Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Red v white poppies

364 replies

Malhao · 11/11/2021 00:33

AIBU to be unimpressed that the staff at school are trying to sell my kids red poppies without explaining the symbolism behind them?

I don't agree with the concept of war and am contemplating sending them in wearing white poppies (I've explained the difference to them and they both agree with the principles behind the white poppies) but wonder if they'll get picked on for standing out?

OP posts:
RobotValkyrie · 11/11/2021 11:00

Is it really that controversial to want to celebrate peace on the anniversary of the Armistice? If there isn't room both for celebration and remembrance, then we have learned nothing.

Peace is about balancing conflicting opinions and interests.
Red poppy + white poppy makes lots of sense.
Red poppy VS white poppy just means repeating the same mistakes.

NothingSafe · 11/11/2021 11:00

I don't wear a poppy at all these days. It's both become a ridiculous corporatised mess (see twitter.com/giantpoppywatch for some of the most bizarre examples) and a symbol clung onto by those who disguise racism behind nationalism and miss the point of e.g. WW2 altogether.

Cam77 · 11/11/2021 10:59

@Andante57
You’re conflating separate events. Of course Mao made huge mistakes which were responsible for worsening the famine. (however, please note that historically, up to and including Mao, awful famines in China have been tragically frequent events). However the fact that he was a very poor leader during those years was totally separate to the huge improvements in women’s rights, life expectancy, and literacy which also came about due to communist party policies in China in the 60s and 70s and beyond. More than a billion Chinese in China can see there was a good side of Mao and also a bad side. Just like there was a good side of the Iraq war (Sadam removed) and a bad side (100,000s of civilian deaths). I trust their understanding of it more than some random Westerner who has probably never stepped foot in the country.

KurtWilde · 11/11/2021 10:52

@Mantlemoose

The red poppy represents remembrance of the British Armed Forces in all wars.. The white poppy represents ALL victims, military and civilians and aims to stop the exclusion of non armed forces from Remembrance events. Why would you not want to honour everyone who died for their country just because they weren't in the forces? The white poppy includes people like the volunteer aircraft watchers, the woman who worked in the factories making equipment to fight with which ultimately caused the death of many of those making them? The people on the street who does helping others? Inconceivable to me only the armed forces deserve remembering.
My mum's aunt worked in a munitions factory and lost her unborn baby because of the work she was expected to do there, whilst heavily pregnant. My grandad was in the home guard. My mum lost an uncle in WWI. As a family we wear a red poppy to remember everyone who was lost, not just the armed forces. I'm sure many people do the same.
elbea · 11/11/2021 10:51

@PinkPlantCase today’s armed forces keep you safe every single day from threats that you have absolutely no awareness of.

Wearing a poppy isn’t just remembering the sacrifice of people that died 100 years ago, it’s about remembering people like Guardsman Matthew Talbot who died in Malawi whilst protecting elephants from poachers. It’s remembering Pte Watson-Pickering who died on Salisbury Plain just a few weeks ago. It’s acknowledging the sacrifices of soldiers currently serving in Estonia on a peacekeeping mission to stop Russia annexing Estonia. It’s acknowledging the sacrifices of the soldiers that left their families for months on end during the pandemic to serve this country in a time of need.

The white poppy belittles their sacrifices, on their website it says the white poppy is to ‘…challenge attempts to glamorise or celebrate war.’ Remembering and acknowledging people’s sacrifices isn’t celebrating war.

PiousPenelope · 11/11/2021 10:51

It's called Remembrance Day... where we remember those that lost their lives protecting us. would you have liked Hitler to have won the war?!

It's not called "Woo-Hoo Let's Start another War Because We Love Blood, Gore and Death".

I am so bored of this woke attitude for everything. Where people don't really understand but think it sounds good.

Couchbettato · 11/11/2021 10:50

@SinoohXaenaHide

I don't buy the poppies from the Roysl British Legion because as a charity they do sponsorship deals with weapons manufacturers which sell weapons to oppressive regimes that use those weapons against civilians. They are happy to keep the machines of war going and ensuring there will be an ongoing supply of war wounded and bereaved. It's hypocritical to do lip service to mourning the dead of past wars whilst actively promoting ways to ensure that there will be more in future.

The white poppies are produced by the Peace Pledge Union, an educational charity that works towards building a future where power and control isn't decided on the basus of who can deal out death most effectively.

