Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Entitled male tradesmen.

186 replies

EmKayEm · 11/11/2021 08:46

Ok.
Had an issue with electrics, kitchen keeps tripping out.
Called a couple of people to come and look at the issue and quote.
One came yesterday, gave me a price, agreed the job, and arranged to sort today. I sorted with work to WFH for the day, as can do stuff around the power being off for a couple of hours.

Last night the guy messages me -
''Um...just wondering...''
"???"
"Are you attached?"
"Why? Does that have anything to do with my kitchen?"

He leaves it a bit, then comes back with

"You can't possibly be single"

Then

"Hope this doesn't come across as creepy lol"

I ignored this. But he still went on. If I had had a bad experience in dating maybe he could change that. He is, of course, "a really nice guy".

I messaged back that my personal life was personal and I would rather keep this strictly professional.

This morning, due at 9am, messages me at 08:15 to say he can't come today due to another job.
I message back to ask when he can, he is a bit vague. I tell him not to to bother, I will contact someone else.
He then messages me to say he was only being nice, I should take it as a compliment etc.

WHAT THE FUCK IS IT WITH ENTITLED CHILDREN DEMANDING ATTENTION???

OP posts:
CharityDingle · 11/11/2021 15:02

And of course there was the joiner who came a couple of weeks ago to repair a broken stair and who directed all of his questions, comments about what he was doing, and all of his chitchat about" how lovely these old Georgian terraces are, they don't make 'em like they use to" to my daughter's visiting 19 year old boyfriend. And no, the boyfriend has no interest in architecture or woodwork, and was very confused. Still, any random male must have more authority over and interest in my home than I, the middle aged woman who bought and paid for it.

Ugh, brings back memories of crap car salesmen. I brought my brother with me, one time, because he is knowledgeable about cars.

However it was made 100% clear to the salesman that it was my money, and my car, to be.

He didn't get the sale, mostly because he addressed himself completely to THE MAN, despite our best attempts.

girlmom21 · 11/11/2021 14:59

@IntermittentParps ah that's understandable. My thinking was if he's over-zealous (perhaps being a bit generous there now that I understand what you meant earlier!), and he doesn't 'get' the cues that suggest a woman isn't interested, like the OP's initial brush offs, he could end up being quite intimidating in person.

He seems quite a strange character either way so I'm glad he cancelled for OP's sake

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 11/11/2021 14:58

you could’ve just said ‘no thanks’

Why thank a man who was being a twat?

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 11/11/2021 14:56

She just gave him crappy replies and was rude to him instead.

You mean she didn't answer a question that had bugger all to do with the only reason he had her contact details - the job she had hired him to do?

He asked her a personal question.

She shut that down.

He carried on.

Why on Earth you, and others, think she should have said anything else, given him any information about her private life, or made up something to put him off, is beyond me.

"That has nothing to do with the job I am hiring you to undertake" is the ONLY asnwer she needed give.

Though @EmKayEm I too would have let him go at that point. I am self employed, go into people's houses every day and have never asked a single one of them a question about themselves.

IntermittentParps · 11/11/2021 14:53

@girlmom21

Genuine question absolutely not intended to be goady - lots of posters are suggesting he should have gone to the OP's house and carried out the work first to "suss her out".

Is this not more predatory than making his feelings very clear?

Personally id be much more comfortable saying "actually you've made me feel quite uncomfortable - please don't come to my house, I'll find another tradesman" via text than I would doing that in person.

'suss her out' can, out of context, sound a bit... well, suss Grin, I grant you. But everyone on here, as far as I understand their posts, means it in the sense of seeing if she mentions a partner/how they get on/if she seems to like him etc. Which is not predatory, but the same as if you meet someone at a party or in an office or wherever, and you both 'suss out', in real time and in context, what you think the deal might be.

So not at all like his behaviour of messaging persistently even after she'd sent a mild warning message and then ignored his further ones.
I can't speak for everyone, but that's what I mean when I say 'predatory' here.

1forAll74 · 11/11/2021 14:43

It would kind of make me laugh really, as you know that there are some types of blokes, who have stupid brains that don't work properly.Then they go around making stupid and inane comments to women, and think they are being a smartass and are desirable, ha ha.

girlmom21 · 11/11/2021 14:39

Genuine question absolutely not intended to be goady - lots of posters are suggesting he should have gone to the OP's house and carried out the work first to "suss her out".

Is this not more predatory than making his feelings very clear?

Personally id be much more comfortable saying "actually you've made me feel quite uncomfortable - please don't come to my house, I'll find another tradesman" via text than I would doing that in person.

