Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No 2 minutes silence at gym. AIBU

543 replies

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 11/11/2021 17:52

I went to my gym today for a class in the swimming pool. I had totally expected the class to finish just before 11am so that those who wanted to could observe the two minutes silence. By 10.55am it was apparent that this was not going to happen so I just took myself out of the pool and sat in the changing room by myself.
So as to not drip feed, I am from a Forces Family and the wrong side of 50! I found this totally disrespectful of the instructor. He could have, at the very least, mentioned that he had intended to not stop before the class. AIBU to be upset by this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
KittenKong · 11/11/2021 21:52

My grandfather was a funny, short man. Always making jokes and messing around. He bought me teddy bears in my birthday. and always gave me money for sweeties. He died when he was still a young man by today’s standards. His heart was knackered.

He volunteered for the army the day war was declared.

He would say that he was ‘in charge’ of his men because he could shout the loudest.

He told me that never got caught ‘by the jerries’ because he ran faster than they did.

He and his men had to hide out in the french countryside when cut off from the rest of the troops.

He was at the opening of at least one concentration camp - first lot of men in. He would vomit at the smell of burnt meat years later.

His whole team were blown up by a single bomb - only he survived.

He had a bayonet - a German one. He said a German soldier ‘gave it’ to him.

These were some of the things he told my grandmother. As a child (I was about 4 when he died) I couldn’t comprehend the horror - it was all adventure and daring do. As an adult - my god.

I think about him - and my grandma and mum too.

ThePoisonousMushroom · 11/11/2021 21:50

@BoredZelda

Shame on you. You represent everything that is wrong with the world today.

Actually, comments like this are more representative of what’s wrong with the world today.

Agreed.
ThePoisonousMushroom · 11/11/2021 21:50

Shame on you. You represent everything that is wrong with the world today

She really, really doesn’t.

Almostmenopausal · 11/11/2021 21:49

@WheelieBinPrincess

I actually hate enforced silences, I never think about the thing I’m supposed to be thinking about. When we did at school I’m afraid I was more than likely thinking about what was in my lunchbox. When I was older i was probably thinking about if I should open the wine tonight even though it’s only Wednesday or if I turned my hot brush off.

That does NOT mean I don’t care about fallen soldiers or think about them in lots of other ways. I just think when someone says ‘now think about this thing’ it’s quite hard to do.

I have no problem being quiet during it though.

You're not making yourself sound like a particularly nice person there WheelieBin...... I'm sure you're lovely! But that didn't make you sound it!
BoredZelda · 11/11/2021 21:49

Shame on you. You represent everything that is wrong with the world today.

Actually, comments like this are more representative of what’s wrong with the world today.

mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 21:48

how we honour the idea of soldiers while failing to support them in so many ways when they return

We should honour and support them

Baluchistan95 · 11/11/2021 21:48

@Kevinishot

I was teaching a spin class at 11am - i didn’t stop mid way through a track to sit in silence - it’s not how classes work. Not one person mentioned it at any point during the day. If you’re that bothered about it, don’t go to the bloody gym at that time.
Shame on you. You represent everything that is wrong with the world today.
BoredZelda · 11/11/2021 21:46

And the people on here saying they wore a poppy but didn't take the time to be silent are very double faced; pretending to support but secretly not giving a damn

Or, they supported the charity and that’s what’s important.

lazylinguist · 11/11/2021 21:45

You understand it's perfectly possible to 'give a fuck' while not feeling the need to demonstrate it publicly to other people, right? And that you have no idea whether the people publicly being silent for 2 minutes actually do give a fuck or whether they're just doing it because it looks bad if they don't? Also why would buying a poppy not be good in itself if it's raising money for veterans? Does that not count unless you be quiet for 2 minutes as well? It's better to do neither than one or the other? How bizarre.

rookiemere · 11/11/2021 21:45

@Marvellousmadness but buying a poppy gives money to the ex forces charity, observing a silence is nice as a mark of respect, but suspect everyone on the receiving end would prefer the hard cash.

AnnieSnap · 11/11/2021 21:44

@ladygindiva

My gran was a deeply religious woman who did a lot for charity. However, she never observed remembrance day, and it was the only Sunday she didn't go to church. When I was old enough she told me why. Her brother died needlessly as a young man in an absolutely horrific botch of a battle in the war, leaving a widow and 3 young children including a newborn baby. She gave money to veterans and war widows charities etc but thought that remembrance Sunday and the two minutes silence were hypocritical, pompous and unhelpful. Just presenting a view of someone who didn't take part, but had the utmost respect for servicemen.
👆 This
BoredZelda · 11/11/2021 21:42

I specifically said I was talking about those I have worked with.

Yes, and I asked if every single one you worked with felt that way. Seems unlikely.

I'd also wonder how many honest conversations you had with your grandfathers about their experience? Very few veterans talked about their dark experiences to their families, because there was a belief that it was better not to dwell on emotions.

