Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for getting annoyed over weight comments?

32 replies

buntybanana · 11/11/2021 09:19

About twice a year I go away on a weekend staycation with two of my friends from uni for a catch up (living in different parts of the country, busy lives etc). We're all getting the point now where we're in stable relationships/marriages and ready to think about kids (all late 20s).

Both my friends have always been overweight (this is relevant) and their lifestyles don't involve exercise or healthy eating really. Now this is no judgement on my behalf - I think they're gorgeous and living their best life. However, I'm slim - partially genetics, partially long distance running / no alcohol / healthy eating. I care a lot about my health and love exercise & an outdoorsy lifestyle.

When we discussed trying to get pregnant soon, both my friends said that they hoped during pregnancy I would finally get fat because I had 'escaped it for so long'. Now I know this was kind of a joke, but I'm actually quite annoyed about it. I feel that I haven't escaped being fat, I've worked hard to be fit!! I'm probably overreacting but I keep thinking about this comment and getting annoyed. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
buntybanana · 12/11/2021 09:47

@MollysDolly and @Cheerychirpy you're absolutely right - it's not necessarily fat, it's pregnant & everyone is different. Thanks for the advice - I'll let it go as it seems to be a reflection on them.

@TheAverageUser good on your husband!! Love this. For some people it takes so much sacrifice & a lot of people don't see behind the scenes - they just assume you're lucky and they're not.

@Natty13 this is awful and I hear you. It's a good reply, I might use the same one!

OP posts:
stereeotype · 11/11/2021 20:16

@Siameasy

Yanbu I hate hearing about slim privilege 🙄 when I sacrifice a lot of pleasure to be slim They’re jealous.
Exactly this!
Natty13 · 11/11/2021 18:28

I'm in a similar situation with overweight friends always "joking" that they hope ill out on weight or whatever. These are friends who knew me when I was almost hospitalised from an eating disorder and have visited me in hospital when I've been admitted with the long term complications from it btw.

I just used to reply "I most likely won't, since I'll still eat healthily and exercise. And if I do, being healthy is more important than my dress size."

TheAverageUser · 11/11/2021 17:58

I was dieting for my wedding and I had a friend who came around and said 'oh you're so lucky you find it easy to lose weight'. My DH piped up and said 'you mean she luckily goes to the gym, walks the dog twice a day, goes to a boxing class and is pretty much always hungry'.

I loved him for that, I'm sure she was kidding or it was flippant but keeping weight off or losing it is hard graft.

Chargreen · 11/11/2021 17:54
Biscuit
Almostmenopausal · 11/11/2021 17:52

Oh for goodness sake OP..... Is there some other issue with these particular friends? You seem to be searching for something to take offence to?

Cheerychirpy · 11/11/2021 12:46

Having a baby doesn’t make many women fat. Having a baby makes many women thinner than before. If maternity leave is spent going for long buggy walks / runs (as many new mums do) you can easily end up much fitter than before. It’s when you are on baby 2 and have to juggle a toddler and a baby that long walks are harder and losing weight after takes slightly more effort.

But for some body types / genes having a baby does make you fat.

ImprobablePuffin · 11/11/2021 12:39

Dig not dog

ImprobablePuffin · 11/11/2021 12:39

I've always found people who make these comments are usually just jealous.

IMO that is not an excuse. People should not be commenting (or joking) about other people's appearances. It doesn't come from a place of love, does it.

FWIW I have always struggled with my weight and my sister is basically a model. Sometimes I do wish I could be as able as her to control my eating etc but I would never make a dog at her about it.

Judith0000 · 11/11/2021 11:57

@Singingtherapy

I understand what you mean OP but just from another perspective - I also work very hard at trying to be slim. I run 5k regularly, eat healthily, frequently sit with a black coffee in cafes when everyone else is having lattes and cake, choose a salad over burger and chips etc etc. None of it works, I'm still obese. I'm completely caught up in the dieting makes you fat scenario. I do well for a few weeks and then the cravings become overwhelming and my binge eating makes an appearance. So in my mind you HAVE escaped getting fat, because you and I make the same effort but you're slim and I'm fat.
Does OP binge eat though? If she does, then I agree, you are both making the same effort but with different results. If not, then you are not making the same effort, and therefore you would expect to see different results surely?
maofteens · 11/11/2021 11:13

I agree it's a reflection on how they feel about themselves rather than you. I'm sure they know you work hard to be fit. I've had friends moan about how having kids has 'ruined their bodies' when they do no exercises or modify their food.
It is insensitive though so you could come back with 'yes running 5 miles a day and watching my intake is really lucky'...

