Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my 2.10 year old doesn't need to be in nursery

38 replies

SatisfyMySoul19 · 11/11/2021 20:16

Hi everyone
I'm a single mum of 2 lovely kids. My girl is 6y and my son is 2.10y .. I am in the fortunate position where my parents own their own business and I do some admin work for them when the children are in bed, so, work isn't an issue just now.
My daughter is in school and thriving there, all great .. My little boy has a speech and language delay (very common for the boys in our family) and possibly showing signs of ASD. He's absolutely fantastic and I love the bones of him. I've been working with him intensively at home and he's come along so, so much in the past few months. He is now able to point, imitate nursery rhyme actions, follow simple commands and is even starting to say a few words! I'm thrilled. I've basically been giving him lots of 1 on 1 time, lots of time outdoors as I believe it is very beneficial to little ones, s structured routine, involving him in things I do along with taking him to mum and tot groups and the park for social interaction.
However, my son is entitled to the 15 free hours for 2 year olds and I've felt pressure from all angles to enrol him because of his speech delay. He started this week and does seem to enjoy playing with the toys but doesn't seem overly happy there. They say he cries quite a lot and I'm struggling to understand what he's getting from it when he's making huge improvements with me at home and we socialise a lot. I would like to start him at 3.5, like I did with my daughter. In my eyes, 2.10 is still very young.
I'm getting lots of crap for wanting to pull him out, that he needs to be in a setting because of his speech, etc etc.
AIBU to want to follow my mother's instinct, pull my boy out for a year and continue with our little adventures and helping him progress?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SatisfyMySoul19 · 12/11/2021 13:45

Thanks everyone Smile I've read all the comments and taken views in to consideration but think the best thing at the moment is for my son to be at home with me. Xx

OP posts:
wheninroma · 12/11/2021 08:35

You know best mum! In terms of his speech and language development, he will be getting FAR more out of his individual time with you. There is a lot of background noise at nurseries which can be stressful and disorientating for them and impede speech development. When he’s with you, he knows he is being heard and you will be continually repeating and interpreting back to him all the words he is trying to formulate. This kind of focus is invaluable. A nursery teacher can’t do this as she doesn’t know him the way you do. Take him out of all the noise - plenty of time for that at school!

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 12/11/2021 08:17

My ds was dx with autism at 2.4 . He started nursery just before he turned 3 and socially it was a really good thing for him

LabStan · 12/11/2021 08:17

He needs to learn how to socialise, he has only had a week.
He will have loads if access to services and school may help push towards an assessment earlier.
In order to get an assessment you must have evidence from two areas, like school and home.
Give him a chance.
Mum to HF ASD and Severely Disabled Boy with Severe ASD....

Bonkerz · 12/11/2021 08:11

My dd went to playschool and screamed for weeks when she started school.
My DS stayed home with me. He was brilliant when starting school and at 10 is a clever and kind boy. Seriously if you don't want to send your child then don't!

TheWitchersWife · 12/11/2021 08:07

It's totally how you feel.
My DS is August born, I originally didn't want to send him to nursery as I was at home with his younger brother anyway and wanted to spend as much time with him as possible. His severe speech delay was flagged up at his 2 year developmental review with the health visitor, every professional he has saw since then from the paediatrician to the speech therapist all recommended he went to the school nursery to help with his speech.
I was trying really hard with him at home with reading, flash cards, interacting with him constantly and he was learning but was very slow.
He started nursery at 3 years and 1 month old and has thrived continuously since then.
I didnt think he could progress as fast as he did since he's started.
The nursery also helped him get his EHCP so that now he's in reception he has the help he needs to continue his learning. They also speak to his paediatrician in order to keep them informed of his progress and his delays and is helping with a possible diagnosis.
My son hasn't had any trouble being upset or leaving me which does make the situation different. I will say in the end I sent DS to nursery because I thought it would be what was best for him rather than what was best for me.

MsAnnFrope · 12/11/2021 08:00

A high quality setting will benefit most children and a week isn’t very long to decide. But equally he isn’t likely to be harmed by waiting until he is preschool age as he has such a supportive mum.
I’m sure you have looked into it already but the SLC charity ICAN has some great parent led resources to support his speech.

Caterinasballerinas · 12/11/2021 07:55

I also wonder if some of the pressure to send him to nursery for those hours is to ensure you get a break? You don’t sound like you need it to be honest there is a lovely enthusiasm from your post about your days. However to me your days sound like my days off work and I do enjoy that I get a balance of time at home with my 2yo and at work. Is there something you could do for you during this time?

Wilkolampshade · 12/11/2021 07:42

No of course he doesn't need to be there. You're an experienced mum with the perspective gained by already having an older child and doing all the right things with him 1-1. The gains made at nursery at this age generally apply to kids who aren't getting quite so much from home for whatever reason. And anyway, I have no doubt he'd catch up.
However, I do agree a week isn't likely to be long enough to settle a child. But in this case, there probably is no need for the disruption at all.

MeanderingGently · 12/11/2021 07:16

They are little for such a short time and you sound like a very supportive mum. Take him out of nursery and follow your instincts.
I never sent either of mine at all, and they had no trouble settling anywhere when they were older, we socialised loads and they were perfectly at home in all sorts of settings.

