Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No 2 minutes silence at gym. AIBU

543 replies

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 11/11/2021 17:52

I went to my gym today for a class in the swimming pool. I had totally expected the class to finish just before 11am so that those who wanted to could observe the two minutes silence. By 10.55am it was apparent that this was not going to happen so I just took myself out of the pool and sat in the changing room by myself.
So as to not drip feed, I am from a Forces Family and the wrong side of 50! I found this totally disrespectful of the instructor. He could have, at the very least, mentioned that he had intended to not stop before the class. AIBU to be upset by this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Lemonsyellow · 12/11/2021 08:36

Admittedly I’ve not been out much recently, but I’ve not even seen anywhere selling poppies.

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 08:34

@mustlovegin

Sombre reflection is possible at any time

Do you do this often? When?

On armistice day I usually mark it by playing Green Fields of France (which is a song of remembrance), followed by some silent reflection on my own. I work during the day, so it's usually at home in the evening that I do it. Like I said, I mark the day.

11am on the 11th is one time to show respect, but it's not the only time. If 11am really matters to you, you won't be swimming at 11am.

At 11am, train drivers don't suddenly stop their moving trains, pilots don't take their hand off the controls, surgeons don't pause operations, nurses don't stop providing care etc.etc. Claiming that this is disrespectful of them is nothing short of ridiculous.

MeredithGreyishblue · 12/11/2021 08:34

Definite conflating of the 2 days. But when the BBC & othe media do it too, it's not hard to see why.

The more recent resurrection of 2 mins on Armistice is, I think, in response to more recent conflicts (Iraq) and to incite waves of patriotism.

My grandparents married on Armistice Day back in the days post the Second World War when it really was recent.

Cosmois · 12/11/2021 08:31

When can we stop? 200 years after? 300 years after? Obviously at some point people will stop. For some of us that is now. It will faze our over time. That is just a fact. My children have no idea about it, I don't think it is something they do at school? They have never mentioned it and noone at their school seems to wear a poppy? I think it is presumed people will mark it on the Sunday if they want to.

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 08:28

@BettyBag

I agree with others regarded forced 2 minute silences. I hate it, its so performative and disingenuous. I used to think 2 minutes silence to reflect on lives lost was a nice a simple way to remember terrible events. As soon as you take the choice away it becomes pointless for me.

3 and 4 year old doing it and this being seen as a positive is bizarre. They are simply being trained. They have no concept of the permenence of death or the horror of war. Its utterly meaningless.

Equally I am baffled at the growing trend of "decorating" for Rememberence Day. Are these tatty huge poppies stuck to lampposts supposed to be meaningful? These shops that do displays like its Halloween? It's just rubbish the same as Christmas decs. Cheaply made tat that will be thrown away.

I'm not even sure what we are supposed to be remembering anymore. The general theme still seems to be focused on WW1 and 2. Presumably because nobody has strong opinions on WW1 anymore and WW2 is the one were we were definitely the good guys. A lot of those men and women have been dead longer than living memory. Which isn't to say their lives weren't important but we don't remember the Napleonic wars do we? At what point do we move on? Currently it just seems to be getting more emphasis not less.

What about the poor young lads who got sent over to be killed and maimed in the desert based on lies and greed? Well its hard putting them front and centre isn't it? Nobody wants awkward discussions about the fact that the people responsible for sending those lads were they should never have been are still walking round unaccountable and making millions with their influence. No, we can't talk about the morality of war, that would challenge the recent (because as many if this thread has pointed out it is recent) narrative that all soldiers are hero's and any questions you have about the morality of war and the horror of what we tell these (often working class) lads to do are belittling their heroism and thus socially unacceptable. The narrative has to be simple, join the forces and you are a hero. Nobody will question this except for hippies and traitors. Now come on boys, sign up today!

Just shut up and be silent. Remembering is enough and sticking tacky red flowers up in your window is enough, it doesn't matter if they are from the RBL or not its the performance thought that counts.

This expresses everything I feel about it.
UpThePodge · 12/11/2021 08:28

I only remember because I worked in a town at the time @MeridthGreyishblue . I didn't work at the weekends , everything stopped

Lemonsyellow · 12/11/2021 08:23

@lollipoprainbow

Yes you can remember at any time but surely it's more poignant to observe the silence at 11am on the 11th day of 11th month (in case people have forgotten when that is) I don't know why suddenly everyone is saying the 2 min silence is only on Remembrance Sunday.
It’s not “suddenly”. The 2-min silence on 11/11 was dropped in 1938. It somehow, due to political grandstanding and other reasons, has now got reestablished in the last couple of decades. What are you actually reflecting upon at 11am on 11/11? Judging from this thread, several don’t seem to know.
MeredithGreyishblue · 12/11/2021 08:18

I don't ever remember cars stopping on Armistice Day. I think we look back and learn memories sometimes. I do think people are conflating Armistice & Remembrance Sunday. Although cars certainly haven't stopped in any number on the latter in my memory either.

