Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think japan and uk have so much in common?

85 replies

Valeriane · 11/11/2021 07:05

I have never been to Japan so 100% open to posters correcting me/adding things! But the other day I was thinking it's funny, the two seem to actually have a lot in common

Driving on the left
Love of tea and codified ceremonies/rituals around tea
Island nations
Big former empires
Hardcore monarchies
A strange contrast between a tightly buttoned aspect on one hand, and then eccentricity and subcultures on the other
Big importance placed on social niceties and possibly repression
Love of whiskey and whiskey making culture
Feeling separate to the rest of their continent (is this true for Japan?)
Very densely populated
Important in developing trains (steam, bullet)
Love of fancy dress/costume

OP posts:
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/11/2021 09:37

@Thewiseoneincognito

Broadly speaking they may seem like similarities but our cultures are like night and day and you do not need to visit to understand that.

The Japanese as a people make us look like a nation of wild dogs in comparison to their civility.

Tell that to dd’s friend, a keen swimmer who was teaching in Japan, and witnessed every single Japanese person leave the pool as soon as she entered it.
SoniaFouler · 11/11/2021 09:34

@Tokyo89 I should have clarified, born and raised in Japan - would they still be “other”?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/11/2021 09:33

@jetadore

I think you’ve noticed driving on the left and being islands and run with it. Most of the rest is a massive reach.
Eaxctly - you might as well add "the people living in both countries have heads - look how similar that is"
Tokyo89 · 11/11/2021 09:28

@SoniaFouler unless you are full Japanese, raised in Japan, you are ‘other’.

Meruem · 11/11/2021 09:26

Arriving back to Heathrow and going on the tube is shocking

Absolutely this. I live in London and whenever I come back from Japan (have been several times) I really notice all the grime on the streets where I live, and I live in a relatively nice area. The tube makes me feel a bit sick it’s so filthy. But then I just get used to it again!

The other major thing I noticed was how little petty crime there seems to be. People will go to a cafe in the middle of Tokyo and leave their handbag or laptop on the table, even outdoor tables, and go off and make their order, knowing their things will still be there when they get back. You could never do that in London. I always felt so safe when I was there. You could walk along dark alleys at night and not feel scared.

The politeness is off the scale. British people are very brash and rude in comparison. But, I do find in general that we are more helpful. We are more likely to give up a seat if we see someone who needs it. Or if someone falls people will rush to help. In Japan they just walk around you! (I know as this happened to me twice!).

I do love visiting there. For me it’s like nowhere else on earth. But I couldn’t live and work there. I couldn’t handle the crazy hours and the way women are treated.

SoniaFouler · 11/11/2021 09:22

Are there mixed race people in Japan? And if born in Japan, speak Japanese, etc, are they seen as Japanese, or “other”? (Not to you OP, to anyone that has lived there).

MRex · 11/11/2021 09:11

Nope. Entirely different, but it's well worth visiting Japan so you can see why.

Tokyo89 · 11/11/2021 09:09

@Valeriane Ah okay. I would say that when you see a Japanese person dressed up it is very often part of their identity and a wider subculture vs fancy dress being something fun you do for a friends hen. Halloween is picking up as an adult holiday (dress up, go out to be seen and drink) in Tokyo though. Potentially Osaka and Kyoto as well?

I don’t have any resources for you but a lot of the points you mentioned are really interesting parts of Japanese culture - tea ceremonies, youth and subcultures, politeness and honourifics and development of technology. I think you would find reading some in depth articles or books really fascinating! You do sounds keen to learn.

RubyFakeLips · 11/11/2021 09:00

@Thewiseoneincognito

Broadly speaking they may seem like similarities but our cultures are like night and day and you do not need to visit to understand that.

The Japanese as a people make us look like a nation of wild dogs in comparison to their civility.

This.

