Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD wants to do different interest badges at Brownies, but can’t AIBU?

170 replies

TheLoveOfBrownies · 11/11/2021 14:15

DD is 7, started Brownies in September and recently done her promise.

She did Rainbows for a year before that.

The interest badges that are done at home, DD wants to do different ones to the ones offered but Brown Owl keeps saying she can’t, she can only do 1 interest badge per term and she must do the badge suggested by Brown Owl, Rainbows was the same, she was not awarded any interest badge she did that was not the one suggested. So for example she wanted to Animal Lover, Drawing, Fruit and Veg, Nature, Recycling and Book Lover at Rainbows and they made her do Construction, Agility and Family Tree.

It feels really restrictive and not in the spirit of Guiding, especially as I as her mum am giving up time for her to do the badges outside of the meetings.

I’ve offered to pay for the badges and was told they can’t stop me but they won’t be verified or given out in her meetings, I offered to help with the meetings, and was told yes but they have a programme they follow so can’t change the badges they offer, I even offered to have a small group of the girls and do an interest badge with all of them but was told no, it has to be the badge for that term only.

DD loves Brownies so I won’t take her out but it does feel unfair that the interest badges are supposed to be pick and choose and we don’t get that option.

I’ve heard the other Rainbows and Brownies Groups locally are the same and don’t let you choose your interest badge. So changing groups won’t help.

It just feels a bit restrictive, surely she should be able to do 2 badges per term (1 each half term) at least? Especially as we've been told that there will no sleepovers or camps until at least October 2022 so she won't get those badges towards her theme awards either.

AIBU? And are all Guiding groups the same now?

OP posts:
Harlequin1088 · 12/11/2021 07:05

Blimey, Brownies has got a bit militant since we were kids, hasn't it??

That's such a shame that your daughter is effectively having her interests stifled because the badge she wants to do isn't on the "approved" list. If she's wanting to do extra badges alongside the ones approved for that term, then what's the problem?? If anything they should be giving her a badge for going above and beyond in her dedication to Brownies!

When I was a kid, I did loads of additional badges alongside the ones we did as a group in Brownies.

In fact, I once famously took on the Gardening badge whilst knowing absolutely nothing about gardening and when the Brown Owl asked me to name some common weeds, I shrugged my shoulders and said, "I don't know the actual names for them but if you took me out into the garden, I could point out which ones are weeds". Still got the badge! I swear, 7-year-old me was an absolute riot 😂

PaperMonster · 12/11/2021 06:58

Has anyone posted this link? Their unit leader needs to read this! www.girlguiding.org.uk/what-we-do/our-badges-and-activities/programme-for-every-girl/interest-badges/

Beamur · 12/11/2021 06:53

Girls should have free choice for interest badges. That's kind of the point!
Ask the Leader to make sure DD hasn't misunderstood. If you're sure it is, then escalate it up until you get a sensible answer. If the Leader us restricting it and refusing to award badges she's running it wrong.

RedHelenB · 12/11/2021 06:45

So she can do them, just not get the public acclaim? I'd crack on and do them then.

earlydoors42 · 12/11/2021 06:35

When i joined Brownies, the first badge they made me do was House Orderly. It had a picture of a broom on it. We had to do lots of types of cleaning and housework. My mum was horrified!

saltinesandcoffeecups · 12/11/2021 01:44

Ok this is the extreme version, but I think I’d go rogue and push the case up the ladder if need be. Let the leaders explain to their structure why they are limiting opportunities. Honestly this is why I think Girl Scouts suck (I’m in the US but it sounds similar). Too stifling.

The whole point is to let the girls grow and learn and become independent women. But honestly the programs are geared toward some weird feel good, everyone else’s feelings at your own expense, mushy, #bekind experience.

It should be about independence, personal growth, and skill building.

Ughh sorry this is a huge pet hate of mine.

Gooseysgirl · 12/11/2021 00:40

This doesn't sound right to me and not in the spirit of the programme at all. We have the opposite problem... I have a stack of badges that I need to sew on to DD's brownie blanket!! The owls take a genuine interest in the girls as individuals and jump on any opportunity to encourage them to achieve badges in addition to the ones they work on during meetings.

00100001 · 12/11/2021 00:22

@LSLLM

*pressed post too quick

What I’m saying is leaders aren’t bothering to keep to the programme, which has been implemented long enough now. Everyone’s doing things their own way and it’s frustrating the girls & parents.

You should complain.

They can do 20% off program time, but with the younger units,they actually struggle to fit the programme in sometimes as meetings are often shorter than Guides, and Brownies/Rainbows are absent more often, because they're oftentimes not in as much control about their attendance.

