Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No 2 minutes silence at gym. AIBU

543 replies

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 11/11/2021 17:52

I went to my gym today for a class in the swimming pool. I had totally expected the class to finish just before 11am so that those who wanted to could observe the two minutes silence. By 10.55am it was apparent that this was not going to happen so I just took myself out of the pool and sat in the changing room by myself.
So as to not drip feed, I am from a Forces Family and the wrong side of 50! I found this totally disrespectful of the instructor. He could have, at the very least, mentioned that he had intended to not stop before the class. AIBU to be upset by this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Aimee1987 · 13/11/2021 14:47

What would you think of someone who visited a place like Auschwitz (mentioned by a PP) who behaved inappropriately? Would you not judge them?
If somone choose to go to Auschwitz and act like a gobshite of course I would judge them.
If the OP went to an armistice day ceremony and there were people there being rude and disrespectful I would say they were out of line.
If somone went to a religious ceremony and acted the fool once again inappropriate.
However the OP went to a gym and was shocked that not everyone thought exactly as she did in that exact moment in time.
As others have mentioned up thread if she cared that much she shouldnt have booked a gym class at that time and next year she can find a service to attend to pay her respect.

Batshaver · 13/11/2021 01:29

Agree with you @terrywynne @CSJobseeker and others.

Humans are tribal, for sure. But nationalism is just an attempt to harness that tribalism in the service of arbitrary borders. A country is a piece of the world that a ruler has said is theirs. It's an arbitrary and often problematic business. Right here in the UK we have an extremely problematic border. There are many others globally. How can a person have a natural affinity to a piece of land whose border is so difficult to define that people die trying to do so? I mean it's obviously not an eternal truth if there is such dispute that there are wars about its extent.

AudacityBaby · 13/11/2021 00:21

@mustlovegin

I also have a feeling that some of the people observing the silence spend the entire 2 minutes judging others

What would you think of someone who visited a place like Auschwitz (mentioned by a PP) who behaved inappropriately? Would you not judge them?

That PP was me. Whilst I’m on - I think one of the most disrespectful things anyone can do is use Auschwitz as a pithy comparator. I actually struggle to comprehend how you thought this was an appropriate thing to say.
Mookie81 · 12/11/2021 20:17

[quote LittleDandelionClock]@SnipSnipMrBurgess

It's a bit like when you are at the pub and having a good time, then someone starts singing, and everyone is hushed to be quiet and listen. Eh no, I didn't come here to listen to you, I came here to do my own thing thanks.

Well, maybe don't go to a pub where they are putting on a music/singing act then Confused They always announce it beforehand, on a noticeboard or poster outside (and inside) the pub.[/quote]
They never said it was a musical act, just someone randomly singing. Hmm
Try reading before frothing.

Fordian · 12/11/2021 19:31

OK, OP, and others.

The vote is 80% YABU/20% YABU

Time to give it a rest?

It's rather more decisive that 52/48%; though stoking up the sort of emotions you deem compulsory went a good way towards that 52%, didn't it?

Collaborate · 12/11/2021 17:13

The horror...

No  2 minutes silence at gym. AIBU
Dreambigger · 12/11/2021 15:19

Its become so competitive..the poppy wearing ..how early can you start ... and the silences. Its all becoming a bit meaningless. Why not just focus on a thoughtful service on the Sunday and leave it at that. Also not everyone culturally observes it. And thats fine doesn't mean they don't value those lost.

terrywynne · 12/11/2021 15:11

@mustlovegin

Animals are not territorial to an area the size of a nation though. So as the poster you quotes said, people are often loyal to small groups (family, friends, neighbours) as a natural instinct such as can be observed in animals

Animals are loyal to those in their social group, not a nation

So it's a matter of distance or size then? Rather simplistic if you ask me

I can consider someone living in Orkney as part of my social group, especially when I perceive them to reciprocate my feelings. You could feel a strong bond with a next door neighbour who refers to a place other than the UK when they say 'my country', like a poster upthread. Interesting.