UK is also filthy, it isn't popular to say but this a dirty country with comparatively dirty houses. Japan is so clean and hygiene focused. When I've been there I find much of the cultural difference wearing except the cleanliness. Arriving back to Heathrow and going on the tube is shocking.

jetadore · 11/11/2021 08:59

I think you’ve noticed driving on the left and being islands and run with it. Most of the rest is a massive reach.

ThePlantsitter · 11/11/2021 08:56

I've never been to Japan either OP and I think it's worth remembering that what we see - media that's filtered for us, news that's filtered for us, tourists who are the kind of people who actually want to come here - is likely to be quite different from what in-country culture is like. I would love to go, it's on my list.

Valeriane · 11/11/2021 08:54

@ThePlantsitter
What do you think the similarities in humour are?

OP posts:
Valeriane · 11/11/2021 08:53

@GlumyGloomer
No! I can see the appeal but anime leaves me cold 🙈 However I am in a phase of reading Japanese novels at the moment and am devouring them!

@Tokyo89
Thanks for such an interesting reply. Maybe "fancy dress" was the wrong way of putting it (and possibly a bit offensive 👀), I was referring to those japanese subcultures where people dress up really outlandishly. It feels like they are almost costumes and I was thinking there's kind of a similarity there with fancy dress and themed parties you get in the UK, maybe a shared taste for "becoming a character".

Interesting that so many posters with experience of Japan say social niceties and society are much more hardcore over there, it makes me think that Japanese people who come to Europe must find it quite terrifying and almost "pagan" feeling.

OP posts:
HarrietsChariot · 11/11/2021 08:50

There are more differences that similarities.

  1. Their trains are punctual, if they are late you get a certificate so you don't get punished by your employer.
  2. They have the death penalty, where the condemned don't know the time of their execution until shortly before it happens.
  3. They have a very different attitude to suicide, it is a much more honourable thing to do over there, provided you don't do it on the railways and cause trains to be late (if you do, the train companies can sue your relatives for the inconvenience).
  4. They are very insular - until the Americans forced them to open up to the world in the latter 19th century there was very little trade or interaction with the outside world.
  5. It's hard to imagine Britain doing a Pearl Harbor on someone.
  6. They have a very different attitude to sexual activity with schoolgirls, the age of consent is 13 and you can buy schoolgirls' (used) underwear from vending machines.
  7. They have a much better record than us for long-term employment, it is much more common to have a "job for life".
  8. Whaling - in the words of REM's Michael Stipe, "Eat, eat whale meat when you need a treat" Wink
ThePlantsitter · 11/11/2021 08:41

Lost in translation is about Americans! Brits & Americans are pretty different culturally in many ways.

Also we totally do have tea rituals they're just so ingrained in the culture we don't notice. I've worked with overseas students for years and remember laughing with my colleagues because one of them came expecting everything to stop dead at 4pm every day for a cup of tea. But then 4 pm came around and we noticed that one of us did put the kettle on... Every day. Plus, tea v with a fry up everyone?

I'm not saying we're the same culturally as Japan (although I think Japanese/British sense of humour had some common points too) but wedefinitely have tea rituals.

MondayYogurt · 11/11/2021 08:39

In some respects we align, more than say Portugal and Japan, or UK and China. But they also have a lot of stereotypes in common with Germany:

Powerhouse economy
Punctual
Meticulous
Excellent manufacturing
Strong automotive industry
Traditional dress for cultural festivals
Reverence for global peacemaking/shame over history

Hoppinggreen · 11/11/2021 08:38

I have never been to Japan but went on a virtual trade mission there a few months ago. We had 3 days of learning about cultural differences and how to do business there and there were some huge differences between The UK and Japan. A lot of them were psychological and really hard to quantify

GlumyGloomer · 11/11/2021 08:36

Op are you ab anime/manga fan? I got that same sort of sense of kinship without ever having been there, because I loved the creative output so much. And being small but influential islands with high population density does create a few similarities. However the differences far outweigh them. Definitely go if you can, it was an amazing experience.

Tokyo89 · 11/11/2021 08:35

On paper I can see where you are coming from but it really is quite different.