I had many conversations with both my grandparents. My grandma was QAIMNS. My granda served both in Europe and the middle east. We read through the letters they sent home and to each other. Both went on to work with Combat Stress. My father served in Northern Ireland and still has his demons but is open about it. The only veteran in my family who hasn’t talked about his experiences is my brother who served in the first Gulf War. Maybe he’ll get to the stage when he is a grandparent that he can finally open up.

Marvellousmadness · 11/11/2021 21:41

Some people just dont give a fuck as they are way too selfish or ignorant. And the people on here saying they wore a poppy but didn't take the time to be silent are very double faced; pretending to support but secretly not giving a damn

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 11/11/2021 21:38

@Colouringaddict It was HMS Barham

shouldistop · 11/11/2021 21:37

It's 1 minute.

You can't book a class at that time and then get upset that it wasn't observed.

lazylinguist · 11/11/2021 21:36

They might be cynical, but not as much as the people saying that a nationally recognised silence is ‘performative’. It’s respect. Do it or don’t do it but you can’t label this poignant day and hour as ‘virtue signalling’. Shame on them.

Yes you can say it's virtue-signalling. And yes, some veterans agree. Did you also discount the views of the NHS workers who were totally against the performative 'clap for the NHS workers' thing, and were encouraging people to do what actually mattered and would help - i.e. use their vote? You don't get to decide 'It's not performative, it's respect'. If people are doing it performatively because they feel they have to, then it is performative.

Colouringaddict · 11/11/2021 21:33

@WhenISnappedAndFarted

My Grandad fought in WW2, in fact he was on a boat that got torpedoed and just survived, a lot of his friends didn't. He only died three years ago but was very anti all of this.

He used to say that he wished people would just remember in private and not do all these forced shows of remembrance.

My Grandad too! I wonder if it was the same ship?
AccidentallyOnPurpose · 11/11/2021 21:32

@Ionlydomassiveones

“No one is saying that Remembrance Sunday is performative. They are saying that silence for 2 minutes in the middle of a swimming pool or supermarket is performative and ridiculous.”

Why? I’d say on armistice day the fact that it’s a swimming pool or supermarket makes it even more poignant as that’s exactly what they died fighting for.

They died fighting for swimming pools and supermarkets?
3scape · 11/11/2021 21:29

Ridiculous. There are services, parades to do your two minutes of reflection. If you want to do it, great, but if you make it compulsory then it is a meaningless exercise.

Kite22 · 11/11/2021 21:26

Are they still alive today? That’s the point. You knew them, you don’t know them. My grandparents etc were alive in WW1, but they are long dead

The point is we are talking about 'remembering'.
I don't need to 'remember' folk who are still alive - I can go and see them, or phone them.

Cameleongirl · 11/11/2021 21:24

But I can't argue with what @Cordyceps and @ladygindiva say either. They are absolutely right.

HesterShaw1 · 11/11/2021 21:24

@BoredZelda

And the more you read about the aftermath of WW2, the more you realise that VE day was no such thing - it was simply when hostilities between Germany and the Allies ended. This has had repercussions ever since.

Actually, those who study it, understand that it was our behaviour having “won” WW1 which led directly to WW2. Having brought Germany to its knees, we then made damned sure they could never recover. That left a breeding ground for the Nazi party to take power. The “roaring twenties” , the booming peacetime economy were a reaction to the wartime years and led to the Wall Street crash which kicked off the Great Depression that was the final nail in the coffin for an already decimated German economy and in those types of economy it is very easy to lead a nation in to fascism.

But yes, we behaved in the same way after WW2 and many of the modern conflicts have their roots in decisions we made unilaterally after WW2 on behalf of the nations who “lost”

Though we didn't behave in the same way after WWII (the USA's Marshall Plan was specifically designed to stop the same thing happening again and through that and the hard work of the Germans themselves, modern Germany became what it is today. It was specifically NOT abandoned to just get on with it and punished).

However my post wasn't talking about the UK after WWII - there are parts of Europe which fought on for months/years, a fact which is largely forgotten. A very good read is Savage Continent by Keith Lowe, though it's exceptionally bleak.

Two minutes silence and wearing a paper/ceramic poppy will not be enough to prevent conflict again. And isn't that what true remembrance should be about - learning from the past so that catastrophic and hideous mistakes aren't repeated?

Ionlydomassiveones · 11/11/2021 21:24

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Lemonsyellow · 11/11/2021 21:23

it reminds me, personally, of how we honour the idea of soldiers while failing to support them in so many ways when they return- so many people with ostentatious poppies will still support immoral corporate wars and would walk by homeless veterans with a sneer of disgust.

This is spot on.

Cameleongirl · 11/11/2021 21:22

I live in the US now, but personally, I do have a few minutes of silence on Veteran's Day as it's called here. Others not feel the same, but I want to remember the sacrifices made so that I can live in a democracy, IYSWIM. My grandfather was killed in WW2 and my FIL served in the military during the Cold War.

Politics is so poisonous here and in the UK that I feel the need to reflect on how lucky we actually are, instead of constantly bickering about everything under the sun....we can only do that because we live in democracies that other people defended against the Nazis, etc.