Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No 2 minutes silence at gym. AIBU

543 replies

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 11/11/2021 17:52

I went to my gym today for a class in the swimming pool. I had totally expected the class to finish just before 11am so that those who wanted to could observe the two minutes silence. By 10.55am it was apparent that this was not going to happen so I just took myself out of the pool and sat in the changing room by myself.
So as to not drip feed, I am from a Forces Family and the wrong side of 50! I found this totally disrespectful of the instructor. He could have, at the very least, mentioned that he had intended to not stop before the class. AIBU to be upset by this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
JamAutistically · 11/11/2021 18:52

@QueenofKattegat

You're being unreasonable. Are you one of those people that complain if they see a news reader not wearing a poppy? Forced respect, for fear of judgement, isn't respect.
Agree.
AuntEater · 11/11/2021 18:52

Why on earth did you go swimming at that time if it was so important to you? As others have said people would quite rightly have complained if they'd paid for the whole of the class but not had the whole time. YABU

IGotHam · 11/11/2021 18:51

If it was that important to you why did you go to an exercise class when you knew it was going to happen?

I intensely dislike how performative remembrance has become. Same as with the poppy police who love coming out every year.

YABU.

Cookie79 · 11/11/2021 18:51

A couple of years ago DD’s karate class fell on Remembrance Sunday. They had the class do the silence holding the plank position.

JamAutistically · 11/11/2021 18:49

@Libertaire

YABU.

If you wish to observe two minutes silence, carry on. Nobody is stopping you.

Others are free to ignore such public virtue-signalling if they wish.

I agree.
Luredbyapomegranate · 11/11/2021 18:49

You are being bonkers. It’s optional. He’s not got to stop a class because how does he know who wants to observe it and who doesn’t? If you do, you make an individual decision to, as you did.

I usually follow it myself, but it’s a complex concept, for many people tangled up with unjust wars etc, or they may simply not be interested. Any response is fine. It’s there for people who want it.

ButtonSister · 11/11/2021 18:49

@Wheresmywoolyjumpers

I think it is a shame. As for the wrong side of 50 - so am I and I have an memory of being about 7 and walking through Parliament Square with my sister when everybody around us just stopped. I had no idea why, but was told after it was the 2 minutes silence. It really had a big impact on me and I think it is a shame it is not observed so much any more.
I suspect that was on Remembrance Sunday not 11/11
beachtosunset · 11/11/2021 18:48

@Wheresmywoolyjumpers

I think it is a shame. As for the wrong side of 50 - so am I and I have an memory of being about 7 and walking through Parliament Square with my sister when everybody around us just stopped. I had no idea why, but was told after it was the 2 minutes silence. It really had a big impact on me and I think it is a shame it is not observed so much any more.
^^this in spades!!

we don't know we're born.

It's the very least we can do. I am extremely grateful to all those who fell giving their life so we can live ours.

It's about reverance and respect.

I'm 45 if that makes any difference.

NoDecentHandlesLeft · 11/11/2021 18:48

Isn't the official silence on Sunday?

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 11/11/2021 18:48

We're all from Forces families - pretty much everyone in this country, including most immigrants - had relatives who fought in WW1 and WW2.

I do a lot of work with the British Legion, including (until recently, as sadly most are no longer with us) WW2 veterans. They all feel it is important to honour fallen comrades but many of them hate the modern virtue-signalling around this. Commemoration should be a personal choice.

whatswithtodaytoday · 11/11/2021 18:48

You wanted to observe the silence. You stopped. No-one else needs to if they don't want to.

