Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they should have Xrayed

85 replies

Starlight86 · 12/11/2021 11:04

DD age 6 had an accident on the trampoline in gymnastics on Tuesday.

She hasn't been able to weight bare properly since then, only able to limp on her toes. The pain is specifically her heel.

The pain has got worse and today she was crying, so her dad took her off to A&E for an x-ray ....... her foot has swollen but not extreme, enough though that the nurse commented on it.

Anyways a doctor came and looked at it, said she wont have broken anything as to break a heel you need to fall from a height and said probably a sprain and sent her on her way.

Husband did try to say about an xray but they said no need...

OP posts:
Starlight86 · 12/11/2021 13:47

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

the doctor said the fall wasnt hard enough to warrant an x-ray and she wont have fractured her heel and due to the fact that the pain is all in the heel means she's just sprained it

I would agree that is unlikely that she has fractured the main body of the calcaneous (heel) though - as I said above - you can never say never in medicine! I don't like getting into guessing diagnoses on the internet, when I haven't seen the patient, but there are a number of other fracture-dislocations of the foot and ankle that should be excluded, particularly a talar fracture. They aren't common in children, but forced dorsi-flexion (the foot being pushed back towards the ankle) is the classic mechanism of injury, and - from your description - may well be what happened to your DD. She could also have a dislocation without a fracture.

Thank you for all your imput.

Im going to asses over the weekend and if i see no improvement at all ill be taking her back for an xray.

OP posts:
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 12/11/2021 13:44

the doctor said the fall wasnt hard enough to warrant an x-ray and she wont have fractured her heel and due to the fact that the pain is all in the heel means she's just sprained it

I would agree that is unlikely that she has fractured the main body of the calcaneous (heel) though - as I said above - you can never say never in medicine! I don't like getting into guessing diagnoses on the internet, when I haven't seen the patient, but there are a number of other fracture-dislocations of the foot and ankle that should be excluded, particularly a talar fracture. They aren't common in children, but forced dorsi-flexion (the foot being pushed back towards the ankle) is the classic mechanism of injury, and - from your description - may well be what happened to your DD. She could also have a dislocation without a fracture.

Starlight86 · 12/11/2021 13:36

Its terrible but i feel like if i went back and demanded an xray i would die of embarrassment if it was nothing, but then equally if i dont and there is something wrong ive potentially damaged her for life and her gymnastics sport which she loves and is on a competitive pathway for.

OP posts:
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 12/11/2021 13:34

@RobotValkyrie

Could be a sprain, could be a fracture... If it were me I'd prefer an x-ray, but exposure to radiations should be minimised, so, tough call...

You can try and get a second opinion, or do a bit of "watchful waiting" first. If your DD is coping well, treating it as a sprain (for now) may be enough, but if she's not coping and/or symptoms worsen, go and get her seen again ASAP.

Instead of popping straight back to A&E, you may try to get an emergency appointment with her GP. They can't do x-ray, but they can advise, if you're not sure (and maybe direct you to services who can help. I was surprised a few months ago that my GP could arrange ultrasound scans without going through our local hospital!)

Speaking as both a GP and A&E doctor, it is a complete waste of time going to a GP at the stage. We don't have x-ray vision. I'm extremely experienced in assessing musculoskeletal injuries, because of my A&E work, but there is nothing useful I could do in general practice at this stage.

Watchful waiting may have been appropriate on Day 1, but this child is now nearly 72h from the injury and still non-weight bearing. That is a concern, and she needs a fracture excluded. She also needs assessment of the whole leg, not just the heel, if this hasn't already happened, because it's not unusual for a young child to describe the pain as being in a different site to the actual injury.

It's still most likely that this is a soft tissue injury. But the only way to be sure is an x-ray and, at this stage, that is what should happen.

Starlight86 · 12/11/2021 13:27

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

She did go ask someone although im not sure who, also totally forgot about this and not to drip feed but last year she was diagnosed with kohler's disease on that same foot (all better and healed now)

So when my husband said he wanted an xray for her due to the fact also she had kohlers in that foot and dealt with that pain for 4 days before we took her.

However the doctor said the fall wasnt hard enough to warrant an x-ray and she wont have fractured her heel and due to the fact that the pain is all in the heel means shes just sprained it.

Advised no gymnastics for 2 weeks but also advised still to walk and run on it.....

OP posts:
RobotValkyrie · 12/11/2021 13:26

Could be a sprain, could be a fracture... If it were me I'd prefer an x-ray, but exposure to radiations should be minimised, so, tough call...

