Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No 2 minutes silence at gym. AIBU

543 replies

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 11/11/2021 17:52

I went to my gym today for a class in the swimming pool. I had totally expected the class to finish just before 11am so that those who wanted to could observe the two minutes silence. By 10.55am it was apparent that this was not going to happen so I just took myself out of the pool and sat in the changing room by myself.
So as to not drip feed, I am from a Forces Family and the wrong side of 50! I found this totally disrespectful of the instructor. He could have, at the very least, mentioned that he had intended to not stop before the class. AIBU to be upset by this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Lemonsyellow · 12/11/2021 09:19

No-one in their right mind should feel patriotic about Armistice Day. There is nothing to feel patriotic about. Lots of people died. Lots of people in power caused those deaths. And “we” didn’t even win. It was a shameful affair. Yes, remember those who died, but there should be no patriotism, only shame. WW2 is different. We were trying to defeat an evil regime, and we were ultimately on the winning side. There’s a place for some patriotism there, if you wish.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 12/11/2021 09:14

A few don't feel patriotic about this country or the people who currently live around them, but that's their problem to deal with, I guess. They shouldn't expect to dictate what we do or what our traditions or rituals should look like

There is a centuries-long and very fine tradition in this country of being sceptical about performative acts of patriotism, flag-waving etc. It's a very important protector of our democracy: it means we are less susceptible to fascist ideologies, which prey on cheap patriotic tropes and uncritical admiration of the military. Long may it continue.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 12/11/2021 09:10

@Lemonsyellow

Surprising that some posters are mentioning that we “won the war”. Armistice Day marks the truce, where both sides agreed not to fight. We didn’t win.
That is not correct. You are right that 11/11/1918 was an agreement to stop fighting, not a formal surrender by Germany, but the formal surrender came with the Treaty of Versailles and subsequent treaties, culminating with the Treaty of Lausanne.

Germany formally surrender in May 1945 (either on the 7th or 9th, depending on which you consider to be the official act of surrender). The surrender of Japan was formalised on 2 Sept 1945.

Lemonsyellow · 12/11/2021 09:09

Much more recent than Children in Need, for example.

MeredithGreyishblue · 12/11/2021 09:08

@mustlovegin

Loyalty to a specific nation state (which is a pretty abstract concept, with borders changing over time) is not a natural human emotion. Loyalty to the people around you can be, but that's not the same thing

It is a natural human emotion, even animals can be territorial and protective of their own, are they 'incited' and 'wrong' too? Do animals go by 'constructs'?

A few don't feel patriotic about this country or the people who currently live around them, but that's their problem to deal with, I guess. They shouldn't expect to dictate what we do or what our traditions or rituals should look like.

Nobody is dictating anything! Nobody is preventing you doing anything!

I hear murmurings of something unpleasantly like xenophobic / racist feelings whispering in the background of that suggestion though. That's usually what follows nonsense like that when balanced (or factual) points are offered.

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 09:07

Itisa natural human emotion, even animals can be territorial and protective of their own, are they 'incited' and 'wrong' too? Do animals go by 'constructs'?

Animals are loyal to those in their social group, not a nation. The UK as a nation and someone's social group are two totally different things. Nations are an abstract concept.

Lemonsyellow · 12/11/2021 09:07

A few don't feel patriotic about this country or the people who currently live around them, but that's their problem to deal with, I guess. They shouldn't expect to dictate what we do or what our traditions or rituals should look like.

It’s not a tradition or a ritual. It’s a relatively recent invention.

OOOOOOOOOH · 12/11/2021 09:07

Each to their own. I don't think anyone is forced . Our town has close links to the army and all traffic stopped here , I suppose that may have something to do with it

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 09:04

Xpost

I'm glad I'm not the only one who feels that way

Lemonsyellow · 12/11/2021 09:03

The silence on Armistice Day in effect became the opposite of patriotic. That was why it was stopped. Everyone was supposed to carry on working, indeed forced to - because working through was patriotic.

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 09:03

In my view, on Armistice day more than any other, patriotism has absolutely no place.

"Patriotism' was cynically used as a tool to persuade millions of young men to volunteer to fight in WWI - and for what? It was a total and utter waste of life. The idea that remembering their loss is somehow 'patriotic' makes me want to be sick.

DismantledKing · 12/11/2021 09:03

It was ‘patriotism’ that caused all those poor lads to be fed through the meat grinder in 1914-18. Remembrance should be just that, not an excuse for jingoistic bullshit.

