Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to hate my engagement ring? Been married 5 yrs.

185 replies

CharlieBird25 · 12/11/2021 13:59

So me and husband have been married for 5 years (together 11 years in total). We have a child together. There's been some good years and some bad years but on the whole we have a good relationship and both work hard for our family.

Anyway... yeah theres no point dancing around the subject - i HATE my engagement ring.

He chose it for me. I had no idea he was going to propose. He went to a lot of effort to organise the proposal - got our family involved. It was sweet. But yeah as soon as he showed me the ring I was like "mmmmmmmmyeah I hate it" (in my head).

I haven't ever told him. I haven't told anyone. But yeah I hate it it's just not "me".

It's got quite a unique wrap around twisted/spiral design with a suspended diamond. I mean I'm sure it would look great on someone but i just don't love it. When I showed my friends they were all like "hmmmm thats....nice! All that matters is that you like it" I said i did because i felt obligated to but really.....i hated it.

I wanted to say something at first but there were people around at the time of the proposal so I didn't want to embarrass him and he was so on cloud-9 that night I didn't want to hurt his feelings. Then it became awkward the next morning because everyone wanted me to wear the ring and take pictures of it which got uploaded to social media and it became harder and harder to say anything. Then more time passed and it just became impossible. I just accepted my fate that I was going to have to wear an ugly ring forever. I told myself it didn't matter. That I was lucky to have a ring at all. That my husband went to a lot of trouble with the proposal it would be really shitty of me to say something after all this time.

Also, because of the unusual design we had to buy a very specific (ugly) wedding ring to fit around it so now I don't like my wedding ring OR my engagement ring. Hilarious.

To rub further salt into the wound my dragon in law (MIL) got engaged a year after us and she and her fiance went to CHOOSE her rings together. Conveniently she CHOSE a ring that had the exact same twisted/spiral/wrap around design. The only difference was it had a bigger rock in it than mine (because OF COURSE she wasn't going to be out done by her daughter in law) but it was, and still is, a reminder of a) how she wants to 1-up me and b) how much I really don't like the ring anyway regardless of whether she chose something similar.

Given how controlling and manipulative she is I would not be at all surprised to find out she influenced my husband in his decision. MIL is extremely materialistic and hugely narcissistic. She will only shop in Waitrose or John Lewis. Wouldn't be seen dead in Aldi. I shit you not I've seen this woman throw a fit in the middle of Tescos because she wanted to buy "Tescos Finest" sausage rolls and we said she had to buy the basic range instead. She actually stamped her foot. She was going thru bankruptcy at the time. (Couldn't make it up) She is also SO wasteful with her possessions. Once she's owned something for 6 months it goes in the bin. No exaggeration. She only wears designer label clothes like Chanel and Zara and of course all of it is financed by her rich husband. I find it quite gross but each to their own. I keep my mouth shut out of respect for my husband.

I on the other hand often advocate for people not being "defined by their possessions" & I am not materialistic in the slightest. I often shop at charity shops, reuse, recycle. I could not give a rats ass if you shop in bargain basement or waitrose. I don't care if our tv is 24" or 80". I dont get my nails done every week, I dont shop high end. I really do not care if your dress was from the bargain bin or if it was made from the wool of Appalachian sheep, licked together by unicorns and dyed with the berries of a rare Himalayan flower, delivered by private jet and charged £1937448292947 for one pocket. I really couldn't care less.

If we lost all of our possessions tomorrow I'd still be ME...........But

if theres one exception to that rule I feel like your engagement ring would be it......right?

It's not about the value. I honestly do not want a massive rock that cost thousands of pounds. It doesn't even have to be diamond. I just want a ring that represents me. Represents US.

I see other engagement ring designs all the time and I'd be lying if I dont get jealous every time. I think "urgh I really wish I had a ring like that but I'm stuck with THIS" I want a ring that I WANT to wear. Not one I feel obligated to wear.

How in the hell do I explain it to husband without destroying his ego and sounding like a massive materialistic bellend? Do I just keep my mouth shut and be grateful for what I've got?

AIBU?