Learn something new every day.

I choose not to wear a Poppy at all. I do still have a few minutes silence and think about the sacrifices that were made for me to live the life I do and the cost that had to so many.

I don't think poppies are necessary to do that, but I think if the school aren't making children pay into a cause that they may or not want to pay into, then wearing a Poppy, to children, is only symbolising that respect. The burden of funding a charity with questionable morals doesn't fall onto the children.

Cam77 · 11/11/2021 10:49

@Lifeisaminestrone
It is not about ....
The meanings of symbols can change over time. They can also be vague. (are we remembering the dead or supporting the troops? Britain can’t make up its mind).
To one person a symbol may be holy. To another deeply offensive.
This isn’t complex stuff.

RobotValkyrie · 11/11/2021 10:47

What I really don't get is how the anniversary of the Armistice, i.e. a day to celebrate a hard-won peace, enjoyed by people all over the world, has somehow been high-jacked to become all about the British Armed Forces.

World Wars were total wars. No-one was truly a civilian anymore, whether they wanted it or not. And this was particularly true closer to the front-lines. If anything, the UK was a lot less affected than many other European countries.
But achieving peace, and maintaining it, takes more effort than war. That's the real lesson here (otherwise there wouldn't have been two world wars). And the peace effort involves everyone. Nothing against armed forces (veterans do deserve support), but focusing on them exclusively is really a bit of a distraction.

PiousPenelope · 11/11/2021 10:47

@ProudMaiasaura

The red poppy is a symbol of respect and gratitude. It is not a pro-war symbol and to claim such a thing is crass and distasteful.

The origins of the red poppy were to provide much needed money to veterans and families of veterans who desperately needed help after a war none of them asked for, but many paid a bitter price.

It's evolved somewhat but the RBL and the Earl Haig still support veterans and their family's.

YABVU and rather insulting.

The red poppy is a symbol of respect and gratitude. It is not a pro-war symbol and to claim such a thing is crass and distasteful.

...and ignorant!

Andante57 · 11/11/2021 10:47

That most things are not all good or all bad

Sure, Chairman Mao was a poppet really. The life expectancy of all the millions of people he murdered wasn’t great.
Blimey, imagine saying ‘well fascism had its good as well as bad points’

lottiegarbanzo · 11/11/2021 10:46

Remembrance Day is on Sunday. Today is Armistice Day.

The necessity or otherwise of WWI is and was deeply contested, including by many who fought in it, some of whom went on to refuse to wear poppies. I find this discussion today, perfectly appropriate.

Cam77 · 11/11/2021 10:44

@Balonziaga
I will wear my red poppy but think the white poppy is completely un-necessary. it's like wearing a symbol that declares that you are 'anti stabbing penguins' - of course you are. Any decent person would be

The modern US is one of the most pro-war societies in the history of the world. The statistics are clear as day.

Lifeisaminestrone · 11/11/2021 10:41

I’m finding this thread on Rememberance Day wholly inappropriate.

We are remembering those who lost their lives or livelihoods who fought with fear and courage.

A number of these comments are inappropriate.

It is not about the politics of war but the individuals on both sides involved.

Cam77 · 11/11/2021 10:41

@Flossy05
No, it’s first aim is “to support the armed forces community”.
From the RL website.

It’s also a way to bash anybody who casts any doubt on any modern military campaign. See today’s DM headline and typical attempted politicization of Remembrance Day. Now THAT is a disgusting insult to people who died in WW2 hoping for a tolerant and reasonable society.

Mantlemoose · 11/11/2021 10:39

The red poppy represents remembrance of the British Armed Forces in all wars.. The white poppy represents ALL victims, military and civilians and aims to stop the exclusion of non armed forces from Remembrance events.
Why would you not want to honour everyone who died for their country just because they weren't in the forces? The white poppy includes people like the volunteer aircraft watchers, the woman who worked in the factories making equipment to fight with which ultimately caused the death of many of those making them? The people on the street who does helping others? Inconceivable to me only the armed forces deserve remembering.

Cam77 · 11/11/2021 10:38

Britain still has a very imperial, pro-war mentality. It was clear as day that Blair was lying his ass off against Iraq AND the HoC was complicit. (remember that more Tories were in favor of it than Labour MPs). It was clear as day that Afghanistan would be a colossal waste of human life and resources. And yet the British Public STILL lapped up and supported the nonsense Blair and Bush were spouting. It would never ever have been bought by the electorates in Germany, Belgium, Spain, Ireland, Switzerland etc. Because the modern day people in those countries have learnt lessons from recent history and don’t see any glory or honor in bombing some far off land.

