Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Red v white poppies

364 replies

Malhao · 11/11/2021 00:33

AIBU to be unimpressed that the staff at school are trying to sell my kids red poppies without explaining the symbolism behind them?

I don't agree with the concept of war and am contemplating sending them in wearing white poppies (I've explained the difference to them and they both agree with the principles behind the white poppies) but wonder if they'll get picked on for standing out?

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 11/11/2021 09:27

@SpinachIsAGatewayDrug

I honestly wish we would all stop trying to police the actions of people who are acting within their own moral code tbh.

If wearing a white poppy suits your personal code, do so. If wearing a red one suits yours, do so.

That would suggest we were living in the kind of democratic, tolerant, free country that people died to protect!
supermoonrising · 11/11/2021 09:26

@toastfiend
I would condemn most of the recent large scale campaigns of the British Army. Incidentally, life expectancy in China rocketed under the communists which has continued to this day. So it wasn't just footbinding they got right. Compare and contrast to India, 1950-2021, which used to be on an equal development footing with China. As you concede, things are rarely black and white, though we often like to believe so.

KurtWilde · 11/11/2021 09:26

Some people are saying that the white poppy is disrespectful to the fallen. I don’t agree, I think that it may imply that the decision to send them to war in the first place may not have been a good one

So our country should've just accepted the advances of Hitler then rather than defend itself??

StillWeRise · 11/11/2021 09:26

@samG76

I would never wear a white poppy. A lot of the Peace Pledge Union were pro-Nazi in the late 30s and even up to 1940. Not just pro-appeasement, but genuinely supported the German invasions of their neighbours. I think Orwell said that the PPU publications weren't much different from those of the British Union of Fascists.
can you give some references for this ?
PurpleParrotfish · 11/11/2021 09:24

Some people are saying that the white poppy is disrespectful to the fallen. I don’t agree, I think that it may imply that the decision to send them to war in the first place may not have been a good one, but that doesn’t say anything negative about individual servicemen and women.
And ‘divisive’ to me sounds like ‘encouraging people to think and ask awkward questions’. Like why the state doesn’t support veterans properly and so many of them end up homeless despite this massive fundraising exercise.
Or why, if the red poppy is supposed to remind us of the horrors of war, do politicians lay wreaths at the Cenotaph while happy to defend the UK’s right to sell billions worth of weapons to Saudi Arabia to pulverise Yemen.
Even if there are no easy answers, we shouldn’t be shut down from asking difficult questions.

SpinachIsAGatewayDrug · 11/11/2021 09:24

I honestly wish we would all stop trying to police the actions of people who are acting within their own moral code tbh.

If wearing a white poppy suits your personal code, do so. If wearing a red one suits yours, do so.

mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 09:23

The UK is not going to be attacked by another state as long as it has nuclear weapons, the Second World War will not be repeated

So you can 100% guarantee this, wow.

Your username dreamingbohemian is very adequate.

IntermittentParps · 11/11/2021 09:23

@samG76

I would never wear a white poppy. A lot of the Peace Pledge Union were pro-Nazi in the late 30s and even up to 1940. Not just pro-appeasement, but genuinely supported the German invasions of their neighbours. I think Orwell said that the PPU publications weren't much different from those of the British Union of Fascists.
That was a long time ago.
toastfiend · 11/11/2021 09:21

@supermoonrising I never disputed that. What I said was that it showed a level of ignorance to condemn an organisation as a whole without any acknowledgement that life for us here would be pretty difficult without them. I don't think the same could be said for Chairman Mao, foot binding or not.

Lemonsyellow · 11/11/2021 09:20

YABU. You don’t seem to understand the symbolism of the red poppy at all. It has nothing at all about being in favour of the concept of war. Goodness knows what you have told your children.

SleepingStandingUp · 11/11/2021 09:20

So school have a box of red poppies and are selling them to kids without telling them why? Just hey kid, buy these? Seems unlikely

supermoonrising · 11/11/2021 09:20

@samG76
I would never wear a white poppy. A lot of the Peace Pledge Union were pro-Nazi in the late 30s and even up to 1940. Not just pro-appeasement, but genuinely supported the German invasions of their neighbours.
So was the Daily Mail, Britain's second favourite newspaper. So was the British Royal Family. Times change.

DameAlyson · 11/11/2021 09:19

I feel the thing we should be remembering today is how tragic war is, how it destroys lives and should be avoided.

The poem 'In Flanders Fields,' that I quoted above, that is the origin of the association of poppies with the war dead, doesn't do that for you?

I'm seeing a lot of what Kipling wrote about here in this thread.

Brefugee, I find that Kipling often has something relevant to say.

supermoonrising · 11/11/2021 09:18

@toastfiend
For those who don't support the Armed Forces, I assume you don't support their involvement filling and placing sandbags when areas are at high risk of flooding?

The armed forces I'm sure does plenty of good work. Meanwhile, Chairman Mao banned foot binding... it's almost like people/organisations can do good stuff and bad stuff at the same time.