Singingtherapy · 11/11/2021 11:12

I understand what you mean OP but just from another perspective - I also work very hard at trying to be slim. I run 5k regularly, eat healthily, frequently sit with a black coffee in cafes when everyone else is having lattes and cake, choose a salad over burger and chips etc etc. None of it works, I'm still obese. I'm completely caught up in the dieting makes you fat scenario. I do well for a few weeks and then the cravings become overwhelming and my binge eating makes an appearance. So in my mind you HAVE escaped getting fat, because you and I make the same effort but you're slim and I'm fat.

SecretaryOfNagriculture · 11/11/2021 11:00

They’re jealous. They’re also pretty dim if they don’t know it’s not acceptable to talk about people’s weight and know words can hurt.

MollysDolly · 11/11/2021 10:56

Two overweight people, who clearly don't like that they are (hence to be thin is "escaping" from this) but don't exercise and eat poorly, have made a shitty comment to you.

Take it in context. They didn't say it to make you feel bad. They feel bad, and the thought of you being overweight makes them feel good. "You're like us now" so we feel justified in our choices.

Don't feel angry at them. Feel sorry for them. If they wanted to "escape" being overweight, (and assuming it's for the normal reasons as you haven't mentioned any medical conditions) then they could exercise and eat healthily. They don't.

Let this one go. But if it's brought up again, I'd be inclined to respond along the lines of "I won't be overweight, I'll be pregnant. And once I've had the baby, I'll do what I do now, exercise and eat well, to keep my weight healthy"

I've always been tiny (I'm a lazy swine, it's genetics) but the number of people when I got pregnant who declared "I can't wait to see you fat!!" Always the overweight friends saying this. Not one of of my thin friends did. It's a reflection on them, not you.

SmileyClare · 11/11/2021 10:43

@buntybanana

I probably should have mentioned I struggled with an eating disorder as a teenager and these kinds of comments bring up stress / negative thoughts
That changes things slightly. Are your friends aware? Now might be the time to share that or remind them of this comes up again in conversation Smile

As an aside, pregnancy doesn't make you fat. You're carrying a baby and your body's preparing to feed it. There's no reason you can't continue exercising, eating well ,return to your usual weight and continue with your love of running.

buntybanana · 11/11/2021 10:42

@honeylulu

It sounds like a joke but there is likely to be some truth in it.

My mother has always struggled with her weight (I've always been slim) and when I announced my first pregnancy (her first grandchild!) one of her first comments was along the lines of "haha it will be so funny to finally see you fat. You'll never go back to bring slim either haha!" She was absolutely gleeful.

I did go back to being slim and she actually seemed pissed off about it.

Gosh this is awful!! Sorry you had to deal with that - sounds toxic
OP posts:
RosiePosieDozy · 11/11/2021 10:38

Seems like jealousy to me. I would ignore for now. If anything similar is said again, I would tell them you don't like them making comments about your weight and it's nasty.

Gothisway · 11/11/2021 10:33

Yeah that’s really not on. They’re toxic bitches for thinking that.

Therealjudgejudy · 11/11/2021 10:29

Not on really.

I'm guessing if you joked about them being over weight there would be an issue...

buntybanana · 11/11/2021 10:26

(Their comments not yours!) thanks for all the responses!

OP posts:
buntybanana · 11/11/2021 10:25

I probably should have mentioned I struggled with an eating disorder as a teenager and these kinds of comments bring up stress / negative thoughts

OP posts:
SmileyClare · 11/11/2021 10:24

@girlmom21

If it was a joke, and you're good friends, I wouldn't say anything.
I agree, it's mildly irritating but people really seem to take huge offense these days about everything. It was a throw away comment, I don't think it's necessary to "call it out".
honeylulu · 11/11/2021 10:24

It sounds like a joke but there is likely to be some truth in it.

My mother has always struggled with her weight (I've always been slim) and when I announced my first pregnancy (her first grandchild!) one of her first comments was along the lines of "haha it will be so funny to finally see you fat. You'll never go back to bring slim either haha!" She was absolutely gleeful.

I did go back to being slim and she actually seemed pissed off about it.

girlmom21 · 11/11/2021 10:15

If it was a joke, and you're good friends, I wouldn't say anything.

DontWiltMySpinachPlease · 11/11/2021 10:10

There's no need to comment on anyone else's body at all, it's no one's business.