Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No 2 minutes silence at gym. AIBU

543 replies

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 11/11/2021 17:52

I went to my gym today for a class in the swimming pool. I had totally expected the class to finish just before 11am so that those who wanted to could observe the two minutes silence. By 10.55am it was apparent that this was not going to happen so I just took myself out of the pool and sat in the changing room by myself.
So as to not drip feed, I am from a Forces Family and the wrong side of 50! I found this totally disrespectful of the instructor. He could have, at the very least, mentioned that he had intended to not stop before the class. AIBU to be upset by this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
AudacityBaby · 15/11/2021 21:54

@DismantledKing

This is why the Royal British Legion can go fuck itself. Remembrance used to be poignant, ‘never again’. Now look at the shit that they share. I used to buy a poppy every year, but stopped some time after the millennium because of this kind of jingoistic bullshit.
That’s dreadful. Remembrance is about paying tribute to soldiers who’ve died in conflict, about the horrors of war. It’s not a marketing or recruitment campaign for the forces. There are plenty of those campaigns already.
ButtonSister · 15/11/2021 13:28

@MurielSpriggs
Thank you, that's a very interesting read

MurielSpriggs · 14/11/2021 22:22

@DismantledKing

This is why the Royal British Legion can go fuck itself. Remembrance used to be poignant, ‘never again’. Now look at the shit that they share. I used to buy a poppy every year, but stopped some time after the millennium because of this kind of jingoistic bullshit.
There's a detailed analysis of some of the British Legion's more questionable behaviour, and the reason why they've made poppies problematic, here:

vfpuk.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/my_name_is_legion-web.pdf

MurielSpriggs · 14/11/2021 21:51

@XenoBitch

YABVU If you really wanted to observe the 2 min silence, you would have made sure you were in an environment to do that to start with. A swimming pool is not one!
Exactly. The original post (and much of the complaining about this issue) seems to have nothing to do with not being allowed to pay your respects as you would most prefer. It's about expecting everyone else to do the same (and wanting to have that policed by a gym instructor!)
pictish · 14/11/2021 21:43

Yes. Lest it happen again.

BeyondOurReef · 14/11/2021 18:55

Viewing the armed forces as heroic and worth emulating strikes me as missing the point of remembrance entirely.

It wasn’t heroic. It was not anything to emulate. It was a horrendous slaughter and we remember - solemnly - so as to try not to emulate it.

DismantledKing · 14/11/2021 17:55

[quote me4real]**@BeyondOurReef* @DismantledKing* The thing about the Legion is they value what people who've served have done. They think people serving their country is and was a good thing. This isn't new for the Legion, for instance they had a picture of the Queen up in my local one.

A youngster (or family) saying they want to be a soldier is partly saying what soldiers did and do is something heroic and worth emulating. No one should be pushed into this, obviously.

Of course there's a difference between people being conscripted (not necessarily good if they didn't want to go) and people who choose to serve and choose to accept the risks of that (even in a place where they are supported etc.) Most people think people who choose to serve their country in this way are great- the Legion helps support
these after they retire and so on.[/quote]
The behaviour of the RBL explains why so many people (including plenty on this thread) no longer wear a poppy. They don’t exist to be a recruiting sergeant for the armed forces, the whole point of the poppy is remembrance.
They still never get another penny from me.

CSJobseeker · 14/11/2021 17:54

@DismantledKing

This is why the Royal British Legion can go fuck itself. Remembrance used to be poignant, ‘never again’. Now look at the shit that they share. I used to buy a poppy every year, but stopped some time after the millennium because of this kind of jingoistic bullshit.
Wow.. Yep, I totally agree. Labelling kids as "future soldiers" is actually pretty sick, and it's got nothing at all to do with remembrance.
me4real · 14/11/2021 17:50

@BeyondOurReef @DismantledKing The thing about the Legion is they value what people who've served have done. They think people serving their country is and was a good thing. This isn't new for the Legion, for instance they had a picture of the Queen up in my local one.

A youngster (or family) saying they want to be a soldier is partly saying what soldiers did and do is something heroic and worth emulating. No one should be pushed into this, obviously.

Of course there's a difference between people being conscripted (not necessarily good if they didn't want to go) and people who choose to serve and choose to accept the risks of that (even in a place where they are supported etc.) Most people think people who choose to serve their country in this way are great- the Legion helps support
these after they retire and so on.

HesterShaw1 · 14/11/2021 17:02

@DismantledKing

This is why the Royal British Legion can go fuck itself. Remembrance used to be poignant, ‘never again’. Now look at the shit that they share. I used to buy a poppy every year, but stopped some time after the millennium because of this kind of jingoistic bullshit.
Oh vile 😯
BeyondOurReef · 14/11/2021 16:52

[quote me4real]@DismantledKing There's nothing wrong with that. Some kid's parents are veterans and some want to be soldiers. And that's ok.[/quote]
I think you’ve missed the point there.

Fine if parents are veterans or kids want to become soldiers.

But remembrance is fundamentally not the arena for celebrating any of that.