CaptainMyCaptain · 11/11/2021 18:47

@FangsForTheMemory

If you're the wrong side of 50, you'll remember that nobody in this country used to observe two minutes' silence except those attending Armistice Day ceremonies. It should be a personal thing.
Quite. It's a fairly new thing, I'm 66 and we never did it when I was young. Having said that I take part now if it's happening where I am but it's not compulsory. You could have checked when you went in to the gym.
SickAndTiredAgain · 11/11/2021 18:46

@happydappy2

We either have a minutes silence to honour the sacrifice made in war, or we don't. I was in a yoga class when 11am fell and we all observed a minutes silence & reflection-there was a tannoy announcement just beforehand so everyone could observe this. Is yr gym part of a chain OP? I would mention it to management.
What do you mean we either have it or we don’t? As a mandated thing, we don’t. And nor should we. As a personal choice, we do. Which is the right way to do it.
SarahAndQuack · 11/11/2021 18:46

@Random789

I wish we could go back to how things were before the Blair-era politicisation of war commemoration, when remembance was sincere, low-key, private, and tinged with a sense of tragedy rather than jingoistic pride.

I believe that the Blair govt's ramping up of public symbols of commemoration began in a harmless enough way -- there was a general feeling that the generation directly affected by the second world war was slipping away, and it felt important to honour them as the 'big' round-number anniversaries of major war events came and went.

But it has ended up making remembrance performative, confrontational, tribal, nationalist, inauthentic. The antithesis of what remembrance used to be, especially in the years after the First World War, when it was a recognition of the pointlessness of slaughter, and didn't spin it into grand patriotic feel-good tropes. Tropes that are so bland now that (as I remember from a couple of years ago) they can be woven into adverts for Sainsbury's and biscuits.

As it happens, I was at a gym class too, and ours did stop for the silence. Fine - I was plaesed to have a chance to join in. But I would ahve been equally happy if they had carried on with the class. I can takes a short reflective silence whenever I need to, alone and at home.

I agree with every word of this.
erinaceus · 11/11/2021 18:46

I think that perhaps sadly - you are being a tad unrealistic to expect the silence to be observed in the way you imagined. Being from a forces family probably gives the two minute silence more significance in your mind than the minds of other gym goers. Given the circumstances I think you did the best thing for you. I don't think you would be unreasonable to mention your concern to the gym's manager but I think in future you might have more realistic expectations of what the public do.

LaetitiaASD · 11/11/2021 18:45

Personally I had no idea there was a minute's silence today. Obviously I am aware that remembrance type activities have been going on recently, but I didn't have a clue of 11am today. I believe that there are two reasons I didn't know -

(1) I detest the jingoistic and nationalistic right wing flag waving that goes on. Remembrance day looks like an opportunity for the right to further it's aims, as opposed to a genuine attempt to commemorate the dead and consider how important it is not to stir up nationalism which itself increases the likelihood of war
and
(2) I detest the jingoistic and nationalistic right wing flag waving government, to the point that they are so despicably immoral and corrupt that I can't abide listening to the news where I get to be made depressed by their latest depravity, and which is where I might have heard that the 11 o'clock thing was happening.

I don't think anyone has the obligation to participate in remembrance day - indeed I feel obliged not to. In an ideal world the country could unite against the futility of the nationalism that lead to wars and death, and the wars and death itself.

ThePoisonousMushroom · 11/11/2021 18:45

@monkeysmum21

YANBU in my opinion. You did the right thing but there is a lot of imperfection in the world. You can expect people who are self-centre all year round to make an exception today.
I didn’t observe the silence today. However I will be taking my pack of Brownies (who I give hours of my time to every week, all year round) to the remembrance parade on Sunday where we will march together with the community and observe the silence together. Self centred, me.
terrywynne · 11/11/2021 18:45

When did it become two minutes? I definitely remember it being 1 minute and 2 minutes for key anniversaries (25 years/50years etc) now it's 2min every year.

I also dislike the feeling of enforced performance that surrounds Rembrance these days and the commercialisation of the poppy symbol. I prefer to reflect in my own way and time.

Heartdogs · 11/11/2021 18:45

I didn't observe it and I would not have been happy to have it forced on me. You did want to partake and did so. It would have been unnecessary for others to have been forced to to please you. Leaving it to personal preference is ideal.

