Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being told to smile at work

178 replies

SmileSmiley · 12/11/2021 10:09

I have worked as a solicitor since 2008. I work in house for a local authority and generally love my job.

I went to a meeting yesterday and the first thing my client told me was to smile. He then told me that he’d been to a meeting the week before with an external solicitor who greeted him with a ‘lovely big smile’. He then asked why I couldn’t be the same.

I was too shocked to respond. I work in a team with my DP who is also a solicitor - this client has never told him to smile or compared him to a male solicitor.

I have a resting sad face and even when I smile I don’t look particularly happy. However, I am fed up of how I look being deemed to be relevant to how I do my job.

I want to raise this with the client but I know he is going to brush me off as being over sensitive. Should I just leave it this time and have a snappy response prepared for the next time?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AsMyGranWouldSay · 14/11/2021 10:43

I think brutal honesty can do wonders in these situations e.g.
"you maybe don't know this but I get really uncomfortable when men comment on my body" while maintaining eye contact.

Your face is part of your body, so it's just as intrusive as talking about your legs or whatever.

Some people need the obvious pointing out for them.

Double3xposure · 14/11/2021 10:04

there are a billion ways to make conversation. They're British, FFS, what about "blimey, this weather?"

Indeed. Usually I say something profound like “ Shame about this weather” or “ Nice to see the sun again after the last few days of rain “.

It never occurred to me to look around the room for a black colleague and say “ The last black person I dealt with was much more smiley than you. You need to smile more - that’s what white people like “ .

I think that would be easily identifiable as racism. I wonder why misogyny is so much harder to spot - indeed it has pages of comments explaining it away or even justifying it.

Pinkgorrilaz · 12/11/2021 20:41

*In private - it swings both ways. I’ve been with women talking about men in a derogatory way and I’ve been called “love” etc by men and aware of men talking about women in a derogatory way.
Private sector. The massive majority accept its half a dozen of one eland the other and get on with work.

Whereas I suspect in public sector (never worked, thank goodness), a lot more navel gazing and tick boxing and well, taking offence in order to get signed off!*

What a load of guff.

You can't extrapolate your career to every other company.

Of course private sector companies address sexism in the workplace.

You just sound like one of those self congratulatory types who thinks because nothing bad has happened to them, people who have experienced negative behaviours from others must be to blame themselves.

It's nauseating. They love coming onto these threads to preach about their career.

And to slag off the public sector. I'm sure you'd be grateful for the public sector when you need the police, fire service or NHS to help you.

OP you're right. This poster is on a wind up. I wish MN had an ignore particular posters function.

saraclara · 12/11/2021 20:27

@Livpool

From the other side I have a resting smiley face - and I have been told to stop smirking (I'm not - just my face) and be a bit more serious 🤷🏼‍♀️
Is your name Priti Patel?
Disfordarkchocolate · 12/11/2021 18:06

I have 'resting scary face' try cultivating that and he'll soon pack that it.

drpet49 · 12/11/2021 17:52

* It is relevant to how you do (some) jobs. A smile goes a long way, especially in client meetings. Not a big beaming and fake smile but if someone is sitting there looking sad it might give a wrong impression, especially if they are quiet too*

^I agree

noodlezoodle · 12/11/2021 17:51

I have epic resting bitch face and a hard paddington stare that can strip paint. I used to get this all the time. I'd be so tempted to just bare my teeth at him, although I don't know that I'd be brave enough.

Fadingout · 12/11/2021 17:51

They would never ever do this to a man! So why do they think it’s acceptable to do to a woman?!

youvegottenminuteslynn · 12/11/2021 16:49

@lentilsforever

I reckon he was filling an awkward silence and it bombed!
I went to a meeting yesterday and the first thing my client told me was to smile. He then told me that he’d been to a meeting the week before with an external solicitor who greeted him with a ‘lovely big smile’. He then asked why I couldn’t be the same

He should be professional, not 'fill an awkward silence' with a sexist request for a woman to smile on command because he likes it when women grin at him.

It would be a much more awkward silence after saying that surely!

lentilsforever · 12/11/2021 16:46

I reckon he was filling an awkward silence and it bombed!

Brefugee · 12/11/2021 16:44

Were you sat, waiting, staring into space? That's the only reason I can imagine he'd have said that. Maybe he was tactlessly trying to make conversation.

there are a billion ways to make conversation. They're British, FFS, what about "blimey, this weather?"

Women not wanting men to tell them to smile has been a topic of discussion for at least the last 30 years or more. They have got the message but they still do it.

If anyone says that to me i just say "why?" At work, i know how to interact with colleagues and clients professionally and when to smile and chat, but i don't have to sit around smiling all the time in between. It is insulting to suggest that.

lentilsforever · 12/11/2021 16:43

It was a general comment on private versus public rather than your situation

IntermittentParps · 12/11/2021 16:41

@HundredMilesAnHour

Is it sexism?? My boss once told me that I need to smile more at work (I wasn't client facing) because I "have presence" so it "worries people" if I look so serious. My boss was female, I'm female, so no sexism at play. Irritating but not sexism.
A woman can be sexist towards another woman. Don't you understand what the word means?
youvegottenminuteslynn · 12/11/2021 16:24

@HundredMilesAnHour

Is it sexism?? My boss once told me that I need to smile more at work (I wasn't client facing) because I "have presence" so it "worries people" if I look so serious. My boss was female, I'm female, so no sexism at play. Irritating but not sexism.
Women can still perpetuate sexist ideas, absolutely, of course they can.
SmileSmiley · 12/11/2021 16:22

@lentilsforever - you’re on a wind up aren’t you? Please tell me you are!