Smartiesandhugs · 12/11/2021 07:05

One thing that stood out to me is that he has only been there a week. This is totally normal for the first week settling in so don’t let that be your guide to take him out.
A SALT would suggest nursery to support a speech delay and IMO it’s a good thing to have a social toddler who can be independent from you at nursery. 15 hours really isn’t much.
I have an almost 3 year old who has benefitted so much from being in nursery, she has picked up so much there and loves being with other children. Maybe it’s not for everyone but I don’t think you have given it enough time to really see the benefits

mayblossominapril · 12/11/2021 06:32

I sent my ds who couldn’t talk at 2 to preschool (where I am the Preschool’s all take from 2 and only work school hours during term time) a few mornings a week. It really helped but they had high staff ratios, were attached to a primary school with all the support that brings. There was no way I would have sent him to a private nursery. So if you have got an amazing preschool or school nursery I would take him out of nursery.

fluffythedragonslayer · 12/11/2021 06:25

I don't think he needs to be in nursery to help his speech delay / ASD but there are other professionals that he might need access to when you are thinking about school starting etc. You can do all these referrals yourself - speech and language, paediatrician if you choose to assess for ASD etc. A nursery SENCO can help with this but are by no means essential. You can also contact your local children's centre for support if you have one.

TuftyMarmoset · 11/11/2021 22:49

2.10? That’s not how decimals work.

It sounds like pulling him out is the right thing to do though.

Mossstitch · 11/11/2021 22:43

Therapist here with some paediatric experience, pull him out I'd say. He's getting great 1-1 communication with you, he cannot be getting that in a nursery setting. His communication/learning will develop much better with you. I pulled one of mine out from playgroup at 2 as he hated it and just wanted to stay with me but settled fine at 3.5 at preschool attached to the primary school.

Tumbleweed101 · 11/11/2021 22:32

Nursery can give you support if you think you may need to access SALT and specialist provision for schooling if his ASD will need support later. However, you can also get this support by making the necessary referrals independently if you know how - it sounds like you are aware of his needs and how to get help if you feel it necessary.

A week most certainly isn't long enough to judge how he will get on at nursery though and children attending a nursery will make friends and learn many good social skills by interacting with other children and adults. However, I personally feel that they get the most benefit from nursery once they are 3 - 3 1/2 yo if they don't need to attend for childcare reasons so it is unnecessary to push him earlier than you feel happy with.

Abracadabra12345 · 11/11/2021 22:10

@SatisfyMySoul19

Thanks everyone. I will be pulling my son out. When he is big and grown, I will never regret this time spent with him at home. X
Crossed with your update. Good for you
Abracadabra12345 · 11/11/2021 22:08

@Sorberret

Children learn best 1 to 1 and his speech won't improve any better in a nursery setting. You sound like you are doing an excellent job with him.
I agree. Is he at a day nursery? They are busy, noisy places and I am certain he won’t be getting the intensive, fun and natural interaction and teaching that you’re giving him. In a few months’ time his speech and development will have increased and he’ll be ready for the next stage and the social setting of nursery will help.

But improving speech in the noisiness of nursery compared to what you’re doing? Nah. You’re doing brilliantly. Stick to your guns

SatisfyMySoul19 · 11/11/2021 22:07

Thanks everyone. I will be pulling my son out. When he is big and grown, I will never regret this time spent with him at home. X

OP posts:
GoodnightGrandma · 11/11/2021 21:43

My DS went to nursery and didn’t settle because there was no where to nap from age 2 onwards, he napped until just before starting school, and he didn’t want a hot meal at lunch.
So I’d pick him up and he’d be knackered and starving.
So I pulled him out.

TAKESNOSHITSHIRLEY · 11/11/2021 21:38

defiantly stand your ground.

todays society of chucking them in an education setting at 2 and 3 just because you "have to" its stupid and a sheep attitude.

trouble is society has been conditioned to think they need to be doing this, same with school.

99% of people ive come across since 2015 (when i started home ed)dont know that there is another legal option out there and no school isnt the be all and end all. same with nurseries at 2.

if the parent wants them at home or the child cant cope with nursery or school at any age that person should do whats best for the child

bugger anyone's unwanted opinions

at this age the child should be at home anyway

i home educate a 11 y old with disabilities(mentally 5/6)and the amount of nosiness and unwanted opinions you get from strangers is daily.

i have a dont fuck with me look and use it. if that dont work they get a and its your business because?

Doona · 11/11/2021 21:08

I don't know where people get the idea that preschool is necessary for kids' learning. That finding has been only shown for highly disadvantaged kids and high quality preschools given at no cost to the family. For everyone else there's no evidence of difference in learning overall. So of course do what feels right for your family.

Hockeyboysmum · 11/11/2021 21:05

Yanbu. Your child you know them best. My 19 month old has been given 2 mornings a week of nursery. Was originally afternoons but he settles better in morning. He initially loved it then hated for a couple of weeks and is now settling again. I was going to take him out as im not working but when i saw photos of how happy he was initially i vhose to persevere. The reason he goes is he has various additonal needs and disabilities. He has a one to one at nursery who is great. From a selfish point of view i really need the 6 hrs a week he is away to try and recharge my batteries or do stuff with my 12 year old. I am a single parent so no one else to help or take him. If at any point i feel he is genuinely not liking it not getting anything from the experience i will 100% remove him.

Dozer · 11/11/2021 21:02

YANBU.

Who is giving you their unsolicited opinions on this?

RowanAlong · 11/11/2021 21:00

Absolutely follow your instincts. You’re not answerable to anyone else on here, or in real life.