Random789 · 11/11/2021 18:45

I wish we could go back to how things were before the Blair-era politicisation of war commemoration, when remembance was sincere, low-key, private, and tinged with a sense of tragedy rather than jingoistic pride.

I believe that the Blair govt's ramping up of public symbols of commemoration began in a harmless enough way -- there was a general feeling that the generation directly affected by the second world war was slipping away, and it felt important to honour them as the 'big' round-number anniversaries of major war events came and went.

But it has ended up making remembrance performative, confrontational, tribal, nationalist, inauthentic. The antithesis of what remembrance used to be, especially in the years after the First World War, when it was a recognition of the pointlessness of slaughter, and didn't spin it into grand patriotic feel-good tropes. Tropes that are so bland now that (as I remember from a couple of years ago) they can be woven into adverts for Sainsbury's and biscuits.

As it happens, I was at a gym class too, and ours did stop for the silence. Fine - I was plaesed to have a chance to join in. But I would ahve been equally happy if they had carried on with the class. I can takes a short reflective silence whenever I need to, alone and at home.

happydappy2 · 11/11/2021 18:44

We either have a minutes silence to honour the sacrifice made in war, or we don't. I was in a yoga class when 11am fell and we all observed a minutes silence & reflection-there was a tannoy announcement just beforehand so everyone could observe this. Is yr gym part of a chain OP? I would mention it to management.

Kite22 · 11/11/2021 18:44

YABU.
They fought for our freedom to make decisions, and not be dictated to.

Until fairly recently people weren't expected to stop at 11am on 11th Nov - that is why we have remembrance Sunday. So most people can attend ceremonies, parades, services together on what always used to be a nonworking day. You can still go and do that on Sunday.
Or you could have gone to the numerous ceremonies that have happened today, in all sorts of places.
Or watch the ceremonies that will be on TV over the weekend.
Or, you could have missed your class.

Or, you could have got out early as you did.
Or, you could have taken a few minutes at any point today to be silent and reflect.

I would have been quite cross if something I had booked and paid for for an hour was cut short, when I fully expect to pay my respects and fall silent at the weekend.

NothingSafe · 11/11/2021 18:43

@BeyondOurReef

I’m sure it also used to be a minute of silence. There’s been inflation.

I agree that the whole performative and judgemental nature of it these days is actually disrespectful if anything. As is the very odd commercialisation around it - buying special poppy broaches with a ‘donation’ to charity included in the price and so on.

It’s quite depressing really.

You mean like this special edition rum in a grenade-shaped bottle isn't a sincere, thoughtful remembrance? Wink

Or if you prefer your remembrance a bit more literal, we could all follow the very remembery example of this family and their skip...

Or, my personal favourite, these custom poppy Adidas. Y'know, founded-by-a-Nazi-Adidas.

I find it all really weird. If you want to remember those who fought for the country, fantastic. But it used to be about quiet reflection and respect and now it seems to be "how much poppy tat can we flog in November, how red can we paint the outside of our pub, and how upset can we get if someone refuses to remember the hardest they've ever remembered and wear a giant poppy on their head to show such remembrance?"

No  2 minutes silence at gym. AIBU
No  2 minutes silence at gym. AIBU
No  2 minutes silence at gym. AIBU
SickAndTiredAgain · 11/11/2021 18:43

YABU, I always observe it but I don’t get cross if other people don’t, particularly while working.

Also surely you didn't expect a shop to force its customers to stand in silence.

I used to work in Waitrose and we did. We’d announce it on the tannoy at 5 to that it was happening, and then at 11 announce the start. They had someone at the door stopping people come in during it. We had to stop work on the tills, which was always a bit awkward if the particular customer you were serving didn’t want to wait but you couldn’t (in a totally silent shop where no one was moving) just keep beeping things through. One year there was a complete arsehole who continues walking round the shop (totally fine if you don’t want to do the silence) but he was also whistling a jolly little tune.

trollopolis · 11/11/2021 18:41

"and the wrong side of 50*

So you're no older than 49 ....