Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Solo Nana Trips

35 replies

SaturdaySummer · 11/11/2021 15:40

AIBU to refuse to let hands off nana take baby on trips alone?

my MiL has repeatedly brought up taking my 5 month old away in the car on trips on her own. I've repeatedly said no firmly. She then went and asked my husband when I went to the bathroom on our last visit and he said yes, to which I firmly said no. I resent that she went behind my back hoping to get the answer she wanted.

She has never changed my baby and always hands him back for me to do it. She doesn't know how much milk he takes for feeds or how often he needs a bottle. She has not seen him for three weeks and has not even text to see how he is so I think it's hair to say she is hands off. She is keen to take my boy on her own to see a friend who lives about an hour and a half drive away. I am obviously not happy with this and can't be sure he would be changed etc when she's never done it up until this point. I really feel they don't have a close relationship and I know I would be anxious the whole time he was away. Is this unreasonable of me?

OP posts:
SaturdaySummer · 11/11/2021 17:28

@RabitWhole

Bit fat nope from me. She wants to take your five-month-old on a 3 hour round trip to see her friend? And then factoring in staying there for a couple of hours, so your baby will be away from you with a relative stranger for 5-6 hours? No way! And I would be telling MIL exactly why.

A three hour round car trip isn't ideal for such a young baby any way, there are limits on how long they should be in car seats for. Use this if you need an excuse

That's a fantastic angle with the car seat and will probably save some aggro with my husband too so thank you.
OP posts:
SaturdaySummer · 11/11/2021 17:27

@DrinkFeckArseBrick

Nope. I'm normally fairly pro mother in laws on here and dont really get people wanting to keep their baby with them at all times, but in this case, she hasnt bonded with your baby, she doesnt know them well, she basically just wants to use them to show off, in way that is probably going to be a bit uncomfortable (3 hours in the car) and distressing for the baby (spending all that time with her when she doesnt know them)
Thank you. I agree, Sometimes there's a lot of mil bashing on here. We get on well as people in all honesty but I don't have enough confidence in her as a nana to hand my son over
OP posts:
Chocolatewheatos · 11/11/2021 16:33

I say this as my 6 month old baby is currently on a day out with my dad. If you don't trust her, she doesn't take him. I trust my dad will be able to calm my crying baby, that he'll feed him what I've told to feed him. That he'll keep him safe and change his nappy and put his cream on. I trust that he will do his absolute best to look after my baby as his top priority. I don't even trust my mum that much, the only people who have looked after my child without me are his dad and my dad.
Just say no. And that she's making you uncomfortable to keep asking.

JumperandJacket · 11/11/2021 16:14

Tricky one. My MIL was similar and once took toddler DS to the supermarket in his buggy - what can go wrong, I thought?

She got back and told us a complicated story about not being able to find what she wanted in the supermarket and having to spend 20 minutes going round other shops. She then finished her story by saying “And when I got back to
the supermarket, someone had given DS a packet of sweets!”

She had left DS in his buggy in the supermarket while she’s gone other shops for 20 minutes. Just…I can’t imagine how you’d think to do that. I know people left babies in prams outside local shops when they popped inside in the 70s but this was something else…

Anyway, my point is trust your instincts. If you don’t think she can do it, it’s fine to say no and your partner should back you up.

RabitWhole · 11/11/2021 16:11

Bit fat nope from me. She wants to take your five-month-old on a 3 hour round trip to see her friend? And then factoring in staying there for a couple of hours, so your baby will be away from you with a relative stranger for 5-6 hours? No way! And I would be telling MIL exactly why.

A three hour round car trip isn't ideal for such a young baby any way, there are limits on how long they should be in car seats for. Use this if you need an excuse

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 11/11/2021 16:11

Nope. I'm normally fairly pro mother in laws on here and dont really get people wanting to keep their baby with them at all times, but in this case, she hasnt bonded with your baby, she doesnt know them well, she basically just wants to use them to show off, in way that is probably going to be a bit uncomfortable (3 hours in the car) and distressing for the baby (spending all that time with her when she doesnt know them)

SaturdaySummer · 11/11/2021 16:08

@AperolWhore

Your baby = your rules and your husband should back you 100%. If MIL want to do things with baby she needs to make constant effort day to day rather than swanning in and out.
Thank you, that's my thoughts too. I suspect it's so she can play the doting nana as my offer to drive them was rejected, she wants to go alone with the baby
OP posts:
SaturdaySummer · 11/11/2021 16:07

@Sauvignonblanket

Not unreasonable at all. But if your OH was up for it he could take her and the baby to see the friend?
He doesn't drive. I offered to take her in the car and she said no, she wants to go alone. I just dont understand why she thinks I would be happy with this when she makes so little effort?
OP posts:
Sauvignonblanket · 11/11/2021 15:47

Not unreasonable at all. But if your OH was up for it he could take her and the baby to see the friend?

AperolWhore · 11/11/2021 15:44

Your baby = your rules and your husband should back you 100%. If MIL want to do things with baby she needs to make constant effort day to day rather than swanning in and out.