FatBettyintheCoop · 11/11/2021 14:22

@SeenYourArse

I didn’t mean invent a bloody partner obviously I presumed by your hysterical outrage you had a partner already! So you could’ve just said ‘no thanks’ that simple if you’d been polite and not condescending as though of course you wouldn’t date a tradesman, then you wouldn’t have had this issue. Yes of course he’d ask a bloke out for a pint if he was attracted to h8m, that’s what normal people do if they see someone they might like as a partner they ask if they might feel the same! Not complicated really at all how else should people find a relationship?!!
‘Hysterical outrage’ ???

The only hysterical outrage I can see here is yours, because no-one is agreeing with you and your 1950’s outdated views on dating.

Why should the OP have to be the one who is polite and say ‘no, thanks’?

What if she was gay? Should she still be thanking him for giving her completely unwanted attention?

If the man was genuinely interested in a relationship, he’d have sussed out the situation whilst he carried a professional job and asked her afterwards in a polite manner. You know, like a normal person. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Instead, he thought he’d try it on and see if he can get a bit of cock action whilst he’s working at her home.

Vile misogynistic behaviour and people like you condone it.

Just Why?

Journeyofthedragons · 11/11/2021 14:18

Absolutely, men like this shouldn't be allowed access to a space where women are alone.

AngeloMysterioso · 11/11/2021 14:12

@changeornot

Personally, I would NOT report him on social media. At the end of the day what he did was socially clumsy and unprofessional but it was not a sackable offence. Posting on social media would result in him losing his entire livelihood.

Possibly for years. I get it- I would be annoyed as well- state to his boss- if you felt his behaviour was inappropriate.

Sorry, I would not pubically demand the sack of someone who made a clumsy mistake - it's entirely disproportionate to the situation.

I find the general culture of - one mistake- lose your entire livelihood.

It's mob culture and creates an unpleasant and divisive atmosphere online and has very real-life consequences.

You’re right, let’s just allow him to spend the rest of his professional life sending inappropriate messages to women who have hired him to do work in their homes, before cancelling the job at the last minute if he doesn’t get the reaction he’s hoping for. We wouldn’t want the poor bugger to suffer the consequences of his own actions now would we? That would be so unkind.

Fuckers like this deserve to lose their careers. That’s fine by me. More work for the decent ones.

MrsToothyBitch · 11/11/2021 13:58

Ugh how creepy and childish OP. Although perhaps you've dodged a bullet not having him in the house after that!

I'm not sure some of them realise how even just making a nice comment comes across when you're letting them into what should be your safest space. I contacted a man to clean my oven recently. I'd used him before ages ago, no problem, but when he called me back on WhatsApp this time, he mentioned he liked my profile photo and it looked good. I'm sure he didn't mean it creepily but it did make me regret booking a time I'd be home alone. Luckily I had to cancel and I've rearranged for a day DP will be WFH. It does make me feel safer.

user1497207191 · 11/11/2021 13:47

@Phobiaphobic

Usually I just get the fuckers demanding I stop whatever I'm doing and make them a cup of tea.
I never get that. Usually they bring their own or go off to the nearest garage or shop to use their costa machine. I leave them to it and after a few hours if I notice they don't appear to have made their own arrangements and havn't disappeared for breaks, I'll offer them a drink.
IntermittentParps · 11/11/2021 13:17

[quote changeornot]@IntermittentParps
But if you are self-employed this is about Cancel culture. It doesn't just happen to JK Rowling.
I've been self-employed too. Fair enough if you've done a job they didn't like- or behaviour they didn't approve of that a colleague/ client may not recommend you- but that is a world of difference than that client trashing your name all over your Insta/linkedin/Twitter page- used to promote business. I agree if feedback -is given it should be on google review- and kept fair, and to the point.[/quote]
You seem to have misread or not understood what I've said. I have not advocated or defended 'trashing' anyone.
Here it is again:
I said, 'Something like the message suggested by ifIwerenotanandroid isn't 'public humiliation', it would be a fair and true review.' and talked about the OP 'leaving a factual review'.

Oddly, in another post you cite and agree with ifIwerenotanandroid just as I do. Did you fail to see that I also did this?

dropitlikeitsloth · 11/11/2021 13:16

@dworky

The worst is "you can't be single". Why not, must I go out with any person who shows an attraction to me?
@dworky it’s because men assume women can’t be single of their own choosing
changeornot · 11/11/2021 13:12

@IntermittentParps
But if you are self-employed this is about Cancel culture. It doesn't just happen to JK Rowling.
I've been self-employed too. Fair enough if you've done a job they didn't like- or behaviour they didn't approve of that a colleague/ client may not recommend you- but that is a world of difference than that client trashing your name all over your Insta/linkedin/Twitter page- used to promote business. I agree if feedback -is given it should be on google review- and kept fair, and to the point.

