Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No 2 minutes silence at gym. AIBU

543 replies

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 11/11/2021 17:52

I went to my gym today for a class in the swimming pool. I had totally expected the class to finish just before 11am so that those who wanted to could observe the two minutes silence. By 10.55am it was apparent that this was not going to happen so I just took myself out of the pool and sat in the changing room by myself.
So as to not drip feed, I am from a Forces Family and the wrong side of 50! I found this totally disrespectful of the instructor. He could have, at the very least, mentioned that he had intended to not stop before the class. AIBU to be upset by this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
KingDangerMouse · 12/11/2021 00:55

Platax - you have completely missed the point. To be a collective honour to those who sacrificed their lives to give us our lives, the impact is to remember the fallen, together, at a single point in time. However, thank you, for your response and to the OP for highlighting how many posters on here are so unaware of what our previous generation sacrificed for us. I urge you all to read this book which will give you insight: A Life in Secrets by Sarah Helm. Changed my life, hope it changes yours.

Aimee1987 · 12/11/2021 00:52

@KingDangerMouse

Agree. I’m in my 40’s. Took it upon myself to learn about WWI and II + other wars/battles. Not taught at school. The devastation for the generation of WWI/II is unimaginable to many today. 2 minutes silence, such a simple, honourable sign of respect to those who lost their lives to save ours. For those of you responding to this thread who think the op is unreasonable, read this book: A Life in Secrets by Sarah Helm. Changed my world and outlook - for the better.
But how does 2 minutes silence honour the dead? This is the point being made over and over with no answer? Surely there are better ways. Also this thread shows there is alot of misinformation around today. It was and still is a memory of the end of world war 1. A war which had nothing to do with the freedom or democracy. It was a political match off between the royal famlies of Europe in which they used their civilian population as cannon fodder. A dispicable thing of them to do. Somone mentioned black history month up thread and that is actually a good idea mabey we should have a remembrance month or week. At my uni we used black history month as a talking platform for discrimination in science and what's wrong with white Male science. It was interesting, perhaps an armistice week in which we focus on the atrocities and more specifically on what caused them and how the aftermath lead to ww2. That way we can actually learn from our mistakes rather then spending 2 minutes a year looking mournful while judging others for not being mournful enough.
Batshaver · 12/11/2021 00:51

Whose lives were saved by WWI? Genuine question as none immediately spring to mind.

KingDangerMouse · 12/11/2021 00:38

Agree. I’m in my 40’s. Took it upon myself to learn about WWI and II + other wars/battles. Not taught at school. The devastation for the generation of WWI/II is unimaginable to many today. 2 minutes silence, such a simple, honourable sign of respect to those who lost their lives to save ours. For those of you responding to this thread who think the op is unreasonable, read this book: A Life in Secrets by Sarah Helm. Changed my world and outlook - for the better.

Almostmenopausal · 12/11/2021 00:32

@Cosmois

We never observe the silence or wear poppies. I don't really see the point tbh. Seems like a weird, old fashioned thing. I don't know anyone that observes it, I was a long time ago and the world has moved on now. There have been many conflicts over the years and eventually after a few generations people stop caring and move on. I think most of us feel like that about WW1 and WW2 now? Obviously if you want to keep up that tradition then that is good for you, but it isn't compulsory and a personal choice. Surely you don't expect people to observe this 2 minute silence until the end of time now?
😧

Wow. Here is a fine example of exactly what is wrong with society.

Disgraceful attitude

Almostmenopausal · 12/11/2021 00:26

@Lemonsyellow I suspect quite a few people don’t know what armistice actually means.