PaddingtonStareBare · 11/11/2021 22:45

That's crap, I'm no longer in a unit, but still have my Leadership Qualification and can award badges.
I'd give her the interest badge as long as I saw the evidence!
A friend of mines DD had a Brown Owl who was a bit militant an arsehole and wouldn't award her certain badges due not 'fulfilling the criteria' she did, and was so upset at not getting her final badge, friend was telling me this over a glass of wine one night, I asked to see what her DD had done.
I took a look that weekend and awarded her the badge myself (lucky enough to have a GG shop nearby) and signed her badge book. Apparently BO was furious but tough, I can certainly award them and will do! I'd do the same in a heartbeat for other Brownies.
When we attended some local events with other leaders, we'd always come away a bit shocked at how some of the older ones treated their units. Yes I know their volunteers but that's never an excuse to be a miserable arsehole to young girls, and then wonder why they struggle to maintain their numbers :(

Courtier · 11/11/2021 22:34

Yep. I remember this at brownies when I was a kid in the early 2000s. I barely got any badges because they didn't let us pick them and tbh it felt like we were there just to mess around and make cards 🙄 I must've got maybe 5... in 3 years.

If we'd been allowed in scouts back then I'd have opted for that.

LSLLM · 11/11/2021 22:23

*pressed post too quick

What I’m saying is leaders aren’t bothering to keep to the programme, which has been implemented long enough now. Everyone’s doing things their own way and it’s frustrating the girls & parents.

LSLLM · 11/11/2021 22:21

I found when the new programme came in, leaders decided to pick and choose what they wanted to do. Some do the program correctly, 👏 others won’t even look at the current interest badges anymore, and use unofficial badges bought from other units who sell them to fundraise.

This might be ok to some, but it’s a bit of a pisser buying the official badge book at £8 as a parent only to be told they don’t do those badges and don’t care what GG say. Also results in a bunch of randomly sized and designed badges.

PaperMonster · 11/11/2021 22:17

As other leaders have said, your unit is doing it wrong. She can do any interest badge she likes at any point. Wish I could get mine to do interest badges!!

user1000000000009 · 11/11/2021 22:09

Try cubs. Way more flexible that that.

underneaththeash · 11/11/2021 22:04

Even that's not clear! So they have to do 3 hours of green activities and then green skill builder + a green interest badge to get their theme award for that section.

OP pm me and I'll call you if it's not clear.

underneaththeash · 11/11/2021 22:02

I'm Brown Owl. No overlap with scouts (in terms of badges), we have overlap in our village as we share stuff, premises etc.

I think you might be confused with interest badges and skill builders.

So, the girls can do any interest badges when they want, eg baking, archeology, dancing etc.
We then do the skill builders eg first aid, camping in the meetings

BUT they also have to do the unit meeting activities - 3 hours for that colour in order to get that theme award - to qualify for the bronze/silver award.

So this term in my unit we are doing (mainly) - Green have adventure theme award:
So in order to get the theme award for the section (to put towards the bronze/silver/gold award) they need to do three things

  1. Al skill builder (at BrowniesC) we 've done aCmp 2 (fire fighting stuff, tent building and torch games)
  2. 3 hours of Green UMA (at brownies) connected to that theme - we've done a night hike, fire building, first aid, hedgehog huts and space stuff.
  3. A Green connected interest badge at home - so Aviation, Space, Archeology

I agree, it is unnecessarily complicated, I'm used to doing presentations and I struggled to get across how it worked to the parents>.

babypeach · 11/11/2021 21:49

My daughter gave up brownies and moved to scouts precisely because of this sort of thing. Compared to other brownie packs in different areas hers did very little and we’re very restrictive . Lovely leaders but there was never a sleepover, trip or anything. Just decorating biscuits, cards, crafts etc and badges that could be got from those. She felt it was like a club aimed at a very particular type of girl stereotype which was fine but dull for her.

Scouts on the other hand is brilliant! Exciting even over zoom, plenty of variety and opportunities to do activities and badges. Same area and same local resources but very different attitude on our area.

00100001 · 11/11/2021 21:35

Ours was a un official rule, and we used it maybe .... Five times in 10 years???
But if your DD could show she liked after an existing animal etc that's fine. We wouldn't have expected her to get a new pet for example!

TheLoveOfBrownies · 11/11/2021 21:20

Not little evidence with little effort is what I mean, as she helps with our cat daily. She has tasks daily associated to those.