SammyScrounge · 11/11/2021 09:18

In what way was the last war futile and pointless? Would you really have been happy with Nazi rule so long as peace was preserved?

austenwildfell · 11/11/2021 09:16

All countries have charities for those in the forces that protected the weak against the tyrants. All countries find that the survivors and relatives of casualties need extra help.
We have the British Legion the Americans have several organisations that support Veterans, Canada has as well they also have red poppies.
Most soldiers are anti-war, they fully understand the consequences of battle.
Go and visit a war cemetery check on the ages.

Ask the British people of the Channel Islands about what it is like to be invaded and occupied by the German Army in WW2. The rest of UK avoided that.
Do some research.

supermoonrising · 11/11/2021 09:15

I'm not a pacifist by any means, but I do recognise that there's a difference between remembering brave men fighting an existential battle for their homelike and way of life VS a marauding hitech army dropping thousands of bombs on some far away land in defence of anti-terror/oil/geopolitical economic strategy.

Unfortunately the poppy has never clearly defined, which isn't helped by the BL defining themselves still loosely defining it as "supporting the armed forces".

toastfiend · 11/11/2021 09:15

For those who don't support the Armed Forces, I assume you don't support their involvement filling and placing sandbags when areas are at high risk of flooding? I assume you don't support their involvement when there's no one else to drive petrol tankers? I assume you don't support their involvement in rescue operations and humanitarian efforts during crises at home and abroad? I assume you don't support their involvement when our emergency services strike or are short-staffed and they're drafted in to put out fires and drive ambulances instead? I assume you don't support their involvement when the NHS are short on staff or lack capacity to coordinate national strategies and Army medics and logistics staff are drafted in? I hope you wouldn't plan on accepting their help in these situations, given that you're so opposed to them? It's not just about fighting wars, they have a huge part to play in supporting British infrastructure and they're often the first people we send to support humanitarian efforts in other countries, to blanketly state that you don't support them whatsoever displays a real level of ignorance. Who do you think would step in to do all these things if they didn't? I assume you're not volunteering to do so?

samG76 · 11/11/2021 09:13

I would never wear a white poppy. A lot of the Peace Pledge Union were pro-Nazi in the late 30s and even up to 1940. Not just pro-appeasement, but genuinely supported the German invasions of their neighbours. I think Orwell said that the PPU publications weren't much different from those of the British Union of Fascists.

dreamingbohemian · 11/11/2021 09:12

@mustlovegin

I’m not sure you can just opt out of the concept of war OP

^This

If we are under attack, we can simply shout 'gentle hands' 'be kind' 'we don't do war in this country' and the attacker will simply go away...Hmm

Some people do live on fantasy land, for sure

This is exactly the danger in mixing up the world wars with today's wars, it takes the nobility of self-defence in the Second World War and extends it to today where it's not really the case.

The UK had not been attacked by Afghanistan or Iraq when it invaded those countries. The campaign against ISIS had more of a self-defence justification, but ISIS would never have come into being if the Iraq war hadn't happened in the first place.

The UK is not going to be attacked by another state as long as it has nuclear weapons, the Second World War will not be repeated. Its biggest threat is domestic terrorism but military force is not the only, or even the best, way to combat that.

If the UK armed forces were used purely in self-defence and for peacekeeping, I don't think people would have so many objections to the poppy. But this has never been the case. I don't personally object to the red poppy but I disagree that those who do are living in 'fantasy land'.

YouJustFoldItIn · 11/11/2021 09:12

I don't agree with the concept of war

Neither do most people. It's not something entered into for fun, you know.

Where would we be now (and most of the rest of Europe) if everyone had thought like you in 1914 and 1939?

Brefugee · 11/11/2021 09:11

"Poppies are worn as a show of support for the Armed Forces community."

and how does that statement support war? I and thousands of people like me joined the military with the express intent of preventing wars. I'm happy to say that on my watch, on the bit that i did, the invading hordes didn't come over the inner German border in their tanks. A lot of us worked very hard at that. You're welcome.

driftcompatible · 11/11/2021 09:08

I don't agree with the concept of war 

I don't either. I put on a poppy this morning though and suddenly all I wanted to do was enlist. Fortunately, as I was Googling 'join the RAF' and planning on how to annihilate my enemies, the poppy fell off and now I'm anti war again.

That ^^ is as stupid as your post.

KurtWilde · 11/11/2021 09:08

School undoubtedly will have explained the significance of the red poppy, now you've confused the issue by somehow twisting the meaning and giving them a white one because you're 'anti-war'. Like all of us wearing red ones love war? Christ on a bike. A remembrance poppy isn't remembering war like oh yes chaps jolly good war that was, let's have a flower to remember it by Confused

I think your white poppy is disrespectful to those who gave their lives, quite frankly.

Pinkspecs · 11/11/2021 09:08

@mustlovegin

I’m not sure you can just opt out of the concept of war OP

^This

If we are under attack, we can simply shout 'gentle hands' 'be kind' 'we don't do war in this country' and the attacker will simply go away...Hmm

Some people do live on fantasy land, for sure

Totally agree.
Swipe left for the next trending thread