This. It's heartbreaking

AudacityBaby · 12/11/2021 00:00

@mustlovegin

Clearly there is a period after which such major events are lost from the collective memory. Right now we're in a transition period, where pretty much everyone who experienced them has died, but their children and grandchildren live on

So because hardly anyone currently alive have experienced these events we should just forget about them? Ridiculous

Not forget, but commemoration does change over time. We don’t commemorate the millions who died in the Napoleonic Wars anymore, but presumably there were ways in which this was done in the period of history following. There is a transition period, though given the absolutely massive death toll in WW1 and WW2 I’d expect the commemoration to live on for some time yet, and rightly so.
Lemonsyellow · 11/11/2021 23:46

@HesterShaw1

Surely the clue is in the name? "Armistice Day" is to remember the Armistice in 1918. There was no Armistice in 1945, because Nazi Germany then Japan unconditionally surrendered.
I suspect quite a few people don’t know what armistice actually means.
WingingItSince1973 · 11/11/2021 23:42

Wow you have that much respect for all those that have died during conflicts and are from a military family that you thought the best way to show your respect was to squeeze some thoughts into 2 minutes at the end of a swimming session. Sounds so dignified and respectful!

HesterShaw1 · 11/11/2021 23:42

Surely the clue is in the name? "Armistice Day" is to remember the Armistice in 1918. There was no Armistice in 1945, because Nazi Germany then Japan unconditionally surrendered.

midsomermurderess · 11/11/2021 23:36

'So because hardly anyone currently alive have experienced these events we should just forget about them? Ridiculous'
That is a curious conclusion to have reached.

terrywynne · 11/11/2021 23:36

I don't remember that bit of the History Boys but that resonates hugely. As a teenager I bought multiple poppies every year as if to prove how much I cared- I just care after all because I bought a poppy every time I saw a seller. And sure the British Legion got my money but did it really prove I cared? Did I reflect on military sacrifice the rest of the year? Or donate to charity at other times? Or take action against war? Not really. But I had shown I cared in November and apparently that was what was required of me.

(I have since grown up, matured, and studied history so my thoughts and actions have evolved somewhat)

Fossie · 11/11/2021 23:34

@FangsForTheMemory

If you're the wrong side of 50, you'll remember that nobody in this country used to observe two minutes' silence except those attending Armistice Day ceremonies. It should be a personal thing.
Not at all. I remember people stopping in supermarkets and even in the street.
mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 23:30

Clearly there is a period after which such major events are lost from the collective memory. Right now we're in a transition period, where pretty much everyone who experienced them has died, but their children and grandchildren live on

So because hardly anyone currently alive have experienced these events we should just forget about them? Ridiculous

Batshaver · 11/11/2021 23:30

People conflate all sorts of things with Armistice Day (the date of which itself was a stunt, so there's been politicking around it from the start) largely because it's been conflated with numerous things by various public figures over the years. Now it's got to the point where it "means": - homeless veterans, justification for invading Iraq, justification for invading Afghanistan, rewriting WWII as a British triumph, rewriting WWII in general, Churchill as hero, our brave boys, innocent boys and wicked generals, Queen and country, Billie Piper in a Union Jack t-shirt, don't tell im Pike, etc etc etc. Like others your age I definitely remember when this wasn't the case and we didn't mark it much at all outside of a small ceremony on the Sunday after.

Anyway OP yanbu. I was also at a swimming lesson and we all felt so fervently about all of the above, and more, that we stopped all movement including breathing and sank to the bottom of the pool. Fortunately I am able to hold my breath for a long time and am also v patriotic so I survived.

SarahAndQuack · 11/11/2021 23:27

@AudacityBaby

There’s a fantastic bit in The History Boys where the teacher challenges the concept of silences and performative behaviour by suggesting it’s a way to forget, rather than remember. A way to consign the thinking, reflecting, grieving and learning to one short bite sized piece of time, rather than to apply it to modern life, to question whether we should be voting for our chosen party, or we’d better serve in honouring our ancestors in a different way.

I’ve thought about that a lot. I don’t wear a poppy, and whilst I’ll participate in a silence if it’s happening around me, I choose to remember in a different way. I bunked off school to protest the Iraq War, and that felt far more meaningful to me that year than the 2 minute silence did.

YABU, OP. Not performing in the exact way that you do doesn’t mean that a person is a self-obsessed snowflake that has no respect and doesn’t know when WW1 and WW2 were.