LOL at some posters' nervousness at the suggestion that patriotism can be instinctive and hence real (as opposed to a mere construct that can be eroded if you try hard enough)

No that's it what I mean. Humans are complex and we develop social and political groups and loyalties for a vast array of reasons. My objection was to saying thay loyalty to the nation state is a natural instinct akin to teritorialism in the animal kingdom. My point in that post being that you can't even equate a relatively small animal territory to a nation.

A nation state is not a natural instinct, it is a complex socio-political-economic constructs (that often make use of constructed narratives around events such as wars to create unity and identity)

I do still thing most peoole would say that their strongest sense of loyalty is to a numerically small group of people. But, especially with global travel and internal communications, it doesn't have to be geographically small (or restricted to your country).

MeredithGreyishblue · 12/11/2021 15:08

@Platax the irony of so much to do with the "our parents fought in the war and we ❤ Winston Churchill brigade so we'll force out immigrants and defend statues" crew is gigantic. It's the strangest thing. Chosen to latch on on to "defending our shores" and forget fighting the atrocities of the Nazi regime entirely. And Churchill was a hideous snob who wouldn't have spat on the masses if they were on fire.

I think of the dead and their families. Not the "patriotism" bit. And I do it on Sunday. And quite often when I walk past the cenotaph. Not when Esther Williams over there wants me to!!!

Comefromaway · 12/11/2021 15:01

I'm just about the right side of 50 and have never observed the 2 minute silence on 11th. It's always been on the Sunday.

CecilyP · 12/11/2021 14:48

I don't really understand how a two minutes silence would work in a swimming lesson anyway. Do people stand shivering at the side of the pool? Or do they clutch the hand rail silently, or tread water in the middle? Even if the class has finished early people will still be dripping and cold. And people who have paid for a full lesson and would rather show respect in other ways are entitled to feel short-changed.

Yeah, the instructor probably did you a favour, OP. You were able to be silent all by yourself in the changing room. If he'd stopped the class early, you would have had all the other punters chattering all around you.

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 14:47

@Platax

I don't really understand how a two minutes silence would work in a swimming lesson anyway. Do people stand shivering at the side of the pool? Or do they clutch the hand rail silently, or tread water in the middle? Even if the class has finished early people will still be dripping and cold. And people who have paid for a full lesson and would rather show respect in other ways are entitled to feel short-changed.
Also, do you remove your swimming cap and goggles? Traditionally one would doff one's cap in order to show respect. It's a total minefield.

In reality, I don't think anyone who genuinely wants to spend 11am on armistice day having a moment of quiet, meaningful contemplation books a swimming lesson for that time.

Platax · 12/11/2021 14:37

I don't really understand how a two minutes silence would work in a swimming lesson anyway. Do people stand shivering at the side of the pool? Or do they clutch the hand rail silently, or tread water in the middle? Even if the class has finished early people will still be dripping and cold. And people who have paid for a full lesson and would rather show respect in other ways are entitled to feel short-changed.

ThePoisonousMushroom · 12/11/2021 14:36

Just to be clear… no one on this thread is trying to prevent other people from having their 2 minutes silence. No one is trying to forbid it. They just want the freedom not to do it themselves.

Platax · 12/11/2021 14:34

There was something similar on twitter a few days ago. Basically someone saying 'you have your Pride Celebrations, and Black Pride Month, and endless celebrations, concessions, and voices for minorities, so please PLEASE allow me just 2 minutes to be silent, and think about all the war dead who gave their lives so that me, AND you can have our freedom.'

@LittleDandelionClock, it's noticeable that you and @mustlovegin make this claim that people are trying to stop the 2 minute silence happening at all but can't point to anyone on this thread who is actually advocating that.