OP posts:
Myusernameisnotmyusernameno · 12/11/2021 15:23

@girljulian

This is why engagement rings are ridiculous. I think it was sweet of him to try and pick it himself, but also this is the obvious pitfall! It's not your fault you don't like it, but it's just a ring. My grandmothers didn't have engagement rings; it wasn't even a thing. My sister has an incredibly ugly engagement ring and we laugh about how un-her it is but she wears it because it's just a thing that reminds her of her fiance trying his best. I wouldn't have worn it; but I'd have just put it in a drawer and not said I didn't like it. Do women all wear their engagement rings all the time forever? In my circle, people stop wearing their engagement rings after they're married, especially when they're big ones. One of my close friends even got engaged the other day and has since replaced the ring with a cheap facsimile because she's scared of losing the expensive original! You could say that?
I wear my engagement ring when I'm not in the house. So anywhere I go that's outside I'll wear it. It really goes with my wedding ring. I 'briefed' my DH for years about what kind of ring I wanted lol. My mum only wore her engagement ring for special occasions and doesn't really wear it at all any more.
Skeumorph · 12/11/2021 15:22

How expensive were the rings?

I'd just lose them both.

Easier than an awkward conversation, and you make sure you jump right in with examples of what you LIKE to replace them.

Cheerbear23 · 12/11/2021 15:21

Tell him the ring keeps snagging and get them remodelled into a design you like.
Lol-ing about sausage rolls too! I think the MIL has got you really wound up!

choli · 12/11/2021 15:21

*If we lost all of our possessions tomorrow I'd still be ME...........But

if theres one exception to that rule I feel like your engagement ring would be it......right?*
Wrong.

Mumoftwo1990 · 12/11/2021 15:21

@CharlieBird25

So me and husband have been married for 5 years (together 11 years in total). We have a child together. There's been some good years and some bad years but on the whole we have a good relationship and both work hard for our family.

Anyway... yeah theres no point dancing around the subject - i HATE my engagement ring.

He chose it for me. I had no idea he was going to propose. He went to a lot of effort to organise the proposal - got our family involved. It was sweet. But yeah as soon as he showed me the ring I was like "mmmmmmmmyeah I hate it" (in my head).

I haven't ever told him. I haven't told anyone. But yeah I hate it it's just not "me".

It's got quite a unique wrap around twisted/spiral design with a suspended diamond. I mean I'm sure it would look great on someone but i just don't love it. When I showed my friends they were all like "hmmmm thats....nice! All that matters is that you like it" I said i did because i felt obligated to but really.....i hated it.

I wanted to say something at first but there were people around at the time of the proposal so I didn't want to embarrass him and he was so on cloud-9 that night I didn't want to hurt his feelings. Then it became awkward the next morning because everyone wanted me to wear the ring and take pictures of it which got uploaded to social media and it became harder and harder to say anything. Then more time passed and it just became impossible. I just accepted my fate that I was going to have to wear an ugly ring forever. I told myself it didn't matter. That I was lucky to have a ring at all. That my husband went to a lot of trouble with the proposal it would be really shitty of me to say something after all this time.

Also, because of the unusual design we had to buy a very specific (ugly) wedding ring to fit around it so now I don't like my wedding ring OR my engagement ring. Hilarious.

To rub further salt into the wound my dragon in law (MIL) got engaged a year after us and she and her fiance went to CHOOSE her rings together. Conveniently she CHOSE a ring that had the exact same twisted/spiral/wrap around design. The only difference was it had a bigger rock in it than mine (because OF COURSE she wasn't going to be out done by her daughter in law) but it was, and still is, a reminder of a) how she wants to 1-up me and b) how much I really don't like the ring anyway regardless of whether she chose something similar.

Given how controlling and manipulative she is I would not be at all surprised to find out she influenced my husband in his decision. MIL is extremely materialistic and hugely narcissistic. She will only shop in Waitrose or John Lewis. Wouldn't be seen dead in Aldi. I shit you not I've seen this woman throw a fit in the middle of Tescos because she wanted to buy "Tescos Finest" sausage rolls and we said she had to buy the basic range instead. She actually stamped her foot. She was going thru bankruptcy at the time. (Couldn't make it up) She is also SO wasteful with her possessions. Once she's owned something for 6 months it goes in the bin. No exaggeration. She only wears designer label clothes like Chanel and Zara and of course all of it is financed by her rich husband. I find it quite gross but each to their own. I keep my mouth shut out of respect for my husband.

