Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did Stephen Nolan go where nobody has dared go before??

92 replies

BlueTouchPaper · 11/11/2021 00:44

That's it, really. I just listened to the podcasts. Everyone should listen. Most women I know are totally unaware that men with penises could be in a changing room near you
Anytime now.

OP posts:
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/11/2021 09:54

@lubeybooby

OP your post reads like the same kind of mad satire Chris Morris used to do

YABU along with the 85% of other brainwashed, groomed, recruited mn'ers in this mad transphobic echo chamber of hate and fear

What exactly is transphobic in the OP's post?

The Nolan Podcast is in the best tradition of the BBC - it's information.

BloodinGutters · 11/11/2021 09:54

@HarrietsChariot

*Most women I know are totally unaware that men with penises could be in a changing room near you Anytime now.*

That's always been the case though. There are no laws which prevent someone from using whichever facilities they feel most comfortable with. This is what I don't get about all this outrage, this is already happening and has done for decades. It's in the news now which might make people think it's a new thing, but it's not. OK you might not like it, fair enough, but to say most people are unaware shows how oblivious they must have been and how few problems (if any) have occurred over the last few decades.

The single sex exemptions in the equality act mean that facilities are single sex.

The buildings regulation act means school toilets must be single sex.

So yeah there are laws.

HarrietsChariot · 11/11/2021 09:53

And another thing. You use the term "men with penises". This term makes no sense. Either you are saying you are happy for women with penises to be in the changing room (implying you are happy for male-to-female transitioners to be there) or you are denying that transwomen are "real" women and are still men, in which case you don't need to say "men with penises" any more than "women with vaginas" (you say "Most women I know" in the same sentence) - they're just plain "men" (who as I said in previous post, have been usung female facilities for years without widespread issue).

ProudMaiasaura · 11/11/2021 09:51

@JulesRimetStillGleaming

No - some of us have been literally saying all this stuff for years. But he did it publicly and he challenged his employer PLUS he's a man which helps a lot if you want to be listened to and taken seriously.
He's also not the first man to raise his head above the parapet...Graham Lineham has been a very vocal supporter of women's rights, with consequences to his personal life and employment - but Nolan does appear to be the first person to successfully raise this as something that needs a spotlight shone on it, with their employer and not lose their job or be dragged to court.

Given what's at stake, I'll accept with grudging grace that I'm happy Nolan appears to be making waves where courageous women have been vilified and threatened. Each step into the light and scrutiny of wider society the better.

Then maybe we can have sensible discussions about how to ensure those who need to transition can be supported through that with grace, dignity and safety whilst women and girls don't lose basic sex based protections against predatory men who manipulate liberalism to their advantage.

HarrietsChariot · 11/11/2021 09:48

Most women I know are totally unaware that men with penises could be in a changing room near you
Anytime now.

That's always been the case though. There are no laws which prevent someone from using whichever facilities they feel most comfortable with. This is what I don't get about all this outrage, this is already happening and has done for decades. It's in the news now which might make people think it's a new thing, but it's not. OK you might not like it, fair enough, but to say most people are unaware shows how oblivious they must have been and how few problems (if any) have occurred over the last few decades.

lubeybooby · 11/11/2021 09:47

OP your post reads like the same kind of mad satire Chris Morris used to do

YABU along with the 85% of other brainwashed, groomed, recruited mn'ers in this mad transphobic echo chamber of hate and fear

bumbleymummy · 11/11/2021 09:46

Is it to allow people to ‘hide’ certain topics that they find upsetting/controversial? Coronavirus posts all ultimately get moved to the coronavirus board too.

Skeumorph · 11/11/2021 09:42

Good - shame MN are so selective about what gets hidden away - AIBU is jam packed full of stuff that could be elsewhere but they leave alone because.....well who knows?

Who knows indeed!

What I do know is that this AIBU is relating to something that is current news and is of interest to a wide range of people.

It no more belongs in its most directly relevant subsection than, for example, the current, tragically very topical thread on dog attacks belongs in The Doghouse.

Or the one that is about soaping dishes belongs in Housekeeping, or the one with nearly 400 replies on how often you deep clean your house should be in there either...

Or the one on sleep training a toddler should be in, um, Sleep...

I could go on.

