Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was the primary teacher unreasonable?

90 replies

Bananarama21 · 11/11/2021 20:10

So I'm a school swimming teacher and been covering the mornings aswell as working the afternoon school swimming and learn 2 swim. Ds5 reading book day changed from Friday to Thursday. I forgot his bag and utilmately he was not giving a treat and watched as all the kids recieved one due to this. DS burst into tears, he's on the spectrum and can have a melt down. Previously he struggled with lockdowns and ended up going back in. When he returned to school it was a struggle to actually get him into the building and was a felt often having a melt down. The teacher explained the reason for no treat to my auntie. I work closely with primary schools and teach many children with various learning disabilities and would never conduct myself in that way especially 5 years old. I feel this might be a set back for him as he has started being reluctant going into school. Teacher is aware of his history.

OP posts:
Platax · 11/11/2021 22:57

@FreshFancyFrogglette

Hmm. I would be upset, but we all take things to do with our kids very personally. To me it depends on the circumstances.

If the it were something like this: teacher states beforehand " for everyone who brings back their reading book on Thursday, there will be a treat". Then yabu, as to change the rules would be unfair on those who followed the instruction.

However, if it was more like this: on the Thursday teacher states "well done to everyone who brought your books back, I have a treat for you " then yanbu. As she hadnt set the rule beforehand, and could have realistically adapted to include your dc, w/o making it unfair on the others.

There's a big difference. Either way, I don't blame your son for being upset, it must have been hard to be left out.

No - because any teacher should be aware that at this age it will be down to the parents. Teachers should also be aware of the need to make adjustments for children whose learning difficulties may mean they can’t process or remember instructions or who may have organisational difficulties.
Platax · 11/11/2021 22:53

@RedHelenB

The childcare being punished, he just wasn't being rewarded.
Being deprived of a treat that the child sees everyone else getting is a punishment
LeicesterIntheMorning · 11/11/2021 22:39

Horrible and cruel

supremelybaffled · 11/11/2021 22:37

@Russell19

Bet you won't forget again.

It's very harsh but done its job.

A 5-year-old autistic child gets punished for something that wasn't his fault, and you think that's fair and reasonable of the teacher?
Dutchesss · 11/11/2021 22:29

I'm so sad for him. To watch all his classmates get sweets and him be singled out for something that's out of his control. It's not right, and an awful way to treat children.

FreshFancyFrogglette · 11/11/2021 22:29

Hmm. I would be upset, but we all take things to do with our kids very personally. To me it depends on the circumstances.

If the it were something like this: teacher states beforehand " for everyone who brings back their reading book on Thursday, there will be a treat". Then yabu, as to change the rules would be unfair on those who followed the instruction.

However, if it was more like this: on the Thursday teacher states "well done to everyone who brought your books back, I have a treat for you " then yanbu. As she hadnt set the rule beforehand, and could have realistically adapted to include your dc, w/o making it unfair on the others.

There's a big difference. Either way, I don't blame your son for being upset, it must have been hard to be left out.

BangaloreLulu · 11/11/2021 22:21

What a shitty way to behave! So, they're basically rewarding the child for something the parent has remembered to do - how many 5 year olds would have remembered their book without prompting, FFS? All they've done is upset a 5 year old because of an innocent mistake made by his mother, which is compounded by them knowing he's on the spectrum. Totally unacceptable!

Cocomarine · 11/11/2021 22:17

@HunterHearstHelmsley

YANBU but this is Mumsnet and you cannot criticise a teacher at all.
Oh not this twaddle again 🙄 So how comes 77% of the vote is with the OP? And the majority of the comments.
MadeOfStarStuff · 11/11/2021 22:16

YANBU

Even aside from SEN, 5 year olds aren’t in charge of whether they have everything they need for school, it’s not their fault if a parent forgets something

HunterHearstHelmsley · 11/11/2021 22:13

YANBU but this is Mumsnet and you cannot criticise a teacher at all.