‘If in some smothering dreams, you too could pace
Behind the wagon that we flung him in,
And watch the white eyes writhing in his face,
His hanging face, like a devil’s sick of sin;
If you could hear, at every jolt, the blood
Come gargling from the froth-corrupted lungs,
Obscene as cancer, bitter as the cud
Of vile, incurable sores on innocent tongues,—
My friend, you would not tell with such high zest
To children ardent for some desperate glory,
The old Lie: Dulce et decorum est
Pro patria mori.’

mustlovegin · 12/11/2021 09:02

Loyalty to a specific nation state (which is a pretty abstract concept, with borders changing over time) is not a natural human emotion. Loyalty to the people around you can be, but that's not the same thing

It is a natural human emotion, even animals can be territorial and protective of their own, are they 'incited' and 'wrong' too? Do animals go by 'constructs'?

A few don't feel patriotic about this country or the people who currently live around them, but that's their problem to deal with, I guess. They shouldn't expect to dictate what we do or what our traditions or rituals should look like.

Lemonsyellow · 12/11/2021 08:57

The only people keen to prevent people from doing what they wish are those who want to enforce a silence on everybody, whether they wish to or not. Patriotism has nothing to do with Armistice Day.

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 08:57

Also, no one is preventing anyone from following their own traditions. The OP chose to book a swimming lesson that would be happening at 11am. No one forced her.

MeredithGreyishblue · 12/11/2021 08:54

Nobody is preventing you from holding an observance whenever you want to.
And of course you can incite patriotism. Same way you can incite any feeling.
Possibly Thatcher post Falklands. Possibly Blair to mask the feelings about the live lost in Iraq. They brought back a tradition that was stopped in the 1930s for a reason.
Nobody is preventing anyone from observing a silence.

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 08:54

You don't think politicians incite patriotism (in the jingoistic sense) when it suits them? What on earth do you think propaganda is for then? Why do governments bother with it?

Loyalty to a specific nation state (which is a pretty abstract concept, with borders changing over time) is not a natural human emotion. Loyalty to the people around you can be, but that's not the same thing.

mustlovegin · 12/11/2021 08:50

to incite waves of patriotism

Patriotism isn't 'incited', it's felt.

It appears a few cannot feel it as their loyalty lies elsewhere, but why do they feel entitled to prevent the majority from following their own traditions if they wish to do so?

mustlovegin · 12/11/2021 08:46

I’ve not even seen anywhere selling poppies

I see loads where I am

terrywynne · 12/11/2021 08:45

@Lemonsyellow

Admittedly I’ve not been out much recently, but I’ve not even seen anywhere selling poppies.
There's been a BL table with all the poppy items for sale in the entrance to our local large supermarket for weeks now. I suspect it depends on your local branch of the British Legion and whether they have volunteers prepared to sell them (bearing in mind that they are usually older, and Covid is still a concern for lots of people)
terrywynne · 12/11/2021 08:43

@Cosmois

When can we stop? 200 years after? 300 years after? Obviously at some point people will stop. For some of us that is now. It will faze our over time. That is just a fact. My children have no idea about it, I don't think it is something they do at school? They have never mentioned it and noone at their school seems to wear a poppy? I think it is presumed people will mark it on the Sunday if they want to.
Or we won't stop but the trends outlined by @BettyBag will grow because people lose the connection to the generations that actually fought and lost. Many of us right now know people alive in the 1940s or heard directly from first world war veterans. In a few generations that will not be the case. And people thoughts on what Remembrance Sunday and Armistice Day are for is going to change as a result. And that is something that should be discussed not just shouted down as disrespectful.

And yes a longer period of events is probably a good idea as that happens (though usually the world wars are taught in school anyway...). That does not mean doing away with the Centotaph ceremony or abandoning 2 minutes silence for those who want them. It just reflects the fact that how we reflect on events and commemorate them does change the further away they become and the less people have a personal connection to them.

Lemonsyellow · 12/11/2021 08:41

Definite conflating of the 2 days. But when the BBC & othe media do it too, it's not hard to see why.

The more recent resurrection of 2 mins on Armistice is, I think, in response to more recent conflicts (Iraq) and to incite waves of patriotism.

Yes, exactly.

AutumnAlmanack · 12/11/2021 08:38

I do respect the 2 minutes' silence but find it really artificial. Like others say, I choose my own time to remember the fallen and not just once a year. I do find the silence at the Cenotaph on Remembrance Sunday very moving though.

What I dislike is the fact that the idea of a 'silence' has been hijacked by every single unpleasant event which happens - bombings, murders, shootings, etc. What happened to people thinking about people and events in their own time?

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 08:38

My great grandfather fought in WWI (and also served after that) and died in 1999. He wasnt the last Tommy, but he will have been one of the last. He hated performative poppying and used to criticise politicians who wore the poppy while making foreign policy decisions that would lead to conflict.

MeredithGreyishblue · 12/11/2021 08:37

@Lemonsyellow

Surprising that some posters are mentioning that we “won the war”. Armistice Day marks the truce, where both sides agreed not to fight. We didn’t win.
That's current right-wing feeling rising. The flag shaggers on Twitter.