That is one of the problems with the mindset that revived the whole thing back in the late 90s - and indeed with many aspects of the right wing mindset: people seem to feel that disagreeing with them is an absolute offence to the extent that they are being persecuted, when nothing of the sort is happening. You have to be able to comprehend that the freedom of speech for which our ancestors were fighting involves people being entitled to have different opinions whilst not wanting those with differing opinions to be silenced. For some people it seems to be anathema that opinions other than theirs are permitted, which is particularly ironic in this context.

Temphelp · 12/11/2021 14:34

I get what you’re saying but I just find it one of many more things that is sad about the world. Nobody holds a minute of silence for us to remember the non-British non-soldiers who died in the war, and the neverending wars that seem to be still going on… Has there been a minute or two of silence for Palestine, Syria, Yemen, Lebanon… I could go on and on.

I’m glad you were able to at least have your 2 minutes alone in the changing room and I hope that offered you some peace. Unfortunately the world is getting on with things faster than ever and rarely do we stop to think about anyone else.

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 14:28

It's also indicative of the brainpower of those people who think patriotism has anything whatsoever to do with remembrance.

I remember those killed in the gulf wars, for example, but I utterly condemn the foreign policy that sent them there.

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 14:27

Yes, that's exactly what's being argued. Grin

I think it's indicative of the brainpower of those people who think patriotism is a fantastic thing, and that being called unpatriotic is a serious insult.

ThePoisonousMushroom · 12/11/2021 14:24

Hang on, are people trying to say that patriotism is a natural instinct that (some) people are born with? Is it fuck Grin. It’s a social construct,

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 14:22

Who is trying to prevent what majority from doing what? I don't see any evidence of anyone trying to stop armistice day activities.

I presume the people preventing others from observing the silence are the same ones who are trying to cancel Christmas to avoid offending Muslims.

Those imaginary people.

Platax · 12/11/2021 14:20

@mustlovegin

to incite waves of patriotism

Patriotism isn't 'incited', it's felt.

It appears a few cannot feel it as their loyalty lies elsewhere, but why do they feel entitled to prevent the majority from following their own traditions if they wish to do so?

Who is trying to prevent what majority from doing what? I don't see any evidence of anyone trying to stop armistice day activities.
RobotValkyrie · 12/11/2021 14:18

YABU for trying to force your religion/beliefs on others.
No lobby group has a right to disrupt public life, no matter how just and worthy their cause might be.

Platax · 12/11/2021 14:17

@MeredithGreyishblue

Definite conflating of the 2 days. But when the BBC & othe media do it too, it's not hard to see why.

The more recent resurrection of 2 mins on Armistice is, I think, in response to more recent conflicts (Iraq) and to incite waves of patriotism.

My grandparents married on Armistice Day back in the days post the Second World War when it really was recent.

I agree that it's a more recent phenomenon. It arose around the same time as Help for Heroes was established, and was part of the same trend of sanctifying the military.

I have every respect for people who join the armed forces, but we all know that they are absolutely not all heroes, and indeed many of them absolutely hate the thoughtless way that term is pinned to them. Many will get through their military career seeing less danger than the average police or fire officer, or lifeboat volunteer. It's also a cause that has unfortunately been adopted by some of the more rabid right wing groups, which is quite ironic given that most of their members wouldn't last 5 minutes in a military career. So to have people like that aggressively telling others off for not staying silent at some arbitrarily fixed time is really pretty unpalatable.

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 14:17

@mustlovegin

I also have a feeling that some of the people observing the silence spend the entire 2 minutes judging others

What would you think of someone who visited a place like Auschwitz (mentioned by a PP) who behaved inappropriately? Would you not judge them?

What the actual fuck?

You're comparing someone finishing their pre-booked swimming lesson with someone behaving inappropriately at Auschwitz?

Have a word with yourself.

CSJobseeker · 12/11/2021 14:15

It's worth noting that unquestioning belief was one of the goals of the state in Orwell's 1984. Because that unquestioning belief was part of what gave them such power over people.