  • British people have a reputation for liking tea (seems correct). Japanese people also drink a lot of tea but it’s on a different level. You go into a lot of small restaurants and your options for drinks will probably be water, beer and green tea. The actual tea ceremony is an absolute honour to attend when prepared by a skilful practitioner and takes years and years of studying before being allowed to conduct one. To add another layer there are a huge number of intricacies to be the recipient of the tea in a real ceremony. Offering a cuppa when someone’s comes to your house doesn’t compare.
  • Japan also takes social niceties to the extreme. Sometimes it’s nice, other times it’s insane. I still don’t know how deep to bow or with what honorific to address most of the people I meet. The Japanese make the British stiff upper lip look like a wet noodle. Unfortunately this probably has a huge part to play in the high suicide rates, overwork and number of recluses (hikikomori).
  • with the ‘feeling separated from the rest of their continent’ I honestly don’t think plays on anyone’s mind here. Japan was never really bound (in a positive way) to the rest of Asia so there isn’t any reason to feel ‘separate’.
  • I’m wondering where the idea that the Japanese love fancy dress comes from?
  • I can’t speak to the development side of things but The trains here occasionally make me want to weep with joy because they are so clean, punctual and well run. I’ve never felt that way about a British train 😂

So maybe superficially they might look the same, but I wouldn’t consider them to be similar. (Sources: currently living in Japan, riding a beautiful train at the moment.)

PooWillyNameChange · 11/11/2021 08:29

I think they're interesting observations OP (and yes. I have been to Japan...twice). Whilst it does feel very different there are interesting parallels which is all the OP is really saying...they are interesting because the countries are miles apart geographically and culturally.

I didn't feel like I was in that much of an alien country in Japan, certainly not to the extent of other posters. I felt more like that in the mountains of North Africa or in the Sahara...and that's where half my family are from! Nothing has ever made me feel more alien than having to politely decline roasted dog, or being in a room full of relatives screaming at each other (or so it felt like) when actually they were just having a conversation several decibels higher than would be acceptable in the UK.

Mummyoflittledragon · 11/11/2021 08:28

Yeh totally agree with you. Hmm We Brits also produce violent anime cartoons for the consumption of young children. We also have an assortment of maid cafés and blind date cafés ( where underaged girls and prostitute themselves). Like the Japanese, we bow to one another, treat business cards as an extension of the person and our standards of female beauty / behaviour are identical. Deffo.

No surprise you’ve never been to Japan.

It’s a fascinating and truly amazing country. However, it is very very different. Of course lots of what I’ve written above is a small snapshot of what is happening in major cities but the cultures and countries couldn’t be more different.

Belekker · 11/11/2021 08:26

I lived there and second what WineismyCarb and EileenGC say.

Have you actually seen a tea ceremony? Having a tea time, tea being the national drink to the extent that its mildly fetishised by some, just doesn't compare.

I loved Japan, visit regularly and still have close friends there and a family who 'adopted' me which I dearly love. But I absolutely could not live there for more than a few years at a time as the VERY DIFFERENT societal mores are suffocating for a European.

JingsMahBucket · 11/11/2021 08:25

@TinySaltLick

I think that whilst there is enough similarity on some of the line items to articulate a comparison of sorts, I found Japan to be the most different from life in the UK of any country I have visited. It has in many ways evolved in isolation so almost everything is different - even down to things like door handles or the shape of a paperclip - every tiny problem has been solved differently and it adds up to the be the most amazing and engaging immersion in a culture so detailed and completely different to our own. The one time I had the opportunity to spend a few weeks there is probably my most treasured life experience.
@TinySaltLick that’s really interesting perspective. I actually want to visit now to mark those differences. Thank you.
Valeriane · 11/11/2021 08:22

@Trixiefirecracker
I'm happy to be told I'm wrong. I realise these are superficial observations by someone who has never been.

OP posts:
Honeyroar · 11/11/2021 08:19

I’ve never felt so far away from home, mentally, anywhere else in the world, than I did in Japan.