OP posts:
TheLoveOfBrownies · 11/11/2021 21:19

@00100001

The only rule we had for interest badges, is you couldn't do them "by accident"

Let's pretend there's a badge called "learn a new skill". And you'd started gymnastics,and had just learnt how to do a backup. You weren't allowed to just flip through the book and go "oh well I l learned to backflip last month I've earned that badge".

You'd have to do it the other way round. See that the badge exists, check the clauses, then resolve to learn the new skill (even if it is a backflip in gymnastics).

Kind of made the girls take it a bit more seriously, and consider their choices, rather than a way to 'blag' their way to an award.

The only one she could of done straight away with little evidence was Animal Lover for Rainbows, all the other she'd have had to work for, there are some badges she has no chance of getting like the Growing/Nature stuff as we have no garden but if we can we'd skip those.
OP posts:
00100001 · 11/11/2021 21:02

The only rule we had for interest badges, is you couldn't do them "by accident"

Let's pretend there's a badge called "learn a new skill". And you'd started gymnastics,and had just learnt how to do a backup. You weren't allowed to just flip through the book and go "oh well I l learned to backflip last month I've earned that badge".

You'd have to do it the other way round. See that the badge exists, check the clauses, then resolve to learn the new skill (even if it is a backflip in gymnastics).

Kind of made the girls take it a bit more seriously, and consider their choices, rather than a way to 'blag' their way to an award.

takingmytimeonmyride · 11/11/2021 19:14

I'm a scout leader, so no idea how Girl Guides runs. But if any of our scouts do an activity that covers a badge outside of scouting then we tick it off.

Eg. Dance classes, gymnastics, counts towards physical recreation. We have a scout who is an amazing artist, so he got his art badge by showing us his work, and we did some with the troop as well.

I used to be a Beaver leader, and the same rules applied there. Any badge they wanted to work on at home we were happy to award with some proof they'd done it.

Obviously we have a programme we run termly but we are always happy to spare some time for scouts to show off anything they want.

Becles · 11/11/2021 18:41

And a unit not doing sleepovers/ camps for another year is just being shit. They are allowed already and have been able to since September without the excessive Covid measures that were being obstructive to that point (and only really suitable for older girls being independent in small groups). Some units are more active than others which is fair enough as different units have different resources, but to put a year's limit on it when all else is viable is crap. If it is a practical issue such as leader avaliability, then it's unlikely that they'd be forecasting that to be resolved in Oct 2022

It's not shut to be cautious about running a trip or residential at this time. Unlike scouts girlguiding has taken a straightforward system and introduced a 12 week minimum for leaders to get permission for a residential.

I'm a keen trip and residential leader, but I'm on my knees with work, family and caring responsibilities. I don't have a stable team of volunteers and I'm on my own for every aspect of outside meeting planning.

I've run 3 trips since we went back face to face and got a sleepover in February. I'm doing it for the girls but I'm doing the paperwork and planning at 11pm because that's the only time I have. Scouting work in groups whereas the unit team are pretty much on their own.

I'm planning the sleepover but have been open that if the numbers rise like they have been or I'm not feeling safe or it could impact my caring responsibilities I'll cancel.

00100001 · 11/11/2021 18:20

@MLMshouldbeillegal

It's a long time since I was a Brownie/Guide, but remember having badges "examined" by someone other than the group leaders. Always a formality, but I had to explain what I'd done/learned to someone who led another unit or was some other approved person by the leaders.

Is that still the case and could that explain what's going on? That they are struggling to get people to look over what the girls have done?

It really isn't that complicated, the badges are fairly straightforward.

For example it might be something along the lines of... Grow something from seed and plan a bumblebee garden. So you'd have to show some sort of evidence that you grew (for example) some cress. You could do that by making a video, creating a collage, doing a presentation, taking photos, writing a diary and drawing the plants etc (however the girl wants... hence Girl Led) and then she might draw a picture of her bumblebee garden, be it with paints, crayons, on the computer...or she might write about it etc. Then when she thinks she's completed it, just show the leaders.

It really isn't a burden for the leaders...

ftw163532 · 11/11/2021 18:00

@Viviennemary

Who would be a volunteer and give up their time for this hassle. Either accept their rules or join a different brownie pack.
I don't think you understand how this works. Volunteers don't have the right to invent their own rules. Just like employees can't.

It's the volunteers who need to accept the rules of the organisation they signed up to. If implementing the programme they voluntarily signed up to isn't for them they can leave.

Some people are ridiculous. Being a volunteer doesn't mean you get to act like the unit is your kingdom. Hmm