DismantledKing · 14/11/2021 16:52

[quote me4real]@DismantledKing There's nothing wrong with that. Some kid's parents are veterans and some want to be soldiers. And that's ok.[/quote]
No it isn’t. It’s not remembrance, which is what the RBL is supposed to be all about. It’s promotion of militarism, it’s literally the opposite of what they’re supposed to be about.

me4real · 14/11/2021 16:47

@DismantledKing There's nothing wrong with that. Some kid's parents are veterans and some want to be soldiers. And that's ok.

DismantledKing · 14/11/2021 16:44

This piece makes the same point very well;
anotherangrywoman.com/2015/11/04/i-dont-wear-poppies-and-this-image-perfectly-encapsulates-why/

DismantledKing · 14/11/2021 16:42

This is why the Royal British Legion can go fuck itself. Remembrance used to be poignant, ‘never again’. Now look at the shit that they share.
I used to buy a poppy every year, but stopped some time after the millennium because of this kind of jingoistic bullshit.

No  2 minutes silence at gym. AIBU
XenoBitch · 14/11/2021 02:43

YABVU
If you really wanted to observe the 2 min silence, you would have made sure you were in an environment to do that to start with. A swimming pool is not one!

TirednWorried · 14/11/2021 02:39

People could get out if they wished. But if people have paid for an hours class then i think they should have the option to receive it.

users689033 · 14/11/2021 02:09

@CupCalamity

I feel the same OP, and I'm not from a Forces family and the other side of 50 to you. Do we really live in such a self centred world that we can't spend 2 minutes thinking of others? So sad. I always observe it, it's really not hard. It should just be a given. In my workplace we all stopped and joined together in the waiting room for it.
Do we really live in such a self centred world that we can't spend 2 minutes thinking of others?

"Betty needs CPR, Dave, carry on."

"Sorry, Dave, I can't. Cup from Mumsnet says I'm self centred unless I stop what I'm doing at exactly 11am to stand in silence."

me4real · 14/11/2021 01:19

@Mushypeasandchipstogo All PP's posts must've shown you why instructors/gyms wouldn't tend to do this if they aren't fairly sure that most of their clients would be on board with it.

Like, maybe if I was teaching a class at the Legion to regulars of there.

But in a gym or in most places an instructor will be leading a class for people with a wide range of views. They will also have people from different cultural backgrounds who mightn't even know what was going on or it wouldn't have much relevance to them.

Or people might just want the class they're paying for.

You can bet that if an instructor did do two minutes silence, in a lot of places there would be someone who would complain to the gym about it.

Platax · 13/11/2021 23:02

I agree about competitive poppy wearing. It's ridiculous that TV companies have become terrified to have anyone on their screens not wearing a poppy to the extent that they're fastened to skimpy costumes on Strictly. Surely the point is donating to the charity, not ostentatiously wearing a piece of coloured paper or a shiny badge.

HesterShaw1 · 13/11/2021 17:48

@Hont1986

I only noticed a couple of people wearing poppies this year. Seems to be less and less each year. And I'm one of them tbh, I haven't worn a poppy in years. Don't like the image which I feel it portrays now, which is support for the military.
The last two years there definitely seem to be fewer. I wonder if it's pandemic related somehow
Hont1986 · 13/11/2021 17:32

I only noticed a couple of people wearing poppies this year. Seems to be less and less each year. And I'm one of them tbh, I haven't worn a poppy in years. Don't like the image which I feel it portrays now, which is support for the military.

Kite22 · 13/11/2021 17:17

‘I buy a poppy but don’t actually take one. If someone judges me for not wearing one then that’s their problem. I don’t care.’

I do understand that thinking, but I think many people will see others wearing a poppy, and then that will remind them to get one themselves. If many people don't wear one, then many more will just forget.

All that said, I went the length of our High Street on Monday, and wasn't able to find a single poppy for sale anywhere Sad
I understand there are not the (2nd world war) veterans that used to stand out in the streets collecting, but I am surprised the RBL haven't put out appeals for people to get the poppies out to banks and shops as used to happen.

Daddydog · 13/11/2021 16:31

Was in TK Maxx last year at 11:11... They respectively announced over the Tanoy the two minute silence... Then forgot to turn off the in-store radio. 2 full minutes of Lizzo, Blaming it on her juice ;)

Itawapuddytat · 13/11/2021 15:42

@mustlovegin

Sombre reflection is possible at any time

Do you do this often? When?

I for one do it when I watch a certain episode from Dr Who "The Family of Blood". The ending always brings me tears into my eyes. I always watch it on or around 11/11. I also buy a couple of poppies every year - my grandfather was a pilot in WW2 and I always think of him and his mates, so many of them had never returned home Sad

This year, on 11/11 at 11 o'clock I was working. I am an interpreter, I was interpreting on a police emergency call. Which started before 11 o'clock and took a while to finish. Neither the police officer, nor the distressed person who wanted to report an incident stopped for those 2 minutes, and I didn't stop either. Should we have stopped, really?

... I too come from a country who was occupied and fought against Germany during WW1, and after WW2 was practically given to USSR. We do have our traditions (not for this day though ) - and they are observed by those who choose to do so. Also, it is not an acceptable thing to shame the people who chose not to observe "in the official way" They might do it in their own ways; and in the past people had enough of "toeing the Party line" and being shamed and condemned in public when not doing so - honestly, I still remember those days and I do not want to ever get back to that, most people don't!

Swipe left for the next trending thread