Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they should have Xrayed

85 replies

Starlight86 · 12/11/2021 11:04

DD age 6 had an accident on the trampoline in gymnastics on Tuesday.

She hasn't been able to weight bare properly since then, only able to limp on her toes. The pain is specifically her heel.

The pain has got worse and today she was crying, so her dad took her off to A&E for an x-ray ....... her foot has swollen but not extreme, enough though that the nurse commented on it.

Anyways a doctor came and looked at it, said she wont have broken anything as to break a heel you need to fall from a height and said probably a sprain and sent her on her way.

Husband did try to say about an xray but they said no need...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
olympicsrock · 12/11/2021 22:10

Also a doctor with ED experience. Would not have xrayed if you had attended immediately but agree that worsening pain and non weight bearing is a concern now. I think worth going back if still not right tomorrow. Keep it up and apply an ice pack - will help swelling and pain.

Crazycrazylady · 12/11/2021 22:02

I broke my heel on a car accident and I was told it's actually a really rare bone to break as it's had to be hit at a really rare angle.. so maybe that's why

nicky2512 · 12/11/2021 19:34

A&E weren’t going to X-ray Ds’s shoulder when he slipped and fell in PE. Doctor wiggled his arm about loads and Ds was in tears.
We were just leaving when Ds said he could feel something moving inside and they decided to do an X-ray but said it was just a precaution.

Obviously he had a broken shoulder. Pain was awful, loads of physio needed and he still has a weakness in that arm over 3 years later.

readwhatiactuallysay · 12/11/2021 19:28

I would also take her back.

Even after an xray The "qualified doctors" sent our friend away with a "sprain" only to be called the day later to be told, no sorry we looked again and it is broken !!! We were all flabagasted, but mistskes do happen and things do get missed.

Take her back tonight to be sure.

AtrociousCircumstance · 12/11/2021 19:20

I’d also take her back tonight.

Ricetwisty · 12/11/2021 19:12

@Darkstar4855

Yes, the qualified doctor can’t possibly know what they are talking about. Complain to PALS, OP Hmm
Doctors are human, and sometimes wrong about injuries. They should have done an X Ray, presumably couldn't be arsed or didn't want to use the resource though.
BingBongToTheMoon · 12/11/2021 19:10

I’d take her back tonight.

Redarrow2017 · 12/11/2021 18:58

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

sueelleker · 12/11/2021 17:14

@NotMyCat

I'm surprised they didn't I went to a&e with a painful foot/ankle, no trauma, no swelling or bruising. They said it wouldn't be broken but would x ray anyway Multiple breaks to my foot and ankle, and I was totally mobile on it
I had an ankle sprain x rayed, and told it was ok. 3 days later they called me to go back, as they'd looked at the film again and found a fracture.
steppemum · 12/11/2021 16:30

MissLucy has given some very sensible advice.

Don;t be afraid to go back and insist a bit more.

Catfox1 · 12/11/2021 16:19

@Darkstar4855

Yes, the qualified doctor can’t possibly know what they are talking about. Complain to PALS, OP Hmm
A qualified doctor told me I didn’t break my knee 13 years ago. Another qualified doctor 5 years later sent me for an x ray and then asked why I never got my historic fracture fixed and that it was now too late. In present day I still can’t kneel on it or weight bear
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 12/11/2021 16:15

Thanks @choosername1234. I'm glad someone appreciates my advice - my patients so rarely do 😉

OneTimeGo · 12/11/2021 15:41

@Sixgeese

When DD was 2, DH fell down the stairs while carrying her. I took them straight to A and E as they were both in pain. DH was X rayed and was found to have broken a rib.

They wouldn't X Ray DD, they said at her age it wouldn't be broken, it was a sprain, it would hurt but we were to make her walk in it as much as possible.

After a few days with no improvement I took her to the GP, they agreed with the hospitals assessment, as did a friend who is a GP who I asked for advice.

After 2 weeks and a lot of crying, I noticed her leg seemed to have started bowing. I took her straight back to hospital, where I was made to think I was a neurotic mother. They X rayed her, in part I think to shut me up.

It turned out her leg was broken in 3 places.

I felt so bad, and that was made worse by the people who were plastering it asking why it had taken me 2 weeks after the accident to bring her to the hospital and why hadn't I brought her straight away.

Please do not be fobbed off like I was, if your DC is in pain and you are worried please get it checked out, they can only know whether or not it is broken with any certainty is by x Ray.

I sincerely hope that you told them VERY clearly that you had taken her straight away and that the hospital refused to x-ray. I hate hearing people being fobbed off like this.
Starlight86 · 12/11/2021 15:36

@FrangipaniBlue

Is the pain actually in her heel or is it that the pain is in her whole foot when she puts her heel down/foot flat?

The reason I ask is because when I broke the metatarsal bone in my foot I could limp on my toes but not bear weight on my heel or with my foot flat.

It’s all her heel however underneath and over the top of her toes are starting to her sore. I assumed this is due to her walked on her toes/limping for 3 days
OP posts:
StopGo · 12/11/2021 15:33

@Darkstar4855

Yes, the qualified doctor can’t possibly know what they are talking about. Complain to PALS, OP Hmm
Maybe it was the same doctor who had a right go at me because my elderly DM was admitted by ambulance after slipping out of her chair?

DM had broken her hip. It happens.

choosername1234 · 12/11/2021 15:18

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

I'm an A&E doctor/urgent care GP. It is unusual to break the heel with a fall onto a soft surface but, if 20 years in A&E have taught me anything, it's never to say never.