I on the other hand often advocate for people not being "defined by their possessions" & I am not materialistic in the slightest. I often shop at charity shops, reuse, recycle. I could not give a rats ass if you shop in bargain basement or waitrose. I don't care if our tv is 24" or 80". I dont get my nails done every week, I dont shop high end. I really do not care if your dress was from the bargain bin or if it was made from the wool of Appalachian sheep, licked together by unicorns and dyed with the berries of a rare Himalayan flower, delivered by private jet and charged £1937448292947 for one pocket. I really couldn't care less.

If we lost all of our possessions tomorrow I'd still be ME...........But

if theres one exception to that rule I feel like your engagement ring would be it......right?

It's not about the value. I honestly do not want a massive rock that cost thousands of pounds. It doesn't even have to be diamond. I just want a ring that represents me. Represents US.

I see other engagement ring designs all the time and I'd be lying if I dont get jealous every time. I think "urgh I really wish I had a ring like that but I'm stuck with THIS" I want a ring that I WANT to wear. Not one I feel obligated to wear.

How in the hell do I explain it to husband without destroying his ego and sounding like a massive materialistic bellend? Do I just keep my mouth shut and be grateful for what I've got?

AIBU?

You could be straight up honest but I get that's hard at this point, maybe suggest designing new rings together for an anniversary day or Christmas etc and that way it's celebrating your time together and you can essential pick something you'd like!
GreenLunchBox · 12/11/2021 15:21

@catinboots123

I have been on MN for about a million years but this is probably the best thread I have ever read.

We have it all -

Shit engagement ring✔️
Crazy MIL✔️
Value vs posh sausage rolls✔️
Zara named as a designer shop✔️

It's days like these that make me glad I haven't flounced despite the many times I have wanted to

Agreed Grin
ifIwerenotanandroid · 12/11/2021 15:20

@Disfordarkchocolate

That ring really sounds like it would get in my way, snag on things etc all the time.

The most tactful thing is to say to your husband its snagging on things and you are going to get is redesigned so it's more wearable. Perhaps stop wearing it for a bit first and give this as the reason. Or accidentally hit it with a hammer.

Grin

I like your other suggestions, as they avoid hurting his feelings as much as possible. It's not that the rings are hideous, it's that they snag. You want to keep the metal & gemstone (thus keeping continuity with your engagement & marriage) but have them made into something more practical.

He may still be hurt, but this sounds like the best option. And you could decide on a style together, which would be another nice touch.

I deliberately chose an antique engagement ring which was very practical (which meant I didn't choose the one at the antiques fair in the same style with diamonds twice the size, the only thing I regret as I love a bit of sparkle), as I knew I'd lose it if I had to take it off; so I wore my wedding & engagement rings all the time & loved them. Sadly I put on weight & my fingers also temporarily swelled up with some medical treatment, & I had the rings cut off. I can't decide what to do now. I really miss wearing them. Should I resize them or get them made into a new piece of jewellery? I can't decide & am stuck in limbo.

WeAllHaveWings · 12/11/2021 15:19

@Bluntness100

I’m guessing it’s something like this.
Or maybe something like this style.....
AIBU to hate my engagement ring? Been married 5 yrs.
BadwordMcGee · 12/11/2021 15:17

I don't like mine so I don't wear it. It's not a diaster, in fact it's not an issue at all. Life is easier not wearing rings, particularly with all the handwashing.

choli · 12/11/2021 15:17

@Bluntness100

I’m guessing it’s something like this.
Call me odd but I love that. Married 25 years, 25 years since I wore my engagement ring. I had no idea people took them so seriously.
catinboots123 · 12/11/2021 15:13

I have been on MN for about a million years but this is probably the best thread I have ever read.

We have it all -

Shit engagement ring✔️
Crazy MIL✔️
Value vs posh sausage rolls✔️
Zara named as a designer shop✔️

It's days like these that make me glad I haven't flounced despite the many times I have wanted to

LittleGwyneth · 12/11/2021 15:12

Get the diamond reset in a different style, they can melt the original band down. That way it's still technically your ring, but in a much nicer design. If you're worried about hurting DH's feelings, tell him that your style has changed over the last few years and you don't feel like it's 'you' anymore, but you don't want to waste it but leaving it in a jewellery box.

