she had to buy the basic range instead. She actually stamped her foot. She was going thru bankruptcy at the time. (Couldn't make it up) She is also SO wasteful with her possessions. Once she's owned something for 6 months it goes in the bin. No exaggeration. She only wears designer label clothes like Chanel and Zara and of course all of it is financed by her rich husband. I find it quite gross but each to their own. I keep my mouth shut out of respect for my husband.

I on the other hand often advocate for people not being "defined by their possessions" & I am not materialistic in the slightest. I often shop at charity shops, reuse, recycle. I could not give a rats ass if you shop in bargain basement or waitrose. I don't care if our tv is 24" or 80". I dont get my nails done every week, I dont shop high end. I really do not care if your dress was from the bargain bin or if it was made from the wool of Appalachian sheep, licked together by unicorns and dyed with the berries of a rare Himalayan flower, delivered by private jet and charged £1937448292947 for one pocket. I really couldn't care less.

If we lost all of our possessions tomorrow I'd still be ME...........But

if theres one exception to that rule I feel like your engagement ring would be it......right?

It's not about the value. I honestly do not want a massive rock that cost thousands of pounds. It doesn't even have to be diamond. I just want a ring that represents me. Represents US.

I see other engagement ring designs all the time and I'd be lying if I dont get jealous every time. I think "urgh I really wish I had a ring like that but I'm stuck with THIS" I want a ring that I WANT to wear. Not one I feel obligated to wear.

How in the hell do I explain it to husband without destroying his ego and sounding like a massive materialistic bellend? Do I just keep my mouth shut and be grateful for what I've got?

AIBU?

OP posts:
LadyMonicaBaddingham · 12/11/2021 14:44

I stopped wearing my engagement ring when I got married. Are you supposed to keep wearing it?!

Bluntness100 · 12/11/2021 14:43

The whole thing is a bit odd op. Particularly the whole sausage roll saga. Where she buys her clothes, where she shops, her rich husband, the food she likes to eat, what her engagement ring is like.

Then comparing yourself to her and bigging yourself up like you are some form of pure saint,😂.

MeredithGreyishblue · 12/11/2021 14:43

@JollyJoon

Cant believe you posted this without a pic? Thems the rules. We need a pic of this ring (blackout your knuckle for privacy)
Stop! My sides hurt! Properly snorty chortling!
WhyMeLord · 12/11/2021 14:43

I guy went to uni with got married and his wife's friend made them their wedding rings, he hated it but didn't have the heart to tell his wife. A few months after the wedding they were burgled, thieves broke into the house and took car keys and wallets that were on a table beside the door (and the car). Would you believe what rotten luck - he had also for the first time ever taken his wedding ring off and left it on the table, the thieves must have taken it too. To this day he is sticking to his story 😂

Anyway, I'd accidentally lose the ring somewhere and go buy a new one together.

You MIL is a totally separate issue I think

TheNarwhalBalloon · 12/11/2021 14:43

I really want to see the ring! Can someone link to a similar style, please?

I think go very gently with your husband and try to say that you'd prefer something more.... Not sure what to insert here as I can't picture the original ring, but maybe something more simple? Classic? Practical? Understated? Whatever you think will tactfully put the point across.

Dddccc · 12/11/2021 14:40

Just don't wear it simple I only wear my wedding band you sound like you just want another ring because you hate the your mil picked one that looks the same

Aposterhasnoname · 12/11/2021 14:39

Missing the point entirely but PMSL at designer clothes like Zara Grin

FigureofEight · 12/11/2021 14:38

It's such an odd thing to be worried about.
Clearly about your MIL

Your H must have enjoyed getting it for you but you are ungrateful

That said my stepMother did this. That's the point I'm making
HmmHmmHmm

PurpleDaisies · 12/11/2021 14:38

[quote BigFatLiar]**@PurpleDaisies* Don’t do this! It’s insurance fraud.*

What? telling your husband you don't like your rings and want to replace them is insurance fraud?

What's it got to do with insurance?[/quote]
You missed my next post where I said I’d quoted the wrong person.

Dropcloth · 12/11/2021 14:37

@PleasantBirthday

This just seems like a whole tangled mess of issues. My action plan would be:
  1. Take off the ring. If you don't like it, put it in a jewellery box and don't wear it;
  2. Don't confuse whether you like the ring or not with your feelings about your mother in law and whether she helped him choose the cursed object;
  3. Spend less time with your mother in law. You don't like her and are obsessing about things that shouldn't really be making you angry.