We try not to x-ray when there is a low risk of a fracture, especially with children, because of the exposure to radiation. If I had seen your DD on the day of her injury, I might not have x-rayed then and there (depending on my examination, obviously), but - if I hadn't x-rayed, I would definitely have told you to come back if there was no improvement within 48 hours.

In your case, the fact that the pain has got worse after 48 hours is a red flag. I would definitely return to A&E and request a consultant review - or go to a Minor Injury Unit if you have one locally that has an x-ray facility .

It is still most likely to be a sprain - they can be extremely painful in the foot. But, if it was my DD, I would want her x-rayed at this point.

I've worked in A&E for almost 20 years and this is the most sensible answer I think I've ever seen on Mumsnet (waves to colleague) 👋
FrangipaniBlue · 12/11/2021 14:41

Is the pain actually in her heel or is it that the pain is in her whole foot when she puts her heel down/foot flat?

The reason I ask is because when I broke the metatarsal bone in my foot I could limp on my toes but not bear weight on my heel or with my foot flat.

Lougle · 12/11/2021 14:29

"ive potentially damaged her for life and her gymnastics sport which she loves and is on a competitive pathway for."

She will be covered by insurance for the trampolining and they can assess her injuries through that. Look it up - they can give physio, etc.

CrazyCatLover · 12/11/2021 14:25

Same as what someone has posted but there are IRMER regulations, meaning health care professionals have to provide X-ray department a good rational for requesting X-rays to minimise unnecessary exposure. Hopefully she will get better soon x

longtompot · 12/11/2021 14:05

My ed sprained her ankle many years ago. We didn't get it looked at straight away as thought she would be ok. After a few days we realised she wasn't, took her to a&e, I was asked many times why I didn't take her sooner and I said if I took my kids in for every injury I'd be forever in a&e.
Anyway, her injury didn't heal and she now has a chronic pain condition.
What I am saying is I'd rather a moment of embarrassment and it be nothing, than what she has been through for the past 12 or so years.

Starlight86 · 12/11/2021 13:57

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow Thank you so much i really do appreciate all you have said xx

OP posts:
Starlight86 · 12/11/2021 13:56

@steppemum

I twisted my ankle a while ago while out walking the dog.

I couldn't stand on it at all, and had to phone dh to collect.
Sat at home with bag of frozen peas and it was so painful. Couldn't weight bear at all, swollen and agony to the touch.

So dh took me to A&E. Due to Covid, he had to drop me off, and then I discovered we needed to be at a different door, and had to hobble 20 yards to the other door. Took me ages, and arrived at the other door, literally crying in pain, and trying to be adult and keep it all together.

Got x-rayed and it was not broken.

I couldn't walk for 2 weeks, and after that, only hobble. Didn't drive for about a month. Pain was awful. Swelling was huge, and when the bruising came out my whole foot was purple.

I know ankles and heels are different, but I am just saying that soft tissue injury can be awful

Yes im so aware it could be this - its just so tricky with a child because as a parent you dont really know whats going on it there.

I would have assumed that most of the time if you have a child presenting the way my daughter did then it would be an automatic xray.

OP posts:
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 12/11/2021 13:56

@Starlight86

Its terrible but i feel like if i went back and demanded an xray i would die of embarrassment if it was nothing, but then equally if i dont and there is something wrong ive potentially damaged her for life and her gymnastics sport which she loves and is on a competitive pathway for.
Do not be embarrassed! I have been a doctor for over 20 years and I still regularly get it wrong when guessing which of the patients have sent to x-ray will turn out to have fractures.

Go back. Say:
(1) She was non weight-bearing at the time of the injury
(2) She has been non weight-bearing or partially weight--bearing since
(3) The pain is getting worse, not better
(4) The foot is swollen
(5) She is a competitive gymnast

If you like, you can also say that you have spoken to an acquaintance who is an A&E doctor, who feels that a group 1 talar fracture and subtalar dislocation need to be excluded. (Of course, you only have my word for it that I'm an A&E doctor, and I would never, ever advise anyone to follow medical advice from a stranger on the internet but, in this case, I am only advising you to see a doctor IRL, not on any treatment.)

These injuries are rare in young children but, when they do occur, they are usually from forced twisting of the foot, as probably happened to your DD.

NotMyCat · 12/11/2021 13:52

I'm surprised they didn't
I went to a&e with a painful foot/ankle, no trauma, no swelling or bruising. They said it wouldn't be broken but would x ray anyway
Multiple breaks to my foot and ankle, and I was totally mobile on it

steppemum · 12/11/2021 13:49

I twisted my ankle a while ago while out walking the dog.

I couldn't stand on it at all, and had to phone dh to collect.
Sat at home with bag of frozen peas and it was so painful. Couldn't weight bear at all, swollen and agony to the touch.

So dh took me to A&E. Due to Covid, he had to drop me off, and then I discovered we needed to be at a different door, and had to hobble 20 yards to the other door. Took me ages, and arrived at the other door, literally crying in pain, and trying to be adult and keep it all together.

Got x-rayed and it was not broken.

I couldn't walk for 2 weeks, and after that, only hobble. Didn't drive for about a month. Pain was awful. Swelling was huge, and when the bruising came out my whole foot was purple.

I know ankles and heels are different, but I am just saying that soft tissue injury can be awful