And I most certainly will if I need to, I'd suggest others start doing the same :)

Clear bias.

doublemonkey · 11/11/2021 09:38

@Skeumorph

If this gets moved to Feminism, I’m literally going to spend the next three weeks reporting EVERY SINGLE aibu thread that’s actually about parenting, relationships, schools, stepchildren, legal matters… you name it
This exactly.

This is something that concerns all women and children, girls in particular.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/11/2021 09:37

@Skeumorph

If this gets moved to Feminism, I’m literally going to spend the next three weeks reporting EVERY SINGLE aibu thread that’s actually about parenting, relationships, schools, stepchildren, legal matters… you name it
Good - shame MN are so selective about what gets hidden away - AIBU is jam packed full of stuff that could be elsewhere but they leave alone because.....well who knows?
FeminismTippingPoint · 11/11/2021 09:36

Great link I hadn’t come across this on bbc sounds.

Government is deafening silent on how transrights disproportionately negatively affects women.

howmuchmningistoomuch · 11/11/2021 09:32

Hmmm - Nolan says a lot of feminists feel unsafe in mixed toilets and transwomen shouldn’t be competing against women in sports … I think it goes further than just those identifying as feminists…

bumbleymummy · 11/11/2021 09:27

Thanks Errol. That’s good to see.

Siameasy · 11/11/2021 09:26

Brilliant news about the BBC. I’ve followed this debate since 2015. The house of cards is starting to fall down

ErrolTheDragon · 11/11/2021 09:13

@bumbleymummy

I read with delight today that the BBC have removed themselves from the clutches of Stonewall and have officially withdrawn from the Stonewall Diversity Scheme.

Have they? Progress I guess!

Yes, and on grounds of membership being at odds with impartiality, not just the 'poor value for money' being used by some orgs.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/bbc-quits-stonewall-diversity-scheme-over-impartiality-concerns-xztzfq0nf?shareToken=f1aee03404b151e2c4d94625808f98d1

PicsInRed · 11/11/2021 09:12

@Skeumorph

If this gets moved to Feminism, I’m literally going to spend the next three weeks reporting EVERY SINGLE aibu thread that’s actually about parenting, relationships, schools, stepchildren, legal matters… you name it
Amen!
Mummyoflittledragon · 11/11/2021 09:09

The Nolan report is brilliant and well researched. But had this been a female journalist, it wouldn’t have had the same impact.

Unfortunately men are the only ones taken seriously.

Please stop and think what you’re saying. Did the brave women speaking out for years mean nothing?

mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 09:04

I read with delight today that the BBC have removed themselves from the clutches of Stonewall

Interesting, thanks

whichiswitch · 11/11/2021 08:54

It's an example of the patriarchy to me. Women have been saying the same of years and get threats of rape and violence but more people pay attention when men are saying the same thing.

BlameItOnTheBlackStar · 11/11/2021 08:54

@JulesRimetStillGleaming

No - some of us have been literally saying all this stuff for years. But he did it publicly and he challenged his employer PLUS he's a man which helps a lot if you want to be listened to and taken seriously.
Yes, I'm sure it must stick in the throats of so many women how much easier it is for your male voice to be heard. Maybe it's easier to be perceived as 'neutral' too.
BloodinGutters · 11/11/2021 08:51

@bumbleymummy

I read with delight today that the BBC have removed themselves from the clutches of Stonewall and have officially withdrawn from the Stonewall Diversity Scheme.

Have they? Progress I guess!

And from the work place equality index. Which is even better.

Most of the organisations that have been publicly de stonewalling still remain in the wpei.

So bbc are breaking new ground.
And with the most straight forward and least apologetic statement.

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 11/11/2021 08:38

No - some of us have been literally saying all this stuff for years. But he did it publicly and he challenged his employer PLUS he's a man which helps a lot if you want to be listened to and taken seriously.

bumbleymummy · 11/11/2021 08:33

I read with delight today that the BBC have removed themselves from the clutches of Stonewall and have officially withdrawn from the Stonewall Diversity Scheme.

Have they? Progress I guess!

BloodinGutters · 11/11/2021 08:29

The fact stonewall made the bbc & ofcom sign NDA’s is hugely significant.

So along with listening to the episode with dr David Bell I’d highlight that part to people.

A ‘charity’ that takes in millions of public funds making organisation it gives ‘trains’ being made to sign an NDA is secret police level crazy. It’s in direct opposition with a free democracy.

FrancescaContini · 11/11/2021 08:07

You, not your