Cordyceps · 11/11/2021 13:09

@Phobiaphobic

Usually I just get the fuckers demanding I stop whatever I'm doing and make them a cup of tea.
You should have seen the look on my last tradesman's face when I told him I had jasmine green tea or calming chamomile, or decaf coffee and oat milk if he fancied that instead 😹
OneTC · 11/11/2021 13:07

Can't believe some people are saying this is alright, it's fucking terrible behaviour

I even think contacting someone after is very dodgy territory. It's still an unprofessional use of that person's contact information that you only have access to owing to your professional position.

Cordyceps · 11/11/2021 13:06

I didn't like it when posters were encouraging the woman to ask her builder for a date because it could make him uncomfortable and it's not not nice or appropriate to hit on people who you know in a work capacity, especially if you are paying them or they have to be nice to you as part of their job (bosses hitting on juniors, diners and drinkers hitting on waiters and bar staff, customers asking out shop assistants, and of course tradespeople by their customers).

However- it is NOT the same as this situation. The woman asking out her builder risks just making him potentially uncomfortable, not scared. She doesn't know where he lives. It's not common for women to send threatening, insulting, or disgusting messages when they are turned down. Women rarely become violent and attack or even murder the men who reject them.

Phobiaphobic · 11/11/2021 12:57

Usually I just get the fuckers demanding I stop whatever I'm doing and make them a cup of tea.

changeornot · 11/11/2021 12:56

@ifIwerenotanandroid

I agree in my opinion - if you wanted to give public feedback -This would be a fairer response- and would get the message to the tradesmen and customers. Then posting all over social media.
Writing a standard review-Didn't turn up to do the job. Felt his attitude was unprofessional etc..

IntermittentParps · 11/11/2021 12:56

[quote changeornot]@IntermittentParps
I agree his behaviour was crap- We can't know his real intention.

And I would be annoyed as well- and would call him out.

But I would not publically humiliate him on social media- as because he is self-employed- he would lose his business.

If you think that is a fair response- then fair enough.

Voting Brexit wasn't meant as an analogy- Just describing that I've seen all sorts of behaviours as being described on social media- as a reason to sack someone. It's the culture of cancel, shame, no mistakes allowed- that I'm against.[/quote]
Something like the message suggested by ifIwerenotanandroid isn't 'public humiliation', it would be a fair and true review. If he is prepared to behave like that in the course of his work then he should be prepared to accept a review of how he behaves as consequences. Live by the sword, die by the fucking sword.

I'm self-employed too and, while in my line of work I don't get 'reviewed' like tradespeople do, I know very well that the equivalent happens in that clients and potential clients talk about me/recommend me/probably sometimes don't recommend me.

We are not talking here about cancel culture (for reference, I have deep reservations about that). We're talking about an honest review of work/pre-work carried out. If an electrician had NOT been creepy to the OP, had come and done the job and then the electrics had blown again and a fault in his work had been found, she would have been justified in leaving a factual review saying so. That is not cancel culture, it's just peer review. And, as I say, if you're self-employed it is part of the deal.

Snugglepumpkin · 11/11/2021 12:52

Making sexual advances in a professional situation is not 'just a little mistake & if it costs someone their job then good.

Women of any age should be safe to hire a tradesman to work in their home without fear of being treated like they are hanging out on a street corner in a red light district with a sign saying "free".

Yaya26 · 11/11/2021 12:50

@MyrrAgain

Why did he ask beforehand?? Do the job and be professional. Then ask afterwards. By text. So you can say no if you want to and don't have to see him again.

Much more normal - people meet people they fancy through work stuff all the time.

I was thinking this.
changeornot · 11/11/2021 12:47

@IntermittentParps
I agree his behaviour was crap- We can't know his real intention.

And I would be annoyed as well- and would call him out.

But I would not publically humiliate him on social media- as because he is self-employed- he would lose his business.

If you think that is a fair response- then fair enough.

Voting Brexit wasn't meant as an analogy- Just describing that I've seen all sorts of behaviours as being described on social media- as a reason to sack someone. It's the culture of cancel, shame, no mistakes allowed- that I'm against.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 11/11/2021 12:45

Surely it's fair enough to leave a review stating what happened, i.e. that he agreed to do the job, arranged a start day & then cancelled after sending repeated messages which were nothing to do with the job? I think most women would get the idea & not use him. But save all the messages as proof first.

Swipe left for the next trending thread