Flossy05 · 11/11/2021 10:38

The red poppy is a symbol of remembrance and hope for a peaceful future. It is not a pro-war symbol.

SilverBirchWithout · 11/11/2021 10:36

I have no problem with the fund-raising and remembrance side of poppy wearing, it is important to mark the sacrifice of previous generations in armed conflicts.
However it feels to me that the original purposes behind Remembrance Day have now become manipulated into holding a different meaning. I loathe the performative nature of poppy wearing by the ‘great and the good’, the media, and companies using it as an advertising/image enhancing exercise. The scrambling to be recognised for being the ‘right-stuff’, and the insincerity of it all and the castigation of individuals who decide not to wear one.
I still buy poppies each year, but feel no need to display myself wearing one.
War (in the main) is a terrible failure by world leaders many lives are wasted pointlessly eg all the lives lost in Afghanistan, Iraq, and WW1. By ‘celebrating’ each year we are somehow perpetuating the myth that war and the death of young men is glorious and honourable, it is not - death and maiming in war is something to be abhorred. I get that it helps the bereaved feel lives were not wasted, but the reality is (in most cases) they were.

BobLemon · 11/11/2021 10:35

“they both agree with the principles behind the white poppies“

FML. YABU to believe this. Kids agree with whatever makes their parent pleased.

RunningFromInsanity · 11/11/2021 10:34

@PinkPlantCase

I have more of a problem with supporting todays armed forces than I do with remembering and honouring those who were lost in WW1 & 2.

Those who served in WW1&2 often didn’t have a choice.

People today very much have a choice, I don’t believe that anyone can join the army today and not know the risks of physical or mental injury.

I wear a red and white poppy together.

He knew the risks and he did it anyway. Bravest person I knew. Every time one of his friends died, we asked him not to go back and he said, if I don’t, who will?
Everanewbie · 11/11/2021 10:33

@Balonziaga

What everyone else has said about the red poppy, obviously.

Regarding the white poppy - nobody 'likes' war. But there seems to be confusion about declaring yourself a pacifist. A pacifist is more than someone who doesn't like war (ie. 99% of the world), it is about being passive to attack. Laying down and letting yourself be killed rather than striking back because to defend yourself would not be a 'passive action' and would be an affront to your self declared pacifist label.

I will wear my red poppy but think the white poppy is completely un-necessary. it's like wearing a symbol that declares that you are 'anti stabbing penguins' - of course you are. Any decent person would be.

Well said.
lottiegarbanzo · 11/11/2021 10:33

I'd just throw in that the need for financial support for former soldiers, widows and dependents post-WWI, pre-welfare state, was very, very different to that need now.

If former soldiers and their dependents are not being supported adequately now, that is a political issue. Some people choose to address all sorts of issues of limited state provision through the discretionary support of certain charities. Others by lobbying politically for more or different distribution of funds raised through taxation. Others again do both. That's another issue of freedom of choice. There is no general, social or moral obligation now, to support the poppy appeal or related charities.

Cam77 · 11/11/2021 10:33

@LindaEllen
You should be happy that you have the freedom to not agree with the concept of war. We are a free country thanks to the men, women, children and animals that lost their lives in the wars.

What would have happened to people who 'didn't agree with the concept of war' and refused to fight in the 1900s? They'd have got shot, that's what

The pro poppy brigade have fingers firmly in their ears. The majority of those against what the poppy has come to symbolize are NOT repeat NOT complete pacifists. They are however against the huge politicization of the poppy in recent years, and the way it’s become a symbol of support for every recent military escapade, most of which are far from honorable.

Just look at the state of today’s headline in Britain’s second biggest selling paper, the DM if you don’t believe the politicization.

PinkPlantCase · 11/11/2021 10:32

I have more of a problem with supporting todays armed forces than I do with remembering and honouring those who were lost in WW1 & 2.

Those who served in WW1&2 often didn’t have a choice.

People today very much have a choice, I don’t believe that anyone can join the army today and not know the risks of physical or mental injury.

I wear a red and white poppy together.

Swipe left for the next trending thread