You can try and get a second opinion, or do a bit of "watchful waiting" first. If your DD is coping well, treating it as a sprain (for now) may be enough, but if she's not coping and/or symptoms worsen, go and get her seen again ASAP.

Instead of popping straight back to A&E, you may try to get an emergency appointment with her GP. They can't do x-ray, but they can advise, if you're not sure (and maybe direct you to services who can help. I was surprised a few months ago that my GP could arrange ultrasound scans without going through our local hospital!)

Starlight86 · 12/11/2021 13:23

@shouldistop yes, coach was there, believe it happened very fast before other child could be taken off, they are all around age 6 so just little kids not realizing

OP posts:
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 12/11/2021 13:22

@Starlight86

From what i gather,

She was on the trampoline, she was jumping and someone else came on and jumped so it made it like a double jump if that makes sense....so when she landed the trampoline was springing back up from someone that had already jumped therefor it wasnt as springy.

Does that make sense lol

The mechanism of injury isn't really key at this point. Sometimes apparently trivial injuries can cause fractures. I suspect the A&E doctor who told your DH that "It can't be broken because it wasn't a significant fall" hasn't been an A&E doctor for very long!

The key points at this stage are that your DD is still non-weight bearing and that the pain is worse. It's also significant that she was non-weight bearing from the outset. She needs an x-ray. Even if it isn't broken she may benefit from immobilisation (splint/cast) but this is only true of some soft tissue injuries and can make others worse, so please get her seen in A&E again, don;t just immobilise to see what happens.

shouldistop · 12/11/2021 13:21

@Starlight86

From what i gather,

She was on the trampoline, she was jumping and someone else came on and jumped so it made it like a double jump if that makes sense....so when she landed the trampoline was springing back up from someone that had already jumped therefor it wasnt as springy.

Does that make sense lol

Christ, that's really dangerous. Any trampolines I've seen always have signs saying not to do that. If that was at a supervised gymnastics class and allowed to happen I'd be very upset.
Starlight86 · 12/11/2021 13:16

Also just to add - our minor injury unit does not xray children.

OP posts:
Starlight86 · 12/11/2021 13:14

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

I'm an A&E doctor/urgent care GP. It is unusual to break the heel with a fall onto a soft surface but, if 20 years in A&E have taught me anything, it's never to say never.

We try not to x-ray when there is a low risk of a fracture, especially with children, because of the exposure to radiation. If I had seen your DD on the day of her injury, I might not have x-rayed then and there (depending on my examination, obviously), but - if I hadn't x-rayed, I would definitely have told you to come back if there was no improvement within 48 hours.

In your case, the fact that the pain has got worse after 48 hours is a red flag. I would definitely return to A&E and request a consultant review - or go to a Minor Injury Unit if you have one locally that has an x-ray facility .

It is still most likely to be a sprain - they can be extremely painful in the foot. But, if it was my DD, I would want her x-rayed at this point.

Thank you, ive written a more in depth about her landing above.

it happened tuesday at 6pm, we took her to A&E today at 9.30am.

OP posts:
Starlight86 · 12/11/2021 13:13

From what i gather,

She was on the trampoline, she was jumping and someone else came on and jumped so it made it like a double jump if that makes sense....so when she landed the trampoline was springing back up from someone that had already jumped therefor it wasnt as springy.

Does that make sense lol

OP posts:
justswaying · 12/11/2021 12:58

I went to a&e after I thought I broke my foot and they refused to X-ray. "We don't just give out x rays to anyone that wants one. You seem to be in a lot of pain, a break wouldn't cause that much pain so it must just be a bad sprain"
A week later I still couldn't walk, went back for second opinion and lo and behold it was broken in two places.

They do sometimes get things wrong

CrotchetyQuaver · 12/11/2021 12:55

Take her back! Or to a different hospital. My DD had similar with a broken wrist they said wasn't (no X-ray done at first visit) they gave her a Velcro splint thing and of course it did nothing. I took her back a week later and guess what they xrayed and it was broken but years later I still feel bad that I didn't push harder at the first visit and she was in a lot of pain because I hadn't been firmer with them.

Rainbowsew · 12/11/2021 12:46

As they A&E doctors have said X-ray may not be done initially with small children (radiographer here) however the caveat is always to seek further advice if pain worsens and as parents know their children, I would think most professionals would take into account a parent saying their child is not improving.