Also lol at Chanel and Zara.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 12/11/2021 15:09

I wouldn't trust a man to blind buy me a bottle of perfume so I don't understand the whole 'man choosing the ring' thing anyway. If you're going to have that thing on your paw for decades to come you have to love it. Men are also weirdly fond of designing engagement rings too, usually men who aren't all that creative or design minded. Always looks a bit rubbish.

I am with your MIL on the Finest sausage roll thing by the way. The value sausage rolls are minging. Wink

Werehamster · 12/11/2021 15:08

@StrychnineInTheSandwiches

Have the stone removed and set in a different ring? Make up some story about the ring catching on things or diplomatically stating that your taste has changed.
This is what I would do!
choli · 12/11/2021 15:08

@DillyDilly

Only wears designer clothes like ‘ ‘Chanel or Zara’ ???? Ha!
I know, I was screeching at thatGrin
SergeiL · 12/11/2021 15:08

My mind boggles at this thread. You do know getting engaged and married isn’t about the rings right? (Or sausage rolls or MILs). And not about what your friends say or the photos?

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 12/11/2021 15:07

I can’t believe people are fixating on the sausage rolls, when the real star of the show is clearly the Appalachian sheep.

girljulian · 12/11/2021 15:07

This is why engagement rings are ridiculous. I think it was sweet of him to try and pick it himself, but also this is the obvious pitfall! It's not your fault you don't like it, but it's just a ring. My grandmothers didn't have engagement rings; it wasn't even a thing. My sister has an incredibly ugly engagement ring and we laugh about how un-her it is but she wears it because it's just a thing that reminds her of her fiance trying his best. I wouldn't have worn it; but I'd have just put it in a drawer and not said I didn't like it. Do women all wear their engagement rings all the time forever? In my circle, people stop wearing their engagement rings after they're married, especially when they're big ones. One of my close friends even got engaged the other day and has since replaced the ring with a cheap facsimile because she's scared of losing the expensive original! You could say that?

BlueMongoose · 12/11/2021 15:06

If you don't like it, don't wear it. Suggest to DH you get an eternity ring instead and keep the engagement ring 'safe' on one side somewhere. If it has a stone in, that's a good reason not to wear it all the time. Or get matching eternity rings and go and choose them together.

IReallyCan · 12/11/2021 15:06

Lol

HopeYourHighHorseBucks · 12/11/2021 15:05

I normally dislike when irrelevant information is put in to an OP but I enjoyed reading this, i can imagine it was very therapeutic for you. Reminds me of when my closest friend came over, complaining of a belly ache and how her DP uses too much garlic etc, turned into half hour of her absolutely assassinating his character.

Anyway, you've been together long enough to be honest about it. Leave out the dragon slayer vibe you got going on and just admit you prefer these type style rings and would like to exchange your ugly mini MIL ring.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 12/11/2021 15:05

Have the stone removed and set in a different ring? Make up some story about the ring catching on things or diplomatically stating that your taste has changed.

Megan2018 · 12/11/2021 15:03

It’s not insurance fraud if you genuinely lose the ring.
I have insurance on my ring already inc accidental damage. If I lost it or damaged it I’d claim. Fortunately I love it so I am very careful with it. If I hated it I might not be so careful. Oops. No-one will know.

But this is hardly a serious thread, there is no need for such pearl clutching. Zara and Chanel, wealthy husband but bankrupt. Yeah, ok.

Bluntness100 · 12/11/2021 15:02

I read your post and understood that you were just putting us in the picture about your MIL because the fact that she probably influenced the original purchase could well be the reason your husband picked such a dubious style of ring.

“Putting us in the picture” 😂😂😂 yes because her sausage roll preferences are indeed vital.

NaturalBlondeYeahRight · 12/11/2021 15:01

I genuinely lost the diamond out of my original ring but I’d never ‘loved’ it. Went and chose a new one myself and DH literally had a look and said ‘that’s nice’. He had no interest or sentimentality about the first one. Perhaps yours is the same now, it’s been a long time.