BadlydoneHelen · 11/11/2021 22:09

To the person who asked why have a book change day: because to change a class of 30 children's books takes an hour and maybe they only have a spare pair of hands to do the job once a week?

cansu · 11/11/2021 22:02

It isn't great. At that age the person doing the remembering is the adult at home! I teach upper primary and am very aware of stuff like this. She should have been able to get round this. E.g. Oh dear mummy forgot but she will definitely bring it in tomorrow. Let's go and get your treat for tomorrow.

fruitbrewhaha · 11/11/2021 21:59

Stupid bloody school, why do they have a book change day? Take a book, read it, bring back when done. Otherwise if you read quickly you have a wait all week for a new book. And if you're very slow you don't finish it.

I think I'd complain more about that really.

Bethany7 · 11/11/2021 21:57

That is so cruel and unhelpful and wrong in so many ways. I am a teacher, I am genuinely shocked to hear this.

BoredZelda · 11/11/2021 21:54

Yep. I’d be willing to be “that parent” on this one.

In ni world is it ok to punish the child for the failings of a parent. (And I use “failings” in a very light way)

RentalsDrivingMeMental · 11/11/2021 21:54

First thing to do is talk to the teacher and ask her to clarify the system (I'm guessing at the mo it's your DS that's told you what happened today?).

Once that's been clarified, you can then complain, but I'd give the teacher the chance to explain it first.

Bananarama21 · 11/11/2021 21:46

Thanks guys you've confirmed my thoughts. She is known to be a strict teacher and gives piles of homework for years 1 its crazy it's trying to remembereverything for certain days for each child. I think she's been qualified afor afew years maybe 5.

OP posts:
Notashandyta · 11/11/2021 21:40

I was a pretty tough year 6 teacher and this would be a step too far even at ten!

5 years old? Totally unreasonable and horrible

StormyTeacups · 11/11/2021 21:40

Yeah, that's shit. At his age he has no control over it, it is down to parents. No school I have worked in would ever do this to a 5 yr old.

MrsMo21 · 11/11/2021 21:40

*have a quiet word with them.

You catch my drift. Small baby sleep deprivation leads to brain mush.

MrsMo21 · 11/11/2021 21:39

I’m a teacher and I’d say that using sweets as a reward system for anything (especially things out of their control) is pretty poor.
Is the teacher an NQT? If so, I understand the error in their practice being down to inexperience and a quiet word with them. If they’re experienced I’d say that’s a chat with the head.

Timetoretiretospain · 11/11/2021 21:38

I’m a primary teacher and I think leaving a child of 5 out of a treat for something they have no control over is a punishment. Even if he wasn’t autistic . Please complain to HT this is not ok .

RockallMalinHebrides · 11/11/2021 21:37

@Russell19

Bet you won't forget again.

It's very harsh but done its job.

Are you always so lacking in empathy? He's 5 with additional needs.
Theunamedcat · 11/11/2021 21:36

are you even allowed to take the book bag in late? my son left his pe kit at home i offered to take it in they said no i said well at least you cant punish him they said they could i said no because he has arranged to get his kit in time for the lesson you are refusing to allow me to give it to him therefore its your fault he has no pe kit they tried saying it was because of "covid" i pointed out that he lived in my house the kit would be coming from my house him meeting me at the school gate to grab his kit posed the same risk of covid as him bringing it to school in the first place i would not be on school property he would not be leaving school property therefore no extra risk i wasn't allowed to drop it off but he wasn't punished for no kit either as it was "out of character" for him to forget

julieca · 11/11/2021 21:34

My initial reaction is for a 5-year-old this is out of order. Even a little treat like a sticker means a lot at that age.
But in the secret life programmes they did give out prizes to some young kids and not others. But they used it as a learning opportunity for the kids and it did work.
However that hasn't happened with your DS. It has made him not want to go to school so it hasn't helped him at all.