Also, I know you believe you're a person who doesn't care about objects etc, but while I believe that you want that to be true, I just don't think it is. Read what you wrote about your mother in law again and the amount of thought you've given, not just to what she does, but also what she has.

I think this is fair. No need to wear any item of jewellery, no need to see people you don’t like, and I absolutely agree with @PleasantBirthday’S conclusion that you’re nowhere near as non-materialistic as you imagine.
BigFatLiar · 12/11/2021 14:37

@PurpleDaisies Don’t do this! It’s insurance fraud.

What? telling your husband you don't like your rings and want to replace them is insurance fraud?

What's it got to do with insurance?

Zilla1 · 12/11/2021 14:36

Suspended can mean different things.

Niessing make some lovely tension bands with truly suspended gems
niessing.com/en/engagement_rings

and samara James? some pseudo-suspended rubover set rings with a twist design

www.samarajames.com/engagement-ring-semi-rub-over-solitaire-round.html?filter=true&metal=62&carat=3&clarity=18&colour=23&cut=24&kw=&cpn=990334261&pk_campaign=Shopping-Broad-Desktop-Regions&pk_kwd=Shopping&gclid=EAIaIQobChMI6fmD44WT9AIVH4BQBh1AFAOhEAQYAiABEgIpx_D_BwE

I personally like both but the OP might have something different in mind and jewellery taste is personal.

There probably is a range, OP, from 'losing' the rings to saying they are uncomfortable to saying you want to have them remodelled to reunse the gem and metal for [reason]. All risk upset.

Good luck.

JollyJoon · 12/11/2021 14:34

Cant believe you posted this without a pic? Thems the rules. We need a pic of this ring (blackout your knuckle for privacy)

Disfordarkchocolate · 12/11/2021 14:34

That ring really sounds like it would get in my way, snag on things etc all the time.

The most tactful thing is to say to your husband its snagging on things and you are going to get is redesigned so it's more wearable. Perhaps stop wearing it for a bit first and give this as the reason. Or accidentally hit it with a hammer.

caringcarer · 12/11/2021 14:33

Why not ask for a nice eternity ring and tell DH you want.to.choose it together. What sausage rolls has to do with it I have no idea.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 12/11/2021 14:32

I'm assuming, from the description, the the wedding band can't be worn on it's own as it has been designed to fit around the ring?
I've got some friends who have rings like that and they look incomplete if not worn as a set.

OP I think you need to speak to your DH. Either tell him that your taste has changed, you find the ring uncomfortable, say your skin is reacting to the metal or something. I don't think I would be able to tell the truth and hurt his feelings, but I'm a soft touch.

SageRosemary · 12/11/2021 14:32

Please ignore @Megan2018, she's inciting you to commit a criminal offence.

Just let your DH know you'd like to have your rings re-modelled, keeping the metal and the lovely stone, for practical purposes

Cocomarine · 12/11/2021 14:31

Zara as designer 🤣

Cocomarine · 12/11/2021 14:30

@ShirleyPhallus

Just talk to your husband and get a new ring then

But leave out all the crap about your MIL and sausage rolls, would be my advice

Spot on Grin
tenredthings · 12/11/2021 14:30

It needs breaking, so you can reset the stone into something you like , or losing. Don't ever tell him you don't like it and dont mention the MIL in relation to your ring !

HelplessAndLost · 12/11/2021 14:30

Tell him you felt it had a malevolent vibe and you destroyed it with the Sword of Gryffindor.

Bluntness100 · 12/11/2021 14:30

She only wears designer label clothes like Chanel and Zara…I really do not care if your dress was from the bargain bin or if it was made from the wool of Appalachian sheep

And yet you really do seem to care. Certainly about your mother on laws clothes. And Zara is not designer it’s high st.

GeodesicDome · 12/11/2021 14:29

MIL is extremely materialistic and hugely narcissistic. She will only shop in Waitrose or John Lewis

Comedy gold!

CantStartaFireWithoutaSpark · 12/11/2021 14:26

I need a photo!

123ZYX · 12/11/2021 14:25

@GreenLunchBox

I think I might have the same engagement ring and I don't like it either. My husbands heart was in the right place but it really wasn't "me".

Me too. The description sounds the same. Where did these guys find it? The Ugly Engagement Ring store?🤣

There must be a very good salesperson somewhere preying on men who have never bought jewellery before