You cannot seriously be suggesting that my ultimate aim is to be signed off? This has actually made me laugh out loud. I particularly enjoyed the way you confidently told me how my colleagues and I behave whilst immediately prior to this you admitted that you have no experience of working in a local authority! 😂😂

Thanks for cheering me up! I love your sense of humour. Or at least I hope it’s your sense of humour and you’re not serious.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 12/11/2021 16:20

I can also believe your ‘Sarah’ trainee story.

Shellingbynight · 12/11/2021 16:17

@SmileSmiley

I don’t think people understand that this is literally my face. When my face is neutral I look ANGRY.

I mean I’m not going to do myself any favours here but I’m 6ft1, slightly overweight, my brow overhangs so I look like I’m frowning, my lips point downwards and my nostrils are naturally flared. To arrange my expression into anything other than this is actually hard work and I can only maintain it for a little while before my muscles in my face start to shake. I’m always very pleasant though. I have also adopted a quieter voice so I don’t sound intimidating because that’s not my aim. But literally throughout my life men (and it has never been a woman) have told me to smile and say it might never happen. I am fed up with feeling like I’m not good enough because I look like I do. 😩😢

I don't think you get these comments because of your looks/height or because men find you intimidating. This is really nothing to do with you, it's all to do with him.

I am 5'3, healthy weight, okay-looking, men would not have found me intimidating. But when I was younger I regularly got told "smile, it may never happen/ give us a smile love". This was generally from strangers (e.g in the street or in shops) and it was I assume because I did not glimpse their faces and break into a smile, because - why would I. It was their problem, not mine.

Dixiechickonhols · 12/11/2021 16:16

Sorry OP not calling you unprofessional at all just saying it can blur lines if client is colleague. From your initial posts it sounded like you were sat there - we were waiting for someone to join and I obviously didn’t keep a smile on my face. From your updates you’ve said you smiled, greeted him, asked how he was and he’s immediately made comment. In that case yes he sounds inappropriate. Is he a new client or has he been ok in past?
I’d speak to my line manager I think if I wasn’t happy in first instance.

SophieKaczynsky · 12/11/2021 16:14

It all boils down to men expecting women to be a fucking ornament. I'd report him if you can

BackBackBack · 12/11/2021 16:12

OP it's not you. There will always be people who compete to come up with the most doormat type suggestion of how you should prostrate yourself in order to do better next time. Back in the real world, you behaved perfectly professionally and were unlucky that Brian from Highways is a sexist twat.

MN can be really bonkers sometimes. There was a thread on here a few years back where the OP's husband was in Scouting (I think) and a rather over-invested woman who wouldn't take no for an answer, turned up on her doorstep. OP, understandably, was a bit pissed off that a complete stranger was hassling her. Cue a race to the bottom with posters competing with each other to be the most saintly - and the utterly batshit suggestion that she was being unkind and unsupportive by not having invited the woman in and offered her dinner.

AryaStarkWolf · 12/11/2021 16:12

[quote dropitlikeitsloth]This is hilarious!!

[/quote] Brilliant Grin

I love the first comment on it :

"When someone tells you to smile use both middle fingers to raise the corners of your lips into a "smile" while simultaneously flipping them off. "

DaisyNGO · 12/11/2021 16:09

Girlmom "Don't you just naturally smile when you greet someone?
I think I'd be a bit 'meh' if someone greeted me in a meeting and didn't smile because I'd assume they were in a crappy mood."

So "good morning" with no smile is rudeness, in your book?

I don't lnow what you mean by "bit meh".

Meetings are usually one of several, work stress is normally very high. I think men in particular often nod hello.

We've established this isn't a client to whom you might have to bow and scrape. It sounds like an internal meeting. If it's an external client, my professional smile, which .i deliberately keep small now, and and an offer of a handshake, and "how are you?" should suffice.

I'm off work at the mo, this thread has reminded me to buy a lottery ticket!

HundredMilesAnHour · 12/11/2021 16:07

So I'd sit at my desk and every so often, grin inanely and do jazz hands. She didn't mention it again.

Beamur · 12/11/2021 16:05

OP I can entirely believe both the 'smile' story and the Sarah one! My work overlaps this world too. Most of my older (and younger) male colleagues are great, but I have come across this behaviour more than once. I've had comments about my clothing and appreciative comments when items were accidentally more revealing than intended and 'cheer up love' etc. In the main it washes over me and I don't take offense but neither do I encourage or reward it. It's tiresome and really has no place at work any more.

HundredMilesAnHour · 12/11/2021 16:05

Is it sexism?? My boss once told me that I need to smile more at work (I wasn't client facing) because I "have presence" so it "worries people" if I look so serious. My boss was female, I'm female, so no sexism at play. Irritating but not sexism.