(And most people in the country are from forces families - my great-grandfather in WW1 and my grandfathers in WW2).

That influenced me too!
AudacityBaby · 11/11/2021 23:25

There’s a fantastic bit in The History Boys where the teacher challenges the concept of silences and performative behaviour by suggesting it’s a way to forget, rather than remember. A way to consign the thinking, reflecting, grieving and learning to one short bite sized piece of time, rather than to apply it to modern life, to question whether we should be voting for our chosen party, or we’d better serve in honouring our ancestors in a different way.

I’ve thought about that a lot. I don’t wear a poppy, and whilst I’ll participate in a silence if it’s happening around me, I choose to remember in a different way. I bunked off school to protest the Iraq War, and that felt far more meaningful to me that year than the 2 minute silence did.

YABU, OP. Not performing in the exact way that you do doesn’t mean that a person is a self-obsessed snowflake that has no respect and doesn’t know when WW1 and WW2 were.

(And most people in the country are from forces families - my great-grandfather in WW1 and my grandfathers in WW2).

Chelyanne · 11/11/2021 23:23

I was in the gym... I set an alarm for shortly before the silence, paused my workout and music for the 2 minutes. We are a forces family.

Lavender24 · 11/11/2021 23:20

@WheelieBinPrincess

I actually hate enforced silences, I never think about the thing I’m supposed to be thinking about. When we did at school I’m afraid I was more than likely thinking about what was in my lunchbox. When I was older i was probably thinking about if I should open the wine tonight even though it’s only Wednesday or if I turned my hot brush off.

That does NOT mean I don’t care about fallen soldiers or think about them in lots of other ways. I just think when someone says ‘now think about this thing’ it’s quite hard to do.

I have no problem being quiet during it though.

Exactly this. Throughout this day I have thought about it in my own time and in my own way but during enforced silences I end up just thinking about random stuff. Horrendous things happen in this country and all over the world all the time. We can't have enforced silences for everything.
mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 23:20

They fought and died for our freedom to do what we want, including not being silent at certain times just because others say we should

Mental gymnastics at its finest

SickAndTiredAgain · 11/11/2021 23:17

Yeah, I totally get why not everyone associates Armistice Day with the first world war specifically, and why it gets jumbled with Remembrance Sunday. Similar names, similar dates, lack of clarity in the media...

I agree they get treated like the same thing. Like the 11th is the actual day, but Remembrance Sunday is the “official” marking of it.
Like having a birthday on a Thursday but celebrating at the weekend, if you see what I mean. Rather than two distinct things.

80sMum · 11/11/2021 23:15

When I was a child and young adult, Armistice Day was barely even acknowledged by the public at large.
The two minutes silence and all the remembrance activities were all on Remembrance Sunday.

I'm trying to think back to when things began to change and 11th November started to become the focus. I'm guessing it would have been about 20-30 years ago.

terrywynne · 11/11/2021 23:09

@MeredithGreyishblue

BBC news at 10 just said Armistice Day was to remember both world wars. Annoying. No wonder people get into rows
Yeah, I totally get why not everyone associates Armistice Day with the first world war specifically, and why it gets jumbled with Remembrance Sunday. Similar names, similar dates, lack of clarity in the media...
MeredithGreyishblue · 11/11/2021 23:06

BBC news at 10 just said Armistice Day was to remember both world wars. Annoying. No wonder people get into rows

terrywynne · 11/11/2021 23:02

Armistice Day is perhaps better thought of as being like VE Day. It has always been formally marked to a certain extent (even after Remembrance Sunday was agreed on as the national day of Remembrance for the world wars) but for many people, Remembrance Sunday is their main day of remembrance.

It gets a bit confused by the fact that 11th of November is sometimes a Sunday thus making the two days the same, by the similarity of names. And, I suspect, by the fact that there was recently an increase emphasis on armistice day due to the 100th anniversary of the end of the first world war in 2018.

Swipe left for the next trending thread