Its a personal thing. Not everyone will be at a cenotaph on Sunday but I'm not going to get angry about it. They do what they can or feel they want to.

Branding people "disgusting" or that they ought to be ashamed is as silly as the hurtling upstairs
to display the ceramic poppy stuff. Performance and lack of critical thinking / empathy for how others see things.

We're not very good with people who don't do things the way we do.

Lemonsyellow · 12/11/2021 08:16

Surprising that some posters are mentioning that we “won the war”. Armistice Day marks the truce, where both sides agreed not to fight. We didn’t win.

Platax · 12/11/2021 08:16

@mustlovegin, people who want to observe two minutes’ silence are obviously perfectly free to do so. The problem arises when they start claiming that this makes them morally superior and start excoriating others for wanting to show respect in different ways.

Colouringaddict · 12/11/2021 08:13

[quote WhenISnappedAndFarted]@Colouringaddict It was HMS Barham[/quote]
I will have to go through his paperwork to find out. He passed in 1985, never talked about it, apart from telling us limp and drooped eye were from his torpedoed ship

mustlovegin · 12/11/2021 08:13

Trust me I know , since my country was basically "gifted" to the USSR

What traditions and rituals do you have in your country? Do you observe and respect them?

Lockheart · 12/11/2021 08:13

@mustlovegin

Sombre reflection is possible at any time

Do you do this often? When?

Many of us do, yes. Just because most people do their artificially prescribed two minutes and that's them done for the year doesn't mean everyone does.
mustlovegin · 12/11/2021 08:11

Sombre reflection is possible at any time

Do you do this often? When?

lollipoprainbow · 12/11/2021 08:11

Yes you can remember at any time but surely it's more poignant to observe the silence at 11am on the 11th day of 11th month (in case people have forgotten when that is) I don't know why suddenly everyone is saying the 2 min silence is only on Remembrance Sunday.

mustlovegin · 12/11/2021 08:10

A programme of events across a broad spectrum, where people of all ages can actively engage, learn things, think about it and link it back to what it means now, how its relevant today. This is a far more engaging way than everyone buying a flower once a year and standing still for 2 minutes

Posters suggesting this probably mean well. But the majority may nonetheless want to continue with the tradition of the 2 minutes silence. Why do some find traditions so difficult and have a constant need to eradicate them?

Also, they way the 'alternative' activities are described seem like a good opportunity to hijack the moment in order to proselytise. Organise all of this if you like, but leave the 2 minutes silence alone.

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 08:08

Yes, that poster is making things up.

Armistice day is important to me, so I mark it. But I wouldn't go to a fucking gym class at 11am and complain that they didn't interrupt it for the silence. If you really care about doing the silence at 11am, make sure you are somewhere quiet.

Also, the two minutes silence at 11am is not the only way to mark the day. Sombre reflection is possible at any time.

butterpuffed · 12/11/2021 08:08

So many on MN argue just for the sake of it and it never matters what the subject matter is. One starts and the rest just pile on like sheep. Real life isn't like this.

lazylinguist · 12/11/2021 07:56

I'm very saddened to read so many posts on here from people who don't value the lives lost in conflict

Stop making things up. Literally nobody on this thread has given any indication that they don't value the lives lost. Do you mean these people don't show in exactly the way you think they should at exactly the time you think they should the fact that they value the lives lost? Because that's really not the same thing.

closedown · 12/11/2021 07:52

None of the disgusted angry people have addressed the fact that people are obviously going to commemorate these events less as time goes on. That's just a fact. At some point, it happens.

I'm curious at what point they think it will be more acceptable? Or if we will go through a phase of some people being disgusted and angry about it whether it happens now, in 20 years or a century from now. I suppose it's inevitable.

UpThePodge · 12/11/2021 07:48

My point being @JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil that some poor poster has been pulled up as a liar

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 12/11/2021 07:47

Some people seem to think that the only worthy actions are the ones that can be seen.

closedown · 12/11/2021 07:44

@mustlovegin

They fought and died for our freedom to do what we want, including not being silent at certain times just because others say we should

Mental gymnastics at its finest

If you need to do mental gymnastics to figure that one out, that says more about you than anyone else tbh. It's pretty straightforward. Nobody who fought or gave their lives for our freedom would be happy about people saying DISGRACEFUL, YOU SHOULD BE ASHAMED OF YOURSELF for not stopping work at a specific time to remember them 100 years later.
JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 12/11/2021 07:42

‘Not sure who you are quoting but cars did stop
It was the norm for people to just stop where they were and observe the silence, supermarket, office, pavements it didn't matter’.

That was on the Remembrance Sunday not the newer 2 minutes silence on 11 November.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 12/11/2021 07:40

I'm very saddened to read so many posts on here from people who don't value the lives lost in conflict, and who aren't prepared to reflect for two minutes as a respectful gesture of remembrance

Can you point me to the posts from people who don't value lives lost in conflict?