Calcaneal fractures are more likely to be caused by falls from height, but with trampolines particularly there is risk of soft tissue injury or more complicated fracture dislocations due to the mechanism of injury, so I'd want to check her out despite radiation doses etc.

Did she fall from trampoline to floor? That'd be an equivalent force to a fall from height. Or did she twist her foot whilst bouncing? That'd be more likely to be a soft tissue injury (and they can be very painful and slow to heal). Children's bones are soft and pliable a high bounce with a twist as she came down does have potential to injure the bone. Take her back and explain your concerns and as best you know the way the accident occured.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 12/11/2021 12:45

@Irishfarmer

I would take her to the minor injuries unit, not A&E. Here they are very good anyway at dealing with broken bones/ non life threating stuff. And are usually way quicker!
But only if the MIU has an x-ray facility. Otherwise they will have to refer the OP to A&E, so she'll end up there anyway.
Irishfarmer · 12/11/2021 12:39

I would take her to the minor injuries unit, not A&E. Here they are very good anyway at dealing with broken bones/ non life threating stuff. And are usually way quicker!

SingingSands · 12/11/2021 12:38

Did she land on the trampoline or on the floor/mat? is what helped the Dr reach his decision that an X-ray wasn't required?

Even if it's not broken, soft tissue and ligament damage can be really badly painful and 3 days is still very recent. Does pain from a break increase with time or does it remain at the same level? I had a really bad ankle and foot sprain last year that definitely got worse before it got better.

Hard one to call - could you give it the weekend with strictly enforced rest and R.I.C.E (be absolutely clear to DD that no walking/attempts to weight bear at all)? Then if no better on Monday another trip to A&E?

wanttomarryamillionaire · 12/11/2021 12:37

I would be taking her back and demanding an x- ray! My dd did this a few years ago and we were told no need for x- ray blah blah blah. We spent the weekend with her sobbing and hobbling about and eventually took her back. She had broken a growth plate in her foot and spent the next two weeks on crutches with a special boot on.

MrsAvocet · 12/11/2021 12:34

Heel fractures are usually really obvious
Well mine was misdiagnosed as a sprained ankle for 48 hours when I was an inpatient on a trauma ward so I wouldn't bet on that! Fortunately a different consultant was on at the weekend and she arranged an x ray then a CT scan which showed a complex calcaneal fracture that I am still awaiting further surgery for years later. I'd previously been more or less told not to be so soft and to walk on it.

StaplesCorner · 12/11/2021 12:34

Actually today, now, might be a quieter time - don't go over the weekend and then Monday morning tends to have the fall out from the weekend too - so maybe today?

StaplesCorner · 12/11/2021 12:33

A&E is often reluctant to X ray they will want you to wait and see if it heals/gets worse. Didnt happen to us but a friend's daughter had a similar injury age 11 (the calcaneal fracture others are talking about?) and she got fobbed off for months, ended up there was a long term problem - can you get a telephone consult with your GP and see if they will ask for/arrange an x-ray so you don't have to go through A&E again? Even so, if you need to then go, choose a quieter time maybe so the wait isn't so long but ultimately A&E make mistakes over these supposedly smaller injuries as others have said.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 12/11/2021 12:31

I'm an A&E doctor/urgent care GP. It is unusual to break the heel with a fall onto a soft surface but, if 20 years in A&E have taught me anything, it's never to say never.

We try not to x-ray when there is a low risk of a fracture, especially with children, because of the exposure to radiation. If I had seen your DD on the day of her injury, I might not have x-rayed then and there (depending on my examination, obviously), but - if I hadn't x-rayed, I would definitely have told you to come back if there was no improvement within 48 hours.

In your case, the fact that the pain has got worse after 48 hours is a red flag. I would definitely return to A&E and request a consultant review - or go to a Minor Injury Unit if you have one locally that has an x-ray facility .

It is still most likely to be a sprain - they can be extremely painful in the foot. But, if it was my DD, I would want her x-rayed at this point.

comfortablyfrumpy · 12/11/2021 12:28

When my daughter broke her ankle she could still move her foot up and down... I think you're right to be questioning this, and I'd be asking for a second opinion/Xrays if I were you. I hope your daughter is OK.

Starlight86 · 12/11/2021 12:25

@JustAnother30Something

Could you not maybe go to Urgent Care?

That's where I'd have gone initially tbf given it was a few days old?

Our urgent care doesnt see children